Who flips REO Properties

Who flips REO Properties

Real Estate Investor · Ontario, CA · Member since 2008 · 152 posts · 5 votes

You hear about wholesailing REO but no one knows about it.

0Reply
508 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Investor · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2008 · 190 posts · 91 votes
17y

You can get a letter from a transactional funding source before you make your offer, so you can submit it with your offer.

Regarding the earnest deposit, yes, you are going to need to come up with the deposit shortly after the offer is accepted. It's highly unlikely that you are going to get 10 offers accepted at once, unless you are offering too much. If that were to happen, and you couldn't come up with the money for the deposits, you could explain to the realtor(s) that you no longer wish to move forward with the deal because you got another offer accepted. They won't be too happy with you, but it's an option.

If you are still worried about it, just make one offer at a time.

Good luck,
Steph

See this reply in the discussion

121 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    Stephani,

    "Not sure if you saw the thread about using land trusts to get around the no-assignment clause- I'm pretty sure the person who posted it was in CA."

    In CA, as well as most other states, the portfolio managers and institutions are very alert to this type of scheme. As such, this Land Trust idea is a poor one.

    The potential legal problems are endless, and I have litigated such scenarios.

    I really signed on to make a comment in the bulk asset section, and perhaps pop in from time to time in general discussions. I have no time, nor the inclination of debating shady RE transactions.

    I can see how any "information" in regard to the hazards of "creative" RE transactions, would not be warmly received in this venue.

    Be careful in the area of foreclosure property transactions, and or institutionally owned transactions! REO

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    No worries Jon, thanks again..

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Jonathan Golstein:

    I have done literally thousands of institutional transactions and here yet to See a double close go through. What I have seen is people indicted in these cases.


    Hi Jonathan -

    Thanks for the info!

    Quick question...can you give us an idea of the specific statute or law under which these people were charged?

    I have a friend who wholesales REOs in CA, and his attorney has indicated that there are no issues with it. If there is some specific statute that he should be aware of, I'd love to give him the information...

    Thanks!

  • Real Estate Investor · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2008 · 190 posts · 91 votes
    17y

    Hi Jonathan,

    I'm just looking for more information about the specific laws that are being violated when doing a double or simultaneous closing on an REO property.

    If you could point me in the right direction, that would be helpful.

    Thanks!

    Steph

  • Real Estate Investor · Stuart, FL · Member since 2009 · 9 posts · 1 vote
    17y

    I have yet to have a title agent, Attorney, or Real estate Brokers specifically tell me the statute which prohibits a
    simultaneous closing on an REO property, just that is
    illegal. I had a local title agent tell me that RESPA is the
    reason she can't do them, but has yet to tell me the specific section that prohibits it. Is it because the title insurance does not like to insure these transactions??

    Can anyone recommend a title company within S. Florida which they are currently using this method?

    My endbuyers have no problem with this method and sign
    documents with full disclosure!

    Thanks,
    Rick

  • Real Estate Investor · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2008 · 190 posts · 91 votes
    17y

    Rick,

    I have also been told many times that they are illegal, but have never had anyone willing to show me the documentation to support the claim.

    If you're in the Ft. Lauderdale area, here are two title companies that should be able to help you out: Universal Land Title (universallandtitle.com) and Independence Title co (IndependenceTitleCo.com).

    I have not used either one, but have a friend who recommends them.

    I believe they will do simul closes on REOs as long as there is full disclosure to the end buyer.

    Good luck,
    Steph

  • Real Estate Investor · Stuart, FL · Member since 2009 · 9 posts · 1 vote
    17y

    Steph,

    Thanks, I'll give them a try!!!

    I enjoy your blog, keep up the great work.

    Rick

  • Investor · Kalamazoo, MI · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 495 votes
    17y

    My method is simple! We work with private investors from all over that buy properties in our area. We market, show and SELL the property via Seller Financing. We work with a servicng company that reports to the credit bureaus and this increases the value of the real estate note(s) over time. A third party payment history verification can make the difference in being able to sell a note that has a payer with bad credit and not being able to sell a note at all.

