What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?
HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out.
@Roberto Westerband on the investment property I will pull a standard commercial loan and have the property stand alone. At that point my current HELOC will be free to be used on the next property and I will rinse and repeat, so "yes" this is a financing variation of BRRR.
@Christopher Winkler I live in the SF Bay Area so I have had a great run of appreciation over the past 13 years of ownership, almost 3x to be exact. I had also been building a relationship up with my lender over the past half decade, so they allowed me to add the value of a second property to my HELOC. There is nothing tying the loan to that property, everything is against my primary residence. My total debt to value on my primary is still less than 30%. I kept the monthly payments the same from my original 30 year fixed to the HELOC, but the pay down rate is substantially higher with my new loan. In my case, on all of my properties, appreciation is the "steak and all of the sides" of my investments and the cash flow is the Merlot that goes with the meal. I do not go after properties that cannot support both sides of the equation: appreciation + cash flow = wealth.
I really like the idea of using a HELOC because it is essentially a giant credit card. No more rushing and fighting for a loan during the purchase phase of a property. I now have the luxury of shopping a commercial loan at my own pace. It also allowed me to act as a "cash buyer" when I went after the 6 plex and it will do so into the future.
The obvious key to this strategy is that you have to be able to buildup to a large enough HELOC. This is not a "get rich quick" strategy. It literally took me years to get all of the pieces into place, but now I have a huge amount of freedom and flexibility.
Do you by any chance invest in properties in the north east? Interested to know how much you pay property management companies for covering escrow services etc. Also, are AIO loans typically only available for non-investment properties?
no pacific north west investing.
and PM companies around here are 8% with 50% lease up if you're in residential space and around 6% flat for multi family oriented PM's 5+ units.
AIO is for primary and secondary homes only (not for investment properties).
Into a HELOC in December. Ours is based on the 1 month LIBOR and has a draw period of 20 years.
We do not have an escrow account so we are responsible for making sure we pay insurance and taxes.
We will be buying a rental within the next two months using the HELOC.
There are a ton of different products out there but this worked for us. PM if you'd like more
@Chris Wilson hey, I would like to know what HELOC you have that uses 1 month LIBOR. Thanks.
I got a HELOC on a paid for house in central Florida. It is from a Credit Union and they loaned 75% of the house value and charged me 5% APR, based on prime.
I used it to buy a SFR from a wholesaler for cash. Four months later, I flipped the house and paid off the HELOC, and will probably use it again.
[
I recently purchased a property and obtained a 30 year mortgage with an interest rate of 3.75%. The property is estimated by the bank to be worth 155K my mortgage is 109K. I want to refi into a 1st Position HELOC in order to pay off the loan quickly (7 to 10 years). Which banks or lenders offer a product like what I am looking for?
I recently purchased a property and obtained a 30 year mortgage with an interest rate of 3.75%. The property is estimated by the bank to be worth 155K my mortgage is 109K. I want to refi into a 1st Position HELOC in order to pay off the loan quickly (7 to 10 years). Which banks or lenders offer a product like what I am looking for?
Why not just put every dollar left over each pay into an extra "Principal-only" payments?
ie. It'll achieve the same thing. At such a low interest regime that we have now, whether you put all your pay into a re-draw facility before spending any of it, and progressively withdraw out of that, or, do what I suggested, will make a negligible difference to your payout time.
In fact, my way could help your discipline, because once you make principal-only payments, you don't get to re-draw them again! Ask yourself: do you really mean what you say? Cheers...
I recently purchased a property and obtained a 30 year mortgage with an interest rate of 3.75%. The property is estimated by the bank to be worth 155K my mortgage is 109K. I want to refi into a 1st Position HELOC in order to pay off the loan quickly (7 to 10 years). Which banks or lenders offer a product like what I am looking for?
Why not just put every dollar left over each pay into an extra "Principal-only" payments?
ie. It'll achieve the same thing. At such a low interest regime that we have now, whether you put all your pay into a re-draw facility before spending any of it, and progressively withdraw out of that, or, do what I suggested, will make a negligible difference to your payout time.
