Growing Markets with 1% properties

Growing Markets with 1% properties

Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes

I'm an out of state investor looking for potential markets to invest in for buy and hold SFR rentals. After hours of scrolling around the map and trying various cities, I was not having much luck finding a market where the numbers made sense. Nothing was getting close to the 1% "rule". So I decided to do some data analysis across the US to see where those markets might be. Here is how I did it and the results. I hope you find this useful!

I wanted to find markets where there are 1% properties (the monthly rent is about 1% of the ARV). I downloaded the data from Zillow (https://www.zillow.com/research/data/) on median rental price by zip code, and the median sales price by zip. I used the most recent data from May 2019. There are 13059 zip codes with both rental data and sales data. I next filtered for zip codes that have a population of at least 7k people. I also picked only zip codes that have a median sales price of at least $100k. That filters down to 6440 zip codes.

Of those, per zip code I did the division to see how close it is to 1%. I selected the zip codes that were 0.8% - 1.2%. That drops to 965 zip codes - now we’re getting somewhere!

As one last filter, I picked zip codes that have a population growth of at least 25% (using usa.com data so 2010-2014). The idea here is to find markets that have a decent chance of appreciating over time.

And the final result is 99 zip codes. Here they are sorted by state!

  • AL: 35040, 36567, 36582
  • FL: 32025, 33936, 33981, 34109, 34110, 34114, 34287, 34465, 34472
  • GA: 30038, 30122, 30168, 30213, 30291, 30296, 30331, 30349, 30701, 31088, 31525
  • IL: 60002, 60073, 60443, 60446, 60505, 60538, 62221
  • IN: 46235
  • LA: 70520, 70726, 70785, 70820
  • MS: 38637, 38671
  • NC: 27127, 27834, 28217
  • NJ: 08330, 08759
  • OH: 43950
  • OK: 73135, 73160, 74429
  • SC: 29073, 29229, 29316, 29505, 29527
  • TX: 75051, 75134, 75159, 76134, 76140, 76310, 77014, 77034, 77038, 77041, 77045, 77047, 77049, 77064, 77065, 77067, 77073, 77075, 77082, 77083, 77084, 77086, 77089, 77090, 77301, 77303, 77338, 77373, 77378, 77396, 77449, 77471, 77477, 77521, 77539, 77545, 77591, 78043, 78046, 78222, 78224, 78503, 78504, 78526, 79416, 79423, 79707
  • WV: 26104

Some caveats: This is using median data from zillow for rents and sales. I'm sure that number has had some significant massaging before zillow puts it out. For rents in particular, it seems like some of these zips have no rentals or only very few - those should probably be thrown out. Also, median doesn't capture the diversity in a market. The median SFR rental may not be directly comparable to the median sale. Likewise, zip code is a very blunt geographical segmentation and misses variations of neighborhood, etc. And of course I filtered out a bunch of stuff as described above. Basically, I'm sure I missed out on areas that have 1% properties and not all of the properties in these zips will be 1%. But this should be a good starting point for doing detailed property analysis.

Hopefully this list is useful for those of you looking for new markets as I am. I’m happy to answer any questions.

30Reply
269 views

Most Popular Reply

Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 33 votes
7y

@Kent Lyons - nice. I would suggest dropping the 25% population growth filter and adding a rent growth filter instead. You've got many areas in the country growing fast, but if there is a large corresponding supply of land the population growth will not translate to rent growth or home price growth. On the other hand you've got places in the country with no population growth but insane rent or price growth due to high demand and constrained supply (ie bay area, jackson hole, many other resort towns). Drop the population growth filter since it's a poor proxy for rent/price growth and just filter on rent/price growth directly.

See this reply in the discussion

45 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2019 · 6 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    Very smart, thanks for putting that work in and sharing it

  • Real Estate Agent · Cupertino, CA · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    Good job. You need to separate condos, th from SFH. The asking price is unlikely to the the finalized agreed (sold) rent. A lot homes need reduction and tenants always want a discount. Average $/sf is a more meaningful since you got 400 to 20,000 sf + homes in most districts.

