Do you lease or buy your vehicle ?

Do you lease or buy your vehicle ?

Real Estate Agent · Warrior Run, PA · Member since 2016 · 341 posts · 146 votes
I’m curious what the community here has to say. My dads in the car business and swears by leasing. I’m all about wealth building and assets and I think buying is the better option. I’m currently torn between buying new/newer used vs leasing....OR buying an old junker for a few years to keep DTI low. What’s everyone else doing?
4Reply
943 views

Most Popular Reply

Allentown, PA · Member since 2016 · 515 posts · 404 votes
8y

@Nicholas Weckstein

If you ever get on the Dave Ramsey bandwagon, he will tell you that on the list of dumbest ways to finance a car: Leasing is #1, Car note is #2, and Owning is #3. You are going to rent out a car that is going to decrease in value once you take it off the lot, the same is said for a car note. The insurance on leased cars and bank financed cars tend to be quite higher than vehicles owned free and clear.

There is nothing wrong with buying older model cars and they don't have to be complete beaters that are on their last leg. You can find pretty descent vehicles between 2005-2014 model years with not too high mileage and be surprised how well they run.

Many people will tell you go for a Japanese model car because they are more reliable, and they are right, most are. However, with my experience, it does not really matter. The parts for American cars tend to run pretty cheap, thus repairs tend to be on the cheaper side as compared to foreign cars.

I have a 2003 Volkswagen Jetta and a 2005 Jeep Cherokee, that I own free and clear. Just them being owned free and clear, makes me happy because its like a boulder lifted off my shoulder. I pay $82 monthly (with comprehensive insurance) for BOTH cars. I average a max of $500 in repairs per year. If you do the math, I still come out on top compared someone leasing or has a car note. I plan on running these suckers to the ground and once I do, guess what I am getting again? A beater.

Not having a monthly payment is a blessing, strive for it.  

See this reply in the discussion

142 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Specialist · Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 111 posts · 28 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Brian Adzadi:

    @Nicholas Weckstein

    If you ever get on the Dave Ramsey bandwagon, he will tell you that on the list of dumbest ways to finance a car: Leasing is #1, Car note is #2, and Owning is #3. You are going to rent out a car that is going to decrease in value once you take it off the lot, the same is said for a car note. The insurance on leased cars and bank financed cars tend to be quite higher than vehicles owned free and clear.

    There is nothing wrong with buying older model cars and they don't have to be complete beaters that are on their last leg. You can find pretty descent vehicles between 2005-2014 model years with not too high mileage and be surprised how well they run.

    Many people will tell you go for a Japanese model car because they are more reliable, and they are right, most are. However, with my experience, it does not really matter. The parts for American cars tend to run pretty cheap, thus repairs tend to be on the cheaper side as compared to foreign cars.

    I have a 2003 Volkswagen Jetta and a 2005 Jeep Cherokee, that I own free and clear. Just them being owned free and clear, makes me happy because its like a boulder lifted off my shoulder. I pay $82 monthly (with comprehensive insurance) for BOTH cars. I average a max of $500 in repairs per year. If you do the math, I still come out on top compared someone leasing or has a car note. I plan on running these suckers to the ground and once I do, guess what I am getting again? A beater.

    Not having a monthly payment is a blessing, strive for it.  

    /\/\/\/\ THIS right here!  Cars are nothing but a money pit as soon as you drive it off the lot. Dumped my brand new lease with all the gadgets two years ago for a well maintained, beautiful 2000 Jeep Cherokee. No payment, and I cut my insurance premium nearly in half! And, I LOVE my cherokee :)  

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @John S.:

    Here is my take on Lease/Buy.  You buy a used car 30k mileage say 25k you put down 3k now you owe 23k at lets say 3%(Very Low interest) the loan is for 5 years. Repairs not high maybe $500.00 a year. 

    Now take a lease $500.00 down total do on 2 year lease $5000.00 This is a car that cost around 30k. No maintenance or repairs.

    Let's look at the numbers: 

    First option you put 3k down and pay for the first 2 years around 12,000.00 in payments and $500.00 maintenance. total out $15,500.00 for two years.  You don't have any value in that car at all at this time.  Go forward to 5 years and paid off now you have spent total 34,500.00 the value of said car that is now 7-8 years old is 2k.  You spent 32500.00 to drive for 5 years.

    Second option, For five years of leases including down payments 14,000.00 and you have had no worries or maintenance.  

    Now decide do you want to be out 32,500.00 in 5 years or 14,000.00.  I think I can find somewhere else to spend the 18,500.00 that would make me money. 

    And yes the insurance on both senerios is higher than owning the car.  And if you keep said car for longer the repair bills go up and the insurance goes down.  

