Why factoring in appreciation is essential!

Why factoring in appreciation is essential!

Real Estate Broker · Madison, WI · Member since 2025 · 14 posts · 5 votes

I don't think in all the episodes of BP I've listened to and all the different forums and discussions I've followed I've heard someone bring up one of the biggest ingredients to investing. YES we've all heard about appreciation but all appreciation is not the same.

Take a $400,000 pile of cash. You can buy a property for cash and it appreciates 3%.

Your 400k investment is growing at 3% plus cash flow from the property that you can reinvest however you see fit.

OR

Buy that same property with $100,000 and have a mortgage. That $400,000 still appreciates at 3% but you only have $100,000 of your own money into it. Your cash flow is smaller but you can still reinvest that however you see fit plus you can invest that additional 300,000k in other investments.

I just doubled your year 1 ROI.

All expenses with the property would be the same EXCEPT the mortgage payment, and the tax implications (cash = larger paper profit, and mortgage = tax deductions for interest etc...)

Biggest risk I see - Life changes and you don't actually hold the property very long and are forced to sell, because you put less down the margin is much smaller in the beginning years.

I know there are situations where you don't want to rely on appreciate to make your numbers work for buying a property but why would you not factor in appreciation why looking at deals.

WHAT is the biggest factor you think I could be overlooking here?

0Reply
112 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Vernon, CT · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 5 votes
    19h

    The big thing is that appreciation isn't that easy to predict.

    Yeah, experience investors that have been in the game for 20 years can probably do it relatively well. And you probably can too as a broker who also owns some properties himself.

    But your average new person is more likely to get sold a fake promise of "5+% appreciation year over year for the next 10 years!" by someone who just wants a commission.

    I remember people buying properties in California in 2019-2021, that were appreciating $100k+ a year. With 3-4% DSCR loans, that still cash flowed.

    Now almost all of them aren't cash flowing, and the investor is losing money every month while not getting the appreciation anymore.

    So it's safer to tell new investors "Don't bank on appreciation" and then they get it as a nice little bonus.

    Kind of how like I started going to the gym to get healthier. My clothes fitting better is a nice little bonus.

    Not always easy to predict out "What's going to happen in the next few decades in this market?"

    • Real Estate Broker · Madison, WI · Member since 2025 · 14 posts · 5 votes
      18h

      I really appreciate this response. It is definitely not easy to predict appreciation.

      Being a broker in a specific market I know how market specific and often neighborhood specific appreciation really is. It gets increasingly difficult to predict appreciation in small time periods. I suppose I should add to my strong opinions on leverage and appreciation that it is more aligned with a specific investing strategy, longer buy and hold time investing will help more accurately predict appreciation.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.