Relocate to begin REI?

Relocate to begin REI?

Multi-family Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 6 votes

Hey all,

I'm young, 28,single, and will have $200K to work with. I am currently debating 2 life plans.

Plan A: Earn my MBA ($70-80K over 2 years, living expenses included), increase my earnings(+$20K/yr), and purchase, rehab, rent owner/occupy brownstone in Brooklyn.

OR Plan B: Forgo the MBA, save the $70K that would be spent on the MBA, and relocate to an area where I could find a comparable job (Science, pharma, RD, earning $40-60K/yr) while I begin REI. Areas I have been considering are Buffalo or Rochester NY, as well as areas in Texas and Florida. Any advice on investor friendly area's would be helpful as well.

Now that I've written this out, it appears to be a more personal decision than a purely financial decision. I love NYC, but by staying I accept the high cost of living and highly competitive real estate market. However, I also love the outdoors and would like to get into fishing/hiking/shooting/hunting, ie things I used to do as a youth, which would be possible by relocating. My long term plans are to be a hands on REI, buying, rehabbing, renting and selling multiple SFR and MFR, which may morph into property management.

Anyways, I would like to get some input/feedback from other BPer's that might have made similar decisions; stay or relocate?

0Reply
93 views

Most Popular Reply

J ScottPro Member
Moderator
Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
14y

I'm going to vote for getting the MBA, but finding a less expensive program. In the northeast, you should be able to find some very decent programs for about 1/3 of that amount, and you can start investing at the same time you're going to school.

Just my opinion...

See this reply in the discussion

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Colorado Springs, CO · Member since 2010 · 476 posts · 305 votes
    14y

    Here's my idea on what you can do withnyour money and possibly never have to work again. First off congrats for being so young and ssving your money. If you live in colorado springs, co you can buy a nice house for around $60k-$100k. If you have a job and qualify for a loan you can buy 10 houses with little to no money out of pocket by getting a fix and flip loan and then refinancing to a permanent loan after the rehab has been done with denver mortgage company. I've been buying up short sales in thr springs with 0-$5k out of pocket and my cashflow is $500. $500 x 10 loans is $5000 a month cashflow. Or you can put more money down and get more cashflow. Or you can take the extra money and buy fix and flips cash.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Lansing, MI · Member since 2011 · 356 posts · 306 votes
    14y

    I'd defintely skip the MBA is your goal is to run your own real estate business. I agree with Monica and would tell you to find a spot where the market is hot, properties are relatively cheap, and has the growth to make it profitable. The big 4 metro areas of Texas can hardly be beaten, not to mention there are no state taxes. And, if you decide to pursue an MBA, you'll have a varietyy of local options.

  • Real Estate Agent · Ivor, VA · Member since 2011 · 73 posts · 21 votes
    14y

    If your plan is to be in business for yourself then why get the degree and miss out on today's opportunities?

  • Multi-family Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 6 votes
    14y

    Well, I feel an MBA, in Real Estate btw, would give me a leg up and a good back drop. A leg up because of my increased earning potential as well as the knowledge and networking opportunities I would gain. Also a backdrop in case my start in REI is far bumpier than expected.

    Is it realistic to set off with $200K in a certain area, with limited experience, and expect it to provide adequate profits to subsist and to grow? I guess this would be my largest hang up.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Lansing, MI · Member since 2011 · 356 posts · 306 votes
    14y

    I think you have 200k, cash, then you absolutely can invest, grow, and profit. When you get a chance, go to citysidecorp.com and check out the amazing houses you can buy in Houston and Dallas for under 100k. While you have to live in the house for a year, you could do well on the back end. And, even if you paid cash for it (which you probably wouldn't), you'd still have plenty to use to fix and flip, wholesale, etc.

  • Real Estate Investor · NY · Member since 2008 · 313 posts · 87 votes
    14y

    With 200k you can definitely build a nice portfolio in Rochester that will cash flow. I would stay out of buffalo personally. Rochester is a much nicer city. Have you been to these cities? You can buy a rented house in Rochester for 20k that is rented for 750-800 a month. You can even get a rented house for cheaper, I have bought houses for 5k rented. If you go or buy anything in rochester let me know Ill give you pointers if you need them

  • Multi-family Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 6 votes
    14y

    I've traveled through upstate NY and to Texas a few years ago on my motorcycle, but I wasn't scoping any areas out for REI. I would plan on spending time within any area before beginning to settle down/invest.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y

    I'm going to vote for getting the MBA, but finding a less expensive program. In the northeast, you should be able to find some very decent programs for about 1/3 of that amount, and you can start investing at the same time you're going to school.