    Good Luck deciding about Leasing-Buying.

    I don't think your numbers are accurate. What car are you using in this example? 

    Probably the cheapest car out there is the Kia Rio LX and base price is $14,000. Here is the numbers from their website:

    48 month purchase, $0 down, 0% interest promotion, monthly payment $308, total paid over 4 years $14,784 (no miles limit) total maintenance maybe $600 for those four years.

    48 month lease, $300 security deposit, monthly lease payment $292, total paid over 4 years $14,016 (limit of 12,000 miles)

    Looking at Cars.com and searching four year old Kia Rio LX, they are selling for $7000 uses, so in this example after four years, you have paid about the same in both situations, but if you purchase, you own a vehicle worth $7000 that has five years of life left. I can assure you over the first four years there is not $500 a year worth of maintenance per year. Oil change is $50 and beyond that brakes and tires will need to be done once and that is only going to be a $400 expense. The other major problem with the lease option is miles limits. In this comparison it is 12,000 miles on the leased vehicle or you get penalties.

    Of course leasing is a better deal for the dealership, that is why they push it.

  • Rental Property Investor · New York, NY · Member since 2011 · 956 posts · 510 votes
    8y

    I bought a 2000 jeep Cherokee in 2003 with 55 k miles . Paid 6,000 . Now it has 180k miles , I’ve put in new brakes and muffler over the years . 

    I often pass by BMW s in the winter stuck on side of road . When this Jeep dies I’ll buy another used one for the next 10 years and save my cash to build wealth through real estate. 

  • Central, MN · Member since 2015 · 148 posts · 184 votes
    8y

    It is a personal preference.  I don't care what I drive, so I drive the old Honda Odyssey family vehicle.  My wife very much cares about what she drives and drives a Jeep Cherokee.  The only people to really respond to this thread are people like me, who don't care what they drive.  In my opinion, if you aren't going to run it into the ground, I'd lease, especially if you are like my wife and want to drive something else every 3-4 years.  You don't have to worry about unexpected costs, you get the set it and forget it treatment.  My guess is many of the folks who drive things into the ground also mow their own lawn, shovel their own snow, etc... OR they choose to not do those things, but make their stand with what they drive.  I don't think either is wrong, but I wish I was in the car business because the folks who drive beaters are fewer and fewer everyday.  I'd say the car folks are doing just fine either way!

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    "the folks who drive beaters are fewer and fewer everyday." 

    Likely a big contributing factor as to why so man people live pay check to pay check. Have to look good driving to the pay day loan store.

  • Guy with Great Hair · Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

    "the folks who drive beaters are fewer and fewer everyday." 

    Likely a big contributing factor as to why so man people live pay check to pay check. Have to look good driving to the pay day loan store.

     yeah, people in mass generally make AWFUL financial decisions, even in the face of good advice.

    so if you find out what most people are doing and do the opposite, you'll probably end up in really good shape ;)

    paying interest on a high depreciation luxury is worse than buying a house in market mania and speculating that it will appreciate to no end. the house MIGHT appreciate, but the car is DEFINITELY going to be worth nothing in 8 years. buying a car should be an effort in minimizing the damage for the necessity of driving.

    Buying a car you like is for suckers, same as real estate.

  • Flagstaff, AZ · Member since 2016 · 44 posts · 60 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

    @Account Closed

    "you can fit an entire sheet of drywall / plywood in a caravan"

    Yep that is the reason I buy caravans with the stow away seats. A caravan and a utility trailer will out perform a pick up truck hands down. Nice thing is mine is jammed full of tools all the time and with tinted windows I never have to worry about theft. Pick up trucks, definatly the yuppie trucks, are pretty useless. Parking lots full of pick up trucks that have never been worked. Nothing more than transportation for most truck owners.

    Love Caravans, most practical vehicle built. Cheep, common as dirt and reliable.

     A 2001 Grand Caravan can tow 1,800 lbs and has a GVWR of 5,550 lbs, with a self weight of 3,999 lbs.

    A 2001 Tundra has 7,800 lbs of towing capacity, a GVWR of 6,200 lbs and a self weight of 4,644 lbs.

    Even a tiny 2001 Ford Ranger can tow 5,620 lbs.

    How is that minivan going to outperform a pickup truck, in any way related to rehabbing and maintaining real estate? I am genuinely curious as to why you think this way. You say funny things quite often, but this one may take the cake.

  • Covington, OH · Member since 2018 · 19 posts · 18 votes
    8y

    Cash for beaters looks like the way to go! Old used cars don't have to be boring! I drive a 1999 Jeep Wrangler! Loads of fun!