    I will probably not spend much time looking at 1%.  But 2, 3, ..5%  possibly Great School rating score combined will give investors a better tool. A graphic coverage for the Union is also very useful.

    Thanks

    Sam Shueh

  • Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2017 · 138 posts · 69 votes
    7y

    Cool info @Kent Lyons!  When you were calculating the 1% based on the rental price, what were you factoring in for things like vacancy, repairs, property management, etc?

  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 33 votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons - nice. I would suggest dropping the 25% population growth filter and adding a rent growth filter instead. You've got many areas in the country growing fast, but if there is a large corresponding supply of land the population growth will not translate to rent growth or home price growth. On the other hand you've got places in the country with no population growth but insane rent or price growth due to high demand and constrained supply (ie bay area, jackson hole, many other resort towns). Drop the population growth filter since it's a poor proxy for rent/price growth and just filter on rent/price growth directly.

  • Lititz, PA · Member since 2013 · 595 posts · 272 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Rob Malda:

    @Kent Lyons - nice. I would suggest dropping the 25% population growth filter and adding a rent growth filter instead. You've got many areas in the country growing fast, but if there is a large corresponding supply of land the population growth will not translate to rent growth or home price growth. On the other hand you've got places in the country with no population growth but insane rent or price growth due to high demand and constrained supply (ie bay area, jackson hole, many other resort towns). Drop the population growth filter since it's a poor proxy for rent/price growth and just filter on rent/price growth directly.

    Good idea. How does one determine if rent growth will occur?  What statistical conditions must exist?

  • Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 33 votes
    7y

    @William Coet - it's hard to forecast but a historical rent/price growth would be a good proxy for future rent/price growth (certainly better than historical population growth). I think once you filter it down you have to look at the markets one-by-one and analyze what's been driving the historical rent/price growth and whether the growth is likely to continue. If it's driven by a single industry or employer (ie shale oil in the dakotas) that's very risky and not sustainable. If it's driven by a diversified demand it's more likely to continue.

  • Real Estate Agent · Wilson, WY · Member since 2016 · 11 posts · 3 votes
    7y

    @Rob Malda I would say that places with a limit on the future supply would indicate a market based more on appreciation than cash flow, and you won't find many 1% rule properties. In Jackson Hole they aren't very prevalent anyway.

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Rob Malda that is a good idea. There is about a decade of historical rent data on zillow and about 20 years of sales data. So depending on if you want to prioritize cash flow from rent or appreciation (or somewhere in between) you could add a filter accordingly across all of the data. From the little bit of poking around these markets are showing strong appreciation (bouncing back from the great depression) with slow and steady rent increases. There could be pockets with more or less of one or the other.
    As a side note, 25% growth actually isn't that much looking at this data. Several of these zips are at 75%+. What it does filter out are markets that are flat or down, which I personally want to avoid.

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Pete Woelfel these are median rental prices (or more likely estimates) from zillow. That would be more or less what the renter pays. Any costs would need to be deducted from that number. And since these are medians, you'd really still need to do a per property analysis. My problem was I couldnt find anything close to that. Once I pulled these zips, there seem to be many options.

  • Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2017 · 13 posts · 0 votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons thanks for sharing this information i actually live in the IN zip code

  • Engineer · Portland, OR · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Rob Malda I would qualify that. While expandable land attenuates pricing on relative housing inventory, new housing stock is generally not competitive against older and cheaper class C housing stock, due to modern costs of building. For the houses I buy to rent I’m not competing with new housing stock and in fact new construction on buildable land increases both my rents and appreciation.

  • Engineer · Portland, OR · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons I use Zillow data a lot and as you discovered it’s a mixed bag. Obviously you have to use both qualitative and quantitative analysis. So I use Zillow data and census/demographic data for baseline qualification then dig down using my own subjective requirements. That will not always capture the best markets but it definitely filters your search to some great potential choices for boots on the ground further research. I think the biggest challenge is discovering what your personal filtering criteria is as clearly you understand numbers well enough.

