$2 million to invest - need $20k per month

$2 million to invest - need $20k per month

Member since 2019 · 13 posts · 6 votes

I am the trustee of my father's trust. He has $2 million available and I need it to make close to $20k per month to cover his monthly expenses. This must be fairly passive. My idea I am toying with is to invest in $2 million worth of turnkey rental properties, paying all cash. No leverage. Going on the idea that the 1% rule appears achievable in many of the successful turnkey markets, this seems like a workable plan. Is it? And while I don't need appreciation, am I fairly likely to get pretty much the same amount back as I started with when I sell them down the road if he passes away? I wouldn't have to sell them immediately.

Are there any far better ideas than this given my requirements, or is this a pretty good, safe way to get close to the monthly cashflow I'm looking for? By the way, I realize it is not entirely passive but I have several rental properties of my own and I will be able to monitor the investments properly. Would greatly appreciate anybody's feedback on my situation.

1Reply
349 views

Most Popular Reply

Brian BurkePro Member
Investor · Santa Rosa, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 7k+ votes
6y

@Alex Williams $20K/month on $2 million is a 12% cash-on-cash return.  I think that achieving that is fairly unlikely, unfortunately.

Rental homes:  Assuming you buy a $200,000 house that rents for $2,000 per month (not the easiest to find but perhaps not impossible), and your expenses are $700/month (vacancy, repairs and maintenance, property taxes, insurance, utilities, capital improvements—35% expense ratio), your cash flow is $1,300/ mo or $15,600 per year.  That’s a 7.8% return.

Hard Money Loans:  You can loan your money out at 12% to real estate investors flipping homes and those in need of bridge financing.  This space is competitive, however. The best properties owned by the best borrowers can get bridge financing all day long for 5% to 8% depending on the project.  12% money most often goes to the lowest quality borrowers and/or properties.  Certainly not always so there is a chance you can score a few borrowers that are high quality and willing to pay 12%. But you won’t be the only one looking for that borrower.  $2 million is a lot to place so that’ll be tough.  Let’s just say you find enough quality borrowers willing to pay 12%—their goal is to resell that property fast so the interest doesn’t kill them—so those loans will soon pay off and you’ll be back out there looking for more borrowers.  Meanwhile whatever money isn’t placed in a 12% loan is probably placed in a bank account earning 0%. Your idle capital will result in your true total return being far below 12%.  The constant drumbeat of payoffs will result in you spending a lot of time on paperwork to originate loans and facilitate releases, plus servicing costs (subtract that from your return too!), and you might run into licensing requirements as well.

Syndications:  You can invest in syndications, but no matter what anyone says most syndications will throw off a cash flow in the neighborhood of 5% in the first year, and might get to 12% by year 5 or 6.  Hitting 10% by year 3 is not impossible but pretty difficult.  I have an institutional investor that will fund our deals if I can project a 10% return by year three. I haven’t shown them a single deal in three years—I just don’t see a 10% return by year 3 unless I alter my underwriting assumptions too far toward the aggressive side of the scale.

Finally, to your question about how to vet syndicators—there are many threads in the BP forum that can get you started. If you wait until spring, BP is publishing a book on this very topic, written by yours truly.  Unfortunately, that won’t help you much today.

You’ll probably find that you need to adjust your expectations downward—perhaps you can balance that by streamlining your father’s living expenses by looking for areas to save costs. Otherwise I suspect you’ll be bleeding off some of the principal to subsidize the expenses that exceed the earnings.

See this reply in the discussion

51 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Alex Williams:

    I am the trustee of my father's trust. He has $2 million available and I need it to make close to $20k per month to cover his monthly expenses. This must be fairly passive. My idea I am toying with is to invest in $2 million worth of turnkey rental properties, paying all cash. No leverage. Going on the idea that the 1% rule appears achievable in many of the successful turnkey markets, this seems like a workable plan. Is it? And while I don't need appreciation, am I fairly likely to get pretty much the same amount back as I started with when I sell them down the road if he passes away? I wouldn't have to sell them immediately.