In fact, my way could help your discipline, because once you make principal-only payments, you don't get to re-draw them again! Ask yourself: do you really mean what you say? Cheers...
HI Brent,
You brought up a good point, why not put every extra dollar into pricipal only payments? I assume this is referring to paying extra principal payments into your closed end loan (fixed loan that cannot redraw your money back out, aka, not a line of credit):
- Interest on a 360 year fixed is calculated per month so it doesnt reamortize mid month so that means if you pay extra your interest savings on that lower balance (paid with extra principal) is not recalculated till the 1st of the next month so your daily interest rate is still being charged at the balance you had on day 1 of this current month. This doesnt sound like a huge deal but like the saying goes small changes make big differences over time and this is how home loans are paid off within 5-8 years. Its not for everyone because an ideal candidate for this is someone who takes home (my opinion) at least 1.50 for every dollar they spend or more.
- on a fixed /closed end loan you cannot reaccess your funds so if you plug in all of your available excess funds as "extra," principal you could have an emergency where you need to access your funds again and you'll be stuck
- on HELOC's and 1st position liens the interest is calculated daily and with regards to products like AIO or all in one mortgage from CMG financial the interest is calculated daily and settled/swept at 12AM each day allowing every outstanding dollar you park into your line to work for you within your line of credit. This is much different with closed ended loans like we mentioned above where balance's and interest charged is recalculated each month on the 1st. The closed end loan in effect charges a borrower "compounded interest," but in this case its not compounded in your favor but in the favor of the banks and they know that. The sad truth is most dont know how this works against them. This does not mean closed end loans are bad because there are pros and cons and the pros are fixed rate, terms, and certainty, but just know that this certainty comes at a premium.
The AIO and 1st lien or HELOC strategy is not meant for financial undisciplined people but you're right if you're undisciplined a fixed loan may often be better because typically that person cannot put extra principle in their loan anyway but they might frivolously spend all their available line credit anyway.
I recently purchased a property and obtained a 30 year mortgage with an interest rate of 3.75%. The property is estimated by the bank to be worth 155K my mortgage is 109K. I want to refi into a 1st Position HELOC in order to pay off the loan quickly (7 to 10 years). Which banks or lenders offer a product like what I am looking for?
Why not just put every dollar left over each pay into an extra "Principal-only" payments?
ie. It'll achieve the same thing. At such a low interest regime that we have now, whether you put all your pay into a re-draw facility before spending any of it, and progressively withdraw out of that, or, do what I suggested, will make a negligible difference to your payout time.
In fact, my way could help your discipline, because once you make principal-only payments, you don't get to re-draw them again! Ask yourself: do you really mean what you say? Cheers...
HI Brent,
You brought up a good point, why not put every extra dollar into pricipal only payments? I assume this is referring to paying extra principal payments into your closed end loan (fixed loan that cannot redraw your money back out, aka, not a line of credit):
- Interest on a 360 year fixed is calculated per month so it doesnt reamortize mid month so that means if you pay extra your interest savings on that lower balance (paid with extra principal) is not recalculated till the 1st of the next month so your daily interest rate is still being charged at the balance you had on day 1 of this current month. This doesnt sound like a huge deal but like the saying goes small changes make big differences over time and this is how home loans are paid off within 5-8 years. Its not for everyone because an ideal candidate for this is someone who takes home (my opinion) at least 1.50 for every dollar they spend or more.
- on a fixed /closed end loan you cannot reaccess your funds so if you plug in all of your available excess funds as "extra," principal you could have an emergency where you need to access your funds again and you'll be stuck
- on HELOC's and 1st position liens the interest is calculated daily and with regards to products like AIO or all in one mortgage from CMG financial the interest is calculated daily and settled/swept at 12AM each day allowing every outstanding dollar you park into your line to work for you within your line of credit. This is much different with closed ended loans like we mentioned above where balance's and interest charged is recalculated each month on the 1st. The closed end loan in effect charges a borrower "compounded interest," but in this case its not compounded in your favor but in the favor of the banks and they know that. The sad truth is most dont know how this works against them. This does not mean closed end loans are bad because there are pros and cons and the pros are fixed rate, terms, and certainty, but just know that this certainty comes at a premium.