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    "Full disclosre from a wholesaler to the end buyer of an REO" I like that! So NOW the entire transaction is legal-presto! A lot of mpeople wish things were that simple I am sure.

    Specific statutes? Lets start here with RE Law 101....

    First off, I know of NO banks, institutions, asset management firms or other, that will indeed accept an offer, draft a contract and accept a deposit on an REO, without 100% affirmation that the buyer is indeed 100% FUNDED!

    Second, the (institutions) most always have stipulations that they reserve the right to back out of the deal up until the transfer of deed. I know of NO (institutions) that would assume the liability of transferring title to a buyer that is NOT a party to the contract, as there is liability in selling ANY property. In MOST cases, a “double or simultaneous close†is a FRAUDULANT transaction on one or many levels.

    CONTRACTING a property with an institution, in which one CLEARLY REPRESENTS that they indeed are THE BUYER, when in fact they are NOT, is FRAUD.
    A "statute of frauds" requires that certain contracts be in writing, and that they be signed by ALL parties to be bound by the contract.
    Typically, to satisfy the requirements of the statute, the writing must identify the contracting PARTIES, recite the subject matter of the contract such that it can reasonably be IDENTIFIED, and present the essential TERMS and CONDITIONS of the PARTIES' agreement.
    The purpose of a "statute of frauds" is, as the name suggests, to prevent injury from fraudulent conduct.
    There is some criticism of the continued existence of these statutes, as they are often used by parties who freely entered into fair contracts yet wish to avoid having to fulfill their agreements. At the same time, the abuses these statutes were designed to prevent are quite real, so a strong argument remains to keep them in place. It is also arguably good public policy to require that parties to certain significant transactions, such as those of long duration or which involve real estate, reduce their agreements to writing. Writing will both reduce the chance of future litigation, and also give the parties the opportunity to take a second look at the terms and conditions of their agreement before it becomes final.
    A brief discussion in regard to the reseller end buyer in a double, or simultaneous close.
    The statute makes certain contracts "voidable" by one of the parties, in the event that the party does not wish to follow through on the agreement. A contract that is "void" cannot be enforced. A contract that is "voidable" remains valid unless one of the parties chooses to void the contract.
    Thus the party contracting with an “institution†would be held liable for non performance in the even the end buyer backed out of the purchase.
    Sometimes, a party to a contract that would otherwise be invalid under a "statute of frauds" will nonetheless be able to enforce it, on the basis of "partial performance" or "promissory estoppel". Where "partial performance" exists, a party who has accepted partial performance by another party under the contract will typically be barred from asserting the "Statute of Frauds" in order to avoid meeting its own contractual obligations. "Promissory estoppel" exists where significant inequities (unfairness) would result from releasing a party from the contract, and the party seeking release knew or reasonably should have known that those inequities would be created at the time of the original agreement. For example, where the party which seeks to be released knew that the other party would incur significant expense in obtaining materials which cannot be transferred to other work, a court may find that under the circumstances the contract should be enforced despite the statute of frauds.

    In the scenario of wholesaling or flipping an REO, in which there is a clear indication of fraud, or even misrepresentation, the promissory estoppels would not prevail. Institutions DO NOT EVER approve of wholesaling or flipping of the contract.

    Disclosure:
    Any information expressed is not intended as legal advice and does not establish any attorney-client relationship. We are trying to provide information helpful to consumers, including legal information. However, you cannot rely on this information as legal advice. This is general information; not advertising, solicitation, or legal advice. If you have a legal question, please contact a lawyer in your state to protect yourself. Do not rely on anything you read here, especially in lieu of contacting a lawyer directly. Every case is different, and every case turns on its own individual facts.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17y

    Jonathan -

    I appreciate the thoughtful response, but in all honesty, I fail to see where a wholesale transaction with a double close fails to meet all the legal criteria you mention...

    Let me address these one by one...

    Originally posted by Jonathan Goldstein:

    First off, I know of NO banks, institutions, asset management firms or other, that will indeed accept an offer, draft a contract and accept a deposit on an REO, without 100% affirmation that the buyer is indeed 100% FUNDED!