  • Liberty Hill, TX · Member since 2017 · 3 posts · 5 votes
    8y

    I have an interesting solution to the car payment situation.

    I started with a cheap car(a 1990 miata with no A/c haha) i bought for $1500 and it was great. But roasting in texas and the occasional break down were starting to wear on me. I am a car guy so fixing the little issues that popped up were no big deal but the were adding up in cost and wearing on my patience. 

    I found the electric car that i felt had the best range to price benefit. For me it was the Chevy bolt because the range is great and so is the price which you can haggle them to mid 30's. This makes alot more sense if you drive alot(which i do, 37 miles each way) because for me i was spending a couple hundred a month on gas.

    So lets say 35k and the government will give you a 7500 tax credit(not including the state and city incentives) thats 27,500. Keep in mind you dont get the 7500 till taxes are filed. if you have good credit make sure to visit a local credit union because i have had car notes as low as 1.9% with a payment in the 450 a month range for this cost on a car. i took how much i was spending on gas which averaged around 200 per month and that left me 250 a month i was realistically paying for the car. with the 7500 coming in from taxes it is like getting paid back for almost a year and a half of the rest of the payment(the 250 a month). with the tax credit and adding in the gas i was using on a very fuel efficient car its almost like the car is free for almost the first couple years. 

    I live in the Austin area so the electric charging terminals are pretty common to see. I rarely pay anything to charge the car because most of the ones i found and use regularly are free. The amount added to my home electric bill is so small that i cant even measure the difference. 

    Side benefits were that i have a new car with warranty that costs nothing and fuel and has no maintenance costs. I never have to stop at a gas station again saving time. Filling up is just something that happens when you arent driving.  The latest Tech like android auto and a fun fast car. my wife and i recently had a child so safety and 4 doors with easy carseat mounts was a plus. Also with the tech like android auto you can have google on demand with a button and easily listen to podcasts through apps on the phone while driving(BiggerPockets=) )

    Not all situations are the same but it is definitely worth a look when the government still has the program for taxes. 

  • Rental Property Investor · York, PA · Member since 2017 · 377 posts · 315 votes
    8y

    @Paul Ewing - Um... am I the only one wondering what the story is behind a bull running into your car?

  • Nicole A.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Baltimore County Maryland and Tampa Florida · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @MIchael Rickerd:
    Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

    @Account Closed

    "you can fit an entire sheet of drywall / plywood in a caravan"

    Yep that is the reason I buy caravans with the stow away seats. A caravan and a utility trailer will out perform a pick up truck hands down. Nice thing is mine is jammed full of tools all the time and with tinted windows I never have to worry about theft. Pick up trucks, definatly the yuppie trucks, are pretty useless. Parking lots full of pick up trucks that have never been worked. Nothing more than transportation for most truck owners.

    Love Caravans, most practical vehicle built. Cheep, common as dirt and reliable.

     A 2001 Grand Caravan can tow 1,800 lbs and has a GVWR of 5,550 lbs, with a self weight of 3,999 lbs.

    A 2001 Tundra has 7,800 lbs of towing capacity, a GVWR of 6,200 lbs and a self weight of 4,644 lbs.

    Even a tiny 2001 Ford Ranger can tow 5,620 lbs.

    How is that minivan going to outperform a pickup truck, in any way related to rehabbing and maintaining real estate? I am genuinely curious as to why you think this way. You say funny things quite often, but this one may take the cake.

     I, too, was curious about that thinking. I figured what he really was trying to say was that lots of people with pickups don't actually work them and use them to their full potential. But yeah, a truck would definitely out-perform a Caravan when it comes to towing and such. 

    We have a 2007 diesel Dodge Ram 2500 (and it's manual trans!), and that thing is a beast. We have used it for a lot of work and fun.

  • Ned J.Pro Member
    Investor · Manteca, CA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y

    I build custom cars as my hobby, so I'm the last one to ask :) I dump stupid $$ into my cars because that's my vice..... don't travel much, don't buy nice clothes or eat out a lot...for me that my one "stupid decision" with $$...everything else I'm pretty good with...

    About a year ago I bought I used 2016 Challenger Hellcat for 55k.....20k under the original price...had 830 mi on it....and I paid cash....was that a stupid financial decision....yes....but oh boy is that car FUN :) and its was a "treat" for myself.... life is too short to make every decision in life about $$... you cant take it with you.

