Lifestyle inflation vs. reasonable standard of living increase?

Lifestyle inflation vs. reasonable standard of living increase?

Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes

I’ve been frugal my whole life. My family jokes that my older brother started borrowing money from me when I was six (he was 16) because I always had $ stacked. But now I’m reaching a point where I want to splurge a little.

For those who live frugally - at what point, if ever, did you start enjoying more of the fruits of your labor? Where is the line between lifestyle inflation and just growing up/evolving?

Background for the question: My husband and I live way below our means. We moved into one of our rentals and though we combined will make over $300k (w2 and rentals) in 2018, our current mortgage payment is <$800/mos. We are in an excellent location but are outgrowing our townhouse. It’s old and doesn’t have an attached garage. We can’t afford to buy a house in this area and it is inconvenient for our jobs and other rentals.

We recently found an amazing house that costs ~$450k...,it’s a 1 acre+ “estate” with a circle drive, private entry gate, the whole nine - it basically has everything we want in a dream house after a few cosmetic updates. the location is better for work commute and rentals, but the surrounding area is less posh and we cant walk to restaurants and bars like our current location. It’s more of an up and coming inner ring burb, tho still technically in the city. This same house would cost $2-4million in our current hood. What do you think?

The frugalista in me hates the idea of doubling our monthly expenses but doing the math we can afford this, even if we both got laid off. Curious to see if anyone else has wrestled with life upgrades and if there is a rule of thumb for making decisions like this?

3Reply
40 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
8y

Congratulations on the W-2 and real estate success and your savings rate.  You are asking an important question.

I recommend sitting down with your husband and writing down your goals.  And then, align your daily decisions with them.  If your location, or financial freedom, or the dream house, or anything else are at the top of the list, you have clarity on how to decide.  You also won't feel like you are sacrificing the other things because you know (1) what's most important to you in life and (2) what matters less.  There is no sacrifice in doing #1 and not #2...the sacrifice comes when you do the opposite.

We often talk about wanting more time with friends and family, or being more healthy, or more charitable, or having financial freedom, or whatever we say we want and then we make daily decisions that are completely disconnected from these goals.  Success in life comes from making daily decisions that align with what's most important to you.

See this reply in the discussion

21 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    8y

    I just bought a house that was 100% more expensive than the last primary residence I purchased. However the monthly payments are still considerably lower than what I can afford, and I am also largely financially independent at this point in life.

    I scrimped and saved til about age 37....now I spend pretty freely as even doing so I have much more coming in than going out.

  • Greg ScottPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · SE Michigan · Member since 2014 · 4k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    8y

    Life is meant to be lived.   While I believe wholeheartedly in being fiscally conservative, if you always are sacrificing for the future that never arrives, that isn't much of a life.  From time to time you need to splurge on yourself.

    The strategy my wife and I have employed is to give ourselves small rewards.   For example, if we got a $100/mo raise (after tax), we might increase our monthly expenses by $50.   With that sort of strategy you are rewarding yourself for increasing your income, while also increasing your savings for the future.

    Sounds like you are on a good path.  Keep it up!

  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y

    @Russell Brazil and @Greg Scott thanks for you input despite my epic run-on sentence (posted from my phone and all spaces were deleted somehow).  

    Lots of wisdom in what you both wrote.  Russell, it's reassuring to hear you've made a lifestyle upgrade/leap and are still financially independent.  That's great.  Greg, you're absolutely right that life is meant to be lived - good reminder.  

    It would suck to save for years and then drop dead before fully enjoying the hard work.

  • Lewisville, TX · Member since 2015 · 344 posts · 264 votes
    8y
    I’ve been completely priced & property taxed out of DFW plus I hate the traffic & drive an hour everywhere lifestyle & heat so I’m moving to Tulsa where I can buy multiple properties cash & everything actually cash flows well. Dallas is at 8 million & it can go to 20 million & Amazon/everyone else’s hq without me! I would say if you can still easily afford it & would enjoy the new place more then go for it!
  • Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    8y

    Congratulations on the W-2 and real estate success and your savings rate.  You are asking an important question.

    I recommend sitting down with your husband and writing down your goals.  And then, align your daily decisions with them.  If your location, or financial freedom, or the dream house, or anything else are at the top of the list, you have clarity on how to decide.  You also won't feel like you are sacrificing the other things because you know (1) what's most important to you in life and (2) what matters less.  There is no sacrifice in doing #1 and not #2...the sacrifice comes when you do the opposite.

    We often talk about wanting more time with friends and family, or being more healthy, or more charitable, or having financial freedom, or whatever we say we want and then we make daily decisions that are completely disconnected from these goals.  Success in life comes from making daily decisions that align with what's most important to you.

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    My wife and I began to spend more freely after we both retired and realised we were then in a position financially to be able to afford to do so. Old age is expensive and you need to insure your investments are more than sufficient to take you to the end. With that in mind once you reach that level of savings you should be able to spend more freely.

    When you have more savings than you will need to take you to the grave you are ready to live less frugally. Few people adequately save for old age.

  • Rental Property Investor · Brooke Park Drive · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y

    For me having kids marked when I went from Mr. Frugal to buying house w yard, 4k per month daycare, family vacations, etc etc.

    Currently considering move from 500k house to 1M, or instead being frugal at the 500k place and doing more REI.

    Anyways a 450k house with combined income of 300k is fine, go for it!

