Move to new PM? Sell? Looking for advice on Memphis SFH rental

Move to new PM? Sell? Looking for advice on Memphis SFH rental

Patrick GiblinPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes

I am an out of state investor I have a SFH rental I purchased 5 years ago from a large, turn key operator, who has continued to PM the property, located in Memphis within the 38118 area code. It was renting for $1495, up until tenant move out in July, purchased for $160k in 2021, 4 beds, 2.5 baths

I've worked hard to keep tabs on the property, keeping it up and communicating with PMs. However, my first turnover is happening and the PM has quoted me over $10 of work (including 15% fee).  While I know I am probably getting marked up, the house has significant wear and tear, despite the team doing an inspection in February (with some issues never really addressed). I've never taken a dollar out of the property, but now all that savings is going right back into the property, and I am weighing my options as it seems if that will happen with most turns, this process is not worth my time


1) Complete the work, move on the a new PM. I've reached out and I am asking specific questions of each

2) List and sell. Zillow says $166 estimate. An investor in the area has told me I'd get much less. To break even, meaning get back my down payment and closing costs and pay of mortgage, I'd need to sell with a formal listing for $170k (assuming 10% closing costs) or $152 cash


This has been my first SFH as an out of state investor, and other than building my own team, I've been pretty on top of things compared to most, so I feel like this is a real gut punch. I work in health care and cannot sneak away during work hours to do emails, communicate with PMs, or other forms of management, which makes it a bit harder

Would appreciate any insights

3Reply
1,462 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
3mo

Have to agree with @Stuart Udis; you have a broken business model. I would love to tell you something more pleasant, but no value in that. So here it goes: 

1.) Your rents are quite low and you have to pay a PM, so not much cash flow to fund repairs and maintenance.

2.) Lack of appreciation over the last 5 years is a really bad sign. US real estate has gone up 38.1% on average since 2021 (Case Shiller)

3.) Low price point = rough tenants. You chose the property, the property chooses the tenants, nothing a PM can do.

4.) Remote and managed by PM. Extra cost burden and lower level of oversight. Nobody will manage your money like you do.

Most new investors on BP have rose colored expectations of PMs (and contractors). Choosing a PM with a lower rate amplifies the problem. What did you expect for $72 per month? That pays for maybe 30 minutes of whatever, most of it is facilitating your 15 min phone call and responding to 2 emails.

I have been investing in SF for 17 years and have tried all sorts of price points. If you want to make money you need to be at least at the median price for your city. Better above median. Better homes, better tenants, better income, better appreciation. The business model works. When you are scraping the bottom of the barrel it gets tough. Some people are scrappy enough that they make it work below that, but: they manage personally, they do most of the handyman work personally, they spend a lot of time and care screening tenants and checking on them.

You can't make money in REI without appreciation. Either cash flow pays for capex or appreciation does. So if you want to call one of them "profit", you need both.

How long before you need a new roof, driveway, HVAC, kitchen, bathroom, flooring, windows, siding,..? They all have a countdown timer attached to them.

You can spend 10k very quickly on a turnover: 

- new paint 3k
- new carpet 4k
- carpentry: a couple doors, some trim, a bathroom cabinet: 1k
- trim overgrown landscaping: 1k
- HVAC service and misc repairs: 1k
- a little bit of plumbing or electrical: 1k
- new appliance.. 
- new water heater..

My recommendation: your next 5 years will be similar to your last 5 years: treat it like a flip and sell it. Buy something that rents for 3k in your home market and manage yourself. There is not a one decent single family home for rent in Burlington at the moment! 5 listings, mostly tiny 650 sqft misfits. As a renter, you have no choice, but rent an apartment. Or frankly, invest in something else, there is always the stock market..

See this reply in the discussion

37 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3mo

    Well, it is impossible to make a judgment without knowing the true condition 5 years ago, so $10K could be reasonable, or could most certainly NOT be reasonable. The 15% fee, IMHO, is a rip off, and moreso if the costs are marked up in addition.

    Based on your comments, there were no previous, annual inspections? FAIL.

    Was this same tenant occupying when you purchased, or was it vacant? Did you ever personally inspect the unit, or get a useful series of photos of the conditions at the time of purchase, either occupied or not?

    What do you mean "I've been pretty on top of things compared to most"? I doubt they did $10K of damage since February. With only one inspection in 5 years, there are numerous apparent issues, starting with the selection of a "turnkey" deal. Define "turnkey". 

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3mo

    @Patrick Giblin Has the property appreciated? If not, and there's no indication that the neighborhood fundamentals support meaningful future appreciation, I would plan for yoru current turn over experience to continue to repeat itself. Has the FMV rent remained at $1,495 since 2021? If so, that's another sign of a stagnant market.

    What you’re describing is the reality of many lower-cost single-family homes purchased in distant markets. They can appear compelling on paper because of their affordability and projected cash flow but are disproportionately impacted by opex and capex.

