Have been looking at a few properties but haven't been able to make the leap yet. Hard to part with money in the bank and get into another mortgage.
That said, our position is good. Plenty of cash - I have around $50-$75K I'm willing to put into my first investment property. Currently looking at duplexes/4-plexes in older, trendy neighborhoods in the 150-250K range. Not looking to flip. Just buy, have rental income defray mortgage, and hold long-term.
How do I overcome this odd paralysis?
Tall......Ya you can get positive cash flow from SFH. Here's how. You buy in small towns or small cities. But the problem is that the positive cash flow is like a couple of hundred bucks. That's not cash flow in my opinion. I wouldn't touch anything making less than 5k per month liquid. And I'm starting to thinking 10k minimum might be better. Like even if your property is making 1k per month in liquid cash that's "fair" but it's even "good". Like what the heck can you buy with 1k. Basically nothing. So no, SFH are not the way to go by any stretch of the imagination. There's no cash flow.
The answer......no, no and no.
No appreciation isn't completely a result of rental increases. If it was I wouldn't be selling my building for 1 million dollars more than I paid for it last year. Because the rents have not gone up that much. The market dictates the prices, not what the rent is. Some markets appreciate faster as we all know. However, rent is one factor of the whole equation. But people sometimes put too much emphasis on it. Yes rents will go up by $50 bucks a year easy. Thats' just two rent increases of $25 bucks each. Is a tenant going to complain and or move based on that? I doubt it. Here most people are raising rents by $100 or more per year. In the city near here, Calgary many rents have doubled virtually overnight.
Mike....why don't you think my numbers work?
$15k gross rent
+ $400 laundry
less 40% expenses = $9400k
- $4200 first
= $5200 left with 25% down.
With a second then you'd be left with less. Possibly $3000 with nothing down. Plus about $4k that's about 5% appreciation per month. So you're left with around anywhere from $7k per month with nothign down, to somewhere in the range of $9200 with 25% down.
Then factor in over the next five years, rent increases and you're only looking at upside. But you'd better just stick with houses. Leave more buildings for me. Leaves more houses for you. ;-)
R2d246,
Just as I said, you're playing fast and loose with the numbers. In your original post, you said that you would have $5,000 per month cash flow with 10% down. Now, you are saying that it will cash flow $5,000 per month with 25% down. In a prior post, you admitted that operating expense are typically 45% to 50%, but now you're somehow running it at 40%. Some expenses are apparently vanishing into thin air. You're just changing the numbers with reckless disregard to the truth. There is no reality here, just fantasy and speculation.
You are also planning on increasing the rents 10% per year and counting on a lot of appreciation, both of which are very optimistic projections. You seem to be operating on the premise that the bubble environment of the past few years will continue into the future. That is very risky thinking.
FYI, I have both SFHs and apartment buildings. That's the reason that I know the reality of the business, while you are just making things up.
If you're going to be in the rental business, you need to at least understand the basics.
Mike
Mike...let me guess you don't own any apartments do you. Are you even a millionaire? Because you're trying to lecture a multi-millionaire, and I didn't do it via SFH's that's for sure.
Okay, I'll admit, I am playing fast and loose with the numbers, and that's exactly how I like to play it. I like to play fast and loose and make lots of money doing it, I'm guilty! I could care less about the numbers. All I ever need to know is like 3 sets of numbers which are:
The purchase price, and price per door.
The mortgage amount and payment and rate.
Rough idea of the expenses. (40-50% of gross)
Here's the thing. I use to be like you. I use to be overly concerned about having the numbers add up perfectly. However, then I started to realize more and more that it won't matter. The numbers will always take care of themselves and I need not worry about them. It's the economics of scale that matter the most.
Even if you buy an apartment building at break even cash flow, which would be really crazy, but even if you did, that just means you're 1 rental increase away from positive cash flow. And when you factor in appreciation, mortgage paydown, depreciation of the asset etc etc...then over time that property will start to make more and more money.
In the end the number of units you control, being that they're cash flow positive, will ultimately shape your financial future. Remember you can't get rich on your own money. You need OPM. The way to do that is by leverage. Which is why I was saying to the fellow to leverage that $75k into $750k of good debt.
