I was just reading Ben's latest blog post and he brought up some real numbers after owning 100 doors. His experience has led him to the conclusion you need to get $1000 per month(sfh) in order to cover expenses and still make a profit. Now he is in Ohio but he is convinced this rule applies nearly everywhere. There are some exceptions for being local but if it was under $1000 that was more of a job/investment vs a semi passive income play.
Here is his post;
http://www.biggerpockets.com/renewsblog/2015/03/03...
Should this be a rule like 50%? Let us know what you think.
I do not agree with it. Only one of my single family homes makes over $1,000 in gross rent each and I still make money on them.
Dawn you are savvy enough to be one of the exceptions. Would you think this is generally a good rule for newbies starting out?
Generally, anyone new at anything is going to make more mistakes than someone more experienced. However, newbies to real estate on Bigger Pockets have access to thousands of more experienced investors to help them with deal analysis and any questions they may have. So it's like having thousands of mentors at your fingertips. Plus, there are many people who are willing to work with someone locally just by having that person offer to buy them lunch or coffee.
Without having the internet, and sites like this, newbies didn't have as much of a support system. So now, someone could take on a project like this. It's just important to know your own limitations.
Your numbers are right where mine are. I was just giving a general idea of how little capex acutally costs on a monthly basis. @Ben Leybovich
is just trying to score high thread counts and stir the pot. pffew.
Dudes - I didn't start this thread. I have not commented on it until now. How is it that I'm trying to "stir the pot"? Tell me, @David J.
Now - if it makes everyone happy, cut the CapEx to what @dawn anastasi suggested right there in the comments to the article - $169.02:
Rent: $700
Tax/Insurance: -$200
Vacancy: -$70
Maintenance: -$70
CapEx: -$170
Management: -$70
That's CF of $120/month!
Seriously? You wanna put up with tenant bull for that? Analyze NPV for those cash flows, and in the best case scenario you realize that at a 5% discount rte you'd be loosing money in today's dollars. In other words, in real terms you'd be breaking even with the buying power of currency after a 5-7 hold period. @Mike McKinzie is right - you'd be better off buying T-bills (although I'd go for t-bone myself - enjoy it a little more)
It's just math, y'all...
lol - I said that "y'all" with a thick Russian accent
I have seen the 1000 dollar paint jobs in the south... they paint the windows shut no prep work and get paint everywhere :) we pay for new construction 2.65 a foot and that includes paint. so 1k sq ft hjouse is 2650... and so. on. but its 3 colors prep and woodwork.
There is no question in the high rental areas like were you live you can get stuff done way cheaper than in many other parts of the country.
It's flattering to be mentioned by you in a post. You always have valuable insights and your career has been pretty impressive from what I can tell. Fortunately our windows still work alright, I mostly use a guy that my father has used for almost 20 years now. He doesn't have a contractor's license but I swear the guy could tear down and rebuild my car with nothing but a hammer and I believe it would still run okay. He's like a home improvement McGyver. There is no doubt that he gives us very fair pricing but I think there are quite a few capable loyal folks in the south and Midwest where so many investors operate. He gets consistent work and referrals from our end. We get solid work and solid pricing.
@Ryan Mullin I don't know why anyone uses anything other than PEX. It's like if I went out looking for a horse and carriage IMO.
since you were so kind to mention me I would like to add that in Chicago its not legal to use PEX... its a union thing I suppose. But yes PEx is the way to go.. WE use it on every new build.. and up in Canada when I bought a new construction up there they used pex and a baffle system that was far better than anything I have seen in the states.. We are behind the times in many ways compared to construction in some of the other 1st world countries.
@Jay Hinrichs I've found some plumbers believe that the tools needed to work with it are outrageously expensive. I'm not sure where they are looking but I haven't found that to be the case. Either way I think they would make up the difference by winning bids on more projects. However, they don't ask me how to run their business, imagine that :)
Ben's right. There is a hard breakeven point that has to do with the cost of maintaining a structure over time. The economies of scale associated with multi-unit properties can mean substantial savings for the property owner.
That said, it's possible to get a return from the $30k, $700 property. See below.
| Purchase | $30,000.00 | |
| Rent | $700.00 | $8,400.00 |
| Vacancy | $70.00 | $840.00 |
| PM | $70.00 | $840.00 |
| Taxes | $72.00 | $864.00 |
| Insurance | $50.00 | $600.00 |
| Admin | $41.67 | $500.00 |
| Capex/maint | $150.00 | $1,800.00 |
| ` | ||
| Net | $246.33 | $2,956.00 |
| Expected ROI | 10% |
This is how I would expect a Cleveland property to price out, using actual numbers from experience. The unlevered return (cap rate) is 10%, which fits my criteria. Capex allows for the following upgrades, plus a miscellaneous repair budget:
| Major systems | |||
| Roof | $4,000.00 | 25 | $160.00 |
| HVAC | $4,000.00 | 20 | $200.00 |
| Ext paint | $5,000.00 | 7 | $714.29 |
| Int paint | $1,000.00 | 3 | $333.33 |
| Per year | $1,407.62 | ||
| Per mo | $117.30 |
One would surmise that there aren't too many maintenance calls for items other than those listed above. At some point, yes, you will have to upgrade the kitchen, etc., but at the same time, you're not responding to a tenant request to make the doorbell work. Using cheap and durable materials for those turnover repairs will go a long way to keeping capex down.