  • New to Real Estate · NY · Member since 2019 · 20 posts · 4 votes
    3mo

    Can you share your PM? 

  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    @Richard F.

    There were inspections when issues came up, but obviously, not enough. I've come to own that. However as I mentioned, I did have the PM do an inspection in February, an full walk through and they did not come up, nor did pictures show the extent of damage since that time. Could I have done more, yah, sure could have. However still feeling like what I paid for my PM to do, they did not do.

    • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Patrick Giblin:

      @Richard F.

      There were inspections when issues came up, but obviously, not enough. I've come to own that. However as I mentioned, I did have the PM do an inspection in February, an full walk through and they did not come up, nor did pictures show the extent of damage since that time. Could I have done more, yah, sure could have. However still feeling like what I paid for my PM to do, they did not do.

      What does your management agreement state regarding annual inspections? Was this ever discussed?  Again I ask were these tenants in there from the first day you owned the property, and how do you know this for certain? If there was a sudden burst of destructive energy since February, were there unauthorized residents...visitors, or hastily placed new tenants you were unaware of? You don't state what you believed the property to be in at time of purchase. What facts are you relying on? Can you share link to your most recent pics so we can better evaluate? 

      Look, I don't know that market, but selling due to one turnover with questionable expenses sounds like a kneejerk reaction. At a minimum, you should have another PM walk it and report. Instruct, in writing, the current PM not to advertise or rent until you make some better informed decisions.

    • Patrick GiblinPro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Richard F.:
      Quote from @Patrick Giblin:

      @Richard F.

      There were inspections when issues came up, but obviously, not enough. I've come to own that. However as I mentioned, I did have the PM do an inspection in February, an full walk through and they did not come up, nor did pictures show the extent of damage since that time. Could I have done more, yah, sure could have. However still feeling like what I paid for my PM to do, they did not do.

      What does your management agreement state regarding annual inspections? Was this ever discussed?  Again I ask were these tenants in there from the first day you owned the property, and how do you know this for certain? If there was a sudden burst of destructive energy since February, were there unauthorized residents...visitors, or hastily placed new tenants you were unaware of? You don't state what you believed the property to be in at time of purchase. What facts are you relying on? Can you share link to your most recent pics so we can better evaluate? 

      Look, I don't know that market, but selling due to one turnover with questionable expenses sounds like a kneejerk reaction. At a minimum, you should have another PM walk it and report. Instruct, in writing, the current PM not to advertise or rent until you make some better informed decisions.


       I appreciate the insight around having another PM walk the property. These posts have me thinking the best course is to search for a new PM and get another quote on expenses. 

  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    @Stuart Udis 

    I bought for $160K, estimate from Zillow (which I know a ballpark at best) is $166K, so not really.


    Rent started at $1,295 in 2021, so it has gone up. Same tenants the whole time.

    @Jorene T.

    REI Nation

  • Huntsville, AL · Member since 2018 · 579 posts · 864 votes
    3mo

    @Patrick Giblin - several comments here:

    1.  Can you share an itemized list of the repairs and costs?  Such as painting 4k, bathroom tub repair 900, etc.  Without that list, it's hard to give much feedback.  But if you've had the same tenant for 5 years, there could have been no major system items on inspection, but 5 years of tenant wear and tear could have resulted in all flooring needs to be replaced (if it was cheap carpet to begin with) and the whole house needs to be repainted.  That's 10k right there with that 15% mark up.

    2.  The property management companies I work with charge zero percent in repair markups, and use licensed vendors that give them a volume discount on top of that.  That's why I've  never argued with the 10% of rent a month for my monthly management fee.

    3.  Any reason you can't invest in either a market closer to home or a market you are very familiar with (such as where you grew up or went to school)?  First mistake numerous investors make is investing in locations they know nothing about other than what they find on google.  When OOS investors talk about Huntsville, which is a very small city, it still surprises me how little most know when they look at properties here.  Two properties in 35805 can be dramatically different for example (there is anything from borderline B class to D/F class in 35805).  

    4.  Yes, I'd sell the property, put it in a 1031, and buy something in a location closer or that you know well.  

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    3mo
    Quote from @Patrick Giblin:

    I am an out of state investor I have a SFH rental I purchased 5 years ago from a large, turn key operator, who has continued to PM the property, located in Memphis within the 38118 area code. It was renting for $1495, up until tenant move out in July, purchased for $160k in 2021, 4 beds, 2.5 baths

    I've worked hard to keep tabs on the property, keeping it up and communicating with PMs. However, my first turnover is happening and the PM has quoted me over $10 of work (including 15% fee).  While I know I am probably getting marked up, the house has significant wear and tear, despite the team doing an inspection in February (with some issues never really addressed). I've never taken a dollar out of the property, but now all that savings is going right back into the property, and I am weighing my options as it seems if that will happen with most turns, this process is not worth my time


