Why are 203k interest rates higher than FHA interest rates?

Why are 203k interest rates higher than FHA interest rates?

Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote

In the process of applying for FHA loans and came across the 203k product. (House needs some rehab that I'd like to roll into my mortgage instead of being out of pocket). I was quoted an interest rate for the FHA loan of 3.25% and an interest rate for the 203k loan of 4.75%. Big difference for what I think is essentially the same product.

Is this usual? Does the higher interest rate for a 203k take into account the risk associated with lending for renovations? 

Thanks a bunch! 

0Reply
53 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris MasonPro Member
Moderator
Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
7y
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

@Chris Mason  what say you chris 

203ks are the most expensive to originate, and highest risk, of all the Agency (fannie/freddie/fha/va/usda) loan products out there. That's why something like 85% of lenders are perfectly happy NOT to offer it at all. Those that do need to offset that risk and those costs. Higher default rates than anything else... the most common FHA 203k thread on here is threads exactly like this one, 2nd most common FHA 203k threads on here consist of "omg my GC bailed on me or went way over budget, now I can't finish out my 203k renovation!" -- and you know within 3 months they will stop making their monthly mortgage payments, though no one typically makes a thread at that point. They are also a time suck for the LO.

Quickest way to get me off the phone: "Hi, I'm a first time homebuyer with no sales experience, no project management experience, no construction experience, or anything remotely similar, I also don't have any established relationships with any general contractors who I have actually done business with in the past, and I'm rate/fee shopping a FHA 203k for a house I am buying, oh and my Realtor says it needs to close in 21-30 days to be competitive, oh and I want a triplex or fourplex." -- I will & do work with some subset of the above, but when it's ALL of that... at some point you gotta triage: do I help 10 other first-time homebuyers get into homes, or do I focus that same amount of time and attention on just this one single homebuyer? 

See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Topeka, KS · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y

    Exactly.  It's higher because it is riskier.

  • Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    @Jacob Sampson thanks for the response!

  • Bonney Lake, WA · Member since 2019 · 12 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    Thanks for posting this question.  This is a good nugget of information and didn't realize 203k would be higher %.

    Does anyone know, can you still do a rehab (that may not be the proper terminology) with a FHA?

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    7y

    Last tome I looked, a few years ago, the 203k was typically .5% higher than the regular 203b.

  • Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    I’m shopping around with other lenders for rates on a 203k. I have great credit so I’m guessing I’d get the best rate available. I’ll report back. 

    Is it wrong that I’m not too worried about the higher interest rate? Worst case scenario is if I do have to pay 1.25% more for a 203k loan, I will only have to bear that higher interest rate until I have enough equity and can refinance - which should be after renovations are complete - and assuming the market stays the same - and I will have a lower rate (minus MI) then. 

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y

    @Chris Mason  what say you chris 

  • Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    @Justin NA there are two types of FHA "Reno" loans under 203k.. standard and streamline. Streamline you can only borrow up to $35,000. Standard you can borrow up to what the home value is post-renovation, but you must work with a 203k consultant who charges fees depending on the amount of the loan. Under both 203k types of loans, you have to pay 3.5% down on the total loan (not just the home value at purchase), so if you're like me and are banking on that low 3.5% down payment, your renovation costs drive that up. I just started with this process and have a lot to learn!

  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 304 posts · 462 votes
    7y

    It is not just extra risk. There are also additional administrative costs. The funds for improvements are placed in an escrow account and paid out as the various subcontractors complete their work. The entire improvement project has to be completed in 6 months. 

  • Bonney Lake, WA · Member since 2019 · 12 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    @Amanda Thomas - This makes sense.  In talking with my agent, she said that the consultant would tell you what you HAVE to fix.  Which is what I gather you mean by rolling those repairs into the loan and increasing your % down.  Then if you wanted to put more into rehab in cash, that part is discretionary.  I'm curious if the consultant fee is a % of the loan or just a flat fee, like an appraiser.

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Chris Mason  what say you chris 

    203ks are the most expensive to originate, and highest risk, of all the Agency (fannie/freddie/fha/va/usda) loan products out there. That's why something like 85% of lenders are perfectly happy NOT to offer it at all. Those that do need to offset that risk and those costs. Higher default rates than anything else... the most common FHA 203k thread on here is threads exactly like this one, 2nd most common FHA 203k threads on here consist of "omg my GC bailed on me or went way over budget, now I can't finish out my 203k renovation!" -- and you know within 3 months they will stop making their monthly mortgage payments, though no one typically makes a thread at that point. They are also a time suck for the LO.

    Quickest way to get me off the phone: "Hi, I'm a first time homebuyer with no sales experience, no project management experience, no construction experience, or anything remotely similar, I also don't have any established relationships with any general contractors who I have actually done business with in the past, and I'm rate/fee shopping a FHA 203k for a house I am buying, oh and my Realtor says it needs to close in 21-30 days to be competitive, oh and I want a triplex or fourplex." -- I will & do work with some subset of the above, but when it's ALL of that... at some point you gotta triage: do I help 10 other first-time homebuyers get into homes, or do I focus that same amount of time and attention on just this one single homebuyer? 