    Just my opinion...

  • Real Estate Investor · the villages, FL · Member since 2008 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    14y

    Just for fun-I have to offer a contrarian view to JScott (which we sometimes do for fun only!). I'm not a fan in most college programs. If you must go, JScott method was helpful and cheaper. If the schooling is to go into RE and understand financial literacy- I think BP is a better and cheaper place to find it. No degree for me and it has worked out fine. Rich

  • Real Estate Consultant · Lansing, MI · Member since 2011 · 356 posts · 306 votes
    14y

    I have to agree with Rich. Plus, the majority of your MBA courses won't be dedicated to real estate. I've looked into dozens of them, and most give you 3-4 courses on real estate. There are good MSRE programs as Texas A&M, Florida, and University of Texas @ Arlington if you want a graduate degree with substantial RE coursework.

  • Multi-family Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 6 votes
    14y

    Thanks for all of the input. Definitely food for thought, I'll be sure to let everyone know of my plans once I settle on a course of action.

  • Real Estate Broker · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2010 · 42 posts · 24 votes
    14y

    Robert- You have some $$$, are 28 and single. You have a lot of years to get an MBA. This is a great time to be investing. Do it now.

    I have an MBA. When you do get one be sure it is from a top or second tier school otherwise there is no real value except your own satisfaction.

  • Multi-family Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 6 votes
    14y

    My school of choice is Zicklin Business School, in NYC. Tuition will be roughly $35K for the two years and median income upon graduation is $63.5K. I currently earn $40K. Viewing it as an investment, it has a good ROI(actually rated #1 nationally for ROI among all US b schools), but this is buffered by the fact that only 60% are employed after 3 months of graduation. For personal reasons, I see it as a means to stay in NYC, increase my earning potential and invest in more expensive properties.

    I will say I am currently leaning towards doing without, for now, and pursuing REI. I hadn't even considered pursuing an MBA part time while REI in another area, thanks Richard Martin. Did you find that your MBA education helped in REI?

  • Real Estate Investor · Bellingham, WA · Member since 2008 · 407 posts · 90 votes
    14y

    You can always get your MBA after you begin investing. You have a nice sum to start with properly leverage you will make a lot more than $63.5K per year.

  • Involved In Real Estate · Rochester Hills, MI · Member since 2010 · 812 posts · 178 votes
    14y

    Can't beat the ft. worth area. It is probably the opposite of New York, everything is cheap. Texas Arlington is right there and my buddy is going through his MBA there. He says its beneficial but he is a IT guy. Can't beat texas woman either.

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    14y

    Texas is a great market, if you can put up with wannabe cowboys. And I agree that a Texas gal is great to go riding with, several have been on my bikes...

    The best time to learn is when you are young and in the schooling mode, most adults who think they will go back don't ever do it, too busy, higher costs and less time for the education to payoff. Do it now!

    There are many successful folks in RE that don't havge any degree, mainly older guys like myself when it was not much of an issue starting out. Times have changed and I'm pretty sure other successful guys my age worked a heck of a lot harder than I did. My MBA was initially for having a leg up in the job market, but I was self employed early on, and what I found that was more practicle was the advantage gained in the quality of my life. Work smarter, not harder! Avoid big mistakes through better decission making.

    Many people think they are capable of thinking analytically, great problem solvers, etc. and may be talented in such aspects. College and an advance degree does not make you smarter it gives you a greater foundation to build from that frankly, others may not even grasp, not having experienced such an education. And I assure you, you will never get the same type of information from any guru book, bio of any person or internet site as you do from any specialized college program, that's not going to happen.

    Just my gut feeling, I'd consider the Austin or San Antonio area, especially the New Braunsfeld (sp?) near San Antonio area. I would think the hardest place in the country for a new investor would be in NYC, the place is over run with old land sharks with big bucks and limited opportunities, unless you want to work for one.

