Looking to expand real estate portfolio

General Real Estate Investing
10moFollow

Looking to expand real estate portfolio

Steve Croy
Rental Property Investor · Hudson Valley, NY · Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 4 votes

Our REI goals right now are to: a.) buffer our FI number (3x-4x) through additional LTR income; b.) find and rehab our dream home.

My wife and I are looking at expanding our portfolio by purchasing additional LTRs and our greatest deficit right now is knowing what our financing options are and what our financing strategy should be. We're not very experienced with leverage, but I suspect we'll need it to scale our portfolio. What are the best resources for that?

Right now we have two SFH, one we live in and the other is an LTR under an LLC. Both were purchased with cash and (mostly) DIY rehabbed. We rehabbed the rental using a HELOC on our primary residence. Other than that, I have strong W2 income, my wife and I have ~800 credit scores and we just hit our FI number. We currently net $1500/mo in rental income, which for right now is being used to help pay down the HELOC more quickly.

We are pretty close to some people who are very experienced in real estate investing and others who can connect us to private funding sources, but I'd also like to tap in to this community to figure out which questions we should be asking and what resources we should consume so we can approach those conversations with confidence, should we need to.

3Reply
115 views

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jaycee GreenePro Member
    Real Estate Consultant · St. Louis MSA · Member since 2024 · 3k+ posts · 727 votes
    10mo
    Quote from @Steve Croy:

    Our REI goals right now are to: a.) buffer our FI number (3x-4x) through additional LTR income; b.) find and rehab our dream home.

    My wife and I are looking at expanding our portfolio by purchasing additional LTRs and our greatest deficit right now is knowing what our financing options are and what our financing strategy should be. We're not very experienced with leverage, but I suspect we'll need it to scale our portfolio. What are the best resources for that?

    Right now we have two SFH, one we live in and the other is an LTR under an LLC. Both were purchased with cash and (mostly) DIY rehabbed. We rehabbed the rental using a HELOC on our primary residence. Other than that, I have strong W2 income, my wife and I have ~800 credit scores and we just hit our FI number. We currently net $1500/mo in rental income, which for right now is being used to help pay down the HELOC more quickly.

    We are pretty close to some people who are very experienced in real estate investing and others who can connect us to private funding sources, but I'd also like to tap in to this community to figure out which questions we should be asking and what resources we should consume so we can approach those conversations with confidence, should we need to.

    Hey @Steve Croy, welcome to the BP Forum! What type of properties most interests you, SFR, 2-4 MF, or 5+ MF? What is your price range/down payment amount? Are you looking for turn-key properties or something along the lines of a "fixer upper"? Are you looking for properties in your local market or somewhere else?

    [email protected]
    0Reply
  • Arman AhmedPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 948 votes
    10mo

    @Steve Croy

    Hey Steve, sounds like you and your wife have a solid start with your LTRs and DIY rehabs, congrats on hitting your FI number, leveraging is definitely the next step for scaling and there are a few approaches depending on how aggressive you want to be, private lenders and DSCR loans are popular for investors looking to add more cash-flowing properties without tying up all their capital, HELOCs can still be useful but can get tricky as you scale, I also work with a lot of out-of-state investors doing similar strategies in the Midwest, using a mix of financing and boots-on-the-ground teams to manage rehabs and rentals, having your financing lined up ahead of time and understanding the different structures can save a ton of headaches and help you confidently scale your portfolio.

    [email protected]614-418-6081
    0Reply
  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    10mo

    @Steve Croy, you’re actually in a really strong spot to scale. Strong W2 income, great credit, two properties already under your belt, and experience doing your own rehab puts you ahead of most early investors. The only thing missing is clarity on financing, and that’s normal if you started by paying cash.

  • From the tax side, leverage is usually your friend. Interest on investment loans is fully deductible, so borrowing doesn’t hurt you. In a lot of cases it boosts your returns because you’re using someone else’s money while still getting depreciation on the whole property.

    As you grow, you'll also want to think about how everything sits from an entity standpoint. Whether you keep everything in one LLC or break things out depends on how big you plan to go and how much risk you want to isolate. It also affects how lenders look at you.

    Since rehabbing is part of your plan, cost segregation is something to keep on your radar too. Even with long term rentals it can help push down taxable income once you start adding more properties. It will not offset your W2 unless you qualify for REP, but it still helps with cash flow.

    If you already have experienced people around you, the best thing you can do is go into those conversations knowing the right questions to ask. You’re definitely moving in the right direction.

