Short sale pocket listing. Fraud?

Short sale pocket listing. Fraud?

North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes

Hi I am new to this site and I'm in need of advice. I have been contacted by an agent letting me know of two of her shortsale listing that she guarantee the owners will take my offer. I went to see the houses and submitted offers on both properties according to the agent recommendation and listing price. She later I informed me that if the bank accepts the offers I would have to pay $5K finders fee to her and $6k move out fees to the seller in cash and outside escrow. Also I found out when signing the offer that she is not representing me and only representing the seller. When asked her about it she says that she is letting a colleague representing me to avoid the bank reducing her commission if she would represent us both. I didn't have a problem doing any of that until I found out by talking to another agent that paying cash out of escrow is consider fraud in a shortsale transaction. So I'm ready to call her on Monday and cancel the deal.

On the other hand both are very good deals if the banks actually accept the negotiated purchase price. I'm wondering if there is any way I could continue with this transaction in a legal manner by asking her to disclose the finders fee and buyers fee in the contract. Also by searching in the internet I found out that agents manipulate the acceptance of the offers in order to make the deal happen. How could I find that out? I'm sure that if I asked I won't get a straight answer.

Please advice if there is anyways this deal can happen with out breaking the law or what should I do at this point.

I have been looking for my first property to flip yet.

Thanks,

Mauricio

0Reply
114 views

Most Popular Reply

Flipper/Rehabber · Greeley, CO · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
13y

short sale fraud is the number one investigated crime by the FBI. I tried to set up An interview with the FBI to get all the facts for a blog article, but they were too busy. They did talk to me though and try to set up a time. All this sounds extremely unethical and highly Illegal. I would do exactly what @Bill Gulley says to do. He knows his stuff.

See this reply in the discussion

56 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    13y
    Originally posted by Mauricio Hernández:
    @ Joel , I haven't signed any HUD contracts yet and I won't sign anything that doesn't disclose the truth. I just signed 2 offers to 2 different properties for the banks to review them, but at this point I want out of the deal and not be involved with this type of agents.

    Maurizio: if the deal was presented to you as you say it was, you hold all the cards. All you have to say is I want out because I am now aware that it is illegal for me to make a side deal with the seller as you suggested. I wouldn't even get into it with her on the issue of paying her a fee outside of escrow. That's more complicated and can be legal under certain circumstances in CA. She'll let you cancel that contract in a second if she thinks you'll report her side deal suggestion to her broker or CAR.

    I'm not sure why an agent wouldn't be taking the side deal thing more seriously, especially when it involves the short sale affidavit where you, the seller and the agent all state there are no side deals. (BTW, not all SS include that affidavit. Regardless, everyone has to be careful with any payments outside of escrow as they could be perceived as intending to deceive the lender).

    I had a seller call me a couple of weeks ago because her short sale buyer fell out of escrow when the property only appraised at $350K. They were in contract for $420K. The seller said the buyer was perfect, because she had agreed to a lease back to her for 2 years so she could stay in the property. When I mentioned the short sale affidavit, she said her agent had told her about it but she didn't think it was a big deal, and neither did her buyer. Her goal was to get me to do the deal, even though I said I think signing anything in attempt to deceive most lenders is a federal offense, and that I wouldn't do it. Her response was "how would the lender ever find out". OMG. So I'm guessing that's where some of the agents are coming from these days.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    @K.Marie, thanks. If she agrees to cancel is there any document I would need to get back as a proof of aceptance of my cancelation? after cancelation would I get in trouble if I dont report her to the state? i want to report her, just not now because i dont want that to have repercution in my personal or family matters. I will wait to avoid any bad blood.

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y
    Maurizio,

    Everyone has been throwing ideas out there to you but no one here is a lawyer. Ask her what bank it is and call and ask them is that the way they do business.


    Joe Gore
  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    Joe is right, but one is a past federal regulator, charged with investigating and enforcing law......me! :)

    Don't call that agent yet, you will not be obligated to do this deal, call the state and follow their instructions, you do not have to be involved and they will take care of it. They can kill the deal without you ever being involved or known as the source of the information. Please just make the call !