    A wholesaler who intends to double close will indeed be purchasing the property from the selling institution, and as such, will need to have the funds to complete that transaction.

    Therefore, the buyer should have the same proof of funds that any REO purchaser would have; the addition of a second contract to the end-buyer has no influence on the necessity of the wholesaler to have proof of funds...and those funds...available.

    As for simultaneous closes, that's a different story, and I don't know enough to support a claim of legality nor illegality for those types of transactions.


    Second, the (institutions) most always have stipulations that they reserve the right to back out of the deal up until the transfer of deed.

    Of course. Though I don't see how this has any bearing whatsoever on the legality of a double close. Perhaps I'm missing something.


    I know of NO (institutions) that would assume the liability of transferring title to a buyer that is NOT a party to the contract, as there is liability in selling ANY property.

    The seller isn't assuming any liability in the transfer of title...that's what a title company (and title insurance) is for. Regardless, in a double close, there are TWO contracts, and the purchaser is a party to BOTH contracts.

    Why do you think that the wholesaler is not a party to the contract?


    In MOST cases, a “double or simultaneous close†is a FRAUDULANT transaction on one or many levels.

    As a lawyer, I assume you are aware that a legal finding of fraud requires intent. For the type of deals we are talking about here, there is no intent for the wholesaler to defraud either the seller nor the end-buyer.


    CONTRACTING a property with an institution, in which one CLEARLY REPRESENTS that they indeed are THE BUYER, when in fact they are NOT, is FRAUD.

    I'm afraid you might be misunderstanding what a typical wholesaler does. The wholesaler IS the buyer...and then the wholesaler IS the seller. Two contracts. Two transactions. Done at the same closing table.


    [A bunch of stuff about the definition of fraud that I don't dispute deleted]

    The statute makes certain contracts "voidable" by one of the parties, in the event that the party does not wish to follow through on the agreement. A contract that is "void" cannot be enforced. A contract that is "voidable" remains valid unless one of the parties chooses to void the contract.
    Thus the party contracting with an “institution†would be held liable for non performance in the even the end buyer backed out of the purchase.

    Okay, no dispute. But still no legal statute that is being violated.


    [Again, more fraud stuff that I don't dispute deleted]
    In the scenario of wholesaling or flipping an REO, in which there is a clear indication of fraud, or even misrepresentation, the promissory estoppels would not prevail.

    Again, fraud requires intent. There is no intent to defraud in the type of transactions we're talking about, so there is no clear indication of fraud.


    Institutions DO NOT EVER approve of wholesaling or flipping of the contract.

    Contracts do not have to approve anything. Anything not specifically deemed violating the contract is -- by definition -- not violating the contract. That's the way contracts work.

    For example, real estate contracts don't specifically approve my going to the movies on a Saturday night, but that doesn't mean I can't.

    Wholesaling involves purchase a property in one transaction and selling it in another transaction. Typically this is done simultaneously at the same closing table. If the REO contract prohibits the resale of the property for some period of time (as does FNMA REO contracts, for example), then the second transaction can't take place simultaneously. But, that has nothing to do with legality...that has to do with a deed restriction enforced by the attorneys closing the deal.

    Now, for any REO contract that doesn't specifically include a deed restriction on the resale, there is no law being broken by purchasing and reselling the property, even when it's done at the same closing table.

    Now, let's summarize...

    You claimed it was "illegal" to wholesale REOs. Your supporting evidence was contract law and "statutes of fraud". Breaking contracts is not illegal, despite potential civil repercussions. And fraud does not apply without intent to defraud, which clearly there is none with a wholesaler.

    So, I haven't yet seen any supporting evidence that wholesaling REOs is "illegal"...that said, I'm still open to any information you can provide...

  • Real Estate Investor · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2008 · 190 posts · 91 votes
    17y

    Hi Jonathan,

    I also appreciate the thoughtful response, but after reading it, I still don't see what part of a double or simultaneous closing constitutes fraud. I am purchasing the property from the lender, as is stated in the contract, closing on it, and then reselling it to the end buyer.

