Bad idea to start investing out of state during Covid?

Bad idea to start investing out of state during Covid?

Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 3 votes

Live in HCOL CA. Trying to find a better plan than pouring most of my savings (170K) into down payment for a 650K House I am currently pre-approved for while living with parents.

What would be the biggest obstacles or risk to buying 1 or 2 rental houses (or a duplex) that cash flows in a lower cost of living region? Would likely need to pay for property manager. I see the obvious risk of becoming first time landlord during instable economic times with high unemployment. Also, the markets I like are relatively less expensive than mine, but not the best cash flow like Mid-West. Mainly, because I would like to invest somewhere I already like and relocate to in future (Nashville, Orlando, Charleston). I can find a nice house in these places for 300K but probably not the wisest investment and would still eat up a good chunk of my savings for 20%+ down payment.

I am newbie and barely contacting lenders and figuring out if I would be qualify for a second home (On Title for my Parent Townhouse) vs. investment property.

Just trying to make the smartest move for long term wealth building.

0Reply
36 views

Most Popular Reply

Jonathan GreeneBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Madison, NJ · Member since 2016 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
6y

What makes you think that investing in a single-family home where you live won't earn more in appreciation over the next three years than investing out-of-state in rental units that you will pay people to manage and/or flip? The problem with all of the advice out there is that it is over-focused on doors and numbers and how many you have. The best investments I've made in my life, and the most money I've made on them, has been buying single-family homes to live in and slowly working on them and upgrading them while I was able to enjoy the amenities and then selling when the home had hit peak marketability. When I spend five years waiting and then clear 200k, I am happy with that and the stress-level is much less than managing five out-of-state rentals all making a very average amount of month until a furnace breaks or a roof caves in. Do you need cash flow or does everything in these boards make you think you need cash flow? If you think about investing as a whole, long-term investing, when you can also get enjoyment out of something, is not something to ignore.

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Property Manager · Lindenhurst, IL · Member since 2016 · 854 posts · 506 votes
    6y

    While both your personal goal (live out of state) and your investment goal (invest out of state) involve out of state, I think it's better to separate those two. Invest in properties that make financial sense to you, and buy a house (in the future) in the place that makes sense to you to live. That way, you should end up with more money, and you can use it to buy your personal home in the future. Also, if you buy your personal home in Nashville thinking you'll live there in x years, but if things change and you no longer want to live there, now you have potentially a mediocre rental in Nashville.

  • Jonathan GreeneBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Madison, NJ · Member since 2016 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    6y

    What makes you think that investing in a single-family home where you live won't earn more in appreciation over the next three years than investing out-of-state in rental units that you will pay people to manage and/or flip? The problem with all of the advice out there is that it is over-focused on doors and numbers and how many you have. The best investments I've made in my life, and the most money I've made on them, has been buying single-family homes to live in and slowly working on them and upgrading them while I was able to enjoy the amenities and then selling when the home had hit peak marketability. When I spend five years waiting and then clear 200k, I am happy with that and the stress-level is much less than managing five out-of-state rentals all making a very average amount of month until a furnace breaks or a roof caves in. Do you need cash flow or does everything in these boards make you think you need cash flow? If you think about investing as a whole, long-term investing, when you can also get enjoyment out of something, is not something to ignore.

  • Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 3 votes
    6y

    @Soh Tanaka

    Thank you for insight! Sounds like great advice, especially considering I am a medical provider and Wife is a nurse.

    We can likely maximize our income in a different city/state and invest wherever that makes the most sense. Thanks!

  • Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 3 votes
    6y

    @Jonathan Greene

    Wow thanks awesome points.

    I have never actually sat down and ran the numbers to compare longterm expected appreciation growth in a HCOL area to the potential yearly accrued savings from buying multiple cheaper properties out of state with all the added costs,stress, and time cost more than anything. You are right on about the over-focus on buying as many doors and cash flow. At 34, I am maxing out my 401K and mostly interested in long term wealth building and diversifying.

    I am fairly risk averse so am also looking at turnkey investment companies to put 15-20K in a safe, if less profitable long term side investment.

    Really appreciate your experience!

  • Real Estate Agent · Oklahoma City, OK · Member since 2019 · 956 posts · 600 votes
    6y

    @Ruben Esparza Aaron Chapman with Security National can help you lending wise regardless of the market you land he. He's in every state and has competitive rates. He also does a high volume and has been in the game for a long time so he can help you strategize. I can't post contact info but if you're unable to reach him just let me know and I can make an intro. 

    For safety during corona you could approve your property for section 8 applicants so that at least some of your payment is guaranteed. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.