    My daily drivers are different....buy low mileage used majority of time....majority of time with cash, but if I can get a really cheap rate I'll finance it for awhile, use my cash to make other $$ and pay it off quickly....but did buy my wife a new 2013 Eqiunox because that's what she wanted and "happy wife, happy life" Is no joke

    Bottom line.....vehicles are horrible investments...so just make sure you make the decision based on the right reason

  • Beaverton, OR · Member since 2014 · 118 posts · 119 votes
    8y

    I'm in the vast minority, but I lease my wife and I's vehicle, and genuinely feel like it's been a better financial decision. However, I've paid FAR less than what I'm seeing people quote here. First lease was a Ford Cmax Energy ($35k MSRP), and that cost me $118/mo with $0 down out of pocket, not even license or tags. I have leased a couple cars since then (Corollas mostly), all for less than $145/mo with $0 down.  And I've never paid a penny for maintenance, tires, brakes, or even oil changes.

    Depreciation and maintenance on a mid-range used vehicle I figure has to at least be in that ballpark of cost, PLUS I get to deduct the lease payment on taxes.

    The biggest kicker of them all though.....Opportunity cost. I've taken the 15k I would have spend to buy two used cheap cars and doubled it in the last 5 years. Pretty much made my leases "free" if you look at it that way compared to the alternative.

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    @MIchael Rickerd

    "How is that minivan going to outperform a pickup truck"

    Comparing a pickup to a van is like comparing a jack knife to a multi tool.

    Because the box of a pickup truck is fully exposed to the weather.  I can not leave my power tools in it out in the weather or expect them to be there in the morning if left out over night. Aside from my tractor I rarely need to tow anything heavier and if I do it will be dirt or gravel delivered in a dump truck. I do tow a 1/2 ton box trailer with dirt and gravel regularly. 

    Pickups are good for carrying limited items only for short time periods. My vans have had my full tool box , compressor, chop saw and all my hand tools continuously for 15 years while renovating. Can't realistically do that with a pickup without having to continuously load or unload. You could however have a cab put on a pickup but if you did that you might as well buy a van that can also be used to carry passengers.

    Head to head a pickup outperforms a van in towing capacity but a van is simply 100% more practical as a all round work vehicle for a contractor.

    I have spent over 40 years exclusively using a van. Full size initially then Caravan when they came out. As a contractor I would never trade one for a pickup as a work vehicle. Check out any company having tradesmen, van will always be the go to work vehicle, first choice every time. Add a trailer and you have everything you will ever need. Add a family and the Caravan does double duty with the stow away seats.

    Pickups have morphed into minimally more than transportation,  van is a work vehicle.

  • Dan BurstainBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2014 · 361 posts · 331 votes
    8y

    You will hear both sides to this argument and rightfully so because every car is different.  It comes down to the Money Factor (aka screw factor).  It is simple math to figure out if you should lease or buy but the big difference when you ask the dealer to delineate the numbers is what they call the Money Factor.  That number really is the true cost of the lease over buying.  I normally lease but just bought two cars for my wife and I because both were sports cars and money factors are much higher on sports cars.   

    Dan Burstain, Investment Realtor51 Review
  • Real Estate Agent · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2017 · 48 posts · 42 votes
    8y

    I just had to get in on this one.  We have two vehicles, Honda Pilot and Buick Enclave.  The Honda is paid for, but we still have a note on the Enclave purchased used about 18 months ago after a total loss.  While the interest rate is decent (under 3%), I hate having car payments.  The first time I had a no car note, I thought I'd hit the lottery.  

    I have leased, purchased, and paid cash.  Cars are made up of many parts that can break down no matter how old.  I once had a brand new car that kept draining batteries.  Before the car was 5 months old, it had gone through 4 batteries.  Sometimes they are good and sometimes they aren't.  Bottom line, however, is that if your goal is to become truly wealthy (not just in terms of finances), you must avoid debt.  If your goal is to be seen in a new car every few years, then leasing is definitely the way to go.  Some would call that keeping up with the Jones' (who don't know you and don't care about what you drive).  As far as convincing your dad to come to your point of view...

    A man convinced against his will is of the same opinion still -- Ben Franklin

  • Real Estate Investor & Consultant · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2016 · 620 posts · 386 votes
    8y

    @Nicholas Weckstein I think buying a used car that you really like is better in your scenario. 

    I am a huge Range Rover fan, so instead of leasing a new one or buying a new one, I found a mint used RR that I love at a price I was willing to spend cash for. 

    IT's an asset. 

    Onward

    sjw

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y

    We buy usually used. We can't lease because we can't keep the mileage down and I have kids who drive which means I pay a ton for insurance when they are still at my address.  A little ding i am not turning it into the insurance company.  In the end though it is mostly about what you need in the vehicle and how you can effectively buy that service/capacity. Do you need to carry tools all the time or for some of you also small kids? Do you need to tow or AWD.  

