Financial Advisor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 19 posts · 3 votes
I am evaluating different turnkey providers and running my own pro-forma numbers. What I'm trying to get a handle on is what market value the property tax is based off - the pre-rehab value the provider paid or the post-rehab value the investor would pay.
One thing that seems consistent across several I've looked at is it seems to me the property tax assumptions most of them are using seem too low, which makes me think they are basing it off prior tax years (when the property was not rehabbed). So if I buy it and the property value is much higher, I need to bake into my assumptions a higher tax.
If so, this seems misleading on the providers estimated numbers.
Yup. Most of the pro formas use the current tax which is before rehab and sale. Your taxes will be based on your purchase price. So factor that in. Amongst a whole bunch of other undercounted and over optimistic assumptions in your typical pro forma! Better yet, ignore the pro forma all together and do your own analysis.
I'm not familiar with turnkey providers, but sometimes the property taxes don't change. First do you nderstand how property taxes are derived? See one of my posts below:
so, if you never have to pull a permit and you are in State that doesn't set the assessment on a sale/transfer price the property tax just may not change. I'm sure it varies across the country, but generally you can paint redo the floors, patch sheetrock, change windows, and remodel kitchen and baths all without a permit. The local assessor will never know that a complete remodel was redone. If you aren't moving walls around, moving electrical or plumbing, you generally don't need a permit.
Just some food for thought.. If you are looking in CA then you know you'll have to recalc the taxes for the purchase price, but that is pretty straightforward As for the providers, its the usual caveat emptor. Its too bad, but you can never really trust anybody.
@Keith Stempel, base it on the purchase price. It may take a while to catch up, but it will. If you don’t calculate it this way, you will likely get burned. Happened to me a couple times in Memphis, even though they supposedly only reassess every 4 years
@Mark S. out of curiousity, how did you get screwed in Memphis?
@Keith Stempel I looked up TN. They are interesting as they have a statutory deduction by property type. Their site even specifically states that if the fair market value is determined to be $100k, then a residential property's assessed value is $25k (residential has a 25% factor). So, depending on where you are looking, the assessed values are artificially low by statute.
@David M., did I say I got screwed? The turnkey providers generally use current property taxes rates based on current figures, not based on sales price to investor.
Oh sorry, I was referring to your post saying: "...you will likely get burned. Happened to me a couple times in Memphis..." So how did you get "burned" was what I was curious about. Sorry for the confusion on my part.
Yup. Most of the pro formas use the current tax which is before rehab and sale. Your taxes will be based on your purchase price. So factor that in. Amongst a whole bunch of other undercounted and over optimistic assumptions in your typical pro forma! Better yet, ignore the pro forma all together and do your own analysis.