And that's the name of the game in these low cost rental markets. Keep expenses as low as possible. Make your living spaces absolutely bulletproof. If you can get through a turnover with a mop job and a paint spray, you'll make a killing. If you install nice carpet and corian countertops, you'll lose your shirt. The $700 tenants aren't expecting all that much anyway.
@Christian Carson - couple of points:
1. You are an attorney, and as such don't have to pay contract services for filing of evictions, the kind of thing that I am assuming you are referring to in Administrative. $41 to you would therefore be more for most...
2. After subtracting the $117 for accrual of replacements, you are left with about $130/month of true CF. OK, but if you calculate the IRR it comes out to a bit over 5%. What this means, is that at a discount rate of 5%, the NPV of these cash flows is at a break even pint over a hold of about 7 years and presuming no appreciation, since we are taking about PIGs here. In this case, why bother?
3. Now - if you sell for $60,000, having bought for $30,000, that would change the entire picture, but then this is not a PIG...
Thoughts?
So a PIG by definition is a $30,000 property that can't be sold for much more than $30,000, because of the neighborhood and is just bought for the cash flow????????
@David Krulac - of course :)
Some people got it. The article, at least the "read between the lines component" had to do with the IRR more than the CapEx. CapEx was just there to illustrate the "fixed cost" nature of what we deal with. But, the essence of knowing whether we are getting ahead is a function of discounting cash flows and seeing past the garbage (cash on cash) which means nothing.
Discount the CCR to today's money. Discount the windfall at the end to today's money. Which is to say, figure out the net present value of both based on a discount rate you deem reasonable. Then figure out the internal rate based on those discounted cash flows. This will give you a very true future worth of today's investment relative to today's dollars.
The thing is - since due to what it is and where it is a PIG by definition precludes that big windfall at the end which would drive that IRR, we have to solely rely on the cash flows. And that's not going to happen in a $700/month rental due to CapEx - the best we would do is break even in real terms. This is what the article was about. Makes sense?
Then there are $30,000 Pigs that are not to buy because they're not appreciating, and there are $30,000 non-Pigs that are priced below market and likely will increase in value.
The problem is that some people will be buying the former and think they have the latter.
On the $30,000 properties that I have bought only one was bought on the presumption of no appreciation growth, and was a superior house for the neighborhood, but the neighborhood will always hold down its value. I bought it as a pure cash flow play, but the monthly rent was 3% and I thought that was acceptable.
I have seen the 1000 dollar paint jobs in the south... they paint the windows shut no prep work and get paint everywhere :) we pay for new construction 2.65 a foot and that includes paint. so 1k sq ft hjouse is 2650... and so. on. but its 3 colors prep and woodwork.
There is no question in the high rental areas like were you live you can get stuff done way cheaper than in many other parts of the country.
In new construction you're starting with bare drywall so yes you do have to primer it and then paint everything -- walls, ceilings, and trim. Generally I only have them paint walls and trim. Sometimes just walls as the trim might be okay, and then it's less. Rarely do I re-paint ceilings. So you do have 3 colors there. I just do 2 colors, walls one color and trim another.
@David Krulac - I think it's safe to assume that a $30,000 / $40,000 / $50,000 turn-key "investment" in the Midwest will be exited at the same price (or less) than that which it was bought for.
In fact, I actually asked a turn-key operator in Ohio what the projected exit in his model is. He told me that they advise people not to bank on any capital gains. In fact, he said, the property mihgt be sold for less than bought, and that's OK since it was being bought for "Cash Flow".
On one hand, Dvid, what they are doing is admirable. They are selling pigs in Ohio. They know there's no futures value-add. They are being honest with investors in communicating this message, which is good.
However, they are justifying the investment via performing very basic CCR analysis to underwrite returns, which do not include CapEx (and other very real costs), and which are not discounted to time (no IRR).
I hope my article illustrated clearly that this logic is a fart in the wind, but many investors are buying this logic. I was going to write a follow-up post presenting the discounted CF modeling, but since I'm being accused of "stirring the pot" as is, I may just hold off on that... Besides, the turn-key community really loves me already as is ... :)
It's just numbers - it really is. We just have to know how to read them...
