Seattle infill: extra height doesn't always mean extra units
A detail worth checking when sizing up a Seattle infill lot: the tree requirements for extra height are different from the requirements for extra units and floor area.
Keeping one qualifying Tier 2 tree can allow 42 feet of height instead of the ordinary 32 feet. But the stacked-flat density/FAR bonus requires two Tier 2 trees, one Tier 1 tree, or a Green Factor score of at least 0.6. One Tier 2 tree alone doesn't get you that bonus.
Here's what that changes on an illustrative 4,800 sq ft legal lot in Seattle's Neighborhood Residential zone. Assume no critical-area density exclusions, no six-home major-transit qualification, and no other special bonuses:
Ground-to-roof attached/detached homes: 4 total homes under the small-lot allowance; 1.6 FAR, or 7,680 sq ft of chargeable floor area.
Stacked flats: 8 total homes; 1.8 FAR, or 8,640 sq ft.
Stacked flats retaining one qualifying Tier 2 tree: still 8 homes and 8,640 sq ft, but the height limit can rise to 42 feet.
Stacked flats meeting the two-Tier-2 / one-Tier-1 / Green-Factor test: 9 homes; 2.0 FAR, or 9,600 sq ft, with the qualifying height allowance.
The nine-home calculation is 4,800 ÷ 500 = 9.6. Seattle's fractional-unit rule rounds up only when the fraction is greater than 0.85, so that is nine, not ten.
These are separate proposals. ADUs count within the total; you don't add two ADUs on top. A mixed plan with stacked flats and separate ground-to-roof homes needs its own calculation.
For an actual purchase, I'd want the designer to sketch the ordinary option and the bonus option on the same survey, with the tree protection area, access and utility routes drawn in. The extra allowance may be hard to use if retaining the tree consumes the space needed to reach the rear building. Chargeable floor area also isn't the same as saleable interior area.
I'd price the tree-dependent option separately until an arborist confirms the classification and a workable protection plan. Then compare the layouts, construction costs and achievable rents or sale prices. The unit ceiling by itself doesn't establish that a project fits or pencils.
The relevant code sections are SMC 23.44.050 (FAR), .060 (density and rounding), and .070 (height)
Has anyone here worked through a Seattle project where retaining a tree improved the zoning allowance but made the layout harder? What ended up controlling the design?