Transfer real property from s-corp

Transfer real property from s-corp

Member since 2020 · 27 posts · 2 votes

I have a piece of real estate owned by an s-corp (of which I am the sole shareholder).

It has appreciated substantially in the decades that I've owned it.

I would like to transfer it to an LLC (of which I would be the sole member).

But, I want to make sure I don't trigger the recognition of a capital gain.

How can I do that?

Thank you!

1Reply
475 views

Most Popular Reply

Accountant · NH · Member since 2019 · 269 posts · 288 votes
2y

The answer...you can't.  

Removing any appreciated property from an S-Corporation triggers a deemed gain on those assets by the S-Corporation (hence also by you) - it's as though you sold it at fair market value, so you get the joy of paying the taxes on the appreciation while receiving no cash.  The other joy you can have is that if you have a very low basis in your S-Corporation given it was previously a C-Corp for decades, you could end up up with a distribution in excess of your stock basis, thus triggering a gain there as well.  The icing on top of these joys - to the extent the property is depreciable in the hands of the recipient - it is an ORDINARY gain, and not a capital gain.  Even better...you can't take bonus depreciation on your newly acquired asset to help offset gain since it was acquired from a related party.

There is a way to effectively transfer out the future appreciation, but your historical appreciation is stuck in the Corporation - you can't get that out without triggering that gain.  Still depending on your estate planning, going through these jumps to save your historical appreciation (thus also a step up in the real estate upon death) could be worth it.

See this reply in the discussion

28 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Accountant · San Diego, CA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 552 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Joseph Skoler:
    Wow!  This is fascinating stuff, but I'm having a very hard time understanding.  I (obvious) don't have a background in accounting or taxes.

    The history of my coming to be the sole shareholder of this s-corp is complex, long and, I have no doubt, filled with tax-planning blunders.

    In case anyone is still interested, and inclined the help, here it is in as abbreviated form as possible:

    1967:  5 families bought this property as a summer vacation for them to use collectively
    1980:  1 of the families sold their share (20% of the property and what is effectively a lifelong lease to one of the 5 cottages).  I was a kid at the time.
    1983:  1 of the cottages got hit by lighting and burned down.  A "reorganization took place, one of the families left the group in exchange for the insurance proceeds and the property then had 4 owners (and 4 cottages)
    2000:  I bought ($42,000) my parent's share.
    2000-2010:  I bought the other shareholder's shares (total $300,000), leaving just me as the sole shareholder
    2017:  Elected to file as S corp.

    None of these transactions were properly recorded.

    2022 1120S tax return (2023 is on extension) shows:

    $0 income
    $15,000 Land (sched L, line 12)
    $122k Loans from me

    ($189K) Retained earning

    $93K cap stock

    ($46k) Sched m-2


    I have no idea how we got to these amounts.

    Does any of this make things easier to understand and easier to get me out of this capital gains problem (or does it just muddy things even more)?

    Thank you.

     Just more confusing for me :P 

  • Accountant · NH · Member since 2019 · 269 posts · 288 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Andrew Abeyta:
    Quote from @Kory Reynolds:
    Quote from @Andrew Abeyta:
    Quote from @Kory Reynolds:
    Quote from @Joseph Skoler:
    Quote from @Kory Reynolds:

    I agree fully with Andrew.

    You are confusing the legal laws under which an organization is structured, which is nearly always dictated by a given state, with the federal tax structure that the entity is operating under, which is dictated under the Feds.

    For income tax purposes an LLC is most often either a disregarded entity (wholly owned), or a Partnership (multiple owners).  That said, an LLC could elect to be treated for US Tax purposes as an S-Corporation or a Corporation.  An LLC is not a federal tax structure, it is a State derived structure to limit liability.

    It is not the change of being an "Inc" to an "LLC" that is triggering the deemed gain that we are warning you of. It is the change in tax structure from an S-Corporation to a disregarded entity (what an LLC wholly owned by you would be for tax purposes). It is the removal of the assets within the Corporate Tax Structure to a Non Corporate Tax Structure.

    The article you cited is entirely about changing the state legal structure, the article does not discuss any of the ramifications of also changing the federal tax structure.


    It's all starting to make sense now -- thank you.

    You identified my confusion.

    So, while my (reasonable) goal is to move the ownership of the property from the corporation to a pass-through entity, it is exactly that process that triggers to the capital gains liability, right?

    And, there is no legal way around that?  Even thought the s-corp is in many ways just me, and a new LLC would in many ways be just me?


    Exactly it - it is that process of moving the property from a corporation to a pass through entity that will trigger that gain, and it is NOT the conversion of that entity for state law purposes to an LLC that triggers the gain.

    While you might think of this wholly owned S-Corp as "just you", for tax purposes it is entirely separate from you.   