I see what you are saying. I found a cashflow neighborhood, not in a city, where cashflow could be had but I anticipated little to no appreciation. Most people are brainwashed to think that all real estate must appreciate. Buy real estate, its the best investment that you can make. And I've found that when you tell people that there will be no appreciation, they think that you are wrong, too conservative, or trying to CYA.
I think that the high cash flow low or no appreciation model does have some merit, but I wouldn't have that as my only investment strategy.
We've talked about buying in neighborhoods with good schools and low crime and growth, but another factor is the percentage of rentals in the neighborhood. In many of my purchases, I'm the only rental on the street of owner occupants. Sometimes I'm the only rental in the neighborhood or development. In one development of 88 houses, I was the only rental and one neighbor expressed concern to me that I was changing the neighborhood into an inferior rental neighborhood! one house out of eighty eight. There are neighborhoods and even entire towns where there are more rentals than owner occupants, a 50%+ of housing is rentals. That's a neighborhood/town that I'm probably not in and not going to be in.
It is extremely difficult to prove that NOBODY can make money on $30,000 houses. It basically comes down to lots of mumbo-jumbo, hand waving, yada, yada. rocket science.
But it is not rocket science. It only takes one example of somebody who IS making money to disprove this premise.
I'm sure a lot of people lose money on such investments, however @Dawn Anastasi IS making money, and I know investors in my area are making money on these investments.
@Christian Carson - couple of points:
1. You are an attorney, and as such don't have to pay contract services for filing of evictions, the kind of thing that I am assuming you are referring to in Administrative. $41 to you would therefore be more for most...
2. After subtracting the $117 for accrual of replacements, you are left with about $130/month of true CF. OK, but if you calculate the IRR it comes out to a bit over 5%. What this means, is that at a discount rate of 5%, the NPV of these cash flows is at a break even pint over a hold of about 7 years and presuming no appreciation, since we are taking about PIGs here. In this case, why bother?
3. Now - if you sell for $60,000, having bought for $30,000, that would change the entire picture, but then this is not a PIG...
Thoughts?
My computer ran out of battery about a second after I submitted my post last night, so I wasn't able to do anything about the corrupted tables (which shows up fine in the WYSIWYG, @Joshua D. !!)
Let me do this in bullet-point format:
To address your point (1), Ben, there's $500 per year in the eviction budget. I don't assume you will have to evict someone every month, nor every year, so this should also account for tenant placement costs.
To point (2): the "replacement" cost is built into the capex budget. Maybe if you're out of state, your PM will bamboozle you into dumping a whole lot into maintenance, but frankly I don't do all that much to these houses other than replace the major systems when needed (which is usually when I buy).
Don't get me wrong, margins are thin. And I'm not one to pay sticker price for anything, so I buy these houses for $5000 and replace all the major systems up front for a maintenance-free house for a good long while. That's the way to do it. :)
I basically agree with the article. My parameters are a bit different. I want to make at least $10,000 gross rent per year (which is about $835 per month) on a SFH or up to a 4 unit house/apartment, otherwise it's not worth it to me. It's also why I think people on this site should have to state how much their portfolio is valued at. When someone says they own 10 "doors" or 10 houses and I see the location is in an area where houses are the price of cars, that doesn't impress me. I don't see the appeal of owning a small home and doing all the work needed to only make $100-$200 in cash flow and own 10 of them. I'll put that money in a REIT if that's my ROI. I rather own 2-3 houses that are valued at the same price as someones 10 house portfolio.
However, SOMEONE has to buy those shacks. So good for you if you do.
@Dawn Anastasi @David Krulac @Jeff S.
Let's pretend you guys were out of the country for the next 18 months. Would your rentals be just fine or is the hands on value you provide so critical that you would be worried?
Outstanding question. THIS should be the new "rule", the one that determines whether you are "investing" or "working."
Agreed, I want to get into real estate as an investment, not to give myself another job. It will take a lot of work to get there, but that's the goal. Not to just save a few dollars because I'm managing them all myself, and now I work twice as much as I did when I had a "regular job"
Amen!
Although I'm a newbie this is the way I feel as well.
I guess the PM fees are always going to be a worry and take a bite outta your cash flow.
But what I really worry about re single family or apartments is the capex / maintenance. If you're clearing say $500/mo. on a place that rents out for $1000/mo. (using the 50% rule) but you've got an older roof and all sort of aging appliances I just really have to question how the property is going to cashflow say 5-10-15 years down the road if you have to do extensive maintenance. I mean a couple washers & dryers here, some foundation and roof work here and there and all of a sudden you've got $10K+ in expenses in one year that is eating into your rents. Maybe that's an extreme case but it's a big worry of mine or the CF places I'm looking at.
