HERE IS WHY THE BRRR METHOD IS NOT WORKING FOR ME

HERE IS WHY THE BRRR METHOD IS NOT WORKING FOR ME

Investor · Merritt Island, FL · Member since 2015 · 16 posts · 4 votes

HELLO ALL,

I know I am not a vocal member on BP Community. However, I havnt missed a Podcast. I jumped into my first rental 3 years ago. Im up to 4 now. I cant tell you how many times Ive heard Brandon say he uses the " BRRRR" method, I know I added another R. Here is why this method is not working for me. It doesn't account for closing cost, time, and rehab fees. Not to mention to get a loan you can only get 75% of ARV.

So lets first address time. It takes at least 6mos for your property to " season" so you can get a refinanced loan on it, for my first 2 it  took a year. This is an extremely slow process. Im not complaining but at this rate, Im not going to reach my number till im 85. Hearty laugh.

For my first property, I took a HELOC loan on my primary residence. Now after 4 properties heres where im at. The first I purchased cash $47k I cash out refied at 75% of ARV of 56k, giving me $42k. Loss of 5k. Im ok with that because its cash flowing $1000 a month, minus mortgage and ins 600. So -5k. Second property I bought for 70k then 23k in repairs. It cash flows $1150 but is work 120k now. However when I Refi I got 75% of 80k or 56,000. So -14k, add in repairs $-27k. The last 2 properties have not been seasoned yet and I bought cash with the remainder of the HELOC $67k and 70k respectively.

Now I have a maxed out HELOC, 2 properties with 30yr mortgages and 2 under the HELOC. I have 6 mos seasoning on one that I cant yet get a loan on. The other will not be seasoned for 5 months.

So you can see how this can easily add up.

My agenda of this post is to not point a finger or even complain but to make BP newbies like myself aware. Hey, there are costs to loans, you can only get 75% back out, and this takes time...

Fortunately, Im a medical professional. I have some disposable income, but Im having a hard time seeing a light to the end of the tunnel.

2Reply
358 views

Most Popular Reply

Roy N.Pro Member
Rental Property Investor · Fredericton, New Brunswick · Member since 2013 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
9y

@David Hendry

The amount you are able to pull out of your property when refinancing is going to vary by location and lender.  Here we can pull out anywhere from 70 - 80% depending on the lender.  We also do not have the seasoning restrictions often read about in the U.S.A.

The forced appreciation play - buy, renovated, refinance - was around long before Brandon and BP started saying BRRR.

The "Buy" step should entail your entire cost of acquisition and not just the agreed price of the property itself.  Inspection costs, realtor fees, Closing costs, etc. are all under this umbrella.

The "renovate" step is where you include your holding costs and, naturally, the cost of the retrofit/renovation itself.

The "refinance" step is where you place a mortgage in exchange for a note.  There may/will be appraisal, registration, legal fees associated with this activity as well.

I'm not seeing the problem with the approach - w/ or w/o the slick acronym - but you might want to tighten up on your numbers and incorporate all of the periphery costs in your deal analysis.

See this reply in the discussion

31 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Atlanta, GA · Member since 2017 · 54 posts · 30 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Ryan Murdock:

    @David Hendry

    on BRRRR strategy : "It doesn't account for closing cost, time, and rehab fees."

    It does. You didn't.

    Ha, nice. Here's why the BRRR is hard for people like me. No W2 income. If you don't have that then good luck.

  • Investor · Champaign-Urbana, IL · Member since 2014 · 84 posts · 49 votes
    9y

    The key for the BRRRR method to work is the purchase price. If the purchase price is too high you won't be able to refinance enough to get your initial investment back.

    That note aside, I think the fact you've already successfully purchased 4 rental properties speaks highly of you and gives an indication of your goals. With this in mind, I would suggest reaching out to private money lenders or hard money lenders. Now that you have a history of conducting these sorts of deals it may be easier for you to convince lenders to do business with you. That way you can purchase more properties each year without having to put your own cash into the purchase. Of course, if you do this you will have to crush the numbers even more to account for the added costs of PVL and/or HML, but with a good enough deal you can still hit that 2% goal.

    I'm just a rookie trying to learn, but that's my advice.

  • Investor · Merritt Island, FL · Member since 2015 · 16 posts · 4 votes
    9y

    Well said Fabio. Thank you.

  • Madison, OH · Member since 2017 · 4 posts · 1 vote
    9y

    I'm running into the same problem. I'm taking action on getting my second rental property and using a HELOC to do so. But paying $250/mo on $40,000 at 7+% is wiping out all of my prospects.

    I'm in a great market and houses are easily affordable at $30k with rehabs requiring 15-20k. Thus making my $300 net monthly income to be $50 until refinance is available 6-12 months later. How do I calculate 6 months + ($1500) into the calculate the HELOC interest only payments in order to make the numbers work?

  • Member since 2022 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    1y

    I've only got one unit but it is a duplex I've owned it almost 3 years and I'm having a hard time getting it refinanced to pull some of the money I put into it out I'm in Michigan so I'm starting to think that Burr does not work in this state

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    1y

    @Jarret Moore We do BRRR all the time in Metro Detroit, including the City of Detroit!

    Also, everyone forgets that you "make your money" when you buy.

    This implies that you don't really have much control over renovation costs or what happens with the market that affects your After Repaired Value (ARV).

    So, if you make critical errors on your assumptions when you buy, you cannot recover from them - except to hold the property until time covers your mistake.

    DM us if you'd like a more indepth review of your situation!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.