Fix foundation repair/water proofing OR convert single family home into a duplex

Fix foundation repair/water proofing OR convert single family home into a duplex

Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 2 votes

Hi there,

Im new to the real estate game and I am faced with an interesting situation. I currently own a single family home with approx $300k in equity in Long Island NY and looking to get some insight. 

A little background:

The property is a 1920s home in a flood zone on the south shore of LI and is affected by flooding and rising water table. Over the past couple of years my home has been flooding more and more due to increased rain and storms. Water is seeping through cracks in the floors and through the walls where it looks like the basement walls have signs of bowing with horizontal cracks. The basement itself is an unfinished basement, as well as unlivable (5ft high floor to ceiling). I had 1 contractor come by today and quoted me a French drain system, as well as raising the basement floor up 6 inches, with 3 sump pump's for a price tag of $16K, not including the repairs to the walls. 

Now the question:

Option 1: Should I pay for repairs to my basement out of pocket, and use the equity to fund an entirely new second investment property?

OR

Option 2: Go big and do a cash-out refi/203K/HELOC to not only repair the foundation and waterproofing, but to add an extension to the home that would support a legal duplex for some income producing property. The house sits on approx 6000sqft of corner lot property and the home is 1160sqft. I would also consider the possibility of raising the property as well to prevent further flood damage.

Im really hopeful to get some guidance on these ideas from all of you.

Thanks!



 

0Reply
46 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2020 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    @Matthew Villalon, thankfully, it seems like either option repairs the leaky/flooding basement. Your title implied that you might not do that step.

    To your question, I think the first factor I had always taken into consideration is: do you live in the house?  And if so, do you want a tenant that close to you, should you pursue option 2?  Personally, for my life stage, I don't want to live in a multifamily property again.

    Second, you need to know your market.  I am in Cincinnati, where duplexes generally sell for less than single family homes.  In fact, one of our flips was taking a property originally built as a single family, converted to duplex probably 30 years ago, and we reconverted back to single family.  Granted, there are a lot of nuances to this: mine had been built of as single, and someone split it up versus you talking about a full addition.  But the logic would be the same: would adding an addition, that is designed as a second unit, actually add value OVER and ABOVE the cost of the addition?  If not, I would look at buying a completely separate property.

  • Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2015 · 355 posts · 268 votes
    2y

    Impossible to say without actual numbers to weigh but on the surface level, adding an extension seems low ROI. You're paying for a brand new build (with high build prices) but people will associate the age/condition with the existing old/leaky structure.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.