Growing Markets with 1% properties

Growing Markets with 1% properties

Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes

I'm an out of state investor looking for potential markets to invest in for buy and hold SFR rentals. After hours of scrolling around the map and trying various cities, I was not having much luck finding a market where the numbers made sense. Nothing was getting close to the 1% "rule". So I decided to do some data analysis across the US to see where those markets might be. Here is how I did it and the results. I hope you find this useful!

I wanted to find markets where there are 1% properties (the monthly rent is about 1% of the ARV). I downloaded the data from Zillow (https://www.zillow.com/research/data/) on median rental price by zip code, and the median sales price by zip. I used the most recent data from May 2019. There are 13059 zip codes with both rental data and sales data. I next filtered for zip codes that have a population of at least 7k people. I also picked only zip codes that have a median sales price of at least $100k. That filters down to 6440 zip codes.

Of those, per zip code I did the division to see how close it is to 1%. I selected the zip codes that were 0.8% - 1.2%. That drops to 965 zip codes - now we’re getting somewhere!

As one last filter, I picked zip codes that have a population growth of at least 25% (using usa.com data so 2010-2014). The idea here is to find markets that have a decent chance of appreciating over time.

And the final result is 99 zip codes. Here they are sorted by state!

  • AL: 35040, 36567, 36582
  • FL: 32025, 33936, 33981, 34109, 34110, 34114, 34287, 34465, 34472
  • GA: 30038, 30122, 30168, 30213, 30291, 30296, 30331, 30349, 30701, 31088, 31525
  • IL: 60002, 60073, 60443, 60446, 60505, 60538, 62221
  • IN: 46235
  • LA: 70520, 70726, 70785, 70820
  • MS: 38637, 38671
  • NC: 27127, 27834, 28217
  • NJ: 08330, 08759
  • OH: 43950
  • OK: 73135, 73160, 74429
  • SC: 29073, 29229, 29316, 29505, 29527
  • TX: 75051, 75134, 75159, 76134, 76140, 76310, 77014, 77034, 77038, 77041, 77045, 77047, 77049, 77064, 77065, 77067, 77073, 77075, 77082, 77083, 77084, 77086, 77089, 77090, 77301, 77303, 77338, 77373, 77378, 77396, 77449, 77471, 77477, 77521, 77539, 77545, 77591, 78043, 78046, 78222, 78224, 78503, 78504, 78526, 79416, 79423, 79707
  • WV: 26104

Some caveats: This is using median data from zillow for rents and sales. I'm sure that number has had some significant massaging before zillow puts it out. For rents in particular, it seems like some of these zips have no rentals or only very few - those should probably be thrown out. Also, median doesn't capture the diversity in a market. The median SFR rental may not be directly comparable to the median sale. Likewise, zip code is a very blunt geographical segmentation and misses variations of neighborhood, etc. And of course I filtered out a bunch of stuff as described above. Basically, I'm sure I missed out on areas that have 1% properties and not all of the properties in these zips will be 1%. But this should be a good starting point for doing detailed property analysis.

Hopefully this list is useful for those of you looking for new markets as I am. I’m happy to answer any questions.

30Reply
270 views

Most Popular Reply

Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2017 · 43 posts · 33 votes
7y

@Kent Lyons - nice. I would suggest dropping the 25% population growth filter and adding a rent growth filter instead. You've got many areas in the country growing fast, but if there is a large corresponding supply of land the population growth will not translate to rent growth or home price growth. On the other hand you've got places in the country with no population growth but insane rent or price growth due to high demand and constrained supply (ie bay area, jackson hole, many other resort towns). Drop the population growth filter since it's a poor proxy for rent/price growth and just filter on rent/price growth directly.

See this reply in the discussion

45 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    Check out Aurora IL. You can get over 1% here and the prices are growing like crazy (5-10%) increases for the 2-4 units lately. Have done a bunch of deals there. Also Elgin IL a bit less growth but still solid cashflow. Some of the other zips you did for IL are iffy and you really need to drive these areas vs look at raw data. The markets within markets can be tottaly differant for 2-4 units, renters vs buyers, owner occupants vs subsidized renters moving in, etc. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Hendersonville, NC · Member since 2016 · 446 posts · 412 votes
    6y

    Nice work!

  • Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2019 · 576 posts · 307 votes
    6y

    I have closed over a dozen deals this year in San Antonio that meet or beat the 1% rent rule, they are definitely out there. If you haven't had luck finding them on MLS, try venturing in the off-market side.

  • Rodney MenendezPro Member
    Developer · South West Florida · Member since 2020 · 74 posts · 53 votes
    6y

    @Kent Lyons

    Hi Kent, any reason why FL was removed from your updated results?

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    @Rodney Menendez just because I personally am not looking there.

    Here is the full list without the filter on state. Also remember this is for SFR, so I'm sure you'd get a different list looking at other property types.

    • Greensboro-High Point [27265]
    • Raleigh [27610]
    • Charlotte-Concord-Gastonia [28083, 28214]
    • Columbia [29073, 29209, 29229]
    • Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Roswell [30014, 30058, 30088, 30134, 30135, 30180, 30213, 30228, 30248, 30253, 30273, 30294, 30296]
    • Jacksonville [32221, 32244] 
    • Deltona-Daytona Beach-Ormond Beach [32725, 32738] 
    • Palm Bay-Melbourne-Titusville [32796, 32907, 32909] 
    • Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach [33484] 
    • Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater [33534, 33570, 33573, 33782, 34609, 34668] 
    • Lakeland-Winter Haven [33830, 33880, 33881]
    • Cape Coral-Fort Myers [33971]
    • North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton [34221, 34286]
    • Port St. Lucie [34983]
    • Birmingham-Hoover [35040, 35235]
    • Memphis [38018, 38125, 38637, 38671]
    • Louisville/Jefferson County [40272]
    • Columbus [43119]
    • Cincinnati [45231]
    • Dayton [45424]
    • Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson [46131, 46221, 46228, 46241]
    • Detroit-Warren-Dearborn [48021, 48066, 48071, 48237, 48239, 48240]
    • Grand Rapids-Wyoming [49507]
    • Minneapolis-St. Paul-Bloomington [55412]
    • Chicago-Naperville-Elgin [60030, 60073, 60107, 60120, 60411, 60435, 60443, 60506]
    • St. Louis [63033] Kansas City [64055, 64056, 64133, 64138]
    • Omaha-Council Bluffs [68106]
    • Baton Rouge [70726]
    • Oklahoma City [73115, 73159, 73160]
    • Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington [75040, 75043, 75060, 75104, 75115, 75126, 75134, 75137, 75146, 75154, 75217, 75227, 75241, 76002, 76018, 76036, 76123, 76133, 76134, 76135, 76140, 76148, 76179] Houston-The Woodlands-Sugar Land [77045, 77047, 77083, 77084, 77086, 77088, 77089, 77303, 77346, 77373, 77388, 77396, 77449, 77489, 77493, 77521, 77545]
    • San Antonio-New Braunfels [78109, 78223, 78233, 78252]
    • El Paso [79924, 79936]
  • Rodney MenendezPro Member
    Developer · South West Florida · Member since 2020 · 74 posts · 53 votes
    6y

    @Kent Lyons Thank you, great Info!

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Gary Parilis nails it. I think rent/price ratios are meaningless if you're making a comparison across markets. Both taxes and insurance rates can vary greatly from market to market. A 1% rent ratio in a market like Dallas with high taxes and insurance rates is much different than it would be in a market like Kansas City with relatively low taxes and insurance. Rent ratios have nothing to do with bottom line.

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    100% agree about taxes. The same applies for say markets with 100 year old homes - your capex is likely to be non-trival. Or a D neighborhood were your vacancy and repairs could be higher relative to an A. So the "1% rule" is of course only a rule of thumb and you need to take into account the specifics of both the local market and each individual property.

    I wish there was better data available. That is really the limiting factor for doing such an analysis at a large scale. I actually don't like using the medians, but that is what I can get. The other part is individual goals. With both of those you can do the analysis property by property, but scaling it up to a larger region is much harder without that info.

