Hi Corinna, from my experience I'd say having the right loan product. Many investors assume they only qualify for conventional financing when a DSCR loan, bridge loan, asset depletion, P&L, or bank statement program may be a much better fit for their goals. The challenge isn't always qualifying, it's knowing which financing strategy to use. It's important to work with a lender who has multiple programs so when they review the documents they can advise which program would be best for the borrower based on their situation.
DSCR qualification shouldn't be a hard stop for most borrowers. There is almost always a way to get it to work. Sometimes just a little bit more down payment or buy down the interest rate. You can also submit a ROV on the appraisal which dictates the market rent used for the loan qualification. There are also DSCR < 1 programs and DSCR Interest Only programs.
From the investor side in California and having rentals in North Carolina, the biggest issue I keep running into is appraisals not keeping up with what we actually need for the deal to work. You can find a great deal, get through escrow, and then have the appraiser come in 10-15% below where you need it because there aren't enough recent comps to support the value. That kills the cash-out refi math and sometimes kills the acquisition altogether.
DSCR requirements are the second one for me. The 1.0-1.25x coverage thresholds make sense in theory but in practice a lot of solid deals in higher-cost markets don't pencil on DSCR unless you put more down or buy down the rate, and both of those moves eat into your returns. Some lenders are more flexible than others on this and Neev's point about exploring alternatives is right — but you have to know who to call.
The deeper issue for me is lender consistency. I've been through the process enough times to know that what a lender tells you on the front end doesn't always match what underwriting actually does. You get pre-approved, move forward on a deal, and then underwriting comes back with conditions that weren't mentioned. The investors I see getting the best outcomes are the ones who've built 2-3 solid lender relationships over time and know exactly how those specific people underwrite. That's hard to replicate by rate shopping every deal.
Happy to DM if you want to compare notes on what's working in the SoCal or Southeast markets.