Moving my 401k to use for Real Estate Investing?

Moving my 401k to use for Real Estate Investing?

Member since 2022 · 18 posts · 4 votes

I have about 120k in my 401k and 100k in equity  at the moment and would like to use it towards real estate investments. I've been researching different services to move my 401k money , such as Whole life Insurance or a self directed ira. How would you go about moving 401k money over and into what and whats your opinions on the concept of using whole life insurance as infinte banking? 

Thank you!

2Reply
125 views

Most Popular Reply

Insurance Agent · Orinda, CA · Member since 2016 · 77 posts · 113 votes
4y
Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

@Ernesto Barragan JR

Be very careful with the whole life insurance. Don't simply rely on the illustration by the insurance agent. They typically make commissions equivalent to one year of your premium payments and have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart. If you know how to invest your money - whole life insurance is a rip off (it might work for those who have no idea how to invest or are unwilling to learn, so the forced saving component of the whole life insurance would provide them with so me benefits at the very high cost). 

Is the 401k with the current or past employer? If past - you are free to move that to a self-directed IRA. If current - you may not be able to access those funds at this time, contact your plan administrator and ask about "in-service distribution". 

You won't be able to combine your IRA investments with your personal investments (regardless if you are using equity in your home or savings). You need to have two separate plans: investing your retirement dollars and separately from that making personal investments.


It's not an either/or discussion. Life insurance is just another asset class. That means it's not an investment and shouldn't be compared to an investment. Having both investments and insurance is completely reasonable as part of an overall strategy.

Just like having investments and real estate is completely reasonable.

Having both investments and insurance will generally create better distribution outcomes in the future than either one can do by themselves.

See this reply in the discussion

36 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2021 · 3 posts · 3 votes
    4y

    Same questions with similar numbers

  • Insurance Agent · Orinda, CA · Member since 2016 · 77 posts · 113 votes
    4y

    Qualified plan money cannot be rolled into life insurance. You’d have to liquidate, pay the taxes and penalties, and pay life premiums with the after-tax money. 

    In addition to this, there are also some practical issues with trying to move a large lump sums into life insurance. The IRS rules around life insurance cash value create some significant tradeoffs. It’s possible but will require some time.

    Maybe consider rolling into a self-directed IRA. That would give you more control over what you can invest in.

  • Specialist · Grand Rapids, MI · Member since 2020 · 116 posts · 80 votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Good question! In order to move money from a 401k to WL, you’d have to pay all the taxes on it that you owe first, then it would go in after tax.

    I’ve designed many of these and I wouldn’t suggest using your 401k money for this. Use non-qualified assets.

    I’d be happy to run numbers if you like.

  • Specialist · Grand Rapids, MI · Member since 2020 · 116 posts · 80 votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    In addition to my other comment… you need to be careful not “MECing” the policy, which basically loses the tax benefits.

    It’s better to design a policy that put the funds in over time.

    It can still be the same amount of money, just over several years. You’d need to run numbers to make sure it doesn’t do this. It’s a very individualized product.

  • Specialist · Grand Rapids, MI · Member since 2020 · 116 posts · 80 votes
    4y

    @Satish Lakhapatri

    Check out my comments… delicate design to maintain the favorable tax status.

  • Investor · Scottsdale Austin Tuktoyaktuk · Member since 2021 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ernesto Barragan JR: 

    @Satish Lakhapatri:

    I have about 120k in my 401k and 100k in equity  at the moment and would like to use it towards real estate investments. I've been researching different services to move my 401k money , such as Whole life Insurance or a self directed ira. How would you go about moving 401k money over and into what and whats your opinions on the concept of using whole life insurance as infinte banking? 

    Thank you!

    I have investors getting 8% return who use their self directed IRAs to fund some of the projects I do. Their money is secured against real estate. That seems to be normal in the industry. 

    My understanding is that they can't touch the money or the profits themselves without a taxable event so they have to have a non-family member handle the transaction.
    I can point you to a company that sets those up if you don't have one already.
  • Investor · Broward County, FL · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 938 votes
    4y
    While you are still employed, many employers won't let you make an inservice rollover out of your 401k. If you leave the company, you can then either keep the 401k or rollover to another 401k or IRA. You can also borrow up to $50k out of your 401k at anytime but it has to be repaid over five years with interest, and you can not deduct the interest. And if you leave the company during these five years, you will have to repay it immediately.

    Self directed IRA have more limitations than solo 401k. So if you have your own side business (even a very small one), it is often suggested to open a solo 401k for that business and use it to be the recipient of the rollover. That will give you much more flexibility.