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Kent Lyons I'm surprise to see Memphis and Birmingham on your new list since you've added population growth to your model. Both have stagnant or declining populations. I don't see Indianapolis or Kansas City on the list. Both fit your rent ratio criteria and also have strong population growth, 

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    @Mike D'Arrigo These are probably details about the specific data and how it is aggregated. I'm not analyzing at a city/metro level, but by zip code. So to pull out the two zip codes in Birmingham as an example, here is the census data about population growth:

    Zip code 35040: 2010: 14965, 2017: 16714
    Zip code 35235 2010: 19484, 2017: 19630

    So both were technically growing in this data, 35235 just barely whereas 35040 is better especially from a percentage perspective. You could imagine putting a threshold on desired growth. It also says nothing of the overall area. Likewise, I haven't looked to see if there is more recent data than 2017 - once the 2020 census is done, that will be a great resource.

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    @Kent Lyons I agree that it's good to drill down to the neighborhood level but when it comes to macro level trends like population and job growth, I like to look at it from the metro level, That gives a better picture of the health of the overall market. Personally, I'm not comfortable with a market that has pockets that are good but the market in general is not healthy, 

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    I should also add that I know zip code is a pretty useless unit for understanding real estate, but it is how the data comes.

  • Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 3 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    @Kent Lyons

    Just want to say thank you for putting this together! While people’s critiques have some validity, this list helps a ton for prospective out-of-state investors who want to understand what areas to consider. Just wanted to send some appreciation your way!

    That said, I’d like to dig through the data myself and maybe make a friendly UI for it. Could you list all your resources and maybe a title of what you used it for? Thank you!

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    @Gilbert Hsu thanks for the positive feedback! My day job is a scientist so I'm always happy to take constructive criticism and I know there are strengths and weakness for any data or analysis. But yes my hope was this would give folks a good starting point to use with all of the other info out there.

    The idea of making this more user friendly with a UI is and interesting one. The data came from the census (2010 and the 2017 update - I'd need to look at exactly which subset I used though, it's huge!). And then the zillow data which you can download from them. Everything else is basically data munging - load it up, do some joins, do some filters, etc.

  • Real Estate Agent · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2018 · 72 posts · 37 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    @Kent Lyons I'm surprise to see Memphis and Birmingham on your new list since you've added population growth to your model. Both have stagnant or declining populations. I don't see Indianapolis or Kansas City on the list. Both fit your rent ratio criteria and also have strong population growth, 

    I can only speak for Birmingham, but many people are moving out of Birmingham proper and into the surrounding areas (like the 35235 zip code). So while inside the Birmingham city limits may be declining, I'd think you'd find the overall MSA is growing. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2019 · 76 posts · 43 votes
    6y

    @Trey Crusey, I have to respectfully disagree. For the past ten years people have been moving from the suburbs and into the city. This trend is happening in tertiary markets across the country. Birmingham is no different. In the past five years there has been an explosion of new apartment inventory Downtown and in Southside. People aren't moving to 35235 from 35205, etc. They are coming from 35068, 35209, and other parts of the suburbs. It is the MSA that has had flat growth. People are moving into Birmingham. I've made a good living this past decade because of it.

  • Chandler, AZ · Member since 2018 · 9 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Kent Lyons, why isn't Dayton disqualified due to its population growth being slightly negative?

  • Rental Property Investor · Silicon Valley, CA · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 50 votes
    6y

    @Anthony Maza I didn't check, but probably for the same reason as Birmingham above. This analysis is not at the city/MSA level it is at the zip code level. So this analysis says nothing about the metro area in general. One thing that is a bit telling is the number of zip codes listed in a region. Areas with only one or a couple are showing only localized effects. Part of that is likely due to size, but it could also be population trends and rent to sales ratios. In contrast, some of these metros have multiple zip codes which might point to a broader regional trend. But to really know you'd need to crunch the numbers.

  • Rental Property Investor · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2021 · 69 posts · 31 votes
    4y

    Hello,

    Since this is such a common investor question, I am curious whether software exists to identify zip codes where the one-percent rule applies (as an average). Perhaps propstream or mashvisor now provide this information?

    Regards,

    Danny

  • Little Neck, NY · Member since 2014 · 27 posts · 7 votes
    4y

    The zillow data is sorted by city, how were you able to break it out by zip code?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.