    Like I mentioned in a prior post, I have consulted with an attorney here in Tampa, as well as the attorney who closes all of my REO wholesale deals, and both have assured me that there is nothing illegal about a simultaneous closing.

    Steph

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Stephani:
    Hi Dwight,

    Like I mentioned in the email- I would suggest consulting with a real estate attorney in your area, as opposed to getting legal advice from title agents, realtors, and mortgage brokers.

    It seems to me that double and/or simultaneous closings are difficult, if not impossible to pull off in CA, so why not try using another method to close your REO deals?

    Not sure if you saw the thread about using land trusts to get around the no-assignment clause- I'm pretty sure the person who posted it was in CA. Here's a link to the thread:

    http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/16/topics/37088-flipping-reo-s-via-land-trust-

    This strategy seems to have worked fine for Anthony, so you might want to consider doing the same and forgetting about a double or simultaneous closing.

    Steph

    Stephani,

    Let's start here as my time is very limited. I will address the other posts as time permits here.

    The "double and/ or simultaneous close" you referred to in you post, was indeed posted by a California investor as follows:

    " Posted: 08/12/2009 at 07:57PM 3 votes

    “I just flipped 3 properties today to a all cash investor using a land trust. I had never done it before and I was skeptical but I closed all three deals same buyer within 3 hours.

    Here are the steps if you want to use a Land Trust to flip:

    1. Put in your offer as xyz title vesting tba in escrow
    2. Get offer accepted.
    3. "Street Name" Land Trust Trustee xyz (whatever buyer that is in Step One)
    4. Find a cash buyer
    5. Sell your land trust to Cash investor ( Wholesale Fee)
    6. Cash Investor is the 100% beneficary
    7. He wires money to escrow.
    8. Property sold
    9. Beneficiary (Cash Investor) fires xyz as trustee and assigns his own trustee for property.

    NO EXTRA COST FOR A DOUBLE CLOSE USING TWO ESCROWS

    NO EXTRA COST FOR TRANSACTIONAL FUNDING
    NO COMPLICATIONS WITH ESCROW AND TITLEâ€

    NO Bank or asset holder that I have ever heard of, is going to entertain accept an offer on an REO from (as xyz title vesting tba), PERIOD!

    In the scenario laid out above, IF the offer made it to escrow, NO escrow company I have ever heard of would follow through with this type of set up. I have NEVER seen an REO without a NO ASSIGNMENT CLAUSE. The potential HIDDEN transaction would be subject to the stature of frauds.

    Escrow companies have been under investigation during this RE related meltdown as have lenders, appraisers, Attorneys, banks etc. SMALL off brand escrow companies in California may be willing to attempt this transaction, but the “bank†would no doubt back out of the deal in escrow for many reasons, if the deal even got that far. I would think that this deal described above was NOT THREE institutionally owned properties.

    Also, just because a certain "creative startegy" may work in the short, does NOT mean that parties will never end up in a serious problem situation.

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    J Scott,

    "A wholesaler who intends to double close will indeed be purchasing the property from the selling institution, and as such, will need to have the funds to complete that transaction.

    Therefore, the buyer should have the same proof of funds that any REO purchaser would have; the addition of a second contract to the end-buyer has no influence on the necessity of the wholesaler to have proof of funds...and those funds...available."

    In some cases NO problem with the above scenario, but that's NOT what we're discussing here.

    "As for simultaneous closes, that's a different story, and I don't know enough to support a claim of legality nor illegality for those types of transactions."

    I do know enough about these type of transactions and in MOST cases involving an institutionally owned asset and transaction, it will not fly.

    Let me address some other issues as time permits,, that may be helpful "information", but NOT legal advise.

    My intent is to be helpful, but in no way do I need or wan't any "legal" debate.

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    the topic is: Who flip REO Properties

    I don't know of any valid way to FLIP an REO and would never recommend this.

    Let me quickly address REO investing and more specifically the CA market.