    1) Complete the work, move on the a new PM. I've reached out and I am asking specific questions of each

    2) List and sell. Zillow says $166 estimate. An investor in the area has told me I'd get much less. To break even, meaning get back my down payment and closing costs and pay of mortgage, I'd need to sell with a formal listing for $170k (assuming 10% closing costs) or $152 cash


    This has been my first SFH as an out of state investor, and other than building my own team, I've been pretty on top of things compared to most, so I feel like this is a real gut punch. I work in health care and cannot sneak away during work hours to do emails, communicate with PMs, or other forms of management, which makes it a bit harder

    Would appreciate any insights

    Welcome to the community, Patrick! Before deciding to sell, I’d get 2–3 independent quotes on that $10k turnover scope and separate true tenant damage from normal wear, deferred maintenance, and upgrades the PM is recommending. A big first turnover after five years doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll spend $10k every time, but the February inspection followed by a large surprise bill would make me question the management process. I’d also get a local agent to give you realistic as-is and repaired values rather than relying on Zillow, then compare selling now against completing only the necessary work, changing PMs, and getting it rented again. Since your biggest constraint is time, a better PM may completely change the experience. If the numbers still work after realistic vacancy, maintenance, CapEx, and management costs, I wouldn’t sell solely because of one painful turnover. If they don’t, selling and redeploying the equity could make sense. 
  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    @Michael S.

    1) happy to send privately

    2) currently looking for PM's that fit that description. If you have any recommendations for the Memphis area, I'd be grateful

    3) Cost/price point was why I picked Memphis as it was my first rental and the area I grew up and live in where not financially possibilities at that time. I did a fair amount of research prior to investing in Memphis. I did not just jump in unaware with no understanding of the market

    4) appreciate the input 

  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    @Jimmy Lieu

    Extremely helpful-thank you-I am trying to be measured as possible, so appreciate your measured response. I don't think I am going to sell, but wanting to explore all options

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3mo

    @Patrick Giblin Part of your evaluation should be how well the major systems are holding up. From my experience, even the "turnkey" homes in the lower price points are less durable, utilize less expensive mechanical systems, fixtures etc. and break down much quicker. You are currently 5 years in and should plan for some systems to begin acting up. Others have already asked about the breakdown of where the $10K is being spent. I wouldn't be surprised if some of the wear and tear is the byproduct of cheap fixtures/finishes that don't hold up. 4 bedroom SFH's will naturally take a beating as well. Still one kitchen but more occupants, ratio of bathrooms to occupants/guests tend to be unfavorable. More likely someone is home at more times during the day meaning major systems are utilized more frequently.

    You are focused on the turnover cost and possible management replacements, but future major capex should be number 1 on your list of priorities. If the real estate hasn't appreciated and isn't showing any signs of meaningful appreciation how are you going to absorb future capex? The longer you hold, the closer you get to those more significant cap ex replacement events and less marketable the home becomes in the re-sale market. In addition, very rare to see a PM conduct preventative maintenance to the extent that maximizes the useful life of major systems and the tenant renting a 4-bedroom home for under $1500 isn't helping either. That's why I always point to the lack of sustainability when owning these lower cost SFH's provide absent meaningful appreciation.

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    3mo

    Have to agree with @Stuart Udis; you have a broken business model. I would love to tell you something more pleasant, but no value in that. So here it goes: 

    1.) Your rents are quite low and you have to pay a PM, so not much cash flow to fund repairs and maintenance.

    2.) Lack of appreciation over the last 5 years is a really bad sign. US real estate has gone up 38.1% on average since 2021 (Case Shiller)

    3.) Low price point = rough tenants. You chose the property, the property chooses the tenants, nothing a PM can do.

    4.) Remote and managed by PM. Extra cost burden and lower level of oversight. Nobody will manage your money like you do.

    Most new investors on BP have rose colored expectations of PMs (and contractors). Choosing a PM with a lower rate amplifies the problem. What did you expect for $72 per month? That pays for maybe 30 minutes of whatever, most of it is facilitating your 15 min phone call and responding to 2 emails.

    I have been investing in SF for 17 years and have tried all sorts of price points. If you want to make money you need to be at least at the median price for your city. Better above median. Better homes, better tenants, better income, better appreciation. The business model works. When you are scraping the bottom of the barrel it gets tough. Some people are scrappy enough that they make it work below that, but: they manage personally, they do most of the handyman work personally, they spend a lot of time and care screening tenants and checking on them.

    You can't make money in REI without appreciation. Either cash flow pays for capex or appreciation does. So if you want to call one of them "profit", you need both.

    How long before you need a new roof, driveway, HVAC, kitchen, bathroom, flooring, windows, siding,..? They all have a countdown timer attached to them.

