Investor · Orange, NJ · Member since 2024 · 2 posts · 1 vote
I've been looking to invest in North Jersey for a while now. My goal is to find a 2-4 unit in Essex county to "BRRR" but I've been searching for months and all of the asking prices seem to be shot out of the water, to where a rehab and refinance wouldn't possibly work unless I'm $100-200k under asking price, even with deals sent from wholesalers and tired landlords.
Does anyone have advice on how they are locating deals or investing in Essex County/North Jersey right now?
Hi Morgan, I am in San Antonio, not north Jersey, so I cannot speak to Essex prices. What I have learned here is that when the asking price does not work, the conversation has to shift to the seller and the payment, not the price on the listing. I spend a lot of time talking to sellers direct and learning what they actually need, and most of the time it does not work out. I am still learning, but that has helped me more than chasing more listings.
@Morgan Martin 2-4s are great for a classic BRRRR, since your looking into BRRRR you should check out our Super BRRRR on our website. A few things to run before you pass on a deal:
Back into your max price from the refi, not the asking price. Take a realistic ARV, multiply by 70%, then subtract rehab and this will give you the MAO. That's the most you can pay and still pull most of your cash back out on the back end.
Don't plan on waiting out seasoning. Some DSCR lenders will refinance on the new appraised value (ARV) as soon as the rehab is done instead of 6-12 months later. That cuts your hold time and your hard money interest.
Check rent coverage early. On a 2-4 unit the lender qualifies on the property's rent vs. the full payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance). Essex County taxes are high, so use the real tax bill, not an estimate.
Look for value-add, not just distress. Can you add sq footage, an ADU ?
Happy to run the numbers on any deal you're looking at.
Morgan, deals still exist, but at asking price the BRRRR numbers rarely work in Essex County, so the buy price has to come down. On a 2-4 unit you can also live in one unit and use a lower-down owner-occupied loan. I place the investor side through my lending partners: the purchase and rehab loan, then the rental refinance. When you have a property in mind, send me a message with the price and the rent and I'll tell you what I can place.
@Morgan Martin , months of searching without a deal can mean the strategy and market don't match. If you need $100K to $200K below asking for the refinance to work, I'd reconsider BRRRR in that area before spending more time searching. A house hack might be worth comparing if you're open to living in one unit. Are you set on Essex County? What's your end goal beyond the first property? I'm open to talking strategy if you'd like.
Hi Marc, I do plan on staying in the smallest unit of the multifamily which is why I'm set on Essex county. My goal after the first property is to rinse and repeat, but the location will be a lot more flexible since I don't plan on living there.
Morgan, trying to make a classic BRRRR pencil out in Essex County off retail listings or recycled wholesaler blasts is basically an extreme sport right now most asking prices are completely detached from reality.
The only way the math actually works in tight North Jersey pockets is isolating off-market properties with real equity spreads (15–40%+ below live sub-market medians) before they ever hit a wholesaler's email blast. When we track off-market data across NJ, focusing strictly on deep-equity distress and listing fatigue is what keeps the post-rehab refinance from falling flat.
Quick question: are you strictly locked into Essex County, or open to neighboring North Jersey counties if the off-market equity numbers actually make sense?
If listed prices need to come down $100K to $200K to work, it's usually a volume problem more than a market problem. From the systems I've built, it takes roughly 30 offers to get 1 accepted on listed property, and most of those offers are well under asking. How many offers have you sent in Essex so far?