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y
    @Bill. I did talk to the agent yesterday, she told me that she will never do anything that jeopardize her license. She says there is a legal way to pay those fees and that can be disclose in escrow, she mentioned that is legal for an agent to charge finder fees and/or pay finder fees to someone other than the agent. She said she gets those listing from an independent agent and is totally legal to pay finders fees as long as it is disclosed. So now she is willing to disclose it and see what the bank says. She also assured me that she presented all offers to the seller (she didn't want to disclose the amount on the offers) and they accepted mine on the premises that is all cash with no contingencies. Se said that the final sale date is approaching so the buyers are under pressure to sell and get out. She is talking to her broker to help her how to disclose the payment of fees. I told her that is fine as long as she doesn't make something illegal look legal. So now the story has changed and remember is all verbal communication only.
  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    @Mauricio Hernández Sounds like a lot of back peddling. My guess is the agent is, maybe, paying a referral fee to whoever generated the short sale lead to her originally. If that third party is licensed, which I doubt, it's probably "legal" but would still need to be disclosed and approved by the shorted lender.

    Is it legal for a buyer to pay an additional commission to a Broker (not directly to the agent)...Yes. But, it has to be on the HUD, and the lender isn't going to approve any additional commission above the 6%, or whatever lower amount they approve. So, that seems unlikely.

    A payment to the seller, not on the HUD...Not. A payment to the seller from the buyer will never be approved on the HUD. As stated before, all parties will be signing affidavits that the seller is receiving no money not disclosed on the HUD. There are no RESPA issues here with a cash purchase, but if you lie on these affidavits you are participating in mortgage fraud against the shorted lender.

  • Real Estate Investor · Saint Petersburg, FL · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 951 votes
    13y

    @Mauricio Hernández I'd start communicating by email so you have a written record of what was stated. I've bought short sales before that were "pocket listings" where the agent gave me first crack at it because of my reputation as a cash buyer that will close and not walk away after they go through all the trouble of getting approved. I would never agree to anything outside of the HUD to the agent or seller. Every short sale I've done where the seller got relocation cash it came from the bank's end (generally I've seen BoA do this).

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    Agents can absolutely be paid by other agents and split commissions, fees or commissions or any combination as may be agreed, an agent can pay another agent without any disclosure as an inner-office deal, the transaction closes with the broker, not really the agent and then agents are paid.

    As this was initially brought up, there were other issues as well, but notice I said way up the "apparent violation" as we don'y really know if the is any wrong doing, we assume there can be and we can see the potential, but we don't know for sure which is why the state should look at the deal and allow the authorities to act, not us.

    I would think with the assurances mentioned, the broker being involved, the bank being informed and disclosures made at closing, everything should be fine. But if anything looks strange, ask and be specific to the facts with the authorities. Good luck :)

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    I will. I am just waiting for the disclosures document so that I can review them, they are also disclosing the fact that im purchasing the proiperty for investment and resale pourposes "non-owner occupied" BTW offer has only been accepted by the seller not presented to the bank.

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y

    I agree let the police get involve and when the smoke clear and there is wrong doing the DA will decide from there now less say if there is no wrong doing you could be sued for damage someones reputation. Before you take any steps make sure you know what you are talking about.

    Joe Gore

  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    13y
    I'm not having an issue with the agent's request for a fee from you. If done right, that can be done legally. But you presented the agent as saying you would need to pay $6K directly to the sellers "out of escrow". That sounds like money that would not be reported on the HUD1. And, if the seller receives and you pay these funds, no one could sign the standard SS affidavit truthfully. What does the agent say about that?
  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    @ K.Marie; The seller told me last that they will disclose all payment on the escrow documents, including finder fees of $10,000.00 (higher than before, now that I demand it must be disclosed) and I wont have to make any payments out of escrow. No more out of escrow fees to the seller on my part either. the seller is under pressure to sell now according to the agent. they will also disclose that i am purchasing the property for investment purposes.

  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    13y

    Does the agent know what she is doing? Has she done a short sale with this lender before? There's almost zero chance that the lender will approve of an offer or a final HUD1 with cash payments to the sellers. Please keep us posted on this one.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    She claims she has done short sales before. She last told me that I won't have to make any payment to the seller in or out of escrow only a finders fee to my agent of $10,000.00 disclosed in escrow. she will submit it to the bank and see if they accept or reject. Foreclosure date is around the corner and my offer is replacing a prior accepted offer by the bank (but buyer didn't qualify). that is the update for now. I am waiting for her to send me all disclosures in writing. It seems to me that this is not going according to what she had planned since I am demanding that every penny I pay has to be in escrow. that just my thoughts.

