First Lien HELOC Strategy

First Lien HELOC Strategy

Developer · New York, NY · Member since 2016 · 50 posts · 7 votes

What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?

HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out. 

  • If you have a 1st lien HELOC, what happens to escrow for taxes and insurance, can it be waived and paid out of your own pocket or is it tied up into the monthly payment?
  • With regards to recourse vs. non-recourse loans, would putting the HELOC in 1st position allow a bank to come after personal assets in the event of a default?
  • Are there any banks/credit unions that charge LIBOR instead of Prime on HELOCs?
1Reply
1,508 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2014 · 942 posts · 1k+ votes
9y

@Roberto Westerband on the investment property I will pull a standard commercial loan and have the property stand alone. At that point my current HELOC will be free to be used on the next property and I will rinse and repeat, so "yes" this is a financing variation of BRRR.

@Christopher Winkler I live in the SF Bay Area so I have had a great run of appreciation over the past 13 years of ownership, almost 3x to be exact. I had also been building a relationship up with my lender over the past half decade, so they allowed me to add the value of a second property to my HELOC. There is nothing tying the loan to that property, everything is against my primary residence. My total debt to value on my primary is still less than 30%. I kept the monthly payments the same from my original 30 year fixed to the HELOC, but the pay down rate is substantially higher with my new loan. In my case, on all of my properties, appreciation is the "steak and all of the sides" of my investments and the cash flow is the Merlot that goes with the meal. I do not go after properties that cannot support both sides of the equation: appreciation + cash flow = wealth.

I really like the idea of using a HELOC because it is essentially a giant credit card. No more rushing and fighting for a loan during the purchase phase of a property. I now have the luxury of shopping a commercial loan at my own pace. It also allowed me to act as a "cash buyer" when I went after the 6 plex and it will do so into the future.

The obvious key to this strategy is that you have to be able to buildup to a large enough HELOC. This is not a "get rich quick" strategy. It literally took me years to get all of the pieces into place, but now I have a huge amount of freedom and flexibility.

See this reply in the discussion

168 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2017 · 28 posts · 11 votes
    9y

    But and most definitely looking to do one or a few REI transactions during my HELOC term. I was ultra conservative in that I did not max out the equity available to me but left some on the table for the in case scenario.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    @Leslie Hsiung, of course, I don't know that you paid too much. And of course, it makes sense to find the lowest interest you can. But as you can now guess, I'm not a big fan of trial period special rates, offered just to get you to jump from a low FIXED rate, to an even lower TEMPORARY rate!

    Anyone who's been observing long-term trends will likely be thinking: I should be getting my FIXED Interest Rate Loan in place NOW, rather than waiting to do it in two years time.

    But here you are, being lured into doing just the opposite? Where do YOU think rates are heading?

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2017 · 9 posts · 6 votes
    9y

    @Brent Coombs maybe I'm naive but even tho rates are likely to go up at some point, I don't think they will go up that drastically. I understand that there is always a risk of anything happening. With the heloc the interest is simple and the amt of interest owed will keep going down as the principal gets paid down, which should happen much faster than with my current mortgage as long as I stay ahead as planned. With the original mortgage loan the interest is fixed but compounded and over 2/3 of it is going towards interest each month, so I continue to make barely a dent in the principal. Is it so bad/risky to look beyond the interest rates in and of themselves and to try to cut down on the overall interest owed over the lifetime of the loan/line in this way? I would close the line ideally within the 10yr draw period before the repayment period when it becomes an amortized loan. I just want my payments to count more, and not feel like im spinning my wheels paying off huge amounts of interest only

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2017 · 9 posts · 6 votes
    9y

    , are there other strategies I should consider? (Sorry accident hit post before I finished the sentence)

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Leslie Hsiung:

    , are there other strategies I should consider? (Sorry accident hit post before I finished the sentence)

    Can you summarize how much you anticipate it would take off your principal over the next two years (as a dollar amount, AND as a percentage of your loan amount)? 

