Short sale pocket listing. Fraud?

Short sale pocket listing. Fraud?

North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes

Hi I am new to this site and I'm in need of advice. I have been contacted by an agent letting me know of two of her shortsale listing that she guarantee the owners will take my offer. I went to see the houses and submitted offers on both properties according to the agent recommendation and listing price. She later I informed me that if the bank accepts the offers I would have to pay $5K finders fee to her and $6k move out fees to the seller in cash and outside escrow. Also I found out when signing the offer that she is not representing me and only representing the seller. When asked her about it she says that she is letting a colleague representing me to avoid the bank reducing her commission if she would represent us both. I didn't have a problem doing any of that until I found out by talking to another agent that paying cash out of escrow is consider fraud in a shortsale transaction. So I'm ready to call her on Monday and cancel the deal.

On the other hand both are very good deals if the banks actually accept the negotiated purchase price. I'm wondering if there is any way I could continue with this transaction in a legal manner by asking her to disclose the finders fee and buyers fee in the contract. Also by searching in the internet I found out that agents manipulate the acceptance of the offers in order to make the deal happen. How could I find that out? I'm sure that if I asked I won't get a straight answer.

Please advice if there is anyways this deal can happen with out breaking the law or what should I do at this point.

I have been looking for my first property to flip yet.

Thanks,

Mauricio

0Reply
114 views

Most Popular Reply

Flipper/Rehabber · Greeley, CO · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
13y

short sale fraud is the number one investigated crime by the FBI. I tried to set up An interview with the FBI to get all the facts for a blog article, but they were too busy. They did talk to me though and try to set up a time. All this sounds extremely unethical and highly Illegal. I would do exactly what @Bill Gulley says to do. He knows his stuff.

See this reply in the discussion

56 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    Actually it sounds like the agent is crossing several lines.

    I suggest you call the state finance department, suggest that a police officer or regulator go with you and you play dumb on the subject, introduce them as your wife or brother-in-law, neighbor or whatever. You need a witness to the verbal arrangements being made and ask her to put here deal in writing as to what you will owe her and how and when it is due.

    If this is a local bank, you should inform them as well and tell them you would like to make an offer, but that you want to ensure everything is done properly, this is after the meeting with your "friend" and before any offer is made,

    I'd say you'll be able to go with an offer through this other agent (better another agent) without a hitch and I'd say your information to the bank in that way may actually help your offer, it would if I were in the bank.

    I'd say get this agent off the street if she is suggesting kick backs outside of closing and undisclosed in a short sale.

    This is how we sting shysters :)

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    You sure this isn't in Miami? Yes, fraud all the way around. The agent should lose their license, just for the extra commission suggestion, outside of closing and direct to her. You'll be signing affidavits that there are no such payments. But if it's that good of a price, the bank's not going to approve it anyway.

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    I think what Wayne means is that the bank won't approve the deal with that agent, not that they won't approve a deal. And Wayne is correct that you will be attesting to the fact that no other money is involved in the deal. Make the calls as I suggested and they will take care of it! Don't do anything else, follow the regulator's instructions, they may want you to pass the deal to them as another investor.....whatever. :)

  • Real Estate Investor · Hampton, VA · Member since 2012 · 562 posts · 109 votes
    13y

    The Realtor is allowing another agent to write the offer and represent you not because it's a conflict of interest as she is representing the seller but because she doesn't want the bank to reduce her commission?

    By you paying anything outside of what is documented on the HUD Statement, I believe would be considered illegal , not sure if it's labeled as "Fraud" .

    In some short sales, the Bank pays the seller a "Relocation Fee" to the seller to cooperate with the selling process and to vacate the property, turn over keys and sign documents stating such. Her commission/finders fee should come from the sale of the property.

    Sound extremely shaky to me even though it may be a good deal, I wouldn't want to risk doing anything illegal for a good deal.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Greeley, CO · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    13y

    short sale fraud is the number one investigated crime by the FBI. I tried to set up An interview with the FBI to get all the facts for a blog article, but they were too busy. They did talk to me though and try to set up a time. All this sounds extremely unethical and highly Illegal. I would do exactly what @Bill Gulley says to do. He knows his stuff.

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    Thanks Mark, been there done that. :)

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y

    Bill I agree while you get the realtor off of the street let's get some of the shady bank officers off of the streets. I am sure Bill will agree there are shady bankers trying to make a buck. Bill I know you suggest to do a sting on the Realtor and At the same time Bill let's set a sting on a banker who is on the take, and I am sure you know a few senses you were in the banking.