    As you surmise, there is no way to avoid the deemed gain on transferring it out of the Federal corporate structure, into a pass through structure.

    There are potential ways to to transfer out the future appreciation while leaving the bulk of the 'old' appreciation in the S-Corp, but no way to get that 'old' appreciation out of the corp without triggering a gain.

    Last item to reiterate - this gain is at the S-level, so it’ll give rise to S/H basis (while simultaneously reducing basis via the distribution). If there’s no tax basis remaining in the property, which I presume is the case given it’s 50 years old, this would be a complete wash for basis purposes.

    That said, if you have stock basis and this is the sole asset of the S-Corp, consider (1) dissolving the S-Corp in the same year and (2) pursuing a cost seg on the property once it’s in your new LLC.

    An important note is that the value of the distribution to you is the basis you’ll receive in the property. If the FMV at the date of distribution is $1M, that will be the tax basis to you (assuming FMV exceeds Net tax basis).

    The depreciation you’ll receive from said cost seg may mitigate the gain, especially if the majority of gain is 1231. This may inherently allow an allowable offset of PAL, when ordinarily the cost seg depreciation would be subject to some possible suspensions.

    Three things to be HIGHLY aware of if one pursues this route.

    One - he did note he has $0 of tax basis in the S-Corp.  Assuming the building has land basis, there would be a gain on distribution in excess of basis.  IE $1m real estate value,, $100k of land basis - $900k gain.  $900k gain increases $0 of S-Corp stock basis to $900k.  Then distributes $1m of proceeds - recognizes $1m gain on distribution in excess of basis.

    Second - IRC 1239.  When property is distributed from an S-Corporation, and is depreciable in the hands of the acquirer, that gain is (very likely) going to be ORDINARY - ouch!  No 1231 treatment.

    Third, with the cost seg study, you only get bonus depreciation if you didn't previously have an interest in the property.  I've only dealt with this directly for partnerships, but it doesn't seem like a far leap that this also would apply to distributions from an S-Corp.  If my initial guess is right (someone else feel free to research), no bonus depreciation would be allowed.  In my example of a $1m building, the taxpayer recognizes $1m of gain, much of that ordinary, and then maybe gets a $100k depreciation adjustment on the outside....so they are getting nailed with $900k of mostly ordinary income.

    Great stuff!
    Gain would be $100K on excess of basis. He would take the $1M distribution and would have a $900K gain on the corp side on the distribution of appreciating property. Thus excess basis (land value would be the gain), are are you saying he gets no basis on the gain? A little fuzzy on that point.

    I’ve never seen 1245 recap on real estate before, ordinarily (no pun intended) this would be 1250 unrecap and *only on the historical depreciation taken*.

    If he bought it for $300K, took $200K depreciation down to the bone and the rest is land, that $900K gain would be $200K unrecap 1250 and the other $700K would be … 1231! It’s essentially a “deemed sale”.

    Fair point on the cost seg! I specifically excluded *bonus* from that prior post for that very reason of ineligibility, however, if the cost seg carves out 20% of the basis as 5-year, 20% as 7-yr, 20% as 15-year and the remainder as 39 year (assuming commercial), that’d still front one heck of a depreciation deduction using MACRS 200% DDB.

    Will still be some net gain, but that would dramatically dramatically reduce the cash he’d have to fork out to uncle sam… PLUS … he’d have new depreciation again! Joy at last. Right now i’m sure this rental is a taxable income cow, as it’s fully depreciated.

     Exactly on the first point - in total the shareholder recognizes $1m of gain after selling the property for $1m in my example - $900k from the property deemed sale, and another $100k from distributions in excess of basis.

    I didn't discuss 1245 - I discussed 1239, very different.  You can either go read 1239, or check out the plain english description of this exact issue in the article below under the last heading.  If the property is depreciable in the hands of the related acquirer, the gain on the deemed disposition between the related parties is ordinary.   It overrides the 1231 treatment you are arriving at.  If the property is not depreciable (IE the allocation of the purchase price to land), then it can escape ordinary treatment, but it also isn't depreciable.

    https://www.thetaxadviser.com/issues/2011/apr/casestudy-apr2...

    If you find  a cost seg provider that legitimately carves out 60% of the purchase price of a building to short life property, let me know who it is  My experience is more like 20-30% on average of the building basis from an architect based study unless it is something like a Hotel/Motel or Mobile Home / RV Park.

  • Member since 2020 · 27 posts · 2 votes
    2y

    Just wanted to thank everyone again for the help.

    I can't say I fully understand all the issues raised, but it sounds like the bottom line is that there is no way to move the asset out of the s-corp without triggering a capital gain liability.

    Interestingly, the thinking required by me to address your comments made me realize that I am not depreciating this asset.  So I'm off on another intellectual trek to figure out if and how I should do that.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.