    Then, can you summarize how much you'd have to pay per month at the end of those two years if the best Interest Rate you could then find was say 5.5% compound interest (using the lower loan amount because of your principal pay down)? Much the same, or more, or less?

    Keep in mind also: if you gained virtually zero equity in the last year by pure appreciation, then you can't be guaranteed any/much further appreciation over the next two years either, right?

    I'm curious: how much on average per month does it cost you to own, vs what rent would be?

    Sorry, I don't have any accelerating strategy to recommend to anyone who already paid full market value with only 3.5% down, and whose mortgage and expenses may be already be more than paying rent, other than: sell, and please, only buy bargains from now on!

    Meantime, there's nothing stopping you from putting any extra funds you do have (starting with the lazy $5k you mentioned) into EXTRA principal-only payments!

    (By the way, you can Edit your posts within 15 minutes, or Update them thereafter, by hovering over the three green dots at the top of your post, and clicking on the appropriate link). Cheers...

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2017 · 9 posts · 6 votes
    9y

    @Brent Coombs wow I may not know much but I'm fairly sure it would be unwise to just sell my place now as the only possible strategy, and am frankly quite upset you would suggest that. Is it a lost cause and I'm just supposed to fold and cut my losses??I'm not sure how you determined that I only put 3.5% down; I put down 5%. Also I did not buy at full market value or asking price, it appraised higher than what I paid. This is my first home and I live in it currently - I was not necessarily looking for a bargain when I bought it but I don't think I overpaid for it. 

    My rent for comparable apts prior to buying were about the same, sometimes more, than my current mortgage.

    There's actually many things stopping me from making extra payments, all related to student loans. My mortgage is not my highest monthly payment owed and the student loans are at a higher interest rate so I prioritize them when I have extra cash flow. That is why i am obsessing over making sure my current mortgage payments are being applied as effectively as possible.

    At my current rate of 4% and amortization schedule, my principal balance in 2 years would only go down by about 23k. If I swap this out for the heloc at 1.75%, my principal would be down by almost 54.5k in 2 years. If I then took that new principal balance and was unable to find another promo rate at another bank and was stuck with refinancing the heloc back to a mortgage with fixed rate 5.5% as you suggested, my new monthly payments would be 245 dollars less than my current monthly payment.

    I already am not taking into account much appreciation in my apartment in the past year, so I'm not counting on it in the next two years either, but if it does that will be even better no? I am focusing instead on how paying down more principal can increase my equity.

    What am I not considering or putting too little/too much weight on? I hope you don't think I am arguing, I'm just really trying hard to understand what's happening with these loans/lines.

    (the dot feature does not appear to work on my browser, I'm sorry for the multiple posting before)

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    @Leslie Hsiung, my "sell" suggestion was not meant to be taken seriously - IF you can't find a cheaper suitable living arrangement. And if you can make this promo deal work as successfully as you calculate, then you don't need to be concerned with naysayers, right?

    If, without paying any extra dollars per month, you'd be paying off an extra $21.5k principal over the next two years, AND thus saving you $245/m thereafter (even at 1.5% higher interest rate than you're paying now), then I've run out of objections.

    But you obviously have issues (eg. student loan!) that will continue to hinder your desire to ACCELERATE your investing ambitions. [Hint: pay every spare dollar into THAT loan!]

    In principle, I don't recommend borrowing up to 90% of its value all the time, just because your equity will sometimes become greater than 10%. I recommend instead: having no more than 75% leverage at any given time (and even less leverage, once interest rates rise)...

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2017 · 9 posts · 6 votes
    9y

    @Brent Coombs Thanks for the explanation. Yes those nasty loans are taking a lot away from my investing, so i'm doing my best to accelerate those. Ive been paying out of my ears on interest on those things which is why I started to obsess over my mortgage payments as well, bc i could see myself getting into the same cycle. 