    You can spend 10k very quickly on a turnover: 

    - new paint 3k
    - new carpet 4k
    - carpentry: a couple doors, some trim, a bathroom cabinet: 1k
    - trim overgrown landscaping: 1k
    - HVAC service and misc repairs: 1k
    - a little bit of plumbing or electrical: 1k
    - new appliance.. 
    - new water heater..

    My recommendation: your next 5 years will be similar to your last 5 years: treat it like a flip and sell it. Buy something that rents for 3k in your home market and manage yourself. There is not a one decent single family home for rent in Burlington at the moment! 5 listings, mostly tiny 650 sqft misfits. As a renter, you have no choice, but rent an apartment. Or frankly, invest in something else, there is always the stock market..

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    3mo

    @Patrick Giblin I'd really stress what @Marcus Auerbach and @Stuart Udis have laid out here. 

    Investment Real Estate is, in simplest fundamentals, just a math's game. 

    The ladder of profit's from greatest drive on down is: (1) Appreciation, (2) OPM, (3) Rents..... 

    The ladder of expenses from greatest impact driver on down is: (1) Capex, (2) Tenant damages, (3) Operational/ Admin expenses.....

    So if your playing the math's game by ignoring profit factor #1, and focusing on #3, and ignoring expense factor #1, but focusing on #3..... The end is inevitable, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy of poor or no returns. That's just how the math's game works. 

    As has been pointed out, properties have tiers, and with those tiers comes tenant tiers. The lower the tier, the more impactful the expense ratios become. That is why to "make it" in those C/D class properties, it's imperative to have a cost basis that set's up the math's to work. Miss that, your on the struggle-bus, perpetually. 

    Class A properties is in many regards the most forgiving for mistakes. Because they garner class A low impact tenancy, generally speaking. Capture appreciation which can pull one up out of a hole. Capital both realized and unrealized grow bigger over time affording more breathing room to, whatever. 

    A class C/D property tends to be in a less than great area, and often a stagflating market if not declining market. You've shared you'r firmly in a stagflating market. 

    I don't care what PM you transition to, nobody has a magic wand in their bag of tricks to shezam a stagflating market into a great one. 

    This is why the "Golden Rule" is: You MAKE money when you BUY. 

    If you bought wrong, the only options are redeploy or await time to dig you out. The time may be years or decades, it's market dependent and size of hole dependent. 

  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    @Marcus Auerbach

    @James Hamling

    @Stuart Udis

    This is all very helpful and has given me a lot to consider. I've learned a lot in these past 5 years, even prior to this turn over. As I've mentioned, I've never taken a dollar out of this home, knowing large cap ex was coming, but if each turn or even more major cap ex's are coming, with little appreciation, the numbers will not work. This area was appreciating a bit prior to my purchase, but in looking back that most likely was the wild run up of 2018-2021...Outside of the expense factor of entering the market at a lower price point, I also wanted to buy out of state on purpose, in order to try and distance myself a bit from the project in order to work on my ability to manage managers, as Ive always been someone who would rather do it myself and would rather do that that put trust in others. However I've learned that I want to be more involved and more hands on, as opposed to managing managers who will never care more about the home than I do and I am just another name and number to deal with.

    Greatly appreciate all the insight from this community

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    3mo

    From a PMC with a LOT of experience managing Class C/D rentals.

    You probably overpaid as you bought form a turnkey operator. 
    - Their goal is profit, which means selling the property at the highest possible price - not a price that makes an owner money.

    The constant advice of, "no one will manage the property like the owner" is misguided. 
    - Maybe 20% of owners can do a better job than us, and only because they don't charge themselves for their time. So, they can "afford" to micromanage everything to save a few more pennies.
    - 80% of owners aren't organized enough to:
    --- stay on top past due balances
    --- track maintenance issues
    --- maintain proper records
    --- effectively market vacancies
    --- have enough availability to consistently schedule showings
    --- screen tenants EFFECTIVELY, especially Class C/D applicants with low FICOs!
    --- use INSURED handyman
    --- find attorneys that specialize in evictions

    Overall, most of posts here about, "no one will manage the property like the owner" are referring to Class A properties with 680+ FICO tenants that put rent on auto-pay, rarely damage anything and leave the rental in great shape when they move out. 
    - WHO couldn't manage a great tenant?

    You are also NOT looking at the positives - same tenant for 5 years?
    How awesome is that? Assuming they had no real nonpayment issues:)
    You already mentioned rents were increased.

    As @Marcus Auerbach already pointed out, $10k of RentReady work after a Class C/D tenant occupied for 5 years is fairly common. We do recommend posting the list of repairs here (don't really need the charges) to see if they are, "Maintaining to the Market". OFTEN owners want to get work done like they will live in a rental, instead of only doing work that meets what the average tenant is expecting.

  • Real Estate Agent · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3mo

    A couple of thoughts:

    -This is the challenge with buying in lower class areas/lower price points. The cost of doing the work is the same. I've noticed between the four markets I invest or have invested in, there isn't much of a difference (and I'm talking between Los Angeles and Nashville for example). This is why I only buy 2+ unit properties. I need the scalability. 