The AIO and 1st lien or HELOC strategy is not meant for financial undisciplined people but you're right if you're undisciplined a fixed loan may often be better because typically that person cannot put extra principle in their loan anyway but they might frivolously spend all their available line credit anyway.
Where I'm from, once upon a time (not so long ago), home loan interest rates were well into double digit interest rates. At that time, I would have agreed that "small changes make big differences over time and this is how home loans are paid off within 5-8 years" (ie. for "someone who takes home at least 1.50 for every dollar they spend").
But it really annoys me that this type of "5-8 years" hyperbole is being promoted to people who don't earn 50% more than they need to spend, and who don't have a high interest rate anyway.
Another point is: So what if it takes 30 years to pay off your home? Your mortgage is probably less than paying rent anyway, and will progressively show even greater savings, each year!
Also, you mentioned "emergencies" (including holidays, new cars etc?). Of course, every one of those re-draws will delay your payout anyway. But even if you did it my "extra principal-only payments" way, once you get ahead of schedule, you can elect to stop making (any) payments, until the schedule catches up with you again. [But, check with your Lender first]. Cheers...
Into a HELOC in December. Ours is based on the 1 month LIBOR and has a draw period of 20 years.
We do not have an escrow account so we are responsible for making sure we pay insurance and taxes.
We will be buying a rental within the next two months using the HELOC.
There are a ton of different products out there but this worked for us. PM if you'd like more info.
Into a HELOC in December. Ours is based on the 1 month LIBOR and has a draw period of 20 years.
We do not have an escrow account so we are responsible for making sure we pay insurance and taxes.
We will be buying a rental within the next two months using the HELOC.
There are a ton of different products out there but this worked for us. PM if you'd like more info.
@chris Wilson Can you tell me which bank you used that offered this HELOC.
I don't want to violate any rules but my brother got this exact HELOC and I'm about to get one for my first purchase. Private message me and I'll introduce you to the bank and broker I'm getting it with. He specializes in this HELOC for real estate investors.
Planning to do this exact strategy with the company mentioned by others but have to wait another 10 months to get 7 yrs past a bankruptcy :(
So, in the meantime, I took a second position HELOC for a total of 80% LTV on my primary home and am using it the same as if it were a first-position HELOC. It's a bigger headache to manage, but it's working to pay down my primary loan faster.
Does anyone know if there is a calculator that combines the rental property calculator and the HELOC 1st position pay check strategy? Wondering how to figure the cash on cash ROI based on the daily interest calculation and accelerated payment.
thanks
As I was reading through these responses I saw someone else mention RYM (can't remember who posted it). My wife and I used this company with amazing results. They teach you the ins and outs of a 1st lien HELOC, all the pit falls and have ongoing support. We are paying down about 4K per month in principal without changing our income or expenses. Send me message and I'll get you the email for the consultant we worked with. He was great.
@Brent Coombs have you run the numbers to see the difference in interest payments from using the HELOC strategy opposed to a conventional mortgage while paying extra each month towards principal? I am having a hard time understanding your reasoning against the HELOC method other than when you say
"But it really annoys me that this type of "5-8 years" hyperbole is being promoted to people who don'tearn 50% more than they need to spend, and who don't have a high interest rate anyway."
I thought BP was more or less about helping others save money, invest that money and make more $$$ while improving our own situations simultaneously.
I understand that you might be looking out for people that are not overly positive in the cash flow, (good on ya) but I don't see a downside to spending/earning the same amount and have NO house payment in several years.
I find it sad that so many people spend 30 + years paying over 2x the amount they bought their house for. Sure it appreciates in value in 30 years, but having it paid off in 5 years isn't going to stop it from appreciating either.. And give you more money to invest!!
What annoys me is the majority of people blindly paying interest over 30 years towards a mortgage because they are chasing lower interest rates and end up spending more money in the long run once closing costs and renewing a 30 year term are factored into the process.