    Last comment, what you think you might do at 28 may not be what you will be doing at 48, we all mature and evolve. I'd suggest you have other marketable skills other than RE as RE is very cyclical, feast or famine unless you are very flexible and can play in various aspects of RE such as management, construction, development, finance and marketing, with a good education you can make a swift transition to any aspect of business. Good luck!

  • Lender · California and Florida · Member since 2008 · 319 posts · 194 votes
    14y

    Hi Scott, my background is in the arts and I lived in NYC for seven years. in between "gigs," I ended up working for a Wall Street firm doing acquisition and merger presentations and I loved it!

    Anyway, I moved back to LA because of some family health issues. My goal was to find a company that would help pay for the MBA. I found two. Ultimately, I ended up working for my Father's company in CA and I did get my MBA. I did a full time program. The craziest 2.5 years of my life. I really enjoyed the process and the network I now have.

    I think there may be a way for you to do everything you want. Might be harder to find, but worth a look.

  • Multi-family Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2012 · 30 posts · 6 votes
    14y

    Also this may be relevant information. I already have a BA in Psychology and BS in Biology. So,myself, family, and others question the need for another piece of paper...

    I am going to seriously look into opportunities in Texas, I've always wanted to live in a warmer climate and I enjoyed my time while I was traveling in Texas.

  • Real Estate Investor · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2009 · 191 posts · 47 votes
    14y

    We moved to find better cash flow in a city with a lower cost of living but moving is not for everyone.

    One suggestion is to look for awhile before you make your first purchase. You might try coming up with a timeline of sorts. You could research your city, other cities and MBA programs for the next 3-6 months. Give yourself a deadline and stick to it.

    Good luck with your decision making process. mck

  • Brian LevredgePro Member
    Investor · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 903 votes
    14y

    My .02 (and it may be worth less than that) comes from the perspective of already having an undergrad real estate degree. Personally, I don't think the MBA is worth it if you really want to get into real estate full time. Yes it can increase your future earning power, but at the same time there are trade offs to that as well. You will have more income but you will also pay more in taxes. That is in addition to extra time constraints which higher paying jobs usually demand. That all needs to be weighed against the decision. And of course there is all the added competition for limited spots (at both grad schools and in the work force) due to the state of the economy.

    You are in better shape than most people starting out since you have a good size amount of capital to work with. If you ultimately want to get into real estate, why not start now? It doesn't sound like there's really anything holding you back except, well, you. Plus, anything you can learn in grad school, you can pick up by buying the books they use to teach the courses. Those are significantly less than taking the class.

  • Investor · San Ramon, CA · Member since 2011 · 1k+ posts · 569 votes
    14y

    In NYC and not going to Stern huh? Boo! It's a good program, but definitely geared towards the Wall Street type.

    My 2 cents. Move, get a job that will pay for your MBA part time, and do real estate on the side once you get settled. Here's the rational.

    The sooner you move to your target area the sooner you start to learn it and the sooner you're comfortable pulling the trigger. Waiting until after you get your MBA just pushes things.

    Get your MBA in your target area. College is a tremendous way to network with people your own age. MBA programs by their very nature are going to have people around money. Bankers, accountants, financial analysts. These people have money, they control money, they are people you want to know and network with. People who get their MBA in NYC tend to stay there, if you move after you've graduated you will leave your entire network behind.

    Get your MBA while working. One big thing is having the company pay for it. Stern ran a little over $100 grand, nice company perk huh? Second, having that W2 will be HUGE in getting financing if you're looking to do buy and hold rentals. Far easier with a "real" job.

    Lastly, get the MBA. Why? Because it puts you on equal footing with the guy across the desk. When I walked into a bank to talk about a commercial loan I noticed he had printed out on his desk a copy of my LinkedIn profile and had highlighted my education. He didn't try to BS me, he knew I was financially as sophisticated as he was. An MBA enables you with a level of financial sophistication, a comfort with numbers and terms, that many don't possess. They may know everything about building and remodeling a house, but if they don't understand how to present financial information, they will always be limited. An MBA could empower you to go from modest to enormous in the long term.

    With all that said... get your stuff packed, throw a dart at the state of Texas, and set the GPS. Best of luck!

  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    14y
    Originally posted by Robert R.:
    Also this may be relevant information. I already have a BA in Psychology and BS in Biology. So,myself, family, and others question the need for another piece of paper...

    I am going to seriously look into opportunities in Texas, I've always wanted to live in a warmer climate and I enjoyed my time while I was traveling in Texas.