    Permanent life insurances have to be funded with after tax money. They are an excellent but complex vehicle, and IUL are often called the "rich man Roth IRA" as they have no upper limit on contribution. They are often misunderstood and need a proper execution to make them excellent. A poor implementation will give dismal result. Many financial advisors can't understand them and are preaching against them making grand statements proving they are confused.
  • Solo 401k Expert · Anaheim Hills, CA · Member since 2012 · 18k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Be very careful with the whole life insurance. Don't simply rely on the illustration by the insurance agent. They typically make commissions equivalent to one year of your premium payments and have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart. If you know how to invest your money - whole life insurance is a rip off (it might work for those who have no idea how to invest or are unwilling to learn, so the forced saving component of the whole life insurance would provide them with so me benefits at the very high cost). 

    Is the 401k with the current or past employer? If past - you are free to move that to a self-directed IRA. If current - you may not be able to access those funds at this time, contact your plan administrator and ask about "in-service distribution". 

    You won't be able to combine your IRA investments with your personal investments (regardless if you are using equity in your home or savings). You need to have two separate plans: investing your retirement dollars and separately from that making personal investments.

  • Insurance Agent · Orinda, CA · Member since 2016 · 77 posts · 113 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Be very careful with the whole life insurance. Don't simply rely on the illustration by the insurance agent. They typically make commissions equivalent to one year of your premium payments and have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart. If you know how to invest your money - whole life insurance is a rip off (it might work for those who have no idea how to invest or are unwilling to learn, so the forced saving component of the whole life insurance would provide them with so me benefits at the very high cost). 

    Is the 401k with the current or past employer? If past - you are free to move that to a self-directed IRA. If current - you may not be able to access those funds at this time, contact your plan administrator and ask about "in-service distribution". 

    You won't be able to combine your IRA investments with your personal investments (regardless if you are using equity in your home or savings). You need to have two separate plans: investing your retirement dollars and separately from that making personal investments.


    It's not an either/or discussion. Life insurance is just another asset class. That means it's not an investment and shouldn't be compared to an investment. Having both investments and insurance is completely reasonable as part of an overall strategy.

    Just like having investments and real estate is completely reasonable.

    Having both investments and insurance will generally create better distribution outcomes in the future than either one can do by themselves.

  • Rental Property Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ernesto Barragan JR:

    I have about 120k in my 401k and 100k in equity  at the moment and would like to use it towards real estate investments. I've been researching different services to move my 401k money , such as Whole life Insurance or a self directed ira. How would you go about moving 401k money over and into what and whats your opinions on the concept of using whole life insurance as infinte banking? 

    Thank you!


    We moved my wife's into a self-directed IRA account. We have not used it yet because we would rather just do a refinance but it is always an option there.

  • Investor · Broward County, FL · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 938 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    They have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart.


    Do not trust any financial advisor, they have a vested interest to manage your money. They don't have your interest at heart...

    Do not trust any real estate agent, they have a vested interest to sell you the most expensive house. They don't have your interest at heart.... They are making a 3% commission on the sale of the house for just driving you there...

    Please don't generalize by making such broad statement. Yes there are unscrupulous people in each profession, but saying a whole profession is unethical because a few of their members are is ridiculous.

    An optimized overfunded permanent life insurance policy give less commission to the insurance agent as he or she is tweaking it to give the best return to the owner by lowering all the fee, including his/her commission.

    The long term IRR of an optimized whole life insurance is in the 3-5% range; The long term IRR of an optimized Index Universal Life insurance is typically in the 5-8% range.

    Yes it is not excellent compared to some 10-20% IRR you can get with real estate, but you have to remember that it is also tax free (so a few percent more to compare apple to apple). It is asset protected, it is liquid, it does not go down. On top of that, you also have a life insurance in case you die early.

    Last but not least, you can use the cash value as collateral for a bank loan at sub prime rate, and reinvest that money to outside investments while deducting the interest cost. So your money works at two places at the same time. By combining the two, your returns are higher than if you were only investing without the life insurance in the middle.

  • Specialist · Grand Rapids, MI · Member since 2020 · 116 posts · 80 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Be very careful with the whole life insurance. Don't simply rely on the illustration by the insurance agent. They typically make commissions equivalent to one year of your premium payments and have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart. If you know how to invest your money - whole life insurance is a rip off (it might work for those who have no idea how to invest or are unwilling to learn, so the forced saving component of the whole life insurance would provide them with so me benefits at the very high cost). 

    Is the 401k with the current or past employer? If past - you are free to move that to a self-directed IRA. If current - you may not be able to access those funds at this time, contact your plan administrator and ask about "in-service distribution". 

    You won't be able to combine your IRA investments with your personal investments (regardless if you are using equity in your home or savings). You need to have two separate plans: investing your retirement dollars and separately from that making personal investments.

     I agree with @John Perrings.  I own both an insurance agency and am a TPA for 401k plans, defined benefit plans, etc.