In my opinion, that is something that should be challenged anytime someone asks a question about it....
Do you challenge the HELOC method because you were on the debate team in high school and like to try and heat up threads for discussion?
You no doubt have more experience than me, so please enlighten me!
Also, I appreciate your corrections on my typos, running sentences and my perspective in advance!
Cheers!
Side note. when I do the math, a continuously growing interest rate on a HELOC still beats a low apr on a conventional as long as you're positive on the cash flow. ... but math was never my strongest.
I have a 1st position HELOC loan as my primary mortgage. It's a variable rate based on 1 month LIBOR. Unfortunately the rates are rising especially over the last 3 months.
I did something crazy and give up my 3.25% 15 year fixed to get a variable (currently 5.3%?).
Why? I wanted to get the BIGGEST line of credit possible so that i could get ready to buy home cheap in the next 2-4 years when the market dips (recession).
It's really a no brainer if you have a 30year fixed loan. With my low rate at 3.25% at 15 year fixed, it's unclear if I will save a lot of money on interest if Libor keeps going up.
But I'm not paying the full 5.3% interest. I'm paying down principle much faster than I would with a 30 year fixed loan and slightly faster than a 15 year fixed loan.
It's a bit complicated to explain but you use this loan as your checking account. You put ALL of your income to pay down the loan as fast as possible. So how about paying bills? You lend back to yourself with the line of credit you have.
I'm not quite going all in like that but most of my salary does go directly to pay down the loan. (larger principal paydown each month).
Please don't PM me. If you want to know more about the loan, PM - albert bui who is on the thread who is the agent who gave me the loan.
@Brent Coombs have you run the numbers to see the difference in interest payments from using the HELOC strategy opposed to a conventional mortgage while paying extra each month towards principal? I am having a hard time understanding your reasoning against the HELOC method other than when you say
"But it really annoys me that this type of "5-8 years" hyperbole is being promoted to people who don'tearn 50% more than they need to spend, and who don't have a high interest rate anyway."
I thought BP was more or less about helping others save money, invest that money and make more $$$ while improving our own situations simultaneously.
I understand that you might be looking out for people that are not overly positive in the cash flow, (good on ya) but I don't see a downside to spending/earning the same amount and have NO house payment in several years.
I find it sad that so many people spend 30 + years paying over 2x the amount they bought their house for. Sure it appreciates in value in 30 years, but having it paid off in 5 years isn't going to stop it from appreciating either.. And give you more money to invest!!
What annoys me is the majority of people blindly paying interest over 30 years towards a mortgage because they are chasing lower interest rates and end up spending more money in the long run once closing costs and renewing a 30 year term are factored into the process.
In my opinion, that is something that should be challenged anytime someone asks a question about it....
Do you challenge the HELOC method because you were on the debate team in high school and like to try and heat up threads for discussion?
You no doubt have more experience than me, so please enlighten me!
Also, I appreciate your corrections on my typos, running sentences and my perspective in advance!
Cheers!
Side note. when I do the math, a continuously growing interest rate on a HELOC still beats a low apr on a conventional as long as you're positive on the cash flow. ... but math was never my strongest.
Tory, welcome to BP, and, welcome to this debate. You've hit the road running! Firstly, I agree that "BP is about helping others save money, invest that money and make more $$$ while improving our own situations simultaneously". You already saw and agreed with why I'm annoyed at the HELOC being promoted as a "program" (that usually costs circa $2,500 upfront for "coaching and training") to people that it's not really suited for (ie. Those who are already stretched budget-wise, but who do have an interest rate in the 3's for their 30 year mortgage)!
And to reiterate bluntly: the "5-8 years" hyperbole cannot succeed, if you "invest that money" (that you're saving with this method, when opportunity presents itself - and, it will)!
Or, are you never going to re-invest until your home is paid off? [But then, put it back into hock?]
Thank you for the welcome and for your time in responding! To answer your question, I am a passive investor and probably will stick to the doors I have until the opportunity presents itself (probably won't happen since I'm very casually looking for it.)