    Are there any far better ideas than this given my requirements, or is this a pretty good, safe way to get close to the monthly cashflow I'm looking for? By the way, I realize it is not entirely passive but I have several rental properties of my own and I will be able to monitor the investments properly. Would greatly appreciate anybody's feedback on my situation.

     Alex, I have a substantial single-family rental portfolio that I also purchased with cash and with no leverage, which I also use to generate passive income.

    If I'm calculating correctly, you are looking for a 12% return from income while remaining passive.

    Every market in the country is different, but in my opinion the numbers on this do not add up and you are very unlikely to hit your goals. If you're looking for a 5 to 6% return it would be easy in many markets (as long as you avoid the high appreciation/low income markets in California etc). 7 to 8% might become a stretch but depending on the market could be done and/or if you are willing to take on some additional risk with the neighborhood etc.. (The latter is not something I personally feel comfortable with doing). 12%, in my opinion, isn't realistic.

    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
  • Real Estate Agent · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Ian Ippolito:
    Originally posted by @Alex Williams:

    I am the trustee of my father's trust. He has $2 million available and I need it to make close to $20k per month to cover his monthly expenses. This must be fairly passive. My idea I am toying with is to invest in $2 million worth of turnkey rental properties, paying all cash. No leverage. Going on the idea that the 1% rule appears achievable in many of the successful turnkey markets, this seems like a workable plan. Is it? And while I don't need appreciation, am I fairly likely to get pretty much the same amount back as I started with when I sell them down the road if he passes away? I wouldn't have to sell them immediately.

    Are there any far better ideas than this given my requirements, or is this a pretty good, safe way to get close to the monthly cashflow I'm looking for? By the way, I realize it is not entirely passive but I have several rental properties of my own and I will be able to monitor the investments properly. Would greatly appreciate anybody's feedback on my situation.

     Alex, I have a substantial single-family rental portfolio that I also purchased with cash and with no leverage, which I also use to generate passive income.

    If I'm calculating correctly, you are looking for a 12% return from income while remaining passive.

    Every market in the country is different, but in my opinion the numbers on this do not add up and you are very unlikely to hit your goals. If you're looking for a 5 to 6% return it would be easy in many markets (as long as you avoid the high appreciation/low income markets in California etc). 7 to 8% might become a stretch but depending on the market could be done and/or if you are willing to take on some additional risk with the neighborhood etc.. (The latter is not something I personally feel comfortable with doing). 12%, in my opinion, isn't realistic.

    Is it significant that you did not recommend any crowdfunding? The amount of research and reporting that you have done in this area just leads me to wonder. 

  • Ian IppolitoBusiness Member
    Investor · Tampa, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Alex Williams:

    I am the trustee of my father's trust. He has $2 million available and I need it to make close to $20k per month to cover his monthly expenses. This must be fairly passive. My idea I am toying with is to invest in $2 million worth of turnkey rental properties, paying all cash. No leverage. Going on the idea that the 1% rule appears achievable in many of the successful turnkey markets, this seems like a workable plan. Is it? And while I don't need appreciation, am I fairly likely to get pretty much the same amount back as I started with when I sell them down the road if he passes away? I wouldn't have to sell them immediately.

    Are there any far better ideas than this given my requirements, or is this a pretty good, safe way to get close to the monthly cashflow I'm looking for? By the way, I realize it is not entirely passive but I have several rental properties of my own and I will be able to monitor the investments properly. Would greatly appreciate anybody's feedback on my situation.

     Alex, I have a substantial single-family rental portfolio that I also purchased with cash and with no leverage, which I also use to generate passive income.

    If I'm calculating correctly, you are looking for a 12% return from income while remaining passive.