    -As people have said, it really depends on the work actually needed. Chances are even if you sell you will still have to do the work or provide a credit/price reduction to compensate. Either way you are paying for it.

    -Selling feels like a way out but this is how real estate investing works. It is a long term play. Only sell if it truly makes sense and you can move the money to a better asset. That could be higher cashflow, better appreciation, etc. 

    -Memphis isn't really known for appreciation, it is known for cash flow. Once everything is fixed up, what is the current rental market look like and how many months would it take to make your money back? 

  • Investor · Worcester County, MA · Member since 2016 · 122 posts · 72 votes
    3mo

    @Patrick Giblin      I'm going to give more of "the glass is half full" response.  Not sure what is that best path for you but there is a case for keeping the property and existing PM:

    1.  I think a five years between turnovers is good.  Your biggest cost is turnovers, with the vacancy, lease up, and turnover maintenance that needs to be done.  So, five years is much better than average.  $10K is a big number, but that amount is probably going to put that house back into excellent shape (I happily use the same PM and that has been my experience).

    2.  Your rent has been nicely increased over time, and I would think that will continue as the market increases.  Cash flow should improve over time and this is a big plus.

    3. I'm guessing you have a low interest rate given you purchased in 2021.  

    4. that 38118 zip code is good for workers at the airport and all of the other logistics companies in the area.  I think there is a lot of demand and the house will re-rent very quickly.

    5. your mortgage is getting paid down and the amortization will  increase as time goes on.

    6.  IMO, if you can, and the house is covering itself (i.e. you are not coming out of pocket in total over the last 5 years), I would continue to hold over a full market cycle.  Like 10-15  plus years.  That way you will benefit from market appreciation,  The market has been  going sideways in values probably since late 2022.  Over time, the market will start appreciating again, and I think you can expect around 3% per year in Memphis.

    7.  The PM that you refer to, that you are currently using is excellent.  They have managed  a few properties for me for around ten years, and they let you stay very passive.  They keep residents in the houses for a long time, I think much more than the industry average, which is the most important thing.

  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    Thanks all. Appreciate the other side of the argument @David B. and the perspective @Drew Sygit and @Rick Albert

    List of repairs below

    Per review of the extensive pictures. Most seems legit. I did say hold off on new carpet and try to clean it (just re did a year ago) and requested holding off on steam cleaning and see how regular cleaning did to the kitchen areas

    Exterior - $1700

    - new light fixture in front

    - new light fixture in back

    - replace any missing/broken tension pumps on storm/security doors

    - remove satellite dish, wires, and bracket

    - remove all stickers from all windows

    - remove all stickers from mailbox except house numbers

    - remove foam insulation and repair and paint fascia at front right side of carport

    - repair and paint wood trim on right side of carport security

    - repair and paint wood siding on right side of carport security

    - wipe down storage room door

    - broom sweep storage room

    - pressure wash siding on detached room in back of house

    - wipe down and touch up walls in detached room and bathroom and closet

    - wipe down and touch up baseboards in detached room and bathroom and closet

    - wipe down and touch up doors in detached room and bathroom and closet

    - paint cabinets in bathroom in detached room

    - wipe down and paint ac vents in detached room

    - wipe down and paint bars and shelves in closet

    - secure soffit at rear of house over detached room

    Main Interior - $2300
    - repair/replace damaged sheetrock
    - paint all walls
    - paint trim, doors, and baseboards
    - paint ceilings and closets
    - replace missing/damaged doorstops
    - replace missing/broken doorknobs
    - replace missing/broken light switch and outlet covers
    - replace missing/broken light bulbs
    - install two new smoke detectors
    - make sure all doors open/shut properly
    - make sure all windows open/close properly
    - replace air filter
    - wipe down and paint bars and shelves in closets
    - wipe down and paint ac vents
    - make sure all cabinets and doors open and shut

    Entryway - $40
    - remove damaged ceiling fan and install light fixture
    - install weather stripping on right side of door
    Kitchen - $300
    - 1 new light fixture(s)
    - paint cabinets inside and out
    - caulk sink, floor, counter
    - install 3 new window blinds
    - clean backsplash
    Laundry Room - $300
    - install 2 new doors
    Hall Bathroom - $65
    - paint cabinets inside and out
    - new toilet seat
    - caulk toilet, sink, tub, floor
    Master Bathroom - $40
    - paint cabinets inside and out
    - new toilet seat
    - caulk toilet, sink, tub, floor

    Bedroom 1 - $30
    - install 1 new window blind
    Additional Items
    These items are estimates only and billed individually/separately.
    Actual costs may vary.
    Locks - $400
    - install deadbolt for carport security door
    Yard - $380
    - cut, edge, weedeat
    - trim up trees

