Selling a rental: how early do you start planning?
One of my tax advisory clients recently called after selling a rental property. Things moved pretty quickly, and now she's wondering what options she still has to defer the capital gain.
It got me thinking about how often tax planning comes into the picture after the big decisions have already been made.
I'm curious, how far ahead do you typically start thinking about the tax implications of selling a rental? A few months? A year? Or only once you've decided to sell?
A few things that are much easier to address ahead:
Knowing your actual tax exposure. The gain isn't simply the sales price minus what you paid. Depreciation, improvements, and adjusted basis all matter, and part of the gain may be taxed at up to 25%.
Considering a 1031 exchange. The 45-day identification deadline and generally 180-day completion window leave little room for figuring things out after closing.
Timing the sale. Closing in December versus January can make a meaningful difference in your tax planning.
Looking at the cash side. How much equity will you actually walk away with after the mortgage payoff, selling costs, and taxes? And what's the plan for that money?
Of course, not every sale needs to be a 1031 exchange. Sometimes it makes more sense to pay the tax, free up the equity, and move on to something else.
Curious how others approach this. If you have sold a rental before, how early did you start thinking about the taxes? Anything you would do differently next time?