Developer · Orlando, FL · Member since 2018 · 502 posts · 306 votes
All of my personal investment properties have been found on-market
1) Be the First Offer (My 1st & 2nd deal): Speed matters! Many great deals are lost because someone else acted faster. Get alerts and write strong offers immediately. This requires great market knowledge.
2) Find Stale Listings: Properties sitting for 90+ days. Find out why it hasn’t sold and offer a solution: - Seller Financing (My 3rd deal) – Help them get their price while securing better terms. - Subject To – Take over their low-interest existing loan.
I bought 3 brand new houses in February 2025 from a builder that were listed in the MLS. The new home builders have lots of inventory for sale and sales are slow, so they are offering incentives. In this case they were offering below market interest rates in connection with a lender. Was able to get 4.75% interest fixed for 30 years and 4.25% interest fixed for 10 years and variable thereafter.
@Devin James you are 100% correct. You either have to act fast and know what you are looking at, your get creative. I personally like the later, its a littler "slower" and the buyer generally feels like they can get all the facts, and puts the buyer in strong position to get remedy or additional concessions.
We do a bunch of on market deals, just closed a duplex this week that had been sitting, just needed someone to take the time to make a curb offer and get inside. ended up being pretty solid and turnkey for the most part.
@Devin James you are 100% correct. You either have to act fast and know what you are looking at, your get creative. I personally like the later, its a littler "slower" and the buyer generally feels like they can get all the facts, and puts the buyer in strong position to get remedy or additional concessions.
We do a bunch of on market deals, just closed a duplex this week that had been sitting, just needed someone to take the time to make a curb offer and get inside. ended up being pretty solid and turnkey for the most part.
Acting fast is definitely more risky, I prefer the second options, which provides for more creativity and time.
I bought 3 brand new houses in February 2025 from a builder that were listed in the MLS. The new home builders have lots of inventory for sale and sales are slow, so they are offering incentives. In this case they were offering below market interest rates in connection with a lender. Was able to get 4.75% interest fixed for 30 years and 4.25% interest fixed for 10 years and variable thereafter.
2) Find Stale Listings: Properties sitting for 90+ days. Find out why it hasn’t sold and offer a solution: - Seller Financing (My 3rd deal) – Help them get their price while securing better terms. - Subject To – Take over their low-interest existing loan.
Are you still finding success on-market?
Devin, I'm curious about your success with creative financing. It's been pretty tough to find a good deal here in Baton Rouge, but there are listings sitting out there that are 90+ days old that are clearly either going to sell to an investor or not at all. Problem is that the numbers don't even come close to working for even a traditional loan much less a HML. I feel like there has to be some opportunity there, it's just that I'm not seeing it.
When you have worked out creative financing, did you approach the seller with that option first, or did you make an offer and then suggest some creative financing options when the seller rejected the offer?
2) Find Stale Listings: Properties sitting for 90+ days. Find out why it hasn’t sold and offer a solution: - Seller Financing (My 3rd deal) – Help them get their price while securing better terms. - Subject To – Take over their low-interest existing loan.
Are you still finding success on-market?
Devin, I'm curious about your success with creative financing. It's been pretty tough to find a good deal here in Baton Rouge, but there are listings sitting out there that are 90+ days old that are clearly either going to sell to an investor or not at all. Problem is that the numbers don't even come close to working for even a traditional loan much less a HML. I feel like there has to be some opportunity there, it's just that I'm not seeing it.
When you have worked out creative financing, did you approach the seller with that option first, or did you make an offer and then suggest some creative financing options when the seller rejected the offer?
Hey Jason,
My deal specifically came from he Seller mentioning "Seller Financing" in the listing description. So you can filter for similar language.
Other than that, it will take hitting the phones on the stale listings. You will be surprised how much the listing agent will say about their Buyers current situation when you get them talking.
There are hidden deals in MLS that not many people see. I just closed two properties in one sale for a client in a 1031 exchange because they were both leased, and the owner preferred to sell them simultaneously.
Got $125K under list price (they were at $550K) and $75K off the other, so a $200K discount. Instant equity and solid cash flow up front.
Sometimes you have to try! Cash helps too, of course.
There are hidden deals in MLS that not many people see. I just closed two properties in one sale for a client in a 1031 exchange because they were both leased, and the owner preferred to sell them simultaneously.
Got $125K under list price (they were at $550K) and $75K off the other, so a $200K discount. Instant equity and solid cash flow up front.
Sometimes you have to try! Cash helps too, of course.
One of the factors that I look at for listed on market properties is Days on Market (DOM) and properties that have had price reductions, sometimes multiple price reductions. A couple mopnths ago I saw a property for sale that had been on market for almost six months and had a price reduction. It had been appraised before listing at $378,000, listed at that price then reduced to $340,000. After back and forth offers and declines was able to settle on a final price of $250,000. We did put in $20,000 in cosmetics, paint, floor coverings and minor repairs. I think that it is worth the original appraisal of $378,000 if not more, and have seen some good comps in the $400,000 to $425,000 range. Very pleased.
I buy a lot off the MLS. I just offer what I think it's worth no matter what the listing price is. Last year I was closing about 25% of the offers I made. This year I'm only at about 10% unfortunately so I do see a lot of properties and make a lot of offers.
I buy a lot off the MLS. I just offer what I think it's worth no matter what the listing price is. Last year I was closing about 25% of the offers I made. This year I'm only at about 10% unfortunately so I do see a lot of properties and make a lot of offers.
I love the #'s behind your post. Makes me want to make more offers! haha
In my market, I come across about 1 strongly underpriced new listing per quarter on the MLS. The last few were actually inherited properties that needed $5-10k of cleaning/updating (same $ as most of our tenant turnovers) and were listed at about $75% of ARV. And the agent was out of town or inexperienced and didn't know its value. Both times, the inheritors just wanted it to sell fast.
I have alerts on the Zillow App, and after walking the property with my agent, I’ve made a cash/no inspection offer within 3 hours of list on the last 2 I’ve seen, and was able to snag 1, but lost out on the other when someone acted faster. I’ve tried the 90+ days route and it’s often been delusional sellers so I’m kind of tired trying that:
Agreed, you definitely have to know your market really well in order to do this.