Do you chose Granite or Formica?

Do you chose Granite or Formica?

Medford, MA · Member since 2016 · 205 posts · 47 votes

Hey Everyone,

I wanted to ask a very simple but problematic question for many investors. When investing in a rental property, do you chose Granite or Formica countertops?

0Reply
77 views

Most Popular Reply

Miami Lakes, FL · Member since 2015 · 133 posts · 83 votes
10y
It all depends on the market. I'd say in A and B class neighborhoods, go granite. Anything less, go Formica. No need to spend money on granite when your tenant pool will likely rather urinate in a corner of the living room rather than waste the energy to walk ALL the way to the toilet! (True story, BTW!)
See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Miami Lakes, FL · Member since 2015 · 133 posts · 83 votes
    10y
    It all depends on the market. I'd say in A and B class neighborhoods, go granite. Anything less, go Formica. No need to spend money on granite when your tenant pool will likely rather urinate in a corner of the living room rather than waste the energy to walk ALL the way to the toilet! (True story, BTW!)
  • Medford, MA · Member since 2016 · 205 posts · 47 votes
    10y

    Thanks for the advice! That is truly weird. What is your stance on the durability of the granite vs the formica. I know granite is more expensive, but do you think the longevity and the decreased maintaince is worth the extra upfront cost?

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    10y

    Cheaper granites are the same price as laminate in the DC area, so I always go granite.

  • Cumming, GA · Member since 2014 · 218 posts · 71 votes
    10y
     @Jared Smith:

    Hey Everyone,

    I wanted to ask a very simple but problematic question for many investors. When investing in a rental property, do you chose Granite or Formica countertops?

     @Jared Smith,

    depends of the rental class.

    now in B-C you want sometimes just a little better then your competition...(kitchen and bathrooms "sells" the house)

    now how "tough"/"enforced" are the cabinets?

    do granite if you can find one of the independents with the tools/connections.... half bulnose/flat in a pattern and really common color.

    ikea has really cheap formica (almost to the point of per/renter  expandable) but you need a quick and good handyman.

    formica also makes solid surface (not just foil)... not sure how it handles a hot pot and knife cutting....

    you can also do really large porcelain/granite tiles (18-20"+ inches) with very thin grout lines...

    concrete can go with a very good sealer, and somebody who knows what to do.

    but in the end, you want something you can replicate again and again with not a lot of headaches down the road...

    continuous success

  • Lender · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y

    @Jared Smith Butcher Block!!! or granