How much cash flow could one get with $150k starting capital?

How much cash flow could one get with $150k starting capital?

Washington, D.C. · Member since 2014 · 35 posts · 9 votes

One of my friends who has had to listen to my incessant ranting about REI had a question for me the other day, and I felt sheepish that I had no idea how to answer him. My plans are largely centered around SFH buy and hold, long-term investing, and my knowledge ends there. He is well-to-do and has money saved up, and was curious about how much cash flow he could get with it in the short-term.

So, my question is this: if you had $150k in capital to blow, were just starting out, and you were mostly concerned about getting the max amount of cash flow in the near future (and if possible setting yourself up to get some more long-term benefits) what would you do? 

Two extra criteria.....he lives in the Washington DC metro area, so things are pricey (but probably willing to look farther out) and seems averse to house flipping.

0Reply
605 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
12y

@Joe Villeneuve you're claiming that ALL Expenses, ALL vacancy and ALL capital amount to $330 out of $975 of rent.  That's 33%.  You may well have seen those sort of numbers.  Two very large datasets that have been posted here in the past that covered hundreds of thousands of units do not support that number.  That number is unrealistically low.  That's the kind of number turnkey sellers use to sucker in naive investors who don't know better.  Building a business based on that number will result in failure when the cows really come home and those big capital items start hitting.  If you're building a portfolio of properties you WILL be replacing roofs, appliances, furnaces, and sewer lines on an ongoing basis.  You WILL have tenants that wreck the place.  You will have lengthy and expensive evictions.  

First time I every shot craps I started with $200 and walked away with a purple, $500 chip.  But I'm not naive enough to think that's a normal outcome.

So, @James Z. use whatever assumptions you want when making investments. I personally do not use a number like Joe's unless I'm willing to manage the property myself and willing to contribute that labor for free. No matter what assumptions you make up front reality will be whatever it will be. If you have just a few properties you may get lucky like I did at that craps table and have very low expenses. Or you might have a really big expense like I did on one of my properties last year where I spent over 50% of the year's rent just replacing a sewer line. This business is chock full of property listings that say "this cash flows" when all the seller or their agent really means is "if you put 20% down and get a 30 year fixed rate loan the PITI will be less than the rent."

See this reply in the discussion

94 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    Sorry Richard,

    I thought I explained the way we handle "maintenance, capex, management and vacancy" on our properties. I know I did...must have been on a different discussion.  My bad.  Sorry.

    First, yes we rarely have vacancy issues since we have a waiting list.

    2nd, we are in a sellers market, so "after rehab" properties do sell higher. Even HUD, REO and FM properties are listed at or above market value on their first listing, even though they need work (sometimes a lot). They eventually come down when the offers are always much lower though. They keep trying though.

    3rd, we don't buy houses with boilers.  All of our tenants are required though to sign up for the local utility companies Appliance Repair Program, which covers the Furnace and HWH...so that's not an issue.  The roof can be, but in cases where the roof is a problem, we either don't buy the house or we fix it during rehab.  In 20+ years, we've never come across any sewer issues...we just do our due diligence ahead of time.  We have avoided sewer issues though with that D.D. and have since avoided a certain area because of it.

    4th, the issue of maintenance, capex  (his can be a huge problem if you don't cover it) and Property Management.  Initially we took a % out of the rent to cover it, but that only "funded the kitty" a little at a time, and if a problem developed early in ownership, well...you were screwed.  So, our approach to it may be considered overkill by some, but we think of it as Risk Control.  I always believe in paying for Risk Control since it usually costs you more in the end if you don't.  Here's how we do it.

    We usually buy houses in cash for a number of reasons.  This is one of them.  By having 100% equity in the eyes of the lender, and usually at least 25-30% based on our cost, we can refinance to get not only our initial cash back (which we use on the next house), but also we can "cash out" part of that equity...which allows us to be proactive in covering the maintenance, capex and Property Management.

    We pay the PM for a year upfront and get it at 8%, so we are actually covering our interest on the loan with the savings too.  The rest goes into a "kitty" that covers the other items.  We would rather have a lump some ready to cover trouble from the start, than build it up over time only to not have enough if trouble occurs before the % we take out of the rent is enough to cover it.

    Over the years we find this to be the safest way of handling all of this.