    I don't see how anyone could (even if totally legal), locate and negotiate a purchase price on an REO, that leaves any room for a profit, in reselling.

    The market is saturated with REO properties that in many cases are cosmetic fixers. Where they can be found is NO secret and the bank will take the strongest offer.

    There are thousands of REO properties to be found, that are under perceived "market value," however in CA "market value" is very subjective.

    Most REO transactions take longer to close than a traditional transactions and there are obstacles to overcome, even in the best case scenario.

    I have represented many clients, in which an REO property LOST value during the transaction period.

    Where I do see an investing opportunity is as follows:

    Best case, look for a short sale in which the inventory is stale and the bank wants the property off the books. Many potential non investor buyers can not see beyond a dirty , or outdated property. These can be obtained well below potential sale value after upgrades and clean up. In most cased the short sale is more workable for end profit than an REO.

    I personally have had a lot of success with this as an investor.

    In most cases the REO's are a nightmare and don't leave much room for profit in a rehab and resale. I have seen NONE that have a potential wholesale profit.

    Keep in mind that this is specific to CA, but I have investor clients and partners that do RE investment transactions all across the Country. Now, buy and hold would be another story altogether with an upside potential.

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    J Scott,

    Wholesaling an property that one purchases with their own money, is a totally different subject than the subject of this thread.

    Some of your points in that regard are correct. But, we're confusing the discussion by discussing wholesaling a property that one has purchased.

    Therefore, the discussion in your post seems mute.

    Attempting to wholesale an REO is a no win proposition in my humble opinion.

  • Real Estate Investor · Audubon, PA · Member since 2009 · 13k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by J Scott:
    Hi Jonathan -

    Thanks for the info!

    Quick question...can you give us an idea of the specific statute or law under which these people were charged?

    ... If there is some specific statute that he should be aware of, I'd love to give him the information...

    Thanks!


    Originally posted by Stephani:
    Hi Jonathan,

    I'm just looking for more information about the specific laws that are being violated when doing a double or simultaneous closing on an REO property.

    If you could point me in the right direction, that would be helpful.

    Thanks!

    Steph

    Jonathan,

    Two BP members - both quoted above - made a request for info regarding specific statutes. Do you have that info for any state? Statute of frauds doesn't cut it IMO, since it's very generic and that doesn't specifically address the concept of the back-to-back closing.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Jonathan Goldstein:

    I don't know of any valid way to FLIP an REO and would never recommend this.

    ...

    Wholesaling an property that one purchases with their own money, is a totally different subject than the subject of this thread.

    ...

    Attempting to wholesale an REO is a no win proposition in my humble opinion.


    I'm not sure how the statements above can be reconciled. I thought wholesaling (which is another work for flipping) WAS the topic of this thread...

    Just to be clear, are you saying that wholesaling with a double close is legal (and can be done) or is illegal (and/or can't be done)?

    If you're saying that wholesaling with a double close is perfectly legal and can be done, then we are in agreement.

    If you are saying that wholesaling with a double close is illegal (and/or can't be done), I still haven't seen any rationale behind that statement, other than your personal opinion.

    You admit that a person is legally allowed to purchase an REO with their own funds. And I assume you believe a person is later allowed to sell that same property to another buyer. The only important detail in a double close wholesale is that the time between the purchase and the sale is negligible. And I don't know of any laws, statutes, etc that prohibit buying and selling the same property in a short period of time.

    Now, if you're saying that fraudulent flipping is illegal, I don't think anyone here disagrees. By definition, if you do something fraudulent, it's fraud. But wholesaling is not fraud, as there is no intent to defraud.

    Perhaps you can clarify exactly what you think is legal and illegal...so at least we know that we're discussing the same points...


    In most cases the REO's are a nightmare and don't leave much room for profit in a rehab and resale. I have seen NONE that have a potential wholesale profit.


    This is your opinion based on your experience, I assume. But you shouldn't assume that your experience is the norm.

    To address both points above...

    I HAVE purchased, rehabbed, and resold nearly a dozen REOs this year. My average profit is about $27K per property. If you don't believe that it's possible, all the details (including the financials) are laid out black-and-white on my blog. It's possible, and I'm certainly not the only one doing it.