    We bought a La Cross new a few years ago because it was an AWD sedan with rear air bags which were important to me and we could not get a good deal used.   We just got a used 2014 SUV with lane departure, backup cams, and towing capacity because we need that now. Both those vehicles we considered that we are buying mileage and we always use our vehicles up.  However I wondering about how much some of you use your vehicle because  vehicles have maintenance cost you have brakes and tires minimum exhaust work if you live in the northeast.  I have never ever owned a car that didn't need maintenance.  

  • Lewisville, TX · Member since 2015 · 344 posts · 264 votes
    8y
    Personally, I would say the two things that have most allowed me to build a high net worth portfolio of real estate is avoiding student loans & then making super economical car choices. I drove a beater hand me down for a couple of years in high school & then was gifted a truck that was purchased cheaply with bare bones options. After I drove 120,000 miles on that mostly while hyper-miling to college a couple hours away & back while building my portfolio of house hacks & later rentals. That truck also ran a very successful lawn service for me & helped with construction products. After college a few years later I bought a Ford Focus for under blue book from a friend facing a second car repossession & potential bankruptcy. I was unable to manually get the title released & unlock his nearly $5k in equity while getting a car that’s very easy to park & gets excellent mileage. I would say with liability only insurance, gas & no car loans thus no interest I’ve spent no more than $2,500 per year driving around car necessary DFW mostly on gas although the repairs have been heavy this last year or so but nothing compared to a an average or even low payments. I buy wipers & spark plugs & brakes online & any other part I can & use local mechanics who work from their homes or an occasional shop for oil change, etc. You can cut car costs significantly have pretty reliable transportation & get around while building wealth. One final thing I’m starting to embrace more is buying a car from an insurance auction & having a mechanic friend repair the car decently so you own low mileage with no car payment or the best of both worlds. We are doing this for my new wife when we return to Texas!
  • Allentown, PA · Member since 2016 · 515 posts · 404 votes
    8y

    @Marci Stein

    Jeeps are the most awesome brand American has ever made, bar none. For the past 5 years I had this used car, the total I have spent repairing it is less than $1,500. 

    Once you fold down those back passenger seats, you can fit a whole army in there if you want to. Ok, well that is a bit of an exaggeration but honestly, my wife had once fit a small fridge, a washer and dryer in that baby all at the same time with space to boot, amazing. 

    Mine is 155,000 and still ticking. The A/C giving a problem but luckily I live in the Northeast where I only have to deal with heat for only 3-4 months. 

    Once this this baby dies on me finally (Honestly don't know when that is going to be). I am going for another early model Jeep. LOVE IT, LOVE IT, LOVE IT. 

  • Jordan MoorheadBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Austin, TX · Member since 2015 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8y
    Buy used and in cash.
  • Lewisville, TX · Member since 2015 · 344 posts · 264 votes
    8y
    Should say *able. And my biggest mistake except for the truck which I didn’t personally choose was buying Ford. The brand outside of some SUV’s & diesels isn’t very reliable & really bad for their smaller cars. Labor is basically double because it’s so compact & $60 for replacement spark plug wires that crumble in your hands. Other parts have been equally annoying. Plus the car is built like a razor blade with them not recommended much past the 100k mileage mark!
  • Rental Property Investor · East Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    8y

    What is it with dad's and bad car advice?

    Mine isn't in the car business or didn't push me to buy/lease new, but he always has. Going way back, he's had some nice cars. He can't remember what happened to them or how much he sold them for but talks about them sometimes.

    But he only has the 1 house. He could have bought 14 other houses with the $ he's wasted on payments and he admits every house he's ever owned doubled in value by the time he sold it. When considering financial advice from a parent, look at their portfolio picture!

    My vote is to buy used with cash. Like a lot of people on here, we could just about buy any stupid car we want but don't choose to impress or be the Joneses.  The Joneses look good but are broke. Spend your money on assets that appreciate.

  • Charlotte, NC · Member since 2018 · 180 posts · 144 votes
    8y
    Always pay cash. Used better than new. Never spend > 2 months salary (2 weeks is my target, wife gets closer to 2 months). Use cost of ownership and comfort as main drivers. Only carry liability insurance. Don’t pay over KBB private party price. Good Luck! Chris
  • Rental Property Investor · New York, NY · Member since 2011 · 956 posts · 510 votes
    8y

    @Brian Adzadi- didn’t they tell you that Jeeps expand according to how much you need to put in it ? that’s what it feels like - Lol. I’ve moved homes in there with queen size beds .

    Anyway , I’d always prefer to be rich than look rich , as @Steve Vaughan says. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.