    CV life insurance, if designed correctly, has many benefits outside of what the balance is at the end.  If designed properly for cash value growth, the commissions are lessened considerably than someone who doesn't understand how to design a policy.

    I CV life insurance quite often for Deferred Compensation Plans for business owners as well due to the tax benefits for the employER.  

    On another note, if you're using it for REI, than the real value is the RE on its own.

    And if you're filing a Schedule E as a REI, then your income doesn't qualify for 401k contributions anyhow.

  • Insurance Agent · all 50 states · Member since 2022 · 184 posts · 122 votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR you just asked the question that every insurance agent and financial manager are going to fight over...  

    The insurance guys have all these products that are really awesome and can do some amazing things... I even like MEC's, but you have to have an agent that is knowledgeable in wealth management and growth.  One that is willing to work with you and the insurance carrier to make sure that the policies are properly funded and that you don't have on of the horror stories that investment managers like to talk about.  

    The argument from both sides goes like this... 

    The financial managers say that insurance agents get paid on huge commissions and that the policies/contracts that we offer don't perform well and that any decent investment manager can out perform what an insurance policy will do.  

    Insurance agents say that if you look at the lifetime return of an insurance product when properly set up and funded it will be on par with almost any mutual fund at year 15. By year 20 the insurance cost basis is much cheaper.  Insurance products are front loaded for fees so as a short term play insurance is definitely terrible.  Insurance is a long term play, and it is one that when done right you still have access to your money so that you can use it to invest in other places.

  • Accountant · Edina, MN · Member since 2020 · 172 posts · 97 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Aaron Porter:

    @Ernesto Barragan JR you just asked the question that every insurance agent and financial manager are going to fight over...  

    The insurance guys have all these products that are really awesome and can do some amazing things... I even like MEC's, but you have to have an agent that is knowledgeable in wealth management and growth.  One that is willing to work with you and the insurance carrier to make sure that the policies are properly funded and that you don't have on of the horror stories that investment managers like to talk about.  

    The argument from both sides goes like this... 

    The financial managers say that insurance agents get paid on huge commissions and that the policies/contracts that we offer don't perform well and that any decent investment manager can out perform what an insurance policy will do.  

    Insurance agents say that if you look at the lifetime return of an insurance product when properly set up and funded it will be on par with almost any mutual fund at year 15. By year 20 the insurance cost basis is much cheaper.  Insurance products are front loaded for fees so as a short term play insurance is definitely terrible.  Insurance is a long term play, and it is one that when done right you still have access to your money so that you can use it to invest in other places.


     Well said - it helps to consider taxes as well. Capital gains on investments and ordinary income on withdrawals. Insurance is tax free growth. Nothing is one size fits all but nothing is as bad as some make it out to seem.

  • Member since 2018 · 6 posts · 0 votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Have you thought of private lenders?

  • Member since 2022 · 18 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @John Perrings:
    Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Be very careful with the whole life insurance. Don't simply rely on the illustration by the insurance agent. They typically make commissions equivalent to one year of your premium payments and have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart. If you know how to invest your money - whole life insurance is a rip off (it might work for those who have no idea how to invest or are unwilling to learn, so the forced saving component of the whole life insurance would provide them with so me benefits at the very high cost). 

    Is the 401k with the current or past employer? If past - you are free to move that to a self-directed IRA. If current - you may not be able to access those funds at this time, contact your plan administrator and ask about "in-service distribution". 

    You won't be able to combine your IRA investments with your personal investments (regardless if you are using equity in your home or savings). You need to have two separate plans: investing your retirement dollars and separately from that making personal investments.


    It's not an either/or discussion. Life insurance is just another asset class. That means it's not an investment and shouldn't be compared to an investment. Having both investments and insurance is completely reasonable as part of an overall strategy.

    Just like having investments and real estate is completely reasonable.

    Having both investments and insurance will generally create better distribution outcomes in the future than either one can do by themselves.


     Whats your opinion on the concept of Infinite Banking through whole life insurance?

  • Member since 2022 · 18 posts · 4 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Steven Foster Wilson:
    Quote from @Ernesto Barragan JR:

    I have about 120k in my 401k and 100k in equity  at the moment and would like to use it towards real estate investments. I've been researching different services to move my 401k money , such as Whole life Insurance or a self directed ira. How would you go about moving 401k money over and into what and whats your opinions on the concept of using whole life insurance as infinte banking? 

    Thank you!


    We moved my wife's into a self-directed IRA account. We have not used it yet because we would rather just do a refinance but it is always an option there.


    If you do plan on using your self directed IRA do you loan yourself the money or are you liquidating the account when you withdraw?

  • Solo 401k Expert · Anaheim Hills, CA · Member since 2012 · 18k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    It is not possible to take a loan from an IRA.