    Flooring - $1824
    - replace carpet in living room
    Carpet Replacement Estimate: $500
    - clean carpet in detached room at rear of house
    Carpet Cleaning Estimate: $60
    - refinish all hardwoods
    Hardwood Estimate: $1264
    Misc Items - $900
    - steam clean tile floor in kitchen and bathrooms
    - steam clean tile surround in hall bathroom
    - incidentals: ongoing lawn maintenance, interior cleanings while the property is being marketed
    for rent, etc.
    Pest Control - $100
    - pest control needed: General pest spray
    Trash - $500
    - trash size: Medium
    Tub/Top Refinishing - $550
    - refinish hall bathroom vanity top and sink
    - refinish master bathroom vanity top and sink
    Utilities - $300
    - utilities: Need all
    - need utilities to refinish hardwoods
    Cleaning - $200
    - full cleaning needed

    • Drew SygitBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
      3mo
      Quote from @Patrick Giblin:

      Thanks all. Appreciate the other side of the argument @David B. and the perspective @Drew Sygit and @Rick Albert

      List of repairs below

      Per review of the extensive pictures. Most seems legit. I did say hold off on new carpet and try to clean it (just re did a year ago) and requested holding off on steam cleaning and see how regular cleaning did to the kitchen areas

      Exterior - $1700

      - new light fixture in front

      - new light fixture in back

      - replace any missing/broken tension pumps on storm/security doors

      - remove satellite dish, wires, and bracket

      - remove all stickers from all windows

      - remove all stickers from mailbox except house numbers

      - remove foam insulation and repair and paint fascia at front right side of carport

      - repair and paint wood trim on right side of carport security

      - repair and paint wood siding on right side of carport security

      - wipe down storage room door

      - broom sweep storage room

      - pressure wash siding on detached room in back of house

      - wipe down and touch up walls in detached room and bathroom and closet

      - wipe down and touch up baseboards in detached room and bathroom and closet

      - wipe down and touch up doors in detached room and bathroom and closet

      - paint cabinets in bathroom in detached room

      - wipe down and paint ac vents in detached room

      - wipe down and paint bars and shelves in closet

      - secure soffit at rear of house over detached room

      Main Interior - $2300
      - repair/replace damaged sheetrock
      - paint all walls
      - paint trim, doors, and baseboards
      - paint ceilings and closets
      - replace missing/damaged doorstops
      - replace missing/broken doorknobs
      - replace missing/broken light switch and outlet covers
      - replace missing/broken light bulbs
      - install two new smoke detectors
      - make sure all doors open/shut properly
      - make sure all windows open/close properly
      - replace air filter
      - wipe down and paint bars and shelves in closets
      - wipe down and paint ac vents
      - make sure all cabinets and doors open and shut

      Entryway - $40
      - remove damaged ceiling fan and install light fixture
      - install weather stripping on right side of door
      Kitchen - $300
      - 1 new light fixture(s)
      - paint cabinets inside and out
      - caulk sink, floor, counter
      - install 3 new window blinds
      - clean backsplash
      Laundry Room - $300
      - install 2 new doors
      Hall Bathroom - $65
      - paint cabinets inside and out
      - new toilet seat
      - caulk toilet, sink, tub, floor
      Master Bathroom - $40
      - paint cabinets inside and out
      - new toilet seat
      - caulk toilet, sink, tub, floor

      Bedroom 1 - $30
      - install 1 new window blind
      Additional Items
      These items are estimates only and billed individually/separately.
      Actual costs may vary.
      Locks - $400
      - install deadbolt for carport security door
      Yard - $380
      - cut, edge, weedeat
      - trim up trees

      Flooring - $1824
      - replace carpet in living room
      Carpet Replacement Estimate: $500
      - clean carpet in detached room at rear of house
      Carpet Cleaning Estimate: $60
      - refinish all hardwoods
      Hardwood Estimate: $1264
      Misc Items - $900
      - steam clean tile floor in kitchen and bathrooms
      - steam clean tile surround in hall bathroom
      - incidentals: ongoing lawn maintenance, interior cleanings while the property is being marketed
      for rent, etc.
      Pest Control - $100
      - pest control needed: General pest spray
      Trash - $500
      - trash size: Medium
      Tub/Top Refinishing - $550
      - refinish hall bathroom vanity top and sink
      - refinish master bathroom vanity top and sink
      Utilities - $300
      - utilities: Need all
      - need utilities to refinish hardwoods
      Cleaning - $200
      - full cleaning needed


      We always break down items into 5 categories to prioritize them:

      1) Health & Safety (avoid slip & fall lawsuits)
      2) Government Required (city & S8 inspections)
      3) Property Preservation (fix it now for $x or more later)
      4) Marketing Impact (stickers on the walls won't rent)
      5) Miscellaneous

      Another issue is what should the tenant be liable for via security deposit forfeiture and collections?

