Recommendation for Self-Directed IRA administrator / custodian?

Recommendation for Self-Directed IRA administrator / custodian?

Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 107 posts · 27 votes

I'm helping my Dad set up a self-directed IRA so he can do some real estate investing. He will want an administrator/custodian that is

1) Reputable

2) Responsive & helpful regarding organizational structure and allowable transactions.

3) Reasonable fees

I have searched the internet, and it looks like the Gold investment shops have spent more money on SEO than the real estate folks. (The "Top 10 Lists" look like shills for gold firms.)

0Reply
65 views

Most Popular Reply

Michael PlaksPro Member
Tax Accountant / Enrolled Agent · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
8y

@Jefferson Smith - 

both people who responded, @Brian Eastman and @Carl Fischer provide the services you're looking for and have solid reputation. Add @Dmitriy Fomichenko, and you have my top 3.

See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brian EastmanPro Member
    Self Directed IRA & 401k Advisor · Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y

    @Jefferson Smith

    There are many quality self-directed IRA providers here on BP. And yes, there is a lot of paid top-10 garbage on the internet that has been put forth by various gold or cryptocurrency dealers. You can ignore that.

    The first question is to identify the right type of provider and plan format, as there are several.  The type of investments your father will be making are going to determine the best tool for the job.

    Self Directed IRA Custodians will typically have the word Trust in their name. These are financial institutions that I like to describe as "E*Trade with different paperwork". The administration and reporting on the account is the same, as dictated by law. Instead of being focused on the public exchanges as the investing platform, however, they have the paperwork and staff training to document non-traditional asset holdings such as real estate, private placements, mortgages, etc. As the custodian, they are a processor, and will hold funds, sign documents, issue payments and receive income at your direction. All of this, of course, takes paperwork, processing time, and some combination of per-transaction, per investment and account-value based fees. This type of service is best when the investments will be singular and static in nature, and when there is not a high need for legal guidance.

    Self Directed Plan Facilitators are a different type of service that establish plans providing checkbook control. There are two formats, either an IRA owned LLC called a "checkbook IRA" or a Solo 401(k) trust which is available to those who are self-employed and have no full time employees. In either of these formats, the plan provider is performing legal structuring to put you directly in control of the funds and operating out of a bank account of your choosing under the umbrella of the plan. You will have signing authority and the ability to directly make investments on behalf of the plan. In addition to the plan setup, most quality providers of such services will offer meaningful support to help you navigate the tax code as you make investments. For any kind of investing that will be time sensitive, involve multiple assets, or assets that generate a lot of transaction activity, these checkbook plans will be much more efficient and effective in terms of time, paperwork and expense.

    As I noted, there are several quality providers of both types of services here on BP. Do some reading in the forums and reach out to a handful by phone.  You will quickly determine what type of service will best suit your father's needs and who are the quality providers.  

  • Carl FischerPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Ambler, PA · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Jefferson Smith

    I recommend you take a look at this bigger pockets list of SDIRA custodians and administrators. You should narrow down to the top 3 and call each of them and ask about their processing time, fees and some questions specific to the deal you are interested in for your Fathers SDIRA. 

  • Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 107 posts · 27 votes
    8y

    Thanks @Carl Fischer. Yeah, I research BP before posting my question, and I have that list. "Narrowing to the top 3" is essentially my question. 

    Likewise @Brian Eastman. Definitely appreciate the general thoughts. Have read a bunch. I'm wondering if there are any reputable ratings/reviews of the places. 

  • Brian EastmanPro Member
    Self Directed IRA & 401k Advisor · Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y

    @Jefferson Smith

    Unfortunately, no, there is no reputable 3rd party independent review of self-directed IRA custodians. Anything you find is going to be either so high level as to be meaningless or paid content to promote a particular provider. It is too specialty of a service, without the necessary volume to demand the focus of an independent review site that would then rely on related ads for income. It is also as a service probably too complex for the average outside review party to be able to meaningfully rate.

    Actually speaking to a handful of providers is the best way to learn about what they can do and their level of expertise.  There is a pretty big variation both in terms of services provided and quality of support.

  • Michael PlaksPro Member
    Tax Accountant / Enrolled Agent · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    8y

    @Jefferson Smith - 

    both people who responded, @Brian Eastman and @Carl Fischer provide the services you're looking for and have solid reputation. Add @Dmitriy Fomichenko, and you have my top 3.

  • Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 107 posts · 27 votes
    8y
  • Solo 401k Expert · Anaheim Hills, CA · Member since 2012 · 18k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    8y

    @Michael Plaks thanks for the shout out!