  • Norristown, PA · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 16 votes
    7y

    @Amanda Thomas Those rates actually look really good for standard FHA and 203k rates. A few months ago FHA was 4.5% and 203k was in the 5.7% range for me. Rates have dropped really low the last month or so. You are also correct that the higher rate shouldn't bother you if the numbers work and knowing you may be able to refinance later. By the time you can refinance though rates might rise again and you could be happy to stay with your 203k rate.

  • Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    Originally posted by @Justin NA:

    @Amanda Thomas - This makes sense.  In talking with my agent, she said that the consultant would tell you what you HAVE to fix.  Which is what I gather you mean by rolling those repairs into the loan and increasing your % down.  Then if you wanted to put more into rehab in cash, that part is discretionary.  I'm curious if the consultant fee is a % of the loan or just a flat fee, like an appraiser.

    Thats right about the renovations; I should have clarified. The 203k is basically used to fund the mandatory requirements of an FHA loan (electrical, heating, no peeling paint, etc). But, if you go that route, you also have the option to fund other discretionary improvements (say, replacing a roof or flooring) under a 203k. You'd have to put 3.5% down on the total amount borrowed - house plus renovation costs. But, the FHA caps the amount you are allowed to borrow based on the projected house appraisal after renovations are complete. If you have all cash to do the renovations, then 203k might not be the best route because the closing process takes longer and it seems like there are a lot of unknowns regarding cost estimates, contractors, etc. I'm totally new to the game, so please take my opinion with a grain of salt. You should read up on them a bit more to see whether it suits your situation.

    As for what the consultant fee is based on, I believe it is a percentage of the work to be performed, but may include "one off" fees like inspections. If there are any FHA consultants on here I'd love to hear your insight.

  • Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    7y
    Originally posted by @Charles Baldi:

    @Amanda Thomas Those rates actually look really good for standard FHA and 203k rates. A few months ago FHA was 4.5% and 203k was in the 5.7% range for me. Rates have dropped really low the last month or so. You are also correct that the higher rate shouldn't bother you if the numbers work and knowing you may be able to refinance later. By the time you can refinance though rates might rise again and you could be happy to stay with your 203k rate.

     Thanks for the insight! Have you gone through the 203k process? 

  • Member since 2019 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    7y
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Chris Mason  what say you chris 

    203ks are the most expensive to originate, and highest risk, of all the Agency (fannie/freddie/fha/va/usda) loan products out there. That's why something like 85% of lenders are perfectly happy NOT to offer it at all. Those that do need to offset that risk and those costs. Higher default rates than anything else... the most common FHA 203k thread on here is threads exactly like this one, 2nd most common FHA 203k threads on here consist of "omg my GC bailed on me or went way over budget, now I can't finish out my 203k renovation!" -- and you know within 3 months they will stop making their monthly mortgage payments, though no one typically makes a thread at that point. They are also a time suck for the LO.

    Quickest way to get me off the phone: "Hi, I'm a first time homebuyer with no sales experience, no project management experience, no construction experience, or anything remotely similar, I also don't have any established relationships with any general contractors who I have actually done business with in the past, and I'm rate/fee shopping a FHA 203k for a house I am buying, oh and my Realtor says it needs to close in 21-30 days to be competitive, oh and I want a triplex or fourplex." -- I will & do work with some subset of the above, but when it's ALL of that... at some point you gotta triage: do I help 10 other first-time homebuyers get into homes, or do I focus that same amount of time and attention on just this one single homebuyer? 

    Chris- definitely agree with you that people get in over their heads without doing enough research on what type of mortgage they can handle or the red tape they need to be prepared for. This is especially applicable in the 203k situation for individuals who have no experience with bureaucracy. I think the easy draw to 203k's are that people see that they can borrow money for renovations without having to wait years to save up, or by taking out a conventional renovation loan. I'm sure it is a headache for many lenders to go through these types of loans as opposed to a conventional or FHA loan. While I haven't ever gone through the process of a 203k, it piqued my interest because as a first time home-buyer, I can get a fixer-upper and build equity in a nice part of town and still have cash reserves. While my original question pertained to interest rates (which in hindsight I probably could have googled to find the answer instead of shooting it off on BP), I'm interested in hearing your opinion about what type of borrower would best benefit from a 203k loan. Thanks!

  • Norristown, PA · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 16 votes
    7y

    @Amanda Thomas I actually made both FHA and 203k offers and I had a normal FHA accepted first so I have not gone through the 203k process personally. I followed a guy in Instagram though @the203kway who has a ton of good information on it.

  • Investor · Washington, DC · Member since 2016 · 175 posts · 73 votes
    7y

    @Amanda Thomas

    After the renovation, refinance to standard FHA loan.