    In terms of you never seeing an REO with wholesale potential, wholesaling REOs is how Steph has made her living the past couple years. I believe she's closed dozens of deals, indicating that not only is it possible, it happens.

    Likewise, I've done a couple of these myself. How do I get the spread?

    The answer is simple -- REO listing agents do a horrible job of marketing their properties. If they include pictures, they're really bad; if they respond at all to potential buyers, it's not in a friendly manner. When we want to wholesale an REO, we take good pictures of the property to get people interested in looking at it. We answer the phone, answer potential buyer's questions, show them the property personally, and help them through the purchase. These are all value-add things that justify the price increase from our purchase of the REO to our sale of the REO, even if the purchase and sale are the same day.

    It's not rocket science, and just because you don't believe it can't be done, doesn't mean it's not being done...some people here are proof of that...

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    J Scott,

    I only have a minute her, so let me come back to some other questions when time permits.

    My evaluation of potential wholesale profit with an REO is specific to the California market. Short sales provide a much better profit potential in most, but not all cases.

    Both REO, as well as short sale purchase present their own difficulty.
    These are almost never straight forward, or easy transactions in my experience. I have done hundreds of these transactions.

    Let me ask you a brief question here:

    "When we want to wholesale an REO, we take good pictures of the property to get people interested in looking at it. We answer the phone, answer potential buyer's questions, show them the property personally, and help them through the purchase. These are all value-add things that justify the price increase from our purchase of the REO to our sale of the REO, even if the purchase and sale are the same day."

    I assume that you are not an Attorney, RE Broker or agent. Is this correct?
    In CA, you would be considered to be offering a banks property for sale to the public. It is not your property. How are you handling reps and warrants? In CA you would likely be crossing the line and performing functions that require you do be an Attorney, or Licenced RE Broker or Agent.

    As far as the specific statutes and case law, there are a number of issues that come into play as far as entering into a contract to purchase an REO, where in 99% of the time there is a NO assignment clause, with the specific intention of assigning the contract.

    In most of the double close schemes mentioned, the "purchaser" is specifically hiding the fact that the fact that they indeed are NOT the purchaser.

    In a "creative" RE investing environment, it is understandable that NOT being open to potential legal problems would be the norm.

    There are too many cases related to typical "creative real estate deals" and
    legal issues and troubles to mention here.

    Hire a lawyer, do what you feel you're comfortable with. As I said, I am not here to debate Legal issues with the general public, but rather to try and be helpful. Looks like that will not be well received though.

    As you well know, there is huge debate in the REI community over legal issues of the double close-simultaneous close issues, so I am surprised that you are so perplexed?

    I am an Attorney as well as an investor, so I am more than confident with my deals, as well as the representaion I provide others in such transactions.

    Although in more cases, I represent the institutions selling the assets. I see problem deals with "investors" all the time and the bank walks.

    I can not and will not give what is considered to be legal advise.

    I do not have the time to go into the hundreds of legal issues, or cases and codes that support my "opinion"...

    Best,

    Jonathan

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    "Now, for any REO contract that doesn't specifically include a deed restriction on the resale, there is no law being broken by purchasing and reselling the property, even when it's done at the same closing table."

    That could be the case, but is not the case with major lenders contracts.

    AND if you are clearly purchasing the property with you OWN money and reselling the same day, that can happen in some cases.

    I am addressing the using OPM (other peoples money) with NO skin in the game, without the banks knowledge. No bank will agree to this type of transaction and have clauses to prevent this.

    Look, I see shady or questionable "creative" deals all the time in the REI environment all the time. I see these "Guru's" giving VERY BAD advise to people who would be in any number of jurisdictions.

    I see "investors", title companies, lenders, and appraisers being prosecuted all the time here in CA.

    I am really interested in how you advertise the banks property and sell it to the end buyer?