  • Carl FischerPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Ambler, PA · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Michael Plaks

    Thanks for mentioning me

  • Rental Property Investor · Vista, CA · Member since 2017 · 51 posts · 28 votes
    8y

    Hi @Jefferson Smith, I came across this post as I have essentially the same question and was hoping to find some recommendations for a SD IRA custodian from people who have actually done business with them.

    I was in your position earlier this year and made a choice based on calling and speaking with a number of companies, as well as getting their rates. I found that what most offered in my area of need was pretty much the same across the board, but their rates varied quite significantly. I ended up going with what seemed to be one of the lower priced companies that is associated with one of the big real estate education companies, and came highly recommended by a large turnkey investment company that partners with them. We even met in person with the company's president and came to the conclusion that they seemed like a good choice.

    What I found from actually working with them is that what they tell you and how they actually perform can vary quite a bit. The company I'm working with has missed stated turnaround times, failed to communicate on important matters, and let things fall through the cracks too many times already that I am tired of babysitting them and am now looking for a new custodian. 

    Since the ultimate list of SDIRA custodians is so lengthy, and have proved that talking to them doesn't necessarily tell you how they will perform, I am still looking for recommendations from people who have actually done satisfactory business with the company.

    Let me know if you find a company that works out and I will keep you posted as well if I find someone!

  • Brian EastmanPro Member
    Self Directed IRA & 401k Advisor · Wenatchee, WA · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y

    @Elaine Hester

    What you describe, unfortunately, is not uncommon with self-directed IRA custodians - regardless of the fee structure. The business model requires people pushing paper to get anything done. If you have a timeline, or investments that require a high level of transactions over time, this can be problematic.

    I suggest you evaluate programs that provide you with direct control over the funds such as a checkbook IRA or Solo 401(k). These plans are not offered directly by IRA custodians, but rather by consulting/legal firms that will layer an entity on top of the retirement plan so as to put you in direct control of all investment transactions.

  • Investor · Jacksonville Beach, FL | NYC | Tamarindo Costa Rica · Member since 2014 · 182 posts · 130 votes
    8y

    We were unhappy with the 'trust' company we went with on a self directed IRA. Slow, mistakes, poor communication - good luck getting useful information from the first line of people answering the phone, and good luck getting escalated to an actual person. After 2 years of being frustrated, we ended up going the Solo 401(k) route, but that may not be an option for folks, in which case the checkbook IRA serves similar purpose - putting you in control of the paperwork and payments.

  • Investor/RE Broker · Eugene, OR · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 968 votes
    8y

    I have a similar experience as @Caroline C. and rolled over from SDIRA to a checkwriting Solo 401k.  If a Solo 401k is not an option for an investor (requires having a solo business with income), then the upfront setup costs for checkwriting SDIRA is actually more costly, and only makes sense for larger retirement accounts.

    For smaller accounts going with a SDIRA custodian might be the best (least expensive) option.  One of the biggest, Equity Trust is the one I had a poor experience with. From a crowdfunding company I invest with, I heard that Sunwest Trust is one of the easiest , no hassle custodians to work with, but I have no personal experience with them.  I believe they also have one of the better fee structures.  

  • Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 107 posts · 27 votes
    8y

    Plaudits for the valuable feedback...keep it coming! So many of the smart folks (I'm listening to like 5 REI podcasts regularly #addict) persuasively recommend an SDIRA over just relying on the Stocks & Bonds Industrial Complex. But evaluation of the firms seems almost blind.

    But there precious little information compares SDIRA firms. Mutual funds or other financial advisors of course offer previous returns info. That is inapplicable to an SDIRA firm, so we're left with customer satisfaction.  Feedback here feels useful to fill the market information gap a bit.

    Much gratitude for the previous comments, and for any further.

    Any other positive or negative experiences with SDIRA firms? 

  • Justin WindhamPro Member
    Banker · Nationwide · Member since 2015 · 4k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Jefferson Smith

    Have you already ruled out the Solo 401k based on your dad's ineligibility?

  • Retirement Accounts Attorney · Southfield, MI · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Jefferson Smith

    Take a look at IRA Services Trust Company. They have been in business since the 1970s, have a good reputation, have never had any IRS issues, have over 50,000 accounts and have fair fees.

  • Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 107 posts · 27 votes
    8y

    My Dad is retired. I don’t think solo 401k fits based his lack of self employment income. 

    So far, kind plugs for: 
    @Brian Eastman
    @Carl Fischer
    @Dmitriy Fomichenko

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.