    If you ever want to look at the tax impact of different financing options or how to structure things as you scale, I’m happy to help.

[email protected]941-914-7779
INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®5241 Reviews
WebsiteView Page
TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
WebsiteView Page
0Reply
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 716 posts · 529 votes
    10mo

    Steve, sounds like you’ve built a solid foundation already. The biggest shift when you go from 1–2 units to actually scaling is learning how to use leverage safely and intentionally, not emotionally.

    Here’s the simplest path I'd recommend based on where you are now:

    1. Get familiar with DSCR loans.
    These are built for rental investors. The lender looks at the property’s income, not your W2 or DTI. With strong credit and decent cash reserves, you'll qualify easily and avoid tying up your personal finances.

    2. Start thinking in terms of repeatability, not “one-time DIY rehabs.”
    DIY works for one house. It breaks the moment you buy a second or third. Build a simple, standardized rehab plan you can hand off to contractors. Predictability is what lets you scale.

    3. Decide on your long-term structure early.
    Most small investors get messy around unit three because they mix personal and rental finances. Set up an LLC for future rentals, keep clean books, and let each property stand on its own.

    4. Use private money only when the deal needs speed or flexibility.
    Great tool, but expensive. Private lenders are best for BRRRR-style projects where you can force equity, refi out, and roll into the next deal.

    5. Your first financed deal should be simple, boring, and cash-flow positive from day one.
    Don't jump into complex rehabs or appreciation plays. Put the training wheels on with a starter DSCR loan and a rent-ready or light-rehab property. Build confidence before expanding.

    If you get the financing strategy right on deal number three, scaling gets dramatically easier going forward. It stops being guesswork and starts feeling like a system.

    0Reply
  • Caeli RidgeBusiness Member
    Lender · Portland, OR · Member since 2016 · 32 posts · 13 votes
    10mo

    Hey Steve, sounds like you two have built a really solid foundation — strong W2 income, excellent credit, low leverage, and hands-on rehab experience. That puts you in a great position to start thinking more strategically about financing and scaling.

    When you already own properties free and clear, plus have a HELOC in place, the next step is usually understanding which lending buckets you qualify for and how they fit your goals. A few options most investors in your position start exploring:

    • Conventional financing – Since you have W2 income and strong credit, this is often the cheapest long-term debt for rentals. You can usually go up to 10 financed properties per borrower. Great for 30-year fixed stability.

    • DSCR loans – These qualify the property based on rental income rather than your personal income. Helpful once you start adding doors and want to keep your W2 income out of the equation.

    • Cash-out refinances – Because your properties are owned free and clear, you can tap equity to create capital for future purchases while locking in long-term debt.

    • HELOCs/HELOANs – Useful for renovations or down payments, especially if you like the BRRRR approach.

    • Bridge/rehab loans – For heavier value-add opportunities as you continue to DIY or manage rehab.

    As for resources, here’s what tends to help new investors build confidence quickly:

    • Learn how lenders calculate DTI, DSCR, reserves, and LTV so you know exactly how you’ll be evaluated.

    • BiggerPockets podcasts and calculators (especially the BRRRR and rental property calculators) are great for getting fluent in the numbers.

    • Talking with a few lending pros just to understand product differences can help frame what you can qualify for before you start hunting deals.

    • Build a simple financing roadmap: which properties will stay free and clear, which will be leveraged, and how much cash flow you want to maintain after debt service.

    You’re thinking about the right things — how leverage fits your long-term plan, not just how to buy the next property. With your financial profile, you have a lot of flexibility. It’s mainly about matching the loan type to the timeline and risk level of each deal.

    – Ridge Lending Group (Licensed in 49 states, excluding NY)

    Podcast Guest on Show BiggerNews: Why Mortgage Rates AREN’T Falling
    0Reply
  • Frankie VozziBusiness Member
    Member since 2025 · 346 posts · 87 votes
    10mo

    Hey Steve, Since you already have strong W-2 income, great credit, and a rental under an LLC, you're in a perfect position to start using leverage strategically. Most investors in your situation scale with DSCR loans for long-term rentals. The key is understanding how lenders look at cash flow, LTV, and seasoning so you can map out a clear path before you buy your next property. I'm with Branch Lending and we help a lot of investors build financing strategies like this in New York, we are local! if you want, I can point you to the right resources and walk you through what your options would look like based on your profile. I sent you a DM, let's connect @Steve Croy.

    [email protected]516-888-7750
    0Reply
    • Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
    Log InJoin for Free