    Every market in the country is different, but in my opinion the numbers on this do not add up and you are very unlikely to hit your goals. If you're looking for a 5 to 6% return it would be easy in many markets (as long as you avoid the high appreciation/low income markets in California etc). 7 to 8% might become a stretch but depending on the market could be done and/or if you are willing to take on some additional risk with the neighborhood etc.. (The latter is not something I personally feel comfortable with doing). 12%, in my opinion, isn't realistic.

    Is it significant that you did not recommend any crowdfunding? The amount of research and reporting that you have done in this area just leads me to wonder. 

    The thing is that it's very rare to find a crowdfunding/syndication deal that doesn't use debt.

    The Real Estate Crowdfunding Review
    View Page
  • Paul MoorePro Member
    Commercial Real Estate Fund Manager · Lynchburg, VA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Hi @Alex Williams.  I would take to heart the responses of many here, and pay special attention to those from @Brian Burke and @Ian Ippolito, as they have done this for a while and have great reputations. 

    As far as notes, have you considered @Dave Van Horn's PPR Note Funds? He has funds offering 12% I think. 

    I would recommend that you do three things if possible: (1) Try to vet a syndicator(s) with the very best track record possible. One who you can trust, and you believe will not lose your money.  (2) Invest with them at a lower cash payout (say 6-8% annually) plus appreciation. (3) Allow the appreciation to grow that $2 million up to (say) over $4 million over a handful of years. And if you can go another cycle, this time at $20k/month income, you should be able to grow that $4 million to $8 million. 

    I am personally (and through my company) investing with best-in-class syndicators who are providing returns like this on a consistent basis. This is very doable. The only obvious downside is that there will be several years where you will get less than $20k/month first. If that is a deal-breaker, then ignore my strategy. 

  • Member since 2019 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    6y

    Thank you to everyone for all the great feedback and information. A lot to consider there.

  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    It's not an undoable way, but why pay cash and not leverage? Leveraging the money will exponentially increase your returns and make you much more likely to achieve $20k+ per month than paying in cash. Any reason in particular for not wanting to leverage?

  • Investor · Canyon Lake, CA · Member since 2015 · 92 posts · 34 votes
    6y

    The best advice I can give is to look at Ian Ippolito's posts above and become a member of his Crowd Funding Real Estate Review. Spend a lot of time on that site, and I think you'll learn a lot about how to invest as an accredited investor. 

    Membership is free, and you'll find the wealth of information to be extraordinary.

    Good luck.

  • Member since 2019 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    6y

    @Ali Boone Ali, because it's money in my father's trust and not just my money, I want to keep the risk as low as possible. I don't want to have $2 million in rentals and 2008 happens again, perhaps I lose tenants perhaps I don't, but I want the money invested with a minimum of risk and stress if things go to crap.

  • United States · Member since 2015 · 401 posts · 394 votes
    6y
  • Developer · Point Pleasant Beach, NJ · Member since 2015 · 303 posts · 216 votes
    6y

    There will be risk in anything you buy.  Just try to keep the risk level as low as possible.  If you use some leverage you wont necessarily be taking on a ton of risk.  Just dont maximize leverage.  Also, in order to minimize risk, learn how to value properties and make sure you buy below market value.  Never get in a bidding war, never be the top bidder for a heavily marketed property... Look for off market deals and buy below market value.  There is no better way to minimize risk and maximize returns. 

  • Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y

    If there was a good, safe way to get 12% fairly passive cash flow, every available dollar in the country would be invested in it.

    Based on the limited information that can be gathered on your goals in a post, NNN and/or syndicaitons may be the best strategy IMO. Anything smaller is going to be a part-time job.

    TK providers are frequent posters on BP but we never hear from TK investors with seven figure portfolios.  I imagine they are out there.

  • Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2015 · 625 posts · 601 votes
    6y

    @Alex Williams IDK your investing experience but IMO you should sit down with a reputable financial advisor and see what they suggest to get you the return you want. You probably have access to investments you aren't even aware of. I would never invest 2 mil in a bunch of low value single family rentals that's for damn sure.

  • Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2015 · 625 posts · 601 votes
    6y

    @Mary Mitchell Real talk. This is the only answer lol.

  • Real Estate Coach · Venice Beach, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Alex Williams:

    @Ali Boone Ali, because it's money in my father's trust and not just my money, I want to keep the risk as low as possible. I don't want to have $2 million in rentals and 2008 happens again, perhaps I lose tenants perhaps I don't, but I want the money invested with a minimum of risk and stress if things go to crap.

    Gotcha. For sure do whatever is most comfortable, but know that if you buy properties for cash flow and not solely on appreciation potential, crashes don't necessarily have to affect the entire property(ies). It's all in buying smartly. Can offer more info on that, but if you buy the right properties even for cash, you should be pretty good for passive income. I only work with turnkeys, but $2M could get you 20 $100k turnkeys that cash flow $600-800/month (net), which at least pushes you up towards that $20k/month. 

  • Rental Property Investor · TN · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Ali Boone:
    Originally posted by @Alex Williams:

    @Ali Boone Ali, because it's money in my father's trust and not just my money, I want to keep the risk as low as possible. I don't want to have $2 million in rentals and 2008 happens again, perhaps I lose tenants perhaps I don't, but I want the money invested with a minimum of risk and stress if things go to crap.

    Gotcha. For sure do whatever is most comfortable, but know that if you buy properties for cash flow and not solely on appreciation potential, crashes don't necessarily have to affect the entire property(ies). It's all in buying smartly. Can offer more info on that, but if you buy the right properties even for cash, you should be pretty good for passive income. I only work with turnkeys, but $2M could get you 20 $100k turnkeys that cash flow $600-800/month (net), which at least pushes you up towards that $20k/month. 

    _______________

     Whatever you do decide to do, do not invest all that 2 million into properties.  If you invest in property at all, you must manage the Trust for the benefit od the Trustor.  That would mean having his $20,000 in a liquid form and ready to go each month.  Dad should never have to wait for a rent payment to come in to live his life.  And you should have extra money for dads emergencies, new roof, new furnace, medical aid if he falls a d needs assistance or rehab.

    And you need to set aside a hefty cap ex, emergency fund to manage the rentals for when a renter trashes the place or does not pay rent for months and you still have insurance, taxes, repairs, utilities to pay, or you need an attorney to evict.

    Maybe you could invest half in rentals, but never all like some are saying.  Not as a Trustee!!

    not sure why but first half of response went to itallice like it eas part of the quoted material.  Wish BP would fix that.

  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2015 · 764 posts · 953 votes
    6y

    @Alex Williams PLEASE heed @Brian Burke. 12% cash on cash from the beginning; while not impossible is highly improbable and suspect.  Offerings that offer a much lower risk profile will range between 4 to 7% in the early years and can offer higher returns in later years.

    Turn-key homes today are a bad model all around for everyone except the developer selling them to unsuspecting "investors."  I'm going to get a lot of heat for saying this but do your research.

    Get educated. Proceed with caution and be patient. :)

    All the very best Alex.

  • Rental Property Investor · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    6y

    @Alex Williams If I had $2 million to invest and it had to make 12% return for your father to live on, I would do one of 2 things (or a combination of both), and neither would be owning real property...

    1) I would invest in notes/become a lender.

    2) Most importantly.... I would tell my dad (or make my dad) lower his expenses. You are living way beyond your means if you are spending $20k/mo, have only $2 million in liquid assets, and no income.

  • Rental Property Investor · TN · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Jason D.:

    @Alex Williams If I had $2 million to invest and it had to make 12% return for your father to live on, I would do one of 2 things (or a combination of both), and neither would be owning real property...

    1) I would invest in notes/become a lender.

    2) Most importantly.... I would tell my dad (or make my dad) lower his expenses. You are living way beyond your means if you are spending $20k/mo, have only $2 million in liquid assets, and no income.