      These should be charged to tenant:

      - new light fixture in front
      - new light fixture in back
      - replace any missing/broken tension pumps on storm/security doors
      - remove satellite dish, wires, and bracket
      - remove all stickers from all windows
      - remove all stickers from mailbox except house numbers
      - remove foam insulation and repair and paint fascia at front right side of carport
      - repair/replace damaged sheetrock
      - paint cabinets in bathroom in detached room (what did tenant do to them?)
      - replace missing/damaged doorstops
      - replace missing/broken doorknobs
      - replace missing/broken light switch and outlet covers
      - replace missing/broken light bulbs
      - install two new smoke detectors
      - replace air filter
      - remove damaged ceiling fan and install light fixture
      - 1 new light fixture(s)
      - install 4 new window blinds
      - install 2 new laundry doors
      - cut, edge, weedeat
      - refinish hall bathroom vanity top and sink
      - refinish master bathroom vanity top and sink


      Would question why the following need to be done as won't add much value:

      - wipe down and paint bars and shelves in closets
      - wipe down and paint ac vents
      - make sure all cabinets and doors open and shut
      - paint cabinets inside and out (why can't just clean?)
      - new toilet seats (dirty or did tenants break?)
      - install deadbolt for carport security door $400 (why didn't they do this when you bought it?)
      - replace carpet in living room (5 years is often max life, but can they steam clean?)
      - refinish all hardwoods (see if can screen & poly, instead of full sanding)
      - wipe down and paint ac vents in detached room (how bad can they be?)
      - wipe down and paint bars and shelves in closet (who cares?)

      Another thing you can do is check out competition on Zillow. Compare quality of your property to other nearby rentals, so you don't over-improve.

  • Josh HandlerPro Member
    Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 72 posts · 86 votes
    3mo

    Patrick, contractor's read on your actual list, since nobody's priced it line by line yet. The scope itself is mostly legitimate turn work for a 4-bed after five years of occupancy, this is what a real make-ready looks like, and whoever wrote it was thorough. The hardwood refinish around $1,264 and the paint numbers are in a normal band for 38118. The places I'd push back: $500 for a medium trash-out on a unit that wasn't a hoarder situation is worth questioning, "incidentals" and "misc" buckets totaling around $900 should be itemized before you approve them, and you were right to hold off on new carpet you replaced a year ago. But the bigger number is the one you named in passing: the 15% sitting on top of all of it. On a $9-10k scope that's $1,300-1,500 of pure markup, and over a few turns that's the difference between this property working and not.

    So before you sell a house with a 5-year tenant history and rising rent over one turn bill, fix the structure instead: separate who manages the tenant from who does the work, and make sure whoever manages doesn't touch the repair invoice. On the PM side since you asked for Memphis recommendations, take a look at 901 Asset Management, flat monthly fee and zero markup on maintenance, ask for Rosina at 901-430-0700 and compare her structure against what you have now.

    For context, I run a construction company here in Memphis and own about 70 rentals in town myself, several in and around 38118, so I price turns like this every week. That zip rents fast for airport and logistics workers, David's right about that, which is exactly why I wouldn't exit over a fixable cost-structure problem.

  • Investor · Statewide, MO · Member since 2011 · 825 posts · 430 votes
    3mo

    My concern would be that few things have gone down in value since you made the purchase. Your house is sadly one of them.  If it can't appreciate when everything else is,  it seems like a down market would crush the value.  

    I rode some properties to the bottom.  It sucks.  They appreciated after I sold them (during your window of ownership),  when yours did not, all the more reason to sell and exit this one.  

    We see turnkey buyers here frequently with the same story.  I would think you're better cutting losses and doing something else.  

    I'd be curious to hear who sold it to you. Have you asked them to sell it? 

  • Investor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2018 · 198 posts · 87 votes
    3mo

    Patrick, I would separate this into two tests before you pick sell or switch PM.

    First, ask whether the asset math still works after a normal turn reserve, not this one invoice. Second, ask a replacement PM to rebuild the February inspection, security deposit charges, work scope, and expected rent in one owner packet before you sign.

    If they cannot show the paper trail from inspection to tenant chargeback to rent ready budget, you are changing names without changing control.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3mo

    Patrick, I’d look at this as a hold-versus-sell decision from today forward, not as a referendum on whether the original purchase was good or bad.

    If you keep it, I’d get at least 2–3 independent bids for the turn and compare management companies based on actual communication standards, inspection process, maintenance markup, leasing fees, and reporting. A $10K turn may be justified, but I would not accept one quote from the current PM without validating the scope.

    Then compare the property’s realistic future cash flow against what you could net from selling. On the sale side, don’t stop at “can I get my down payment back?” You also need to factor in selling costs, depreciation recapture, any taxable gain or loss, and whether you have suspended passive losses that could become usable when the entire passive activity is disposed of in a qualifying taxable sale.

