The Third Partner

The Third Partner

Real Estate Coach · Miami, FL · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 487 votes

A guy calls me about a property in South Florida. Three bedrooms, two bathrooms, decent neighborhood, needs some work. He's buying it for $230,000, putting another $70,000 into renovations, and figures he can sell it for $390,000.

"Sounds interesting," I tell him. "You got your numbers worked out?"

"Every penny, Drago. Roof, plumbing, electrical, kitchen, bathrooms, landscaping. I even budgeted for the dumpster."

"Good. What about insurance?"

"Insurance?"

"Yeah. The thing you pay for so the lender can sleep at night."

"Oh, that. My agent's getting me a quote."

"All right. Call me when you have it."

Two days later, he calls back.

"Drago, we have a problem."

"What happened? Contractor find termites?"

"Worse. Insurance."

"How much?"

He tells me.

I put down my sandwich.

"That's for the whole year?"

"Yes."

"Does it come with a boat?"

He doesn't laugh. I don't blame him.

Now, I've been in this business long enough to know that every real estate deal has at least three people making money. The buyer, the seller, and somebody neither of them invited. Sometimes it's the county. Sometimes it's the title company. Sometimes it's a guy with a clipboard who charges $450 to tell you the water heater is old.

But insurance is special. Insurance is the only business where you pay somebody a fortune, then spend the rest of the year hoping you never have to speak to them.

My customer starts explaining that the house is nowhere near the beach.

"How far?"

"About fifteen miles."

"Well, congratulations. The hurricane will have to drive."

He tells me the roof is new. The windows are impact-rated. The electrical system is updated. The house has never flooded.

"Wonderful," I say. "Did you tell the insurance company?"

"Of course."

"And?"

"They said the premium would have been higher otherwise."

There you go. A discount on something you couldn't afford in the first place. Everybody wins.

"Listen," I tell him, "get a couple more quotes. Make sure they're looking at the right property details. And let's calculate what this does to your holding costs."

"Can't we just skip insurance until I sell?"

"Sure. And while we're at it, let's skip the roof. Save seventy grand."

He sighs.

"Drago, I thought I was buying a house."

"You are."

"Feels like I'm buying an insurance policy with a house attached."

Now he's getting somewhere.

We go through the numbers again. Purchase price, renovation, interest, taxes, utilities, insurance, selling costs. Suddenly that beautiful $90,000 difference between his purchase-and-rehab budget and expected resale price looks a lot less beautiful.

"Still a good deal?" he asks.

"Maybe. But we need to know what you're actually going to make. Not what the house looks like it'll make before everybody sends you a bill."

He goes quiet for a moment.

"You know what really bothers me?"

"What?"

"The insurance company makes money whether I flip the house or not."

"That's right."

"And the lender makes interest."

"That's generally how lending works."

"And you make your commission."

"Now hold on. I haven't made a dime yet."

He laughs.

"Everybody gets paid before me."

"Welcome to real estate investing, my friend. You're the guy taking the risk. That's why you're supposed to make the profit."

We eventually find a more reasonable insurance option. The deal still needs some work, but at least the numbers start making sense again. Before hanging up, he asks me one last question.

"Drago, you think insurance companies ever lose money?"

"Of course they do."

"Really?"

"Sure. Otherwise they'd insure everybody."

I hang up and look at my sandwich. It's gone cold. Between the lender, the insurance company, the county, and everybody else, there's always somebody with a hand out. The trick is making sure there's still something left in yours.

0Reply
238 views

1 Reply

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 468 posts · 157 votes
    2d

    Hi Drago — this story is a perfect warning, and it isn't just a Florida problem. Here in Memphis I see the same thing with older homes: a buyer falls in love with the purchase price and the rehab budget, and nobody prices the insurance until the offer is already in. A roof near the end of its life or an older electrical panel can change the premium, or whether a carrier will write the policy at all — and that can turn a good deal into a bad one overnight. What I tell buyers is to get an insurance quote before we make an offer, not after we're under contract, and to treat insurance like a line item in the budget. Your "third partner" line is exactly right: the lender, the contractor, and the insurer all get paid whether the deal works or not. The investor is the only one taking the risk, so check every number before you sign.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.