    Joe Gore

  • Investor · Nashville, TN · Member since 2013 · 187 posts · 23 votes
    13y

    o/p, can you get the agent to send you an email confirming the numbers and the agreement? If she's dumb enough to do that, this should be an easy bust...might even earn you some brownie points at the bank...

  • Rental Property Investor · Upstate, NY · Member since 2012 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    13y

    Sounds like the proverbial 'find the deal reward'.....

    Though somewhat different it reminds me of one we reviewed for a friend where the private money lender added $2,500 in miscellaneous fees, but all 'declared' in the closing docs.

    $950 for a 'full' search (but not the title insurance)

    $795 for a survey update (act cost $125)

    $375 for a drive by appraisal.

    Were some of those I can still remember.

    Then the mtg broker he was using (to qualify the borrower) added a $3,500 origination fee !!! & yes his wife wanted the home so bad they paid & paid.

    On Colluding bankers ... if it wasn't for the couple we knew (& 'reimbursed' back in the '80's) I could not have qualified for the 4-5 Principal residence mortgages that I refi'd from OH financing :)

  • Rehabber · Niantic, CT · Member since 2012 · 443 posts · 150 votes
    13y

    I would steer clear of this agent, and probably go with @Bill Gulley suggestion as well. Wow. Agree w/all of the comments above - if the story is accurate, this sounds like a clear-cut case of fraud. I'm a licensed agent in CT and took a short sales class earlier this year. Let's just say my teacher would be horrified by this scenario!

    Also, regardless of whether it's a short sale or not, I personally would NEVER agree to payments outside of escrow. I want every penny documented and every move spelled out in a contract. If someone here has a scenario where it's appropriate to do otherwise, I'm all ears.

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y
    Karin,

    You think it is legal for a bank to give the seller funds outside of escrow, which is better known as cash for keys.


    Joe Gore

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    That's a good idea Ben R. especially if she has already done that.

    Joe, I've done that as well several times, my favorite smash are brokers who charge upfront fees and don't close anything.

    Mauricio, no telling what comments will be made, it's a forum. You aren't an attorney or a regulator or a police investigator or agent, so don't go there. You have done the right thing by asking about the situation and you need to report it and allow those who are authorized and trained to follow up on this issue, don't try to play spy guy and do something on your own.

    There are apparent violations of federal law and serious issues, there also may be others involved, you never know who might be involved so don't take anything upon yourself. First contact the state regulators and follow their instructions. :)

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y

    Bill,

    I agree

    Joe Gore

  • Rehabber · Niantic, CT · Member since 2012 · 443 posts · 150 votes
    13y

    @Account Closed thank you for bringing up another scenario. I don't know all of the ins and outs of cash for keys, but wouldn't it still be documented? Sounded like Mauricio is being asked for the equivalent of cash in an envelope in a back alley.

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y
    Originally posted by Joe Gore:
    Karin,


    You think it is legal for a bank to give the seller funds outside of escrow, which is better known as cash for keys.


    Joe Gore

    There are several ways a seller can receive some money or have expenses covered with consent of the bank. But not as described here. :)

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y

    Bill,

    You say you were a Bank Examiner for FDIC so that would cover all banks is that correct? Did you work there in 1980?

    Joe Gore

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    Yes I was, National banks are under the Comptroller of Currency, FDIC has state banks and insured depository institutions. While there have been many changes much is the same and yes, it's been awhile.

    I have some other experience in investigations and compliance that I have omitted from my profile, not really that RE related. :)

  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 4k+ posts · 744 votes
    13y

    Bill,

    I know this is not real estate. So you know Gus Shaffer Ford in Joplin and Joplin Freightliner?

    Joe Gore

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    Bill, what I meant by the bank probably not approving it anyway, had to do with the OP saying it was such a good deal, which sounds like it's under priced, and likely won't get approved on just the price alone.

    Yes, it is quite common for an agent, when they have both the buyer and the seller, to use a different agent/their broker as the "official" buyer's agent, due to banks cutting the commission to 3-4% for a "dual" agent. Is it really only half the work when you represent both sides....I think not.