    JV

  • Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2014 · 13 posts · 4 votes
    12y

    I would say that notes are the way to go. No tenants,trash,toilets or BS. At $150k to invest, you could buy a 1st position mortgage with $200K in the secondary market. The mortgage is covered by equity in the home and it will pay you about $11K a year, After 5 years with the principle not affected hardly at all you could sell the note and buy another one. Once you make a little money, funnel it into a little higher risk mortgages like seconds and make even more return on investment without affecting your original $150K. This is a simple example but, you can make more money depending on your involvement. 

    Your cash cow is now mooing......Good Luck

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    You're missing the point Joe.  It's not about how you manage your own properties.  I basically do complete system replacements myself as a way to keep maintenance costs (and especially midnight calls) as low as possible.

    The issue is the representations you are making on the houses you have for sale.

    Evenutally a furnace needs to be not just repaired but replaced.  Same with a roof.  You may not have had any sewer issues, but you have either a septic that needs to be pumped and then replaced ever 25 years or so or city sewer with a monthly bill.  If you pay for a year of PM up front before selling your turnkeys, that's great, but what about Year 2?

    The point here is that presenting a house with a schedule rent of $1050 and taxes and insurance of $240 as having $810 in NET cash flow is simply wrong.  I'm not big on the various BP "rules", but this sort of house in this sort of neighborhood strikes me as a virtually certain candidate for 50% of gross going to expenses.  

    And to be honest, what you said about furnaces and the Appliance Repair Program says to me that you aren't even replacing older systems in your "rehabs" which means you're doing cosmetics.  I actually rented a house without repainting it once.  But it have a new boiler and a new roof.

    So at 50% realistic expenses, even if you get $1050 you are looking at 525 a month before financing.  With 25% down on your asking price, the typical investor is going to be looking at about $300 for P&I.  So a realistic NET cash flow (something of a misnomer itself, but that's another discussion) is something like $225 a month.  

    So $18750 down, and lets say closing costs bring us to $20k even (would be too low here, but I understand these things vary regionally).  $20k cash to get $2700 a year.  That is a very respectable 13.5% return.

    Not worth it to me, in that sort of neighborhood and with that level of management effort and risk, but worth it to a lot of people probably.  So why not advertise that, instead of fanciful numbers?

    I think the suspicion people will have is that you are fluffing the number less in order to sell the houses than to sell your classes to newbies.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Richard C. 

      one of the reason TK operators advertise like that is because of the keep up with the JONES syndrome... and they need their marketing cash flow number to be as high as possible to get ones attention and compete with other markets and marketers.

    But like you said its not reality in any way shape or form.. and NO sewer problems in 25 years I find that hard to believe. plumbing gets plugged in the best of homes and in the best of areas with the best of tenenats. In those tree lined streets and old clay pipe there has to be clogs

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Richard C. 

      one of the reason TK operators advertise like that is because of the keep up with the JONES syndrome... and they need their marketing cash flow number to be as high as possible to get ones attention and compete with other markets and marketers.

    But like you said its not reality in any way shape or form.. and NO sewer problems in 25 years I find that hard to believe. plumbing gets plugged in the best of homes and in the best of areas with the best of tenenats. In those tree lined streets and old clay pipe there has to be clogs

     Sure, I get that.  And I expect people get taken in by it all the time.  But probably only ONCE, y'know?

    I can't make 13% consistently in my market.  It takes luck, marketing effort I don't want to expend, or both.  Someone who could sell me a true midwestern turnkey that actually returned 13% from truly rehabbed properties with solid management in stable areas could sell me houses as fast as I could put the money together, for years on end.  I would like to think that that repeat business would be worth more than fleecing a newbie once, but apparently not, or more people would be doing it.

  • Rental Property Investor · Mercer Island, WA · Member since 2008 · 22k+ posts · 14k+ votes
    12y

    Folks, lets PLEASE get back to the "what returns can I get from my $150K" question.

    @James Z. my big warning here would be that as soon as people know you have serious cash to invest all sorts of opportunities will come out of the woodwork.  Many of those offers will look a lot better than they really are.  You MUST understand what you're investing in thoroughly before you invest.  Otherwise you can easily be separated from your cash and left with investments that return nothing.  Real estate also has a bad habit of sucking more cash out of your pocket.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    The Appliance Repair plan covers replacement as well.  We don't buy houses with a new furnace or HWH problem obviously on the horizon.  We don't need to...too many other options.

    As far as representations, 50% cost doesn't happen here.

    What you are trying to apply in your analysis is completely valid...in most general cases.  In our case, our program has been developed from our extensive experience in our market.  Our analysis dictates a number of key zip codes where we apply our system to because that area is perfect for it. 