    Sorry what do you mean by leverage? Like what the bank has over me? Is there a specific reason for 75% as your recommended level? Thanks again for your input

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    @Leslie Hsiung, yes, the word "leverage" in that context means your debt (as a percentage).

    I'm suggesting that beyond 75% debt, borrowers are entering a danger level, because it's not unheard of for values to go DOWN by 25% or more - and for Banks to then call in the loans!

    How will that look for you, if you already owed 90% of a pre-price-drop value?

    You do know that there are hundreds of thousands of homes that are still valued at less than are owed for them, dating back to 2005-7, right? And that doesn't include the millions of homes that have already been taken back by the Banks via foreclosure since then, for the same reason.

    That is NOT a scenario you want to find yourself in!

    Why do you think Banks (these days) are GENERALLY loathe to lend more than 75% of its value?

    But of course, some (like your Lender) find it hard to resist slipping back into their pre-GFC ways!

  • Investor · Chaska, MN · Member since 2014 · 2 posts · 3 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Chris Wilson:

    I found one bank that uses LIBOR as the index for the HELOC. No negotiation. It's just how the product is configured.

    The LIBOR historically has been lower than prime rate but the bank adds a spread to come up with your interest rate. i.e. LIBOR 0.5 + Spread 3.5= interest rate 4.0. The idea is that the variable interest rate will remain lower than if it was based on prime rate.

    We chose this product because it had a lower cap for the max interest rate and a longer draw period than other HELOCS we found.

    @Chris Wilson could you please share which bank you used for the HELOC product?

  • Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2015 · 99 posts · 35 votes
    9y

    If you have used HELOC in first lien position please update the thread or message me, seems most banks are not interested to give you this loan product even if you have the equity. 

  • Beebe, AR · Member since 2017 · 5 posts · 2 votes
    9y

    I have found other websites that are also advocating the HELOC in the first lien position it's a way to pay down your mortgage in a much faster time and have the opportunity to invest in other real estate at the same time. I won't mention their names on here because I'm still trying to research them for legitimacy. I haven't found anything else other than this post that says this is possible and I too am very interested in this as I could pay off my mortgage in 3 to 5 years and invest at the same time. If anybody knows of any other Banks or credit unions that are doing this I would love to know their names to get more information. When I have asked Wells Fargo, my local credit union and my wife's bank nobody seemed to know what I was talking about.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    @Brian J Cook, I have difficulty with your "at the same time" comment. I would think you're either disciplined enough to put every dollar of income into your HELOC (and NOT re-use it until it's paid off), OR you can use use your faster-gained equity to re-invest the paid off portion of the HELOC? ie. Not BOTH simultaneously.

    What magic beans are they trying to sell? [ie. If you're that discipled, you don't need to pay for their "product" anyway].

  • Investor · Chaska, MN · Member since 2014 · 2 posts · 3 votes
    9y

    @Brian j Cook i have found a broker who is offering  thus program.. message me if you like. 

  • Beebe, AR · Member since 2017 · 5 posts · 2 votes
    9y

    @Brent Coombs  -

    "and invest at the same time"

    I missed that in proofreading.  Thanks

  • Santa Clara, CA · Member since 2013 · 5 posts · 1 vote
    9y

    All,

    Looking for a good HELOC product for primary residence property in CA.

    So far, I have zeroed in on TowerFCU. Ideally would like a lender who's linked to T-Bill or LIBOR. There is one T-Bill lender (SoundViewFCU), but for properties only in Washington. I haven't been able to find a LIBOR lender. 

    @Shashank Dhadphale, could you please share?

    @Lorna Kaaloa, who is your lender?

    TowerFCU: Prime - 0.5%, upto 312K.

  • Nampa, ID · Member since 2017 · 1 post · 1 vote
    9y

    @Leslie Hsiung   you might listen to and watch the https://replaceyourmortgage.com/   I think it will give you all the answers you need to know and it also has calculators to put in the info you are talking about in your previous post.  

