A Bad Deal That Made Money Is Still a Bad Deal
A fellow tells me about a flip he just finished.
“Drago, I made $42,000!”
“Congratulations! What was your projected profit?”
“Twenty thousand.”
“Even better. What changed?”
“Well, the renovation went $18,000 over budget.”
“That's not usually how profits go up.”
“Yeah, but the market went crazy. I sold the house for $40,000 more than expected!”
“So you made $42,000 because your numbers were wrong twice?”
He didn't particularly appreciate that observation. And I understand why. He bought a house, renovated it, sold it, and walked away with a nice check. What's not to celebrate?
Plenty, actually.
Imagine two investors.vInvestor A does his homework. Conservative purchase price, realistic renovation budget, adequate reserves, reasonable resale assumptions. He makes $25,000. Investor B overpays, underestimates repairs, has no contingency fund, and gets rescued by an unexpectedly hot market. He makes $42,000. Who's the better investor? If you judge by the check, Investor B wins. If you judge by the decisions, I'm not so sure.
There's a concept in decision-making called "resulting": judging the quality of a decision entirely by its outcome. It's a dangerous habit in real estate. A good decision can lose money because something genuinely unpredictable happens. A terrible decision can make money because the market happens to bail you out.
The trouble begins when the second investor mistakes good luck for good judgment. Because next time, he may buy a bigger property, stretch his budget further, and skip even more due diligence. After all, his system works. Until the market stops cooperating.
Profit tells you what happened. Process tells you whether you can do it again. And that's why I believe every investor should review successful deals just as critically as unsuccessful ones. Not to spoil the celebration. But to figure out which part of the profit came from skill, which came from the market, and which came from plain old luck.
(Here's a question for the experienced investors: have you ever made good money on a deal you later realized you probably shouldn't have taken? And did that experience make you more careful, or more confident?)
AI-assisted writing.