    We have a very different set of market conditions in Michigan (particularly in the SE), that don't exist in other areas of the country.  This area is very high on the list for outside investors because of this.  In March metro Detroit was ranked #1 in the Buy vs Rent list...as in cheaper to Buy than rent....and #8 in the country for Landlords due to low cost to buy, low taxes, and higher rents.

    I almost forgot.  Wayne County (which is where Detroit, Drbn Hgts, Redford, etc.. is) was rated the #1 (as in the best) Real Estate Rental Market for 2014 (April)...by BiggerPockets.

    JV

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    Yeah, that's fair, sorry.

    So James to answer your question, in my area (which does not attract out-of-state investors for a reason) I could get into single families that would REALISTICALLY return 7-8%. Say $13-14k a year. That is just carefully buying rent-ready houses off the MLS.

    Doing what I actually do, which is a sort of small-scale fix-and-hold, I can do better.  Maybe 10 or 12 percent after a significant amount of effort up front.

    Both scenarios with a better-than-average chance of real appreciation in the mid-to-long term, not that you should count on it.

    But I am careful and conservative, and working in a rural area with pretty high property values and a stable but not growing population.  I expect others are doing much better.  But this is working for me.

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    The "that's fair" was to Jon. Still not buying what you're selling, Joe :).  But I'm dropping it on this thread.

  • Washington, D.C. · Member since 2014 · 35 posts · 9 votes
    12y

    @Jon Holdman  Thanks for getting things back on track, though I did find the catfights invigorating and informative! I hear your warning loud and clear...I'm a very cautious and conservative person with my money, so when I do have the kind of capital my friend has saved up I will not let go of any of it until I have what appears to be a sure deal.

    @Richard C.  It's good to hear that you're managing to do well despite non-ideal conditions where you are. As for me, my market is very volatile and extremely expensive, and honestly I don't think it's a good place for me to start my investing career. I hear good things about Baltimore though, which is a drive-able distance for me.

    @Tara Piantanida-Kelly I think being the bank would be a great move for him, if he wants to make some money while he takes time to learn the ropes (which I feel obligated to suggest to him, if he decides to do anything with the info I feed him)....also the apartment idea is interesting to me personally, should I get that kind of capital. I've always been drawn to the idea of apartments, but feel like it might be folly to set my sights that high before I have some SFH rental properties beneath my belt. I've been weary of apartments because of the prices in my area...using free websites like redfin etc, most 5-7 unit apartment buildings, that look hideously run down, are about 60 years old, and are in bad neighborhoods that are NOT appreciating, sell for a million dollars plus in my area. I suppose that again, I need to look farther out.

    The tax lien/notes ideas are also interesting, so thanks Tara and @Frank Buono  for bringing that up...but I don't fully understand them yet, and have heard repeatedly that one should have some good real world RE experience before experimenting with those. If I'm not ready for them he's definitely not.

  • Wholesaler · Sandy, UT · Member since 2014 · 9 posts · 4 votes
    12y

    Well.... If he tries wholesaling he would use none or very little of that 150K he has and could generate an infinite return.

    20K a month is pretty easy in our market for wholesalers to achieve in their spare time.

    2- Hard money lending to other investors would generate 1-2 points per month typically secured by real estate.

    3- He could partner with an experienced investor on a flip transaction where he puts up the money and collects 40-50% of the profits.  While I mostly just pay 12% simple interest I partner fairly often and my last deal made my investor partner $105,000.00

    4- He could buy a note on property and that could be fairly profitable. My best deal ever I bought a note a $90,000 with a $45,000 rebate to me on it and doubled money in 90 days.

  • Residential Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2013 · 281 posts · 110 votes
    12y

    This hasn't been said yet but what if you guys learned together...you do the work he provides the money and you JV together? Without experience it would be a little more risky but if he's putting up the money you need to do everything possible to make it less risky and teach him how/why...could be a good partnership if done right.

  • Investor · Melbourne, FL · Member since 2014 · 32 posts · 19 votes
    12y

    ugh, i had such hope for this thread...