    If you keep it as a rental, I’d also evaluate cost segregation if you have not already. It may accelerate depreciation on qualifying components, but the benefit depends on whether those losses are actually usable under the passive-loss rules.

    Since your biggest frustration seems to be the management burden, I’d first see whether a better PM can solve that problem before selling a property solely because the current PM has made ownership painful.

    Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Patrick GiblinPro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    3mo

    thanks @Drew Sygit

    The deposit is going toward many of these costs. I also went through line by line and ask them to remove/take out many of the items you mentioned.

    @Eduardo Cavasotti extremely helpful thank you

    @Ashish Acharya more to consider thank you

  • Investor · Charleston, SC · Member since 2018 · 198 posts · 87 votes
    3mo

    Glad it helped. Line by line cleanup is the right first pass, then I would ask the PM to separate tenant damage, normal turn costs, deferred maintenance, and owner upgrade items so the sell or keep decision is not blended together.

  • Andrew GlissonBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 135 posts · 97 votes
    3mo

    Patrick, I track every rental listing and every recorded sale in Memphis and can give you some actuals for 38118.

    On the rent. You were at $1,495. Right now there are 41 four-bedroom listings in 38118, and the middle half sit between $1,395 and $1,600, with a median of $1,450. So your rent doesn't seem to be the problem. Worth knowing though: 29 of those 41 are still sitting on the market, and the typical Memphis listing in your zip takes about 36 days to come off. Budget for a real vacancy, not two weeks.

    On the sale, and this is the number I would want if I were you. Zillow's $166k is a pretty rough estimate. Here's what actually closed: In 38118 since Jan 2025, four-bedroom houses sold at a median of $150,000, with the middle half between $116,500 and $198,500. That's 115 recorded salesl. The zip as a whole has drifted slightly down: sale was $133,250 in 2024, $130,000 in 2025, $129,200 so far in 2026.

    You said you need $170k on a formal listing to break even, or $152k cash. Break-even asks you to land in the upper half of your zip with a house that has wear and tear and a $10k punch list. Possible, but you would be selling against your own condition. The $152k cash number is right at the median for a four-bed, and cash buyers here generally buy below the median, not at it.

    Which means the decision probably is not "is this a bad rental." At $1,450 to $1,495 on a $150k to $160k basis, this is an ordinary 38118 deal, roughly at the 1% rule, and it performs about like its neighbors. The decision is whether you want to put $10k in and keep going with better management.

    I'd def get a second quote... and I'm happy to build a comp report for your street or address specifically if you want them.

    Disclosure: I manage rental property in Memphis, so I am not a neutral party here. Everything above is measurement of public listings and recorded deeds.

    LPS Short and Long Term Property Management
    • Patrick GiblinPro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Burlington, VT · Member since 2020 · 49 posts · 26 votes
      1mo

      Thanks! I am keeping the property and have new tenants in November. It has been a lot of back and forth with the old PM and new PM, but I couldn't really get a sale number that worked. I hope with a new PM and better management I can get through this part of the cycle and maybe sell at a better time

  • Miami, FL · Member since 2026 · 766 posts · 124 votes
    3mo
    Quote from @Patrick Giblin:

    I am an out of state investor I have a SFH rental I purchased 5 years ago from a large, turn key operator, who has continued to PM the property, located in Memphis within the 38118 area code. It was renting for $1495, up until tenant move out in July, purchased for $160k in 2021, 4 beds, 2.5 baths

    I've worked hard to keep tabs on the property, keeping it up and communicating with PMs. However, my first turnover is happening and the PM has quoted me over $10 of work (including 15% fee).  While I know I am probably getting marked up, the house has significant wear and tear, despite the team doing an inspection in February (with some issues never really addressed). I've never taken a dollar out of the property, but now all that savings is going right back into the property, and I am weighing my options as it seems if that will happen with most turns, this process is not worth my time


    1) Complete the work, move on the a new PM. I've reached out and I am asking specific questions of each

    2) List and sell. Zillow says $166 estimate. An investor in the area has told me I'd get much less. To break even, meaning get back my down payment and closing costs and pay of mortgage, I'd need to sell with a formal listing for $170k (assuming 10% closing costs) or $152 cash


    This has been my first SFH as an out of state investor, and other than building my own team, I've been pretty on top of things compared to most, so I feel like this is a real gut punch. I work in health care and cannot sneak away during work hours to do emails, communicate with PMs, or other forms of management, which makes it a bit harder

    Would appreciate any insights

    @Patrick Giblin
    Before selling, I’d run the numbers on the property as if you were starting fresh today: realistic market rent, the $10K turnover, new management cost, current mortgage payment, and what you’d actually net from a sale. If it still cash flows after the turnover, changing PMs may make more sense than selling just to break even. I’d also get a couple of local rent opinions before assuming the prior $1,495 rent is still achievable.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.