The Man Who Purchased an Excellent Problem

The Man Who Purchased an Excellent Problem

Real Estate Coach · Miami, FL · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 487 votes

Mr. Fletcher had been looking for an investment property for nearly six months when he discovered a building that was, by any reasonable standard, a disaster. The roof leaked. The heating system belonged to another century. Half the windows were broken, and the basement flooded whenever it rained. Mr. Fletcher fell in love immediately.

His wife accompanied him on the second viewing. She asked whether he had noticed the water running down the staircase. Of course he had. That was one of the property's most attractive features.

He purchased the building. For the next six months, Mr. Fletcher was the happiest man in town. He rose before dawn, argued with contractors, studied plumbing diagrams, and spent his evenings comparing insulation materials. He knew the price of every fitting at Home Depot and had developed strong opinions about waterproof membranes. His wife had never seen him so cheerful.

Eventually, the roof stopped leaking. The heating worked. The windows were replaced, the basement was dry, and the building was ready for tenants. Mr. Fletcher walked through the finished property. Everything was clean, functional, and exactly as he had planned. He felt strangely disappointed.

The following week, he returned to inspect the heating system. He adjusted a valve that required no adjustment and replaced a perfectly good thermostat with a slightly better one. Then he began considering whether the new windows might benefit from replacement. His wife suggested that he leave well enough alone. Mr. Fletcher found this expression deeply offensive.

I understand the man. Some of us are born tinkerers. We cannot leave well enough alone. We repair things that are broken, improve things that work, and occasionally repair things we have already repaired.

There is an old Serbian saying: A priest with nothing to do will even baptize baby goats. We have a similar warning about the devil finding work for idle hands. But I suspect that even the devil would have trouble keeping up with a determined restoration enthusiast.

And God knows we have become a civilization of restorers. Every second television show seems to feature someone rescuing an abandoned house, a rusty automobile, or a piece of furniture from the indignity of being old, usually with the promise of selling it for a handsome profit.

But I wonder how many of us are genuinely interested in the finished product. Perhaps the object is merely an excuse. We see something neglected and imagine what it could become. We work on it, correct its imperfections, and gradually bring it closer to an ideal that exists only in our heads.

Maybe restoration is a form of self-improvement expressed through material objects. We cannot so easily rebuild ourselves, but we can rebuild a house. The progress is visible, measurable, and occasionally comes with a fresh coat of paint. And when the work is finished, we need another project. Not necessarily because we want another house, but because we miss the person we were while fixing the last one.

Anyway, Mr. Fletcher soon discovered another property. It had severe foundation problems, extensive water damage, and an electrical system that frightened the inspector. He returned home in excellent spirits.

His wife asked whether he intended to renovate it. Certainly, he replied. And what would he do when it was finished? Mr. Fletcher looked at her with genuine surprise. He had never considered that possibility.

0Reply
246 views

1 Reply

Jump to latestLatest
  • Delray Beach, FL · Member since 2024 · 49 posts · 26 votes
    1w

    Haha, I think every real estate investor who has dealt with older properties can relate to Mr. Fletcher!

    I think there's an important difference between loving the process and making a good investment. At some point you have to stop improving things just because you can, especially when the additional work isn't bringing any real return.

    That said, I completely understand the satisfaction of taking a neglected property and turning it into something people actually want to live in.

    And yes, somehow the next property with a hundred problems always looks more exciting than the one you just finished..

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.