  • Mindy JensenPro Member
    BiggerPockets Money Podcast Host · Longmont, CO · Member since 2014 · 7k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    8y

    @Ericka G. , the problem I have with upsizing is that many people do it as soon as they get an extra dime in their pocket.  You sound like you have your financial head on straight. A larger house with a better commute to replace your current home isn't necessarily bad - and the finances you shared make it seem like an easy upgrade. 

    You didn't mention your other bills, like credit card debt, car payment, child care, etc so I'm assuming they are easily payable or nonexistent. 

    What I don't like is that you aren't in love with the area. I moved out of my dream home because it was located in my nightmare neighborhood. It isn't always about the house. Make sure you can live in the neighborhood, not just the home.

    Oh, and I fixed your weird spacing...

  • Rental Property Investor · Durham, NC · Member since 2016 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    8y
    Ericka Grant if you make over 300k I would say you can do up to around a 600k type house. At some point you want to enjoy the fruits of your labor and you’re probably at that point or nearing it. I plan to live frugally and cheapily for 12-15 years and then start upgrading parts of my life slowly (car house etc). I’m only 23 so I have about 11 years to go.
  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Thank you everyone for all of the candid responses. This is very helpful. Lots of good points to consider. Mindy Jensen Thank you for fixing the spacing and sharing your input about your own experience with a dream home in a nightmare area...something to consider. We do like the area it is just so different than anywhere we’ve lived in the past...The housing stock actually reminds me of the area we currently live in but less populated and less walkable. It’s hard to tell if we will miss the convenient chaos of the current area. Personally I’m over the traffic and snobby people in our current hood. I often walk to the grocery store because I can rarely find parking at our local Publix :(
  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Caleb Heimsoth your timeline sounds about right! Good luck with the journey
  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Michael P. Wow! Good for you for making the jump successfully - sounds like it is working out for you and your family. Are you able to save a similar amount as you’ve upgraded or do you feel you have ample reserves at this point and thus can spend a larger % of your income?
  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Thomas S. Good point about saving for old age...I guess I will up our insurance if we do end up upgrading houses
  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Mike Dymski you hit on something I’ve been wrestling with in 2018...we’ve accomplished most of the big goals on our vision board and have been trying to figure out what is next. Now that you mention it, the “dream” house is literally the last thing on our shared vision board that hasn’t been ticked off. So I guess after this it will be time to make a new vision board!
  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Matt Millard I hear you! We have similar issues with traffic and congestion in ATL. That’s a big part of the desire to move to another, less trafficky part of town. Good luck with the move to Tulsa!
  • Dallas, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 745 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Ericka G.:

    Thank you everyone for all of the candid responses. This is very helpful. Lots of good points to consider.

    Mindy Jensen Thank you for fixing the spacing and sharing your input about your own experience with a dream home in a nightmare area...something to consider. We do like the area it is just so different than anywhere we’ve lived in the past...The housing stock actually reminds me of the area we currently live in but less populated and less walkable. It’s hard to tell if we will miss the convenient chaos of the current area. Personally I’m over the traffic and snobby people in our current hood. I often walk to the grocery store because I can rarely find parking at our local Publix :(

    I think I am late to the party, but imo the question I think comes down to asking what does your dream look like?   Whats the goal?

    I agree with Mindy, if you dont like your current house and especially neighborhood, moving is probably a good idea.

    If you are making 200K, have no other debt, and are looking to buy a $450K house, I would say you are well with acceptable limits for a house.  I know some dont like him, but Dave Ramsey as an example says a house with a payment less than 25% of you income on a 15 year fixed (or less) note with 20% is acceptable. Dave Ramsey, talks about at least 15% of your income going to retirement as one of his baby steps.

    If you are worried about lifestyle inflation, pay off the house over the next couple of years.  or even pay cash for it.

    I think once you get to a fair amount of savings, identifying what your goals are in the future might help give you a better guide as to what you can spend in the meantime.

  • WorldWide · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    Having bought a house with land in a suburb that's less than 10 minutes away from downtown, I can never see myself moving somewhere without a proper yard anymore. I could care less about living an urban lifestyle and walking to a bar/cafe/etc. (though, I have one around a corner), but that's why everything is so subjective and personal. Do what makes you happy at the end of the day. 1.5x income-to-house is not a bad ratio, at all. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2016 · 294 posts · 104 votes
    8y

    I think it depends on your age and kids, and you account balance. I would say uder 40, under million, with no kids, stick with what you have and leverage in rentals. 

  • Investor · Akron, OH · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y

    I moved out to the burbs many years ago when my son was young and while it was great for kids I really missed being able to walk to grocery stores and restaurants and the library. We downsized and moved to a small walkable town when our kids went to college. I guess my advice is to make sure you consider what is really most important to you (but then if you still get it wrong it's probably still fixable so don't over worry)

  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 366 posts · 283 votes
    8y
    Quick update: we decided not to move into the bigger house in the burbs (it didn’t appraise and the seller wouldn’t come down) and are happily still living below our means. The Financial freedom that comes with living modestly is so sweet it will take a very special house to get us to move at this point. ALSO, similar townhome/same community as ours just sold for $30k MORE than what we had ours under contract for a month ago, so I feel like the low new house appraisal causing our deal to fall through was a blessing in disguise. We’ll see what the future holds.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.