Attn Bper: Bens $1000 a month rule - learn it, love it, leave it?

Attn Bper: Bens $1000 a month rule - learn it, love it, leave it?

Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes

I was just reading Ben's latest blog post and he brought up some real numbers after owning 100 doors. His experience has led him to the conclusion you need to get $1000 per month(sfh) in order to cover expenses and still make a profit. Now he is in Ohio but he is convinced this rule applies nearly everywhere. There are some exceptions for being local but if it was under $1000 that was more of a job/investment vs a semi passive income play. 

Here is his post;

http://www.biggerpockets.com/renewsblog/2015/03/03...

Should this be a rule like 50%? Let us know what you think.

1Reply
511 views

Most Popular Reply

Dawn AnastasiPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 4k+ votes
11y
Originally posted by @Matt R.:
Originally posted by @Dawn Anastasi:

I do not agree with it.  Only one of my single family homes makes over $1,000 in gross rent each and I still make money on them.

 Dawn you are savvy enough to be one of the exceptions. Would you think this is generally a good rule for newbies starting out?

Generally, anyone new at anything is going to make more mistakes than someone more experienced. However, newbies to real estate on Bigger Pockets have access to thousands of more experienced investors to help them with deal analysis and any questions they may have.  So it's like having thousands of mentors at your fingertips.  Plus, there are many people who are willing to work with someone locally just by having that person offer to buy them lunch or coffee.

Without having the internet, and sites like this, newbies didn't have as much of a support system.  So now, someone could take on a project like this.  It's just important to know your own limitations.

See this reply in the discussion

126 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y

    What I find fascinating with most blogs and posts on these forums is that almost all numbers being used in the poster's analysis are fabricated or hypothetical. I have also seen numerous times where one's assertions are challenged with a request to substantiate their claim with some real numbers. 

    I think the article has many valid points and gets the point across. However, @Serge S. perhaps it would be much more substantive if you used actual CapEx numbers from your own properties instead of the ones presented?

  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    11y

    @Serge S. 

    Yes, I have also lost good tenants to them buying a house, not mine.  I lost some excellent 7 year tenants to the first time home credit of $8,000.

    But I also have some long term tenants who have stayed very long times, I have a 30, 20, 17, 15, 12, and I have a tenant on his second tour of duty with me.  I did lose a 21 yr tenant, but I did sell them a house, but not the one they lived in as a tenant.  I also had a existing tenant who a built a brand new house for. 

  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    11y

    @Account Closed 

    There is no luck involved, only skill in creasing my ownership.

  • Clemson, SC · Member since 2012 · 82 posts · 19 votes
    11y

    Based on Ben's blog post, I believe his point is that buying cheap houses at retail in C/D neighborhoods is a poor financial decision.  This conclusion is certainly not groundbreaking, and reaching it doesn't require complicated financial analysis.  

    Ben did a great job in taking a simple real estate investing fact and turning it into an entertaining blog post.  I think people are taking the bait and providing the extra clicks.  Ben, I hope, is not asserting that it's impossible to cashflow at sub $1,000 rents and/or with sub $30,000 properties.  Real estate inputs are entirely market-specific, so certain markets will provide great investment properties at sub $1,000 rents because the lower gross rents are offset by lower costs - both monthly costs (taxes, insurance, etc.) and capex.  If Ben can't make money off sub $30,000 properties or sub $1,000 rent properties  in many of the markets investors on here invest in, then he should edit the title of the blog post.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @David Krulac 

    @Serge S. 

    I hear ya on the occasional sale.. what I am talking about is today's fresh PPM's that want to emulate the Blackstone's and Colony capitals... With there own version of going into a market and buy 500 homes.. then exiting in 5 years with returns projected in the 20% range.. with cash flow at 8%  which I can see the 8% cash flow because that's about what a investor that has to hire everything out can make...

    its the counting on reselling without substantial rehab and making the big returns that I have to wonder about.. I personally don't see it.

    I can understand it with the PPMS for multi's that were done 3 to 5 years ago and values rocketed as rents increased and money became so available.

    I have only sold maybe 3 or 4 of my properties to tenants and these were pre foreclosures ( when you could legally buy them in Oregon) and the folks just bought their home back from me.

    Now as I exit the rental business My wife has one of her aggressive lenders calling the last 9 or 10 of my tenants and trying to qualify them to buy our homes.. other than one home the rest of my current rentals are all A class so if tenant does not buy they will be retailed.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @William Donaldson 

      Ben is still searching for his next deal and its only been 2 years if what he writes about is correct.. I am personally 262 deals ahead of him in the same amount of time.. But there are JUST NO DEALS out there that make sense  !! have to force them to make sense LOL.

    And for certain there is a time and place for all asset class's..And a person for each one.. some will no doubt succeed others will end up Like Ben is talking about... No doubt about that as well.