    Robert R.,

    Texas is not a warmer climate...IT IS HOT! All the time! Like you think your legs are going to melt when you sit in your car seat at the end of the day from April to September kind of hot! BTW, i get to say this because I was born and raised in Dallas, still have family there and invest in the Dallas/Ft Worth Metroplex.

    Make sure you visit Texas in the summer time before moving. It is definitely not for everyone, but that being said, several Texas markets are positioned excellent for real estate investors today.

    And...I vote for a real life education. Unfortunately, I am friends with a lot of MBA's who are stuck in mailrooms and waiting tables hoping for the next big hiring announcement. It is a tough road to hoe right now. Take your time as you noted and make a good choice.

  • Wholesaler · Chicago, IL · Member since 2011 · 219 posts · 38 votes
    14y

    My advice would be to first get familiar with the market you want to move to before you actually move. Start talking and networking with investors in the area and find out if its a good market to invest in and if there is good upside potential.

    Personally, I would forgo the MBA if you want to make a living in REI. If you want to work at a job the rest of your life, then an MBA is a good investment.

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    14y

    Interesting and now that I see you have other degrees I'll make a suggestion of food for thought.

    Have you considered being a corporate property manager? Not a large appartment complex but for a corporation like Kraft, GE, Pizza Hut, or Shoney's? They have people who manage existing properties and search for new locations in expanding markets. Some are traveling internationally and some stay pretty much at the office. An MBA will put you in 6 figures in such ventures.

    Your biology degree will be a great fit for several industries that have large real estate portfolios. Resurants, food preperations, chemical industries and probably oil and gas as well (considering the environmental impact issues).

    A complimentary aspect, you get paid to research other markets and areas for commercial properties and much of it applies to small investors as well. On your own you could then invest for yourself, you may find yourself in picking up small commercial properties from the overall knowledge gained on the job.

    Just a thought....

  • Investor · charlotte, NC · Member since 2012 · 121 posts · 21 votes
    14y

    Great topic.. i wanted to put my two cents in because you mentioned Zicklin and because this is a topic I debate with myself. (my debate is more of when I want to go back not if I should)
    - I actually just recently graduated zicklin. I didn't get an mba or an re degree I got another business grad degree. But in my program I had some room so I fit in two re classes. I did it right after my undergrad and had no real work experience. I did (well like to think i do) have some real estate knowledge and was a realtor the summer before it. Anyway, picking a school where you want to invest is something very important. I met alot of really great people. Including people who either worked for large real estate firms or whose family owned a ton of re throughout the city and other places. The two classes I took were real estates taxes and real estate law.
    real estate taxes- it was taught by a tax attorney who went to nyu law. We learned about 1031's(like kind exchanges) , calculating the mom and pop rules and making investment decisions based on taxes. (such as knowing how to depreciate things based on your future plans). Although I learned alot, some of it was way to complex for what I would be doing and the rest didn't click until I did a return for someone recently and started reading more on this site. I think it was really giving me training to go work for someone than it was to prepare me to invest for myself.(well this is what most educational facilities do) I think after working a few years it would have helped me more.

    real estate law- taught by a real estate law professor from Columbia. He worked in negotiating leases and contracts for large corporations. We learned alot about past events and history in terms of nyc real estate. We read through contracts and mortgage statements to understand them. I learned things, but I dont think someone whose starting out really needed that class. I learned the same things when I took my real estate salesperson course. And this site also offers you alot.

    - in terms of nyu- if that is even a consideration- look at the shack school of real estate. It is very well known for its real estate program. But it does have a commercial focus and is expensive.

    -lubin(pace) also has a reputable program.

    -zicklin- is great for its networking . Most of those people are out there in nyc doing these things everyday. But I met few actual investors. The rest worked for some firm. One investor I did know, who could easily have afforded nyu by the way, told me he actually learns most of his info from attending seminars and reading journals not by sitting in the classroom.

    - personally.. i think an mba is something i want to pursue after getting my re business going so that I can take it to the next level. Try to find someone in the programs that can give you the syllabus. I may have stuff laying around I could even give you. See if it even contains the type of info you actually want to learn.

    Just wanted to give you info because these are the questions I would have asked and since you mentioned zicklin. If I can be helpful let me know.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.