  • Member since 2019 · 20 posts · 2 votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons

    This is really cool. Thanks for posting. I am from Atlanta and will check out the GA zips.

  • Real Estate Agent · Oklahoma City, OK · Member since 2019 · 956 posts · 600 votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons this is so great!! Areas around those zips in OKC you can get them fairly often as well. It really depends on the provider you're working with on if you can actually snag them or not. I'm off-market all the way. 

  • Rental Property Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2018 · 18 posts · 4 votes
    7y

    Thanks for sharing this Kent!

  • Rock Hill, SC · Member since 2019 · 4 posts · 4 votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons. Awesome. Thanks for sharing. I own in

    NC 28217 and would agree with the analysis!!

  • San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 3 posts · 3 votes
    7y

    @Kent Lyons great job! Thanks so much for doing this. Good info

  • New to Real Estate · Dallas, TX · Member since 2019 · 22 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    Thanks for posting this!

  • Investor · San Francisco, Bay Area · Member since 2019 · 62 posts · 16 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kent Lyons:

    I'm an out of state investor looking for potential markets to invest in for buy and hold SFR rentals. After hours of scrolling around the map and trying various cities, I was not having much luck finding a market where the numbers made sense. Nothing was getting close to the 1% "rule". So I decided to do some data analysis across the US to see where those markets might be. Here is how I did it and the results. I hope you find this useful!

    I wanted to find markets where there are 1% properties (the monthly rent is about 1% of the ARV). I downloaded the data from Zillow (https://www.zillow.com/research/data/) on median rental price by zip code, and the median sales price by zip. I used the most recent data from May 2019. There are 13059 zip codes with both rental data and sales data. I next filtered for zip codes that have a population of at least 7k people. I also picked only zip codes that have a median sales price of at least $100k. That filters down to 6440 zip codes.

    Of those, per zip code I did the division to see how close it is to 1%. I selected the zip codes that were 0.8% - 1.2%. That drops to 965 zip codes - now we’re getting somewhere!

    As one last filter, I picked zip codes that have a population growth of at least 25% (using usa.com data so 2010-2014). The idea here is to find markets that have a decent chance of appreciating over time.

    And the final result is 99 zip codes. Here they are sorted by state!

    • AL: 35040, 36567, 36582
    • FL: 32025, 33936, 33981, 34109, 34110, 34114, 34287, 34465, 34472
    • GA: 30038, 30122, 30168, 30213, 30291, 30296, 30331, 30349, 30701, 31088, 31525
    • IL: 60002, 60073, 60443, 60446, 60505, 60538, 62221
    • IN: 46235
    • LA: 70520, 70726, 70785, 70820
    • MS: 38637, 38671
    • NC: 27127, 27834, 28217
    • NJ: 08330, 08759
    • OH: 43950
    • OK: 73135, 73160, 74429
    • SC: 29073, 29229, 29316, 29505, 29527
    • TX: 75051, 75134, 75159, 76134, 76140, 76310, 77014, 77034, 77038, 77041, 77045, 77047, 77049, 77064, 77065, 77067, 77073, 77075, 77082, 77083, 77084, 77086, 77089, 77090, 77301, 77303, 77338, 77373, 77378, 77396, 77449, 77471, 77477, 77521, 77539, 77545, 77591, 78043, 78046, 78222, 78224, 78503, 78504, 78526, 79416, 79423, 79707
    • WV: 26104

    Some caveats: This is using median data from zillow for rents and sales. I'm sure that number has had some significant massaging before zillow puts it out. For rents in particular, it seems like some of these zips have no rentals or only very few - those should probably be thrown out. Also, median doesn't capture the diversity in a market. The median SFR rental may not be directly comparable to the median sale. Likewise, zip code is a very blunt geographical segmentation and misses variations of neighborhood, etc. And of course I filtered out a bunch of stuff as described above. Basically, I'm sure I missed out on areas that have 1% properties and not all of the properties in these zips will be 1%. But this should be a good starting point for doing detailed property analysis.

