Real Estate Investor · Victoria, TX · Member since 2015 · 13 posts · 7 votes
I just did my first 1031 exchange selling a single family and buying a 4 plex. I did this outside my SDIRA (Self Directed IRA). It got me thinking about using the 1031 exchange within my SDIRA. Here's my thought process..... The purpose of the 1031 is to push capital gains (which are higher than normal tax rate) to some date in the future. What about within the structure of a SDIRA? Profits within my SDIRA aren't taxable until they are withdrawn and then they are taxed at your then current income bracket rate. Would that mean that any capital gains realized on property within the SDIRA will not be taxed at the then capital gains rate but at the lower personal income rate. If that's the case then there is no real reason to do a 1031 on property within the SDIRA because I'm not really gaining any advantage. Right?!?
I am interested in the thoughts of others here. Am I correct or am I missing something? Please let me know.
@Vic Caldwell, No reason to do a 1031 inside your SDIRA because it is all tax deferred anyway. Inside your reitrement accounts simply buy and sell. Outside you've got the 1031 option.
@Vic Caldwell, No reason to do a 1031 inside your SDIRA because it is all tax deferred anyway. Inside your reitrement accounts simply buy and sell. Outside you've got the 1031 option.
Dave, Thanks for the quick response..... That's what I was thinking but want to make sure I'm not missing some "insider" secret. Sometimes it's not the question you ask but the question you don't ask that can make all the difference. Vic
Ps. The capital gains rate is actually lower than regular tax rates. That’s the downside to investing inside your ira. You are converting all your capital gains into regular income.
There is no need to do a 1031 (which is a tax-deferred exchange) because an IRA is already tax-deferred vehicle. You are not taxed on a sale of a property inside of an IRA, unless that property is mortgaged. Then Unrelated Business Income Tax will apply on a portion of the sale. That is the only instance when 1031 exchange in an IRA would make sense.
Now, since you have a self-directed IRA and able to invest tax-deferred, your goal should be to get the maximum return possible. This may or may not always be rental property. Because you have access to virtually unlimited investment options you should always be on the lookout for investments with best possible return, which would include private lending, syndications, private placements, private businesses, etc.