     I am guessing that the $20k a month is for a nursing home with a private aid and possibly experimental, not insurance covered, medical expenses.  

    Otherwise the expenses are way beyond the means.

  • Member since 2019 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    6y

    I guess I need to clarify a few things. There is quite a bit more than $2 million available. That is just what is immediately liquid and I’m seeing how much I can make with it per month. I can also add to that amount from other sources and get the required percentage down below 5%. I am the trustee and the other beneficiaries are my two brothers. We all have no immediate need for the inheritance. They are in complete agreement with me investing the funds wherever I end up investing them - this post was just to find out everyone’s opinions and see what new ideas and methods are suggested, for me to research further and thoroughly. Not for me to jump on the first suggestion posted and throw all my money into it, as some seem to fear. That’s kind of the purpose of BP, no? The trust allows me to wait as long as I want to liquidate the assets after my father passes and my brothers are fine if I have to wait several years for house or stock prices to rebound if necessary. So no one need fear any foolish use of my father’s last pennies. I simply wanted the best ideas for making a stable, steady monthly income from a given nest egg, for which I will also be talking to a financial advisor - but often they do not know much about or believe in real estate as a vehicle and thus I posted here. Again, the very point of BP, no? If anyone has good ideas if the requirement were under 5% per year then I’d love to hear them. At present I’m leaning towards a mixture of a dividend index fund, a note fund and possibly some apartment syndication. But as I said, I’m looking for ideas that I can look further into. I’m not going to leave my father destitute by throwing all his money into the first idea I hear. Also, the $20,000 is because he generously gives money to family members each month, and if possible he would like to continue. It’s not because he lives beyond his means.

  • Rental Property Investor · TN · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Alex Williams:

    I guess I need to clarify a few things. There is quite a bit more than $2 million available. That is just what is immediately liquid and I’m seeing how much I can make with it per month. I can also add to that amount from other sources and get the required percentage down below 5%. I am the trustee and the other beneficiaries are my two brothers. We all have no immediate need for the inheritance. They are in complete agreement with me investing the funds wherever I end up investing them - this post was just to find out everyone’s opinions and see what new ideas and methods are suggested, for me to research further and thoroughly. Not for me to jump on the first suggestion posted and throw all my money into it, as some seem to fear. That’s kind of the purpose of BP, no? The trust allows me to wait as long as I want to liquidate the assets after my father passes and my brothers are fine if I have to wait several years for house or stock prices to rebound if necessary. So no one need fear any foolish use of my father’s last pennies. I simply wanted the best ideas for making a stable, steady monthly income from a given nest egg, for which I will also be talking to a financial advisor - but often they do not know much about or believe in real estate as a vehicle and thus I posted here. Again, the very point of BP, no? If anyone has good ideas if the requirement were under 5% per year then I’d love to hear them. At present I’m leaning towards a mixture of a dividend index fund, a note fund and possibly some apartment syndication. But as I said, I’m looking for ideas that I can look further into. I’m not going to leave my father destitute by throwing all his money into the first idea I hear. Also, the $20,000 is because he generously gives money to family members each month, and if possible he would like to continue. It’s not because he lives beyond his means.

    Thanks for the additional information.  Its good to know.

    Unfortunately BP also has many scammers and when someone posts that they have money or want to borrow money lots of scammers contact the person privately.  Next thing we know, they were scammed and disappear.  That is why we send out cautionary posts to people. 

    And lots of people do spend their last dime buying a run down shacks and then ask how to fund fixing it or what to do with no rent coming in to pay the mortgage. 

    We tend to protect as we educate.

  • Rental Property Investor · Durham, NC · Member since 2016 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    6y

    @Alex Williams investing this in illiquid rental property would be a bad idea.

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2018 · 30 posts · 3 votes
    6y

    @Alex Williams i would be happy to set up time to talk and see if we could be a good fit for each other. Let me know.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.