As far as 1st lien HELOC and investing goes, it seems advantageous to me to have the option to reinvest from the LOC if the opportunity falls on my lap as opposed to having debt/equity tied into a conventional loan. I am not debating here, but to me it seems like an easy way to roll money into new properties without paying closing costs. Certainly there are more options and you obviously don't prefer this one. Which method(s) have you found beneficial or that you are keen on?
I see how this cannot lighten the burden of interest if you are continually borrowing from the LOC, but can't the equity be making more $$ in other ventures while a conventional is still heavy with interest and no access to the equity.
Again, I am not debating. I am telling how I view it knowing that I don't have 20/20.
What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?
HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out.
HI Roberto,
Yes there are banks that use different indexes but typically the ones that do are commercial LOC's or lines of credit. I've seen lines of credit on WSJ Prime, Prime, COFI index, Treasure maturity indexes, Libor, and many others.
A popular 1st lien HELOC primary is a primary and secondary residence product (non investment properties) and it can go up to 75-80% LTV which doesnt sound too high, but the max loan amount is 2,000,000 vs typical HELOC (home equity lines of credit) that cap out at 350-500k. This product is called a "All in One," or AIO loan from CMG Financial. The advantage of this LOC is that it offers an integrated checking account/routing acct # so you can treat the loan as a "checking account," and it auto sweeps or calculates interest daily and closes out your position so that means any funds credited to your account can lower your daily interest cost.
I have one that is fixed for 5 years interest only but its a commercial LOC that I use for acquisitions and it calculates simple interest which is nice when you want to make early payments or if you'd like to do those pay check parking strategies or rapid debt free strategies.
Most lines of credit do not have escrowed tax and insurance so this means you will have to pay it on your own.
When I do LOC's on rental's I just have the PM (property management) take over the responsibility of escrowing the property taxes and insurance so I dont have to remember when to pay them.
Typically LOC's are full recourse but at a low enough LTV Im sure you can negotiate a non recourse LOC but that'd probably be in the commercial realm at a bank small enough where they'd be willing to negotiate, probably.
Thank you for the detailed post Albert.
Can you re-fiance your 5yr HELCO at the end for another 5 yrs? And if so do they charge you fees?
What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?
HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out.
HI Roberto,
Yes there are banks that use different indexes but typically the ones that do are commercial LOC's or lines of credit. I've seen lines of credit on WSJ Prime, Prime, COFI index, Treasure maturity indexes, Libor, and many others.
A popular 1st lien HELOC primary is a primary and secondary residence product (non investment properties) and it can go up to 75-80% LTV which doesnt sound too high, but the max loan amount is 2,000,000 vs typical HELOC (home equity lines of credit) that cap out at 350-500k. This product is called a "All in One," or AIO loan from CMG Financial. The advantage of this LOC is that it offers an integrated checking account/routing acct # so you can treat the loan as a "checking account," and it auto sweeps or calculates interest daily and closes out your position so that means any funds credited to your account can lower your daily interest cost.
I have one that is fixed for 5 years interest only but its a commercial LOC that I use for acquisitions and it calculates simple interest which is nice when you want to make early payments or if you'd like to do those pay check parking strategies or rapid debt free strategies.
Most lines of credit do not have escrowed tax and insurance so this means you will have to pay it on your own.
When I do LOC's on rental's I just have the PM (property management) take over the responsibility of escrowing the property taxes and insurance so I dont have to remember when to pay them.
Typically LOC's are full recourse but at a low enough LTV Im sure you can negotiate a non recourse LOC but that'd probably be in the commercial realm at a bank small enough where they'd be willing to negotiate, probably.
Thank you for the detailed post Albert.
Can you re-fiance your 5yr HELCO at the end for another 5 yrs? And if so do they charge you fees?
You can always refinance your HELOC to extend your terms or draw period but you're subject to the margin and index at that time relative to your current HELOC assuming you have a HELOC at this moment.
Most HELOC's are based on 0-2.00% margin which is a fixed portion of a line of credit in addition to a index (CMT, LIBOR, COFI, and others) which is a variable index for cost of money in the world or US. Some indexes are better than others for being more or less volatile so its important to know which index your bank is using.