  • Lender · Lusby, MD · Member since 2014 · 60 posts · 38 votes
    11y

    I use the 12% cash flow rule when analysizing potential rental properties. 

  • Specialist · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Dawn Anastasi:

    I do not agree with it.  Only one of my single family homes makes over $1,000 in gross rent each and I still make money on them.

     Dawn, I couldnt find the thread you recently posted for the townhome you payed $16k for, that rented for ~$800/mo. I believe you found the unit on craigslist listed for $20k.

    I was wondering, that unit sat for almost 6 months, and no one bought it for even $20k? Surely, they are many investors even in your area that have just $20k laying around, so why did no one buy it for so long? This was boggling my mind. You can PM me or feel free to reply here so everyone can learn. Thanks!

  • Rental Property Investor · Winslow, ME · Member since 2008 · 826 posts · 281 votes
    11y

    The $1,000 per month rule, if I'm hearing it right, would be like saying, "In order to make stock market investing worth it, you need to make $1,000 per month." What does that mean? What if I have 1,000,000 bucks? What if I have $35 bucks? 

    A house that you pay $35,000 for and get $700 in rent for is going to make you very good money, even if you don't self manage. A house that you pay $125,000 will absolutely lose you money if you get $1,000 a month...

  • Real Estate Broker · Naples, FL · Member since 2013 · 9k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    11y

    You cannot apply this "rule" across all markets. Furthermore, there are so many variables in each property that applying this "rule" to various assets in the same market may not make sense.

  • Investor · West Bend, WI · Member since 2014 · 214 posts · 149 votes
    11y

    My first duplex rental I paid 38K for in a good town. Fully rented with long term tenants at $995/month total. Has new roof, newer siding, new windows, new furnace and updated electric. I am meeting with my mentor next month for the first time. He is a multimillionaire real estate agent and REI. I cant wait to hear what he has to say about my current strategy, which is just my current strategy. I plan on buying larger multifamily investments once I have several smaller properties to leverage for larger projects.

    Ben has been uncharacteristically quiet for how many times he is mentioned in this forum.  I certainly have nothing against Ben and I have found some of the insight he provides useful and I am thankful to him for that. That said, applying blanket rules across every market and every circumstance using broad assumptions is irresponsible in my opinion.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    11y

    @Serge S. @Jay Hinrichs 

    Agreed. I think the consensus so far is it is not a rule that can be applied across the board in all areas. There were experienced posters that were not on board who can make it work in those sub $1000 areas. 

    There is a number that could represent a rule but that number varies in each location. I personally like the rule at $1000. If my buddy asked me what he should do, I would say get at least $1000 a month in rent to make it worthwhile and have a tenant quality you can bank on. I realize some areas that might be $750 but still that is cutting it close. I do think if you live by this rule you potentially will have less issues down the road on all fronts. 

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    11y

    @Dawn Anastasi @William Donaldson @Dan B. @Richard C. @Account Closed 

    Thanks for posting ladies and gents! All your input is appreciated. It looks like the consensus was this is not a rule. Even if it was there will be many local exceptions as noted above. 

  • Omaha, NE · Member since 2014 · 201 posts · 85 votes
    11y

    I think most of the posts are missing what the entire article was actually about. 

    it was simply stating the obvious, cap ex is a fixed minimum amount and wont work as a percentage of rent when applied to your typical $600 or $700/mo SFR.

    If you properly figure out cap ex, as in his simple demonstration (which im betting most of us havent done), even if you lower it down, cap ex is still $150/month on top of everything else on an SFR. Therefore it is physically impossible for a $600 or $700 SFR property to cashflow over the long term in most cases after you account for taxes, vacancy, maint. etc. it may cashflow well for 1 yr, 5 yrs, 10 yrs, maybe even 20. But if kept, then you are losing money.

    If you are ok with buying yourself a job to help lower cap ex then thats a different story as he mentioned. I am personally ok with buying a few properties and looking at them "as a job". my reason? Because only I can fire myself from that job! I work in construction, job stability comes and goes. My initial intent with rentals WAS/IS to buy myself a job that I control. 

    Eventually I and likely others here plan to grow out of it. But for the immediate future for me atleast, I need a job only I can fire myself from.

  • Real Estate Broker · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2009 · 575 posts · 496 votes
    11y

    Man...  there are so many flaws with this "rule" and Bens article(s) its unreal.   Two thumbs down.   Would not re-read.    

  • Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2009 · 210 posts · 261 votes
    11y

    Roof = $4,500 (1 every 20 yrs)

    HVAC = $9,000 (@ $4,500 - 1 every 10 yrs)

    Water Heater = $1,500 (@ $750 - 1 every 10 yrs)

    Total = $15,000

    $15,000/20 yrs = $750 a year = $62.50 a month.   You can increase the prices by 60% and still come out to less than $100 a month for the capex on those 3 items.  I think my son drinks that in go-gurts every month.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    11y

    @David J. 

      or a bottle of my favorite napa cab !!