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Jonathan Goldstein:

    I assume that you are not an Attorney, RE Broker or agent. Is this correct?
    In CA, you would be considered to be offering a banks property for sale to the public. It is not your property. How are you handling reps and warrants? In CA you would likely be crossing the line and performing functions that require you do be an Attorney, or Licenced RE Broker or Agent.

    Yes, my wife is an agent, and specifically holds her license for the purpose of our business.

    That said, once you have a property under contract, you have "equitable interest" in that property, and I don't know of any laws or NAR regulations that would prohibit you from marketing that property at that point...EVEN WITHOUT A LICENSE.

    If you know of some law/regulation that would prohibit the marketing of a property that you hold equitable interest in, I'd love to hear it, as it would affect the business model of a lot of people I know...


    In most of the double close schemes mentioned, the "purchaser" is specifically hiding the fact that the fact that they indeed are NOT the purchaser.

    Are you familiar with how a double close works?

    If so, you know that the initial buyer IS IN FACT A PURCHASER. They actually close on the property.

    No hand-waving, no fraud, no misrepresentations...in a double close, the buyer CLOSES ON THE PROPERTY with their own funds.

    No different than if the buyer was planning to live in the property, or rent it out, or whatever. The only difference is that he intends to resell it AFTER HE PURCHASES IT. (immediately after, but I don't see how that's relevant to the discussion)

    Why do you say that the buyer is not actually purchasing the property in a double close?


    There are too many cases related to typical "creative real estate deals" and
    legal issues and troubles to mention here.

    Okay, name one. Give me one example of a wholesaler doing a double close on an REO that got into legal trouble. And when you do, please cite the specific statute that he was prosecuted under.

    That's all I've been asking, and while you claim to have plenty of examples, you don't provide any. Give me a statute and some example of case law that supports your thesis.


    As I said, I am not here to debate Legal issues with the general public, but rather to try and be helpful. Looks like that will not be well received though.

    It's not well received when you flout your expertise, but then can't back it up.

    As a lawyer, how would you feel if you walked into a courtroom, had opposing counsel claim that your client had broken the law, but could not cite a specific statute that was violated?

    You'd probably laugh and walk away...


    As you well know, there is huge debate in the REI community over legal issues of the double close-simultaneous close issues, so I am surprised that you are so perplexed?

    Again, I am only perplexed that a lawyer is claiming something is illegal, but can't provide any specific statutes that prohibit the action. As a lawyer, I'm surprised that you find this request to be unreasonable.


    I can not and will not give what is considered to be legal advise.

    Not asking for any. Just asking for a reference to a statute that I can take to my attorney to discuss the legality of my business dealings.


    I do not have the time to go into the hundreds of legal issues, or cases and codes that support my "opinion"...

    Okay, how about just one?

  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    Quick Comment:

    The institutions have a legal standing in limited disclosure, and you as the buyer have a right to inspection etc.

    Once YOU are the owner, you do NOT have the same extent od limited disclosure, or the luxury as a private SFR seller in most States.

    As such, YOU can be on the hook for non disclosed issues that cause "damages," and I have litigated such cases.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Jonathan Goldstein:
    "Now, for any REO contract that doesn't specifically include a deed restriction on the resale, there is no law being broken by purchasing and reselling the property, even when it's done at the same closing table."

    That could be the case, but is not the case with major lenders contracts.

    I've purchased REOs from almost all the major lenders, and other than FNMA, I've yet to see deed restrictions on the resale of an REO. And even with FNMA, that restriction is only if the price is more than 20% above the purchase price.

    See, even FNMA recognizes that people ARE GOING TO FLIP these properties...they just don't want it to be for too much money (indicating the bank was ripped off or that fraud was committed).

    If FNMA didn't want people to flip, they could have a deed restriction without any ability to sell for some period of time. But they don't. You can resell for up to 20% above the purchase price the minute you close (i.e., a double close) without violating ANY terms of the contract.


    I am addressing the using OPM (other peoples money) with NO skin in the game, without the banks knowledge. No bank will agree to this type of transaction and have clauses to prevent this.