    Banks do have a tendency to look a little harder at a deal where the agent has both sides, and rightly so. Many times this is the result of an agent having a particular buyer for property, usually an investor who is of course looking for a deal, Prior to approaching the seller. Then, a little MLS listing manipulation to look like the property was "adequately exposed" to the market for 5 days or so, then the "pocket buyer" gets their contract executed. This was fairly common a few years ago when the banks were trying to catch up with the incoming volume of short sales, and you could more easily sneak a really good deal through. Not as easy today.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y

    thanks all for replying.

    The offers where written and signed last week. I didn't know it was illegal and nevertheless a crime to give cash bonuses outside of escrow (call me naive but It was painted to me like that's how is done now a days and is not a big deal I thought it was more a matter of ethics on the agent part) until I commented the situation to another realtor yesterday and she told me it was fraud. I haven't sign any affidavit yet only an offer and I will never sign an affidavit that does not represent the truth. ( I didn't know about the affidavit until searching the internet yesterday) I want out of the deal and retract my offers, I'm am not planing to commit any crime nor fraud. Is it too late for me to cancel my offers. Agent told me that the price on one of the properties has been already approved by the bank to another seller that bailed out and I should get a quick approval this coming week. That why I want to cancel it today since I don't want to be a part of this. Can I still cancel all my 2 offers?

    @bill gulley, your advice is correct but the issue for me is that this agent is someone I know (my sister friend) and she knows my family. So I can't bring an undercover to put her in jail. The most I would do is an anonymous call to the authorities.what I definetly want to so is get out of this deal immediately.

    Let me know if you have anymore advice.

    To give you some background. In June I sold a commercial property that I owned for 10 years and I decided to use the equity to invest it in flipping houses. I have yet not found one property that would take my offer as it easy to see that most of the shortsales go to the pocket buyers and that is why I thought this is normal practice. I have 4 agents working for me but so far nothing. If there is any advice of how to successfully find house would like to hear, I am trying auctions, offers on shortsales,etc

    Thanks

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    13y

    @Mauricio Hernández

    Your purchase contract most likely has an inspection period, and/or other "get out of jail free" (no pun intended) clauses, that would allow you to walk away without penalty. I don't know the standard Calif contract, or what else may have been added or deleted. Now, you could simply proceed with the contract as is, and not pay anyone outside of closing, as I assume there was nothing in writing on this, and then one of them would have to try and cancel the contract if they wanted. That might be my play, except you have the family situation to deal with. I believe fraudsters should get a taste of their own medicine occasionally.

  • Investor, Entrepreneur, Educator · Springfield, MO · Member since 2009 · 21k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    13y

    That agent was no friend, IMO, many play the role, you don't do this to friends.

    Just call the state in the morning, fax the docs to them and them and tell them where you are on the deal.

    Follow their instructions, you won't be buying this if you don't want it. Don't be concerned with that. You can't go through with this deal.

    Call the state, you don't have to be involved, but to back out you need to report it.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y
    @ Bill Gulley, can I just call the agent tell her I don't want to proceed with the transaction because of the legality of it an be out? Then later in a separate action call the state. I don't have any docs on the last offer as she forgot to bring 2 copies to the viewing. I just want out and later I will decide about reporting her. I understand that friends don't do that to friends. I wish she would it warned me straight out that cash out of escrow in short sale was a crime and to do it at my own risk, but she didn't. I'm hesitant about reporting her just because I somehow know her.
  • Joel OwensBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Canton, GA · Member since 2010 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    13y

    In residential you have what is called RESPA ( real estate settlement procedure act ).

    Part of RESPA is that EVERYTHING has be disclosed on the HUD 1. You will be signing affidavits under penalty of prosecution and perjury that no outside agreements exist and everything is stated on the HUD 1 at closing.

    This broker/ agent if they are really doing this needs to be reported to the state real estate commission and the authorities.

    You need to run from this as fast as possible. If you are ensnared in this deal already you need an attorney to help you either unwind this deal to get out or structure this deal with full disclosure to make sure you are protected and do everything correctly regardless of what this broker/agent is trying.

    Yes people get paid relo money and other incentives from the bank but it shows at closing on the HUD 1. This seller is saying " pay me for going through this short sale outside of closing and nobody will know ". The seller sounds sleazy and so does the listing agent.

    RUN!

    No legal advice.

  • North Hollywood, CA · Member since 2013 · 38 posts · 2 votes
    13y
    @ Joel , I haven't signed any HUD contracts yet and I won't sign anything that doesn't disclose the truth. I just signed 2 offers to 2 different properties for the banks to review them, but at this point I want out of the deal and not be involved with this type of agents.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.