  • Investor · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2013 · 27 posts · 4 votes
    12y
    Joe, I am quite interested in what you postedin one of your replies: 3rd, we don't buy houses with boilers. All of our tenants are required though to sign up for the local utility companies Appliance Repair Program, which covers the Furnace and HWH...so that's not an issue. I am an investor in Detroit so would DTE offer this? Are you saying that a tenant will rent the home and put in their own furnace and hot water tank? That's a pretty heavy capital investment. And they will take it with them when they vacate? This seems like an awfully good deal for the landlord. What are the chances of this really happening?
  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    Eugene,

    No.  DTE covers the repair/replacement of the existing ones.  We deduct the $14/month from the rent as long as they sign up for it.  This way, we know we won't be paying to replace them, DTE will be, and we also won't be called in the event they break down/leak/stop heating, etc...since the person who's name is on the bill must call...that person being the tenant.

    Joe Villeneuve
    REcapSystem
    A2REIC

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    12y

    @Joe Villeneuve 

      I have seen this program for water heaters never for HVAC... Not sure how they can insure that stuff for that low of fee..

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Joe Villeneuve 

      I have seen this program for water heaters never for HVAC... Not sure how they can insure that stuff for that low of fee..

     They can't and don't.

    For $14 a month you can get the repair coverage. For an ADDITIONAL $17 a month you can get the replacement policy, which pays $750 for a furnace, if it cannot be repaired.

    The deal Joe is talking about does not exist. The deal that does exist, at least for that first $14, is not a terrible deal. So once again, instead of just honestly representing a decent deal, we have to wildly exagerrate to make it appear to be an out-of-this-world deal.  Why?

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    The $17 replacement deal is an awful deal. $204 a year for a maximum payout of $750. On something that has a useful life of at least 20 years.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    $8.95/month - Furnace/boiler + HWH (w/75 deductible)
    $13.95 - Furnace/boiler + HWH with no deductible
    19.95 - add the washer + dryer
                            or, 
               fridge + range/cooktop

    19.95 - Wash + dryer + fridge + range/cooktop 
    28.95 - All of the above + central air....$347.40/year

    It's worth it for not having to take calls from the tenant, having an unlimited number of repairs on these items, parts (if you look at the parts covered you'll see it covers all the major and minor items that would result in most people just buying a new unit).

    To us this is just a form of risk control.  We would rather pay 28.95 (in rent credit) to put a ceiling on our repair costs on all the above items, than have the potential of having a couple of them pop up on us during the year....and have the tenant call the utility company direct instead of us on New Year's Eve.

    All you need to do is have any one of these items break down during the year (like the drum on the dryer, or the fan on the A/C unit, or the blower on the furnace, and the service charge alone would be higher than the yearly cost.

    Joe Villeneuve
    REcapSystem
    A2REIC

  • Investor · Waynesville, NC · Member since 2014 · 408 posts · 121 votes
    12y

    So your local electric utility is offering this? I would certainly be interested in something similar if it were available in NC.

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    Which is why I said the repair policy is not a bad deal. But it does not, in fact, cover replacement. And even the replacement policy only covers a maximum of $750 on a furnace replacement.

    Aside from that, how is that $30 not an expense? Therefore to be deducted from gross rent before determining net?

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    I already calculated that in.  The rent given assumes that credit already given.  750 covers our cost for the furnace but, we get our furnaces inspected thoroughly before we buy as part of the utility company's "Energy Saving" plan...so at no cost to us.  If there is a problem that looks like a new furnace is in the near future, we take that into consideration in our offer, or just pass on the house.

    All the other replacement issues ARE covered for parts and labor by the plan.  

    The age of the roof and mechanicals play a large role in our offers, either by making them lower or no offer at all.  

    JV

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    Austin,

    Yes.  This program is offered in our area.  We sign up for it as soon as we buy the house, so we're covered during rehab.  This gives us an hedge for when we buy a house with no power.

    JV

  • Bedford, NH · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    So that $14 a month has now turned into $47. And you say the rent listed accounts for thatcredit. OK. So the real rent is $1100 (which would make it the most expensive rental in about a 20 block radius, but OK).

    So you in fact are looking at 47/1100= about four and a half percent to insure against the maintenance expenses associated with several major systems. Through in a similar amount for maintenance on everything else and you are about where I figure maintenance should be budgeted.

    You still need to account for capital expenses. The fact that nothing big is on the immediate horizon is entirely irrelevant. Eventually there will be a need for a roof, new panel, cabinets etc, etc. That is why you if you are accurately accounting for expenses you need to budget another 10% or so for cap ex. Probably more in your case since by you own admission you don't replace roofs and furnaces.

    That house you have listed will cash flow at a couple hundred bucks. Maybe a little more if your buyer is local and self manages. And the buyer better cross his fingers since the rehab is cosmetic.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    12y

    Where did you get $47/month Richard?

    JV

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.