What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?
HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out.
HI Roberto,
Yes there are banks that use different indexes but typically the ones that do are commercial LOC's or lines of credit. I've seen lines of credit on WSJ Prime, Prime, COFI index, Treasure maturity indexes, Libor, and many others.
A popular 1st lien HELOC primary is a primary and secondary residence product (non investment properties) and it can go up to 75-80% LTV which doesnt sound too high, but the max loan amount is 2,000,000 vs typical HELOC (home equity lines of credit) that cap out at 350-500k. This product is called a "All in One," or AIO loan from CMG Financial. The advantage of this LOC is that it offers an integrated checking account/routing acct # so you can treat the loan as a "checking account," and it auto sweeps or calculates interest daily and closes out your position so that means any funds credited to your account can lower your daily interest cost.
I have one that is fixed for 5 years interest only but its a commercial LOC that I use for acquisitions and it calculates simple interest which is nice when you want to make early payments or if you'd like to do those pay check parking strategies or rapid debt free strategies.
Most lines of credit do not have escrowed tax and insurance so this means you will have to pay it on your own.
When I do LOC's on rental's I just have the PM (property management) take over the responsibility of escrowing the property taxes and insurance so I dont have to remember when to pay them.
Typically LOC's are full recourse but at a low enough LTV Im sure you can negotiate a non recourse LOC but that'd probably be in the commercial realm at a bank small enough where they'd be willing to negotiate, probably.
Thank you for the detailed post Albert.
Can you re-fiance your 5yr HELCO at the end for another 5 yrs? And if so do they charge you fees?
You can always refinance your HELOC to extend your terms or draw period but you're subject to the margin and index at that time relative to your current HELOC assuming you have a HELOC at this moment.
Most HELOC's are based on 0-2.00% margin which is a fixed portion of a line of credit in addition to a index (CMT, LIBOR, COFI, and others) which is a variable index for cost of money in the world or US. Some indexes are better than others for being more or less volatile so its important to know which index your bank is using.
I don't have one yet but I am in the market and ready to make a move in the next two months. I am currently just trying to learn as much as possible so that it is set up properly. Any information you can provide is much appreciated.
Thank you for the welcome and for your time in responding! To answer your question, I am a passive investor and probably will stick to the doors I have until the opportunity presents itself (probably won't happen since I'm very casually looking for it.)
As far as 1st lien HELOC and investing goes, it seems advantageous to me to have the option to reinvest from the LOC if the opportunity falls on my lap as opposed to having debt/equity tied into a conventional loan. I am not debating here, but to me it seems like an easy way to roll money into new properties without paying closing costs. Certainly there are more options and you obviously don't prefer this one. Which method(s) have you found beneficial or that you are keen on?
I see how this cannot lighten the burden of interest if you are continually borrowing from the LOC, but can't the equity be making more $$ in other ventures while a conventional is still heavy with interest and no access to the equity.
Again, I am not debating. I am telling how I view it knowing that I don't have 20/20.
I actually don't have a beef with your methodology. Absolutely, the "the equity can be making more $$ in other ventures"! I do have a beef with upfront thousands of dollars being sought by so-called "Pay-off-your-home-sooner" Programs.
eg. Did you need to pay for a Put-all-your-income-into-a-Heloc Program - upfront?...
@Brent Coombs I agree. I was under the wrong impression that you did not agree with the tactic and was curious why. I disagree with it for the undisciplined as well, but am naive enough to think anyone willing to try it would be a forward thinker.
To answer your question, I do not pay for someone else to shop for me and once again, appreciate your time in responding! (I may have overreacted out of curiosity)
@Roberto Westerband I ran the numbers on my personal property and my payoff was 10 years. I also ran the numbers on my mothers home and her payoff is 4 years. I have only found HELOC on primary homes. If used properly they are amazing loans to cut the total interest cost.
Just closed on a first position HELOC. Have done a lot of online research, including looking into the truthinequity and