  • Specialist · Portland, OR · Member since 2010 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    11y

    @David J. my experience says you need to look at all of it. Calculating capex is one thing but there are repairs, cleaning and maintenance. I am thinking closer to $200 a month and I am frugal, have very little turnover, and my tenants are gentle.

    Lets add $75 for insurance and $125 for taxes and lets say $50 for legal, misc supplies, and utilities. If your rent is $750 that leaves $300 for debt relief. Where is the cash flow?

  • Investor · Willow Spring, NC · Member since 2009 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Chad U.:

    What I find fascinating with most blogs and posts on these forums is that almost all numbers being used in the poster's analysis are fabricated or hypothetical. I have also seen numerous times where one's assertions are challenged with a request to substantiate their claim with some real numbers. 

    I think the article has many valid points and gets the point across. However, @Serge S. perhaps it would be much more substantive if you used actual CapEx numbers from your own properties instead of the ones presented?

    Agree. Anyone can make their point by double counting. Paint is Cap Ex? Is this how they really do their taxes? 

    And copper piping has a useful life of 20 years? Why don't you count the copper wiring too? If you are calculating in the copper being stolen, then put in PEX in once. Do that when you buy, and never have an issue. 

    Strike Plumbing ($6000 in worn out copper), fixtures (expense), Components (expense), Structure (unless you are in CA;), Countertop (expense), Paint (expense), and Landscaping (expense).

    So your "Cap EX" numbers are cut in half. 

    <Joke=ON>

    Below is a picture of a local newbie project who bought a 25 year old house. Me: What the $^@& are you doing?  Newbie: Gotta tear out the drywall... it's 20 years old!! 5 years past it's prime! I read Ben's blog!

  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    11y

    @David J. 

    I don't replace 50 year roof every 20 years.

    I can get new furnace installed for about $3,000.  The typical furnace I replace is because of conversion from oil to gas.  Just sold a house with a gas furnace from 1952 and a house with a 1953 furnace.  Of all the furnaces that I have replaced, I've never had to replace any furnaces and some I installed 30 years ago.  Heat pumps, not that's another story, I have replaced 2 recently, one was 12 yrs and one was 13 yrs.

    HWH typically $600 to $850, I never spent $1,500.  Had one last 35 years, and just replaced another one recently from the 1980s.  OTOH, I did have a HWH with a 6 yr warranty need replace at 6.5 yrs.

  • Real Estate Investor · Nashville, TN · Member since 2014 · 78 posts · 44 votes
    11y

    I always get something out of Ben's posts even if I don't agree with them. With that being said, do some of his assumed replacement numbers look high to anyone else? $2,500 for paint? Does he hire Banksy? $5,000 for windows? Are they stained glass? Are these estimates in future dollars? Maybe trade work is significantly more expensive in Ohio than in Tennessee but I had a 1500 square foot property painted a few months ago and it cost less than $1000 including paint. There is a company in my town that sells and installs windows for $100 per (most sizes). Does this hypothetical property have 40+ windows? Obviously we should budget for CapEx and perhaps most newbies don't but after reading that article I think it's time I move to Ohio and paint for Ben.

  • Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2009 · 210 posts · 261 votes
    11y

    @Jeff S. 

    I agree that I was only including capex.  That is just because I was referring to all the "what about the roof" folks.  I also agree that you have to look at everything.  A blanket statement that you need 1,000 a month to make any money is just blatently wrong.  I have purchased more than a couple $40,000 houses where my stretch of the flyover states that rent for $750-$800 and i am happy witht he returns I get.  $300 a month on a $40k investment is about 9%.  Lever it up and you would do a bit better.  You are right though, you have to know what you are doing, and have a little experiance, because 3k can disappear pretty quick on a turnover.

  • Dawn AnastasiPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    11y

    I also think that the numbers in the CapEx section are high. $2,500 for painting? I also usually have painting done for a 1,000 square foot house at about $600-$800 plus the cost of paint (which is usually about $100).

    I don't think the foundation needs to be replaced every 50 years either.

  • Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2009 · 210 posts · 261 votes
    11y

    @David Krulac 

    Your numbers are right where mine are.  I was just giving a general idea of how little capex acutally costs on a monthly basis.  @Ben Leybovich 

    is just trying to score high thread counts and stir the pot.  pffew.

  • Real Estate Broker · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2009 · 575 posts · 496 votes
    11y

    I'm not going to re-read this thread...  but has anyone commented on the $6,000 in copper plumbing..?    Copper?     Dude..    PEX...   PEX!!!   should be $1200 maybe 2k tops...   

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.