I was doing some calculations and in about 3 months once I close on 3 buildings I'm working on my net worth will start to increase at the rate of about $100k per month. Do I need to know precisely to the penny, no. The rough numbers will do, because the numbers always take care of themselves. And this done using apartments as the vehicle, you cannot do this with SFH. You'd have to own hundreds of them to pull that off, and the economics of scale wouldn't work because you'd have to buy hundreds of homes and manage thousands of headaches. I just could not see the ecomonics of that being an easy reality for the novice person pulling it off. And even if that was true that would mean you'd have to purchase hundreds of homes. That could take years and years. This is a dead issue. Ask any successful millionaire realestate investor what works better, SFH's or Apartments, and most if not all would say Apartment buildigns. If you really think you can get rich off SFH's and you're own money, be my guest. If you want to buy SFH's go ahead, leaves me with more apartments to buy, leaves you with more SFH's.
That's the single most ridiculous statement I've ever seen written. The numbers don't matter - they'll always take care of themselves! Who are you kidding? I've got to tell you that I am always suspicious of anyone who claims to be rich but doesn't even understand the basics of the business.
How is anyone to evaluate a statement like that. Since your numbers are all over the place, it's tough to tell. Will your net worth really increase $100K per month or is it $10K per month or maybe only $1K per month? According to you, the numbers don't matter, they will always work themselves out.
For the record, I never said that anyone should only invest in SFHs. In fact, I said very clearly that I have both SFHs and apartment buildings. My point was that it is smart to START with SFHs and learn the business. Then, using sound business principles, expand at a controlled rate and in a sustainable manner.
You apparently are treating real estate investing like a spin of the roulette wheel. That is your choice. I am in the rental business and am running my operation as a business.
Mike
Mike....what I meant by that statement was that once you get a building and it's cashflowing each month, then what does it matter. Of course you have to know what it's generating. But once you set it, you can forget it. And just reap the rewards. Thats' why I'm just suggesting that he set up the right investment where he can forget it, and not have to ever worry about digging into his own pocket to cover a mortgage payment.
No the numbers don't matter to me anymore. Once you make enough money what does matter. Calculating to the penny only matters when you don't have as much to work with. As long as I have the approximate numbers I'm fine with that. And ya when it's time to buy I do crunch the numbers, but what's the point when where just shooting the **** on here. And the three new buildings will be netting approximately $50,000 per month. Added to the buildings and business I have I'll end up with $100k per month.
Listen, you and I just have two different styles of play in the same game. But it's not about us. It's about this guy who has $75,000 and wants to make the most of it.
If he learns to buy a house and rent it out, that's exactly what he'll learn. If he buys an apartment building and learns to run it, then that will become he's skill set and experience. Which is more valuable? I could teach my dog how to buy a house and rent it out. He's only got $75k to work with. So why not put it in what will reap the most rewards in terms of both cash flow and experience. This is a fully grown man. He's not a kid who needs to be potty trained.
How do you know his income would even support him a rental house goes vacant for a few months if someone bails on him? Where's the income to support that mortgage payment? At least with an apartment you'd never have the whole apartment go vacant. At worst maybe 5 or 10%, but you'd still cash flow on most average deals. And if you keep on top of things you could run it with very little vacancy. If you really own do apartments then you know this.
Okay so you're saying he should buy a house and learn the ropes? And that's suppose to mean less maintenance, less headaches, and less risk? But less rewards.
I'm saying go for apartments, perhaps more issues, more headaches, but far more rewards. And the rewards are not even in the cash flow of the building, the experience of learning to do so is far more valuable. The main reward is just buying that first one and then having the confidence and knowledge to continue buying more of them. Also you might have more issues that will come up, but I think that there's far less risk because like I said, if someone bails on you it's no big deal. You can re rent the unit still pay your mortgage and still have cash flow. Where as with a house, if someone bails then you have to come up with the mortgage payment out of your own pocket. Far more risky in my opinion.
We just have two different contrasting views. I just don't see how putting your funds into a house is anything to get excited about. The money you make at the end of each month is not even worth the headache of owning the place.
P.S.: To the fellow who started all this....If you do decide to buy a SFH, then let me introduce you to my dog, he'll show you what to do.