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    @Mauricio Hernández

    The commission thing will probably still trip them up, if it's on the HUD. But, the bank will simply eliminate it, and everyone will have to sign off. By the way, you've mentioned twice about the disclosure to the bank about you being a non owner occupant. The lender does Not care in a short sale, only during the initial offering on a REO. Not sure why someone is even mentioning this. Any idea who the investor is..Fannie, Freddie, FHA,etc? The chances also aren't that great they can "slide you in the place" of the previous buyer, in time to beat the auction.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    I just received the California Residential Purchase Agreement sign by the seller.

    On page 4. under SELLER DISCLOSURES next to other terms: the agent wrote the following: BUYER TO PAY $790.00 TO BROKER FOR PROCESSING FEE. BUYER ACQUIRE AS INVESTMENT PROPERTY. BUYER AGREE PAY ADDITIONAL INCENTIVE BONUS TO MY SELLING AGENT-(NAME OF AGENT) $11,000

    that is all I have, before we submit the offer to the bank. I have not seen or sign any HUD, may be this will come later.

  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    13y
    So now the deal is costing you an $11K in additional commissions and an $800 processing fee? The original deal was $5K to the agent and $6K to the sellers.....which adds up to $11K. Hmm. Anyone else think it looks like a kick back from the agent to the sellers? I think you are being worked my friend. I don't trust any agents who charge a processing fee. It's their way of padding a deal when the lender will only contribute 5% on a short.

    To be honest, it doesn't sound like you have enough experience to handle a purchase without your own agent on this, one that would represent YOUR interests. Nothing personal. But from your questions, I can can tell that you don't know how the process works. This agent isn't the person I think you should learn it from either. :)

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    Mauricio, definitely shenanigans going on here, be prepared for more of the same if you proceed. As K Marie points out, 5k plus 6k adds up pretty close to 11k. You generally won't see a HUD until a couple of days before closing, if that. You can request a copy of the preliminary HUD being submitted to the bank with the short sale package, but that doesn't mean you'll be seeing the same one, with this bunch involved.

    My suggestion, if you decide to stay with this one, is to simply delete the $11k from the contract, and send it back. It's still unlikely they get this done on time, unless the trustees, which I think you have there, typically delay them for the defendant.

  • Investor · Central Valley, CA · Member since 2012 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    13y
    Originally posted by Wayne Brooks:
    Mauricio, definitely shenanigans going on here, be prepared for more of the same if you proceed. As K Marie points out, 5k plus 6k adds up pretty close to 11k. You generally won't see a HUD until a couple of days before closing, if that. You can request a copy of the preliminary HUD being submitted to the bank with the short sale package, but that doesn't mean you'll be seeing the same one, with this bunch involved.

    My suggestion, if you decide to stay with this one, is to simply delete the $11k from the contract, and send it back. It's still unlikely they get this done on time, unless the trustees, which I think you have there, typically delay them for the defendant.

    Wayne: In general, the foreclosing trustee service works for the benefit of the lender. They will communicate vital info between the borrower and beneficiary. But for the most part, the sale gets held if the bene says go ahead with it. Or gets cancelled if the borrower files BK. I'm totally over simplifying. But since there is no court and no defendant in a trustee's sale, the delay process is different than with the judicial foreclosures. It's all paperwork, faxes and phone calls.

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y

    What is strange know one is saying who the realtor is.

    Joe Gore

  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
    13y

    this is common practice in Miami. Sad.

    I had one owner agent two years ago when I went to see the property that he knew the bank's bottom line number because he went through several prior contracts. He said he would tell me that number and sign off the contract if I agree on a side deal to buy his pool furniture for $20,000 which consist of several plastic chairs you can get at Walmart for $9.99.

    I really wish something can be done about it. Its all over in Miami.

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    K Marie, that's what I thought, so the likelihood of a delay, being originated from the defendant's side, is slim. Banks will generally try to delay from their side, if they already have an approval issued for a particular buyer, and the buyer is trying to get to closing. But for the bank to delay it because they get a New contract, unlikely, but possible.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    Thanks to everyone for the the advice. I just canceled both purchases, and her I wont be buying any future properties either. They had about 4 properties ready for me with a guarantee that the seller will take my offer. They even told me that I didn't have to pay any cash to the seller. Eventhough I have no proof of wrong doing, some stuff looked shady. I opted for not doing any future business with this realtor. Thanks again.

  • Rehabber / Flipper · Simi Valley, CA · Member since 2010 · 597 posts · 259 votes
    13y

    This is proof of wrongdoing:

    "I would have to pay ... $6k move out fees to the seller in cash and outside escrow."

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    Did I mention call the regulators?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.