    Hopefully this list is useful for those of you looking for new markets as I am. I’m happy to answer any questions.

     Hi Kent, stumbled on your post, very insightful! I too live in the Bay Area and am looking OOS. I was wondering what market you ended up going with if you don't mind me asking?

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    @Alexander Canha I actually was bad a following my own analysis! I had a potential partner in the north atlanta area (which if you notice, is not on this list). I went chasing some opportunities there, but either the numbers didn't work or they didn't take hold.

    I actually just redid my analysis making some simplifications, using current data (through July 2020), and my own personal criteria. Based on that, I'm going to redouble by efforts looking at parts of Columbia SC, a few zips the south side if Atlanta (OTP), and next on my list will be the south side of Dallas and Ft Worth.

  • Investor · Marin County California · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    Interesting experiment.  

    St Clairsville OH (43950) looks like a place where you would go to lose money.  

    I would keep adjusting the algorithm.  

  • Member since 2018 · 20 posts · 6 votes
    6y

    I'm in 29229 sc, I invest in 29106. I can find 1% rule properties all day. In this area it is very easy to find sub 100k properties that are perfect brrrr candidates. 100k is an arbitrary number that may seem cheap in California but out here they are just reasonably priced homes. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Darius Ogloza:

    Interesting experiment.  

    St Clairsville OH (43950) looks like a place where you would go to lose money.  

    I would keep adjusting the algorithm.  

    For sure this isn't going to give a final answer and will have both false positives and false negatives. The intent was where were likely places to go fishing and then do your real diligence.

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    To follow up, I've changed some of my early criteria. My new list is looking at positive population growth, non-negative rent growth in the past year, less than 40% rental and more than 50% owner occupied. And finally median rent to sales of 0.7% - 1.4%. This gives a healthy margin plus or minus the 1% since these are nominally median values and come from zillow (so taken with a large grain of salt).

    Finally, I personally have no desire to deal with rentals where it snows, so I filtered this mainly to the south (I left in the west, but nothing showed up and no offense to El Paso but it didn't just fit on the map).

    Metro and zip codes:

    • Greensboro-High Point [27265]
    • Raleigh [27610]
    • Charlotte-Concord-Gastonia [28083, 28214]
    • Columbia [29073, 29209, 29229]
    • Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Roswell [30014, 30058, 30088, 30134, 30135, 30180, 30213, 30228, 30248, 30253, 30273, 30294, 30296]
    • Birmingham-Hoover [35040, 35235]
    • Memphis [38018, 38125, 38637, 38671]
    • Louisville/Jefferson County [40272] 
    • Baton Rouge [70726] 
    • Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington [75040, 75043, 75060, 75104, 75115, 75126, 75134, 75137, 75146, 75154, 75217, 75227, 75241, 76002, 76018, 76036, 76123, 76133, 76134, 76135, 76140, 76148, 76179]
    • Houston-The Woodlands-Sugar Land [77045, 77047, 77083, 77084, 77086, 77088, 77089, 77303, 77346, 77373, 77388, 77396, 77449, 77489, 77493, 77521, 77545]
    • San Antonio-New Braunfels [78109, 78223, 78233, 78252] 
    • El Paso [79924, 79936]
    • Rental Property Investor · NJ and PA · Member since 2019 · 206 posts · 105 votes
      6y

      @Kent Lyons Thank for doing all this analysis. Very helpful stuff. One key thing I'm surprised hasn't come up in the comments (and never seems to in conversations about the 1% rule) is taxes. they can vary hugely across markets. I think, rather than rent/price, a better measure is (rent-taxes)/price, and then maybe discount the guideline a bit to something slightly below 1%.  Personally, I think 1% is still too low in any case, but that's for individual properties, not for market medians.

    Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.