Am I getting in over my head? 馃槵

Am I getting in over my head? 馃槵

Member since 2017 路 3 posts 路 0 votes

Hi all! I'm sorry if this is long and confusing. I am new at this. 

I own a condo in Mililani, HI, that I bought in September 2015 and currently live in. It's financed via a HELOC (popular thing here in Hawaii), and I have a decent amount of equity in it, about $150,000, with $50,000 available to use.

I am considering buying a small studio here, a leasehold for $165k (cheap for Hawaii), with a very low lease fee until 2078. I plan to move to the second place for a time (it is much closer to my current job), and rent out the first (already have a property manager lined up). I would put $16k down on the new studio using some of the equity from my condo.

Here is the complication. My job is flexible and allows me the option of working remotely. My whole family is in New Hampshire, and my dad is currently in a nuesing home with dementia, so I'd like to move closer to home for a year or so, starting later this year. I'd also like to use my VA loan to buy a home in New Hampshire, since that's where I plan to eventually live permanently. My VA loan is 100% available, and would remain so even if I bought the studio here in Hawaii.

Question - is it unwise to buy the second place in Hawaii? I want to get it mainly as a place for me to come back to for my job from time to time, but ultimately as a second rental property. However, I don't want to jeopardize my chance of being approved for a VA home loan in New Hampshire. My income is good, about $85k not including rental income, but that would be about $500k of debt hanging over me. Both places would hopefully be rented while I'm gone (for a total of about $3800k per month), and I do have an over two year history of getting rental income from my condo (I've been renting out the extra bedrooms). However, I don't want to end up in the position of having both places in Hawaii, but being unable to qualify for a $300k or so VA mortgage in New Hampshire because of the debt to income ratio.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

0Reply
36 views

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender 路 Salem, NH 路 Member since 2014 路 46 posts 路 23 votes
    7y

    Hi @Account Closed,

    Its tough to say without seeing your entire financial picture, but in general, I think you would be better off looking to get the primary residence set up in NH first, using the VA loan.

    Regardless of how much income is on the application it can be tough to qualify for a new mortgage, with two other mortgage payments in the mix. Since you have lived in your current home for a little while, most lenders will be able to offset that mortgage payment if you get a 12 month lease signed prior to moving out. With the other property being recently acquired, they are likely going to have to "hit" your debt to income ratio for that full payment which could hinder your qualification.  


    There are also "reserve" requirements that pop up when you have multiple financed properties, which require a certain amount in your accounts AFTER closing,  that only get more intense the more properties you have.  

    If your number 1 goal is to get into a place in NH closer to family, I would recommend looking into that prior to purchasing second HI property. 

    Let me know if I can help out in any way. 

    Thanks! 

  • Greg GaudetPro Member
    Investor 路 Pukalani, HI 路 Member since 2017 路 414 posts 路 291 votes
    7y

    If both properties produce positive cash flow (which you probably shouldn't buy unless they do), then your DTI should not be hurt by purchasing the condo. Maybe it will hurt your DTI short term, for the first year or two, but once you show that rental income on two years of tax returns it will improve your DTI.

    I'm dealing with that right now, after buying 5 rentals in my first year I need to watch my DTI carefully. But I was just approved for a heloc on the last unit I bought and they reported my DTI at 24% without counting my rental income. Heloc and mortgage underwriters calculate DTI differently, actually almost every bank will calculate it differently so there's no one answer. Mostly I'd say talk to your lender at length. In fact, don't talk to your lender... talk to Darren Au at Primary Lending (he's on Oahu). His cell is 228-6610 and he'll text you back within seconds at all hours of the day and night. His service is unbelievable, and he's also an investor. I can't say enough good stuff about the guy, seriously. Plus I believe the banks cover his fee, so getting his extra level of service shouldn't cost you anything (double check with him).

    You might also want to just refi the condo into a traditional loan before you buy your next unit. 

    Last thing, make sure you find out when the leasehold renegotiation date is. If it's coming up soon you might want to look into that and see if lease rents are expected to increase, as they usually do. 

  • Investor 路 Kaneohe, HI 路 Member since 2015 路 91 posts 路 36 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    Hi all! I'm sorry if this is long and confusing. I am new at this. 

    I own a condo in Mililani, HI, that I bought in September 2015 and currently live in. It's financed via a HELOC (popular thing here in Hawaii), and I have a decent amount of equity in it, about $150,000, with $50,000 available to use.

    I am considering buying a small studio here, a leasehold for $165k (cheap for Hawaii), with a very low lease fee until 2078. I plan to move to the second place for a time (it is much closer to my current job), and rent out the first (already have a property manager lined up). I would put $16k down on the new studio using some of the equity from my condo.

    Here is the complication. My job is flexible and allows me the option of working remotely. My whole family is in New Hampshire, and my dad is currently in a nuesing home with dementia, so I'd like to move closer to home for a year or so, starting later this year. I'd also like to use my VA loan to buy a home in New Hampshire, since that's where I plan to eventually live permanently. My VA loan is 100% available, and would remain so even if I bought the studio here in Hawaii.

    Question - is it unwise to buy the second place in Hawaii? I want to get it mainly as a place for me to come back to for my job from time to time, but ultimately as a second rental property. However, I don't want to jeopardize my chance of being approved for a VA home loan in New Hampshire. My income is good, about $85k not including rental income, but that would be about $500k of debt hanging over me. Both places would hopefully be rented while I'm gone (for a total of about $3800k per month), and I do have an over two year history of getting rental income from my condo (I've been renting out the extra bedrooms). However, I don't want to end up in the position of having both places in Hawaii, but being unable to qualify for a $300k or so VA mortgage in New Hampshire because of the debt to income ratio.

    Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

     what part of the island is this property with 59 years left on the leasehold interest?

  • Rental Property Investor 路 Hollis, NH 路 Member since 2018 路 108 posts 路 36 votes
    7y

    @Account Closed Sounds like you have a some touch choices. HI and NH are my two favorite places, for very different reasons (VT is in there too)! 

    If in your shoes I guess I would try to understand how stressful the situation may be in nh with a family member being ill. If things don't go well after moving to NH and you start to feel more stress, can you easily deal with the 2 places in HI? You may be setting yourself up for some added stress on top of what may already be a stressful situation. Only you know the situation and how you may react, but something to consider I think. 

    Best of luck!

    Rick

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.