1 Rental Property, $200k in Equity- Looking to Expand

1 Rental Property, $200k in Equity- Looking to Expand

David SchusterPro Member
Member since 2022 · 4 posts · 3 votes

Hello BP Community,

My wife and I currently own one rental property in the North Phoenix area and are looking to scale our real estate business. We purchased the property in 2020 as a primary residence and then turned it into a long-term rental in 2022. Prior to purchase the roof was replaced as was the water heater. During the time we lived there we made some minor upgrades/repairs- renovated upstairs bathroom, replaced carpet on 1st floor with LVP flooring, added artificial turf to the backyard, replaced pool pump, and replaced the HVAC system. We have had the same tenants since we leased it in 2022 and fortunately they have been great- minimal maintenance requests, very easy to communicate with, and pay on time.

We have a 30 year fixed mortgage on the property at 2.875%, the property cash flows about $1,200/month, and there is roughly $200,000 in equity in the property. My wife and I are interested in expanding to help bump up our cash flow to help at least one of us exit our current W2 jobs but are hesitant to do so given the current market climate. The rental property is in a HOA community that has a 30 day minimum lease term so converting to a STR isn't an option. We do have access to a HELOC on the property which we leveraged to purchase our current primary residence (balance borrowed has been fully repaid at this point) but we would rather not pull that lever to roll into a new property given current interest rates and the adjustable nature of the HELOC. We have discussed selling the property and rolling it into a multi-family but again feel like we may be trading a fairly hands off property with good cash flow for one that may be a bit more labor intensive and only yield marginally better performance.

Any advice on how to expand our rental portfolio/maximize its performance is greatly appreciated! 

1Reply
20 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2022 · 51 posts · 30 votes
    2y

    Hey David, My wife were in a very similar situation with our first place. We had a 2.9% rate on it with great cash flow, and it was our previous PR. We ended up going the HELOC route on that property for a few reasons. 1) the interest at the time was only 5%, which although seemed high, didn't matter too much with our potential property showing a 18% ROI 2) we leveraged a second home loan with 10% down for that new property, so our HELOC withdrawal was relatively small compared to what would be needed for a traditional loan on a rental. 3) I dont think I will see the rates in the 2% again in my lifetime, so figured I should hold on to that "free money" instead of selling it. My view on it was yes the rate was high, but making 18% on a new property trumps a 5% interest payment in my opinion. Hope this helps!

  • Josh YoungPro Member
    Rental Property Investor / REALTOR® / Property Manager · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2023 · 384 posts · 421 votes
    2y

    @David Schuster

    Nice job on the first rental, sounds like you did a great job and are getting cash flow and appreciation. You need to calculate your return on equity to see if it's time to leverage that equity more, you also want to calculate your blended interest rate of the original loan and the the HELOC to see if that's the best rate or if a cash out refi would be better.

    If I were you I would look at doing the same move again and buy another primary residence and turn your current house into your second rental. Buying a primary residence requires the lowest down payment and will get you the lowest available interest rate.

    If you don’t want to move again then your next best option might be to buy a new or almost new single family home in a fringe area like casa grande for $300k. These have the highest rent to price ratio and have minimal cap ex since they are new.

    Another option would be to buy a short term rental, but that is going to be more expensive and is more active than long term rentals.

  • Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2024 · 15 posts · 1 vote
    2y

    I Sent you a message!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.