    If you wish to invest using self-directed IRA - you don't need to withdraw the funds, you buy real estate inside of the IRA. IRA owns the property, not you. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2014 · 19 posts · 9 votes
    4y

    Call Vantage IRA! vehicles to borrow against your IRA to buy real estate.

  • Insurance Agent · Orinda, CA · Member since 2016 · 77 posts · 113 votes
    4y

     I do IBC myself and help others set it up in their lives every day. So I guess you could say I’m a big fan 🙂

  • Investor · Broward County, FL · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 938 votes
    4y
    I am using the same concept but with Index Universal Life Insurance instead. Better return on the long term than Whole Life but with more volatility year to year.
  • Insurance Agent · all 50 states · Member since 2022 · 184 posts · 122 votes
    4y

    @Ernesto Barragan JR the infinite banking strategy is a great strategy that has many pros.  there are cons as well... you need to work with an agent that is well versed in setting up these policies as they can be set up wrong.  That is where the horror stories about life insurance policies imploding and falling apart or not performing as advertised.  according to my mentor there is less than 1% of life insurance agents that have done the homework, and have the understanding of how to set up and manage a "infinite banking policy".  So getting to know and understand the policies and making sure that your agent properly explains how these policies can and should be used is imperative to the policy staying in good standing and you the client/owner of the policy being able to use the policy in the way it is intended.

  • Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 888 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ernesto Barragan JR:

    I have about 120k in my 401k and 100k in equity  at the moment and would like to use it towards real estate investments. I've been researching different services to move my 401k money , such as Whole life Insurance or a self directed ira. How would you go about moving 401k money over and into what and whats your opinions on the concept of using whole life insurance as infinte banking? 

    Thank you!


    If you are still working with the company you might be able to get a loan on against your 401k, and that would be the easiest option as you could do a BRRR and pay back the loan. If you aren't a self directed could be an option but with 120k you really are limited on acquiring properties, however could lend on rehabs. With Self directed getting loans is more difficult and you owe taxes on the leveraged portion, and is more complicated than I like. I just pulled out funds and payed the penalties early this year. While to some that was a bad move given how the market has performed this year vs my property I am ok with my decision.

    For Infinite banking it sounds nice, but more complex and time consuming than just making money the ways I know. I like to keep things simple and easy; staying to what works for me.

  • Financial Advisor · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2015 · 834 posts · 799 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ernesto Barragan JR:
    Quote from @John Perrings:
    Quote from @Dmitriy Fomichenko:

    @Ernesto Barragan JR

    Be very careful with the whole life insurance. Don't simply rely on the illustration by the insurance agent. They typically make commissions equivalent to one year of your premium payments and have a vested interest selling the policy to you, they do not have your interest at heart. If you know how to invest your money - whole life insurance is a rip off (it might work for those who have no idea how to invest or are unwilling to learn, so the forced saving component of the whole life insurance would provide them with so me benefits at the very high cost). 

    Is the 401k with the current or past employer? If past - you are free to move that to a self-directed IRA. If current - you may not be able to access those funds at this time, contact your plan administrator and ask about "in-service distribution". 

    You won't be able to combine your IRA investments with your personal investments (regardless if you are using equity in your home or savings). You need to have two separate plans: investing your retirement dollars and separately from that making personal investments.


    It's not an either/or discussion. Life insurance is just another asset class. That means it's not an investment and shouldn't be compared to an investment. Having both investments and insurance is completely reasonable as part of an overall strategy.

    Just like having investments and real estate is completely reasonable.

    Having both investments and insurance will generally create better distribution outcomes in the future than either one can do by themselves.


     Whats your opinion on the concept of Infinite Banking through whole life insurance?

     The idea of leveraging the cash value of a life insurance policy was covered in depth in this BP discussion:

    https://www.biggerpockets.com/...

    If you are thinking seriously about it, I'd read through as much as you can take. The thread was pretty old when I first chimed in and it is still ongoing.

    I think that it is important to get the idea of "Infinite Banking" out of your head. That's a trademarked "system". You should understand that leveraging the cash value to invest in real estate is different than simply treating a policy's cash value as a substitute for a credit card. This means that you want a policy that has as much cash value as legally possible right from day one. Most IBC policies are not Maximum Over-funded. The agents leave room for you to add more premium later under the guise of "paying yourself interest" And as @Mike S. states above, it can be done with either Whole Life or Indexed Universal Life. Much of what you'll hear is simply unsupported propaganda.

  • Specialist · Grand Rapids, MI · Member since 2020 · 116 posts · 80 votes
    4y

    @Mike S.

    Whole life is a more conservative approach.

    I’ve designed them with both, and it’s hard to compete with the IUL. The concept with Whole Life is that you’ll invest in RE and get a higher ROR in the outside investments.

    So Whole Life is basically a lending play.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.