Ethical dilemma- super dirty unit, but the guy is disabled.Evict?

Ethical dilemma- super dirty unit, but the guy is disabled.Evict?

Investor · Southern, NH · Member since 2015 · 99 posts · 28 votes

I recently acquired a building and there is one unit which is disgusting, smelly, and dirty. There have been multiple complaints of the smell by the other tenants. The smell equals that of underwear that has been worn for 2 weeks straight in 90 degree heat with a constant Taco Bell diet. Furthermore, it is the first unit of 11 when you walk in. Every tenant walks by and new prospective tenants as well.

The tenant has been there 10 years and always paid on time. His rent is $100-$150 under market value.

It sounds like an easy decision to evict, but he is a single, older male with multiple medical conditions. He certainly doesn't have the financial means to find another place and has disabilities which require him to have close parking and a handicapped accessible unit, therefore, limiting his options to find another place. He has no local family around.

Part of me wants him out because he is hurting my investment property and he is disturbing the other tenants. I am losing $150 a month in cash flow for as long as he stays and he will never leave on his own.

The human part of me fears what will happen to the guy if evicted. He honestly might die living in his car.

If I raised his rent, he wouldn't be able to afford it, and that would lead to eviction, so that would basically be the same as evicting him because of the complaints.

I'm in a tough spot. I've only met the guy once, should it be on my conscience to keep him with a stable living environment?

The maintenance man goes in and cleans up his unit every 6 months. Here is his unit before a cleaning:

What should I do?

0Reply
149 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Durham, NC · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
10y

I would explain to him that part of his lease agreement is that he maintain the property in a relatively clean/decent/responsible manner.  (Hopefully, your lease with him actually states something to that effect.) 

I would then explain that he has not been doing that in the past, but that from today forward he will be held responsible for failing to adhere to that part of the lease.  It is one thing to be disabled, but if the man can walk to his car and drive around, he can certainly keep his apartment somewhat clean.  It may be difficult for him to walk to the dumpster, so I might arrange for him to be able to leave a trash bag outside his back door and have the maintenance man take it to the dumpster.

Tell him that any future complaints will result in a unit inspection, and that a failed inspection will result in eviction.  I would give him two weeks from your conversation to have the unit cleaned.  Tell him he can either clean it himself or he can hire and pay for a cleaning service to come weekly and clean the apartment.

Regarding the rent: with 22 units, I personally would be okay with leaving his rent at its current level.  Some landlords will say you should never leave a dime on the table.  Some will say landlords should always be considerate of a tenant's needs and financial situation.  I think there's room for compromise, but I also wouldn't say you were wrong to increase the rent to market rate if that was your decision.

NOTE: I am not a lawyer and not familiar with the landlord/tenant laws in New Hampshire.  You should verify that it is legal to evict for filth in your state.

See this reply in the discussion

28 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Mike HurneyPro Member
    Real Estate Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 545 votes
    10y

    @Eric Hathway Good, I like the fact that you went to Social Services (with his permission?) and your manager will be documenting a conversation/new lease term/actions.

    But you've got to follow up on anything you agree to!

    IMHE A long time ago I had a Tenant cry that they couldn't afford my rent:-( I suggested they say a prayer and seek higher help/divine intervention. Three weeks later they presented me with a check from a UU church for all the back rent and a month in advance. Six months later I had to boot them and lost 1.5 months rent.

    Another time (3 years ago) a Vet got behind so I took him to the local town Veterans rep. I thought he was going to kill this Marine and I almost had to tear him off the Tenant. VA covered the arearage and he told me to call his cell should he get behind again. So far so good...

  • Investor · Woburn, MA · Member since 2015 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    10y

    Hi I'm not an expert but...I'm thinking he's been there so long because the other landlord allowed this behavior to continue. The reason he pays on time every month may be because he doesn't want to give you an excuse for eviction. Its just my opinion but sounds like this man is a hoarder and I doubt very much he will change. I am a landlord and have had many welfare (section 8) tenants over the years. What I learned is people don't change their habits, especially hoarding because it's a mental illness. He doesn't mind living like that or he would have hired a cleaning person by now. I would give him 60 days to vacate instead of 30 because you're a nice guy, stating that the apartment needs to be totally rehabbed and he cannot live there while the work is going on. I would also put him in touch with the resources he needs like housing, etc...My best paying tenant was a drunk and I felt sorry for him until he fell asleep smoking, causing a fire in his unit. Took 4 months to rehab and put a new tenant in. Just be prepared to spend some money cleaning things up for a new renter. It will be totally worth it. You can also charge more rent than your other tenants pay if you've fixed it all up. Also, consider this, if the board of health is called you may be the one written up for the violations and it would be at your expense to clean up the apartment only to have him trash it again (remember mental illness). Then evicting him could be messy. He could claim retaliation. Bottom line take care of your property and your other tenants and hire a good attorney that deals with evictions and you'll sleep better.

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    10y

    You had best be very strict with your expectations and time lines for him to shape up. I do not believe there is any possible way he will change and you will evict so the sooner you commit to getting him out the better it will be for you and your tenants.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.