@John C. you have to use your head. To begin with do something like Ben did which was a "reserve study" of sorts and prepare yourself. If you need a roof in 2 years the 50% rule isn't worth squat. Just look at all of the components and estimate useful life and prepare yourself. In 20 years or so you can look back and go oh yeah, looks like about 50%.
Another thing, if you are in low budget properties 50% won't be enough as is pointed out in this thread.
This is a crazy long post and I looked at the numbers Ben had and just shake my head. Some of em seem pretty reasonable. Some of em are just completely nonsense. You can argue with me all day long but I can guarantee you that I'm NOT going to be replacing copper in a home every 20 years.
Are you kidding me? I'm seeing houses today that are 50 years old and still have the same copper in em. And there doesn't appear to be anything wrong with it either. Maybe before they had pvc, I could see plumbing needing some repairs. That clay drain tile is garbage.
But now that everything is pvc, there is no way I'm buying that you're going to replace copper every 20 years. My home is 15 years. I haven't replaced a single pipe. And there is no way on this earth that I'm going to need to replace ALL of it in another 5 years.
HVAC 10? Again, my hvac is 15 years old. Not a problem.
So its one thing to look at how the IRS suggests you can depreciate things at. Its another reality to do a reasonable cap ex projection off it. The IRS doesn't know what the heck is going on. Just because a person replaces an hvac system doesn't mean it has no useful life left. Maybe they just wanted a newer a/c?
Cabinets/countertops 20 years? Again, I'm getting some houses with 40 year old cabinets. And, guess what, they're not in terrible shape. They're staying. They'll be there another 20 or 30 years too. Countertops get replaced during rehab typically. But its much cheaper to replace countertops (600 if you use stock laminate and then pay for labor) then the 4,500 they are setting cap ex for.
Come on. If you're honestly replacing cabinets when they hit 20 years, you have an issue.
I'd bet the realistic numbers of what the true lifespan of these items is would be more like 1,000 a year and not the crazy 3k number I'm seeing here.
Even a roof. Where are you getting 5k for a roof? Its going to depend entirely on the size of the home no? A typically 1,400 to 1,500 sq ft home with an attached garage is going to be around 19 square? Are you going over the existing or replacing? Replacing? Then 220/square? If doing a second layer, then 175/square?
I'd say a roof is more like 25 to 30 years these days anyway - if you're going with the better shingle which most people do nowadays.
Again, just taking the depreciation schedule and saying that the IRS version of the useful life is how long it will actually last is the whole problem with this argument. Its not reality.
Quite honestly, if anybody on here is replacing their cabinets every 20 years, please let me know. I would love to have them. :-)
really depends on your tenants ... you get nice easy going tenants your probably right you get some rough ones and you could have cabinets get thrashed and need replacing.
Also depends on what your market will bear.. will your houses rent with 40 year old cabinets that have been painted 7 times...
Also tenants never change filters in HVAC so unless your on top of that you can have an HVAC not go to its full life span.. etc etc.
I suspect it somewhere in the middle.. What I do know though is a home that has been maintained as a rental is not suddenly going to sell for a retail price.. major cap ex would need to be spent to do this.
And of course it depends on the market for certain. what works in Ohio may not work in Vegas etc etc.
@Jay Hinrichs "What I do know though is a home that has been maintained as a rental is not suddenly going to sell for a retail price.. major cap ex would need to be spent to do this." - this is so true, and has such dramatic impact on returns. I did not talk about this in the article, as this would have mean a complete overload to an already heavy piece...
see this comment I made at the beginning of the thread
"
Not sure about the 1000 dollar rule.. but one thing I think is a flaw in the buy hold mind set is that these properties can be rentals for 5 to 10 years then sold to owner occ for a profit.
I don't see that at all ... even If you could somehow talk someone into moving into a rental area and being a new homeowner the improvements you would need to make to make the property RETAIL ready would probably eat up half or more of any cash flow you made the previous 5 years.
I see this with the current crop of smaller players starting buy and hold funds... I read these PPM's and the business model is all the same.. some type of cash flow generated by rents. Say 8% to the investor.. then they are going to sell in 5 years for a big profit so investor then cash's in and makes a PROJECTED 20% plus return.. I think this is wishful thinking as there is no provision in the PPM for major reno to get it ready to sell at the end of the term. I think its very wishful thinking that a home used and maintained just enough to be a rental will sell for a profit great enough to meet the PPM sponsers projections. Now caveat being inventory that was bought 2 to 4 years ago at the bottom of the trough.. but for these NEW PPMs just coming into the market I wonder "
@Jay Hinrichs - pigs cannot be re-positioned for retail; it's a function of where they are even more than what they are. What makes them a pig is that nobody wants them. lol
$1,000/month rentals can be, but, as you said, major CapEx will be required. If there was appreciation to catch the slack then the IRR can be in good shape, if not...