    Good luck 

  • Flipper · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2015 · 1 post · 0 votes
    9y

    @Chris Wilson, I am eager to find out about the bank you found that is tied to Libor for the HELOC...this is what I have been searching for!

  • Morrisonville, NY · Member since 2013 · 61 posts · 46 votes
    9y

    I've replaced my conventional mortgage with a first lien Home Equity Line Of Credit (not a home equity loan). Instead of extra mortgage payments, I only pay interest on the outstanding balance and I can make additional principal payments while still having instant access to the funds if needed. I don't know how many lenders would approve a HELOC on an investment property. You'd have to shop around.

  • Rincon, GA · Member since 2015 · 5 posts · 2 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Richard Patrie:

    I've replaced my conventional mortgage with a first lien Home Equity Line Of Credit (not a home equity loan). Instead of extra mortgage payments, I only pay interest on the outstanding balance and I can make additional principal payments while still having instant access to the funds if needed. I don't know how many lenders would approve a HELOC on an investment property. You'd have to shop around.

     @Richard Patrie are you able to share details about that heloc program you mentioned? Curious about what bank you used and if they only lend to locals.

  • Morrisonville, NY · Member since 2013 · 61 posts · 46 votes
    9y

    I went through Bank of America. The HELOC was on my primary residence.

  • Waipahu, HI · Member since 2017 · 1 post · 0 votes
    9y

    @Leslie Hsiung live in Honolulu and interested in getting a first lien Heloc. I was wondering what local you went to

  • Lender · Bellevue WA & Orange County, CA · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Roberto Westerband:

    What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?

    HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out. 

    • If you have a 1st lien HELOC, what happens to escrow for taxes and insurance, can it be waived and paid out of your own pocket or is it tied up into the monthly payment?
    • With regards to recourse vs. non-recourse loans, would putting the HELOC in 1st position allow a bank to come after personal assets in the event of a default?
    • Are there any banks/credit unions that charge LIBOR instead of Prime on HELOCs?

     HI Roberto,

    Yes there are banks that use different indexes but typically the ones that do are commercial LOC's or lines of credit. I've seen lines of credit on WSJ Prime, Prime, COFI index, Treasure maturity indexes, Libor, and many others.

    A popular 1st lien HELOC primary is a primary and secondary residence product (non investment properties) and it can go up to 75-80% LTV which doesnt sound too high, but the max loan amount is 2,000,000 vs typical HELOC (home equity lines of credit) that cap out at 350-500k. This product is called a "All in One," or AIO loan from CMG Financial. The advantage of this LOC is that it offers an integrated checking account/routing acct # so you can treat the loan as a "checking account," and it auto sweeps or calculates interest daily and closes out your position so that means any funds credited to your account can lower your daily interest cost.

    I have one that is fixed for 5 years interest only but its a commercial LOC that I use for acquisitions and it calculates simple interest which is nice when you want to make early payments or if you'd like to do those pay check parking strategies or rapid debt free strategies.

    Most lines of credit do not have escrowed tax and insurance so this means you will have to pay it on your own.

    When I do LOC's on rental's I just have the PM (property management) take over the responsibility of escrowing the property taxes and insurance so I dont have to remember when to pay them.

    Typically LOC's are full recourse but at a low enough LTV Im sure you can negotiate a non recourse LOC but that'd probably be in the commercial realm at a bank small enough where they'd be willing to negotiate, probably.

  • Real Estate Agent · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 450 posts · 196 votes
    9y

    @Leslie Hsiung

    Generally Oahu appreciates about 5% a year.  Of course, there's no guarantee on what will happen in the next couple of years, but demand continues to outstrip supply.  

    If you like, I can generate a CMA for you, since I'm also an agent on Oahu. Just shoot me an email or text!

  • Developer · New York, NY · Member since 2016 · 50 posts · 7 votes
    9y

    @Albert Bui 

    Do you by any chance invest in properties in the north east? Interested to know how much you pay property management companies for covering escrow services etc. Also, are AIO loans typically only available for non-investment properties? 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.