    Since when does a bank care where the cash comes from in a cash deal. Why do they care if it comes from my bank account, from my parent's "house fund" for me, from an HML, from a transactional lender, from my cousin's friend's next-door-neighbor's mom's boyfriend?

    The bank doesn't care...as long as you can provide POF and then actually provide those funds at closing. I've never seen a bank contract that says, "The cash must be your own cash." They don't care whose cash it is, as long as it makes it to the closing table...

    If you have some evidence to the contrary, I'd love to hear it.


    I see "investors", title companies, lenders, and appraisers being prosecuted all the time here in CA.

    What are they being prosecuted for? Specifically?

    See my reply above...I just want to know what statute, what regulation, etc that is being violated.

    If you claim it's "fraud," then you need to provide some proof that it is fraudulent to purchase a property with cash and then resell it to someone else...as that's what a "double close" is.


    I am really interested in how you advertise the banks property and sell it to the end buyer?


    I advertise to my buyers with an email, pictures and some basic information about the property. I give them an opportunity to view the property. And then if they want to put it under contract with me (AFTER I already have equitable interest in the property through an executed, binding contract with the bank), I provide them a state-based standard purchase agreement.

    My title company closes my purchase of the property from the bank with my funds (I'm 100% certain this is legal), and then my title company closes the other deal with my end-buyers funds (I'm 100% certain this is legal).

    Which of those transactions do you believe is illegal and why?

  • Real Estate Investor · St. Petersburg, FL · Member since 2008 · 190 posts · 91 votes
    17y

    Hi Jonathan,

    When I advertise my deals I tell the end buyers that I have the property under contract with the bank and will be selling it the same day that I am purchasing it. My contract with the end buyer also states that the sale is contingent upon me purchasing the property from the current owner (the bank).

    When we go to the closing table, they are required to sign a disclosure stating that they are aware that the property is being flipped and that their cash is being used to fund both transactions. They will not insure the title unless this document is signed.

    I'm not trying to pull a fast one on the buyer, and am always upfront with them about what is going on.

    I could easily get the money to close on the deals for the A-B transaction (between me and the bank), but there will be costs associated with borrowing the money, so I prefer to do it the other way. I have been advised by my attorney that there is nothing wrong with me closing my deals in this manner, so I will continue to do it this way until they pass a law which prohibits it (which I'm guessing is going to happen in the not so distant future).

    Steph

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    17y
    Originally posted by Jonathan Goldstein:
    Quick Comment:

    The institutions have a legal standing in limited disclosure, and you as the buyer have a right to inspection etc.

    Once YOU are the owner, you do NOT have the same extent od limited disclosure, or the luxury as a private SFR seller in most States.

    As such, YOU can be on the hook for non disclosed issues that cause "damages," and I have litigated such cases.


    I'm not sure how this is relevant to the discussion going on here, but I'm not sure what type of disclosure you are referring to...

    Are you talking about property condition? If so, the standard Purchase and Sale Agreement where I live provides the opportunity to claim that there is no seller disclosure available, and the buyer has every right to accept those terms. Additionally, the seller could very well provide a disclosure, and honestly tell the buyer that he has no knowledge of the property condition.

    I'm not sure if this is what you're referring to or not, but regardless, I have a feeling that what you're referring to above has nothing to do with whether the buyer has owned the property for 1 minute or 20 years...so it has nothing to do with wholesaling the property.

    Again, just waiting for reference to one statues or regulation that supports your opinion...as a lawyer, I find it hard to believe that you don't consider that to be a reasonable request...
  • Real Estate Attorney · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2009 · 31 posts · 2 votes
    17y

    Stephani,

    "Hi Jonathan,

    I also appreciate the thoughtful response, but after reading it, I still don't see what part of a double or simultaneous closing constitutes fraud. I am purchasing the property from the lender, as is stated in the contract, closing on it, and then reselling it to the end buyer."

    Absent of deed restrictions or lender stipulations, this could be fine.

    I am more addressing the using OTHER people money and a situation in which one mislead the bank.

    This happens all the time and creates PROBLEMS, that I myself care not to be involved with.

    Does that add any clarification as far as YOUR situation and strategy?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.