  • Real Estate Agent · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2011 · 1k+ posts · 543 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Amanda Thomas:

    In the process of applying for FHA loans and came across the 203k product. (House needs some rehab that I'd like to roll into my mortgage instead of being out of pocket). I was quoted an interest rate for the FHA loan of 3.25% and an interest rate for the 203k loan of 4.75%. Big difference for what I think is essentially the same product.

    Is this usual? Does the higher interest rate for a 203k take into account the risk associated with lending for renovations? 

    Thanks a bunch! 

    FHA 203k loans have higher % because they are riskier for the lender, they require more work for the lender, they require more personnel for the lender to administer the process, and there is a cost trade off with being allowed to include rehab costs into the loan compared to paying for the rehab in other ways.

  • Real Estate Agent · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2011 · 1k+ posts · 543 votes
    7y

    Amanda Thomas

    replied about 20 hours ago

    @Justin No there are two types of FHA "Reno" loans under 203k.. standard and streamline. Streamline you can only borrow up to $35,000. Standard you can borrow up to what the home value is post-renovation, but you must work with a 203k consultant who charges fees depending on the amount of the loan. Under both 203k types of loans, you have to pay 3.5% down on the total loan (not just the home value at purchase), so if you're like me and are banking on that low 3.5% down payment, your renovation costs drive that up. I just started with this process and have a lot to learn!

    The Streamline 203k no longer exists. HUD replaced it with the Limited 203k in September 2015. Now the 2 types of FHA 203k loans are the Limited 203k and the Standard 203k.

    The Limited 203k is maxed out at $35k but that amount includes the contractor pricing, Contingency Reserve (not required but recommended), lender fees, inspection fees, title update fees, etc. So, the actual contractor pricing should stop at $30k max. 

  • Chris MasonPro Member
    Moderator
    Lender · CA · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Amanda Thomas:
    Originally posted by @Chris Mason:
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:

    @Chris Mason  what say you chris 

    203ks are the most expensive to originate, and highest risk, of all the Agency (fannie/freddie/fha/va/usda) loan products out there. That's why something like 85% of lenders are perfectly happy NOT to offer it at all. Those that do need to offset that risk and those costs. Higher default rates than anything else... the most common FHA 203k thread on here is threads exactly like this one, 2nd most common FHA 203k threads on here consist of "omg my GC bailed on me or went way over budget, now I can't finish out my 203k renovation!" -- and you know within 3 months they will stop making their monthly mortgage payments, though no one typically makes a thread at that point. They are also a time suck for the LO.

    Quickest way to get me off the phone: "Hi, I'm a first time homebuyer with no sales experience, no project management experience, no construction experience, or anything remotely similar, I also don't have any established relationships with any general contractors who I have actually done business with in the past, and I'm rate/fee shopping a FHA 203k for a house I am buying, oh and my Realtor says it needs to close in 21-30 days to be competitive, oh and I want a triplex or fourplex." -- I will & do work with some subset of the above, but when it's ALL of that... at some point you gotta triage: do I help 10 other first-time homebuyers get into homes, or do I focus that same amount of time and attention on just this one single homebuyer? 

    Chris- definitely agree with you that people get in over their heads without doing enough research on what type of mortgage they can handle or the red tape they need to be prepared for. This is especially applicable in the 203k situation for individuals who have no experience with bureaucracy. I think the easy draw to 203k's are that people see that they can borrow money for renovations without having to wait years to save up, or by taking out a conventional renovation loan. I'm sure it is a headache for many lenders to go through these types of loans as opposed to a conventional or FHA loan. While I haven't ever gone through the process of a 203k, it piqued my interest because as a first time home-buyer, I can get a fixer-upper and build equity in a nice part of town and still have cash reserves. While my original question pertained to interest rates (which in hindsight I probably could have googled to find the answer instead of shooting it off on BP), I'm interested in hearing your opinion about what type of borrower would best benefit from a 203k loan. Thanks!



    Basically, the expectation that a purely retail FTHB "American Consumer" is going to just find something on the MLS at full retail market price, find a GC and pay the full retail market price for their services, full retail price for all materials, and all that, is completely out of whack. In my market at least, you have to be working some angle, or the ARV is going to be a lot ton less than the proposed total loan amount (price+reno), and the loan will be denied.

    Sales or marketing experience: to get the sales price down. Off market = you found the deal yourself.

    Project management experience: to keep the reno costs down. Can look at a big list of things, and quickly identify where the "action is."

    Reno/GC experience: to keep the reno costs down. You haveestablished relationships with GCs and will not be paying full retail prices, or you are a GC.

    Other stuff I haven't thought of: what do you bring to the table that the other 200 people finding that 203ks even exist on Google don't bring to the table? 

  • Patrick HawkinsPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Baltimore Metro Area · Member since 2019 · 1 post · 0 votes
    7y

    @Amanda Thomas

    If the 203k program is not working out for you try a private bank. Sometimes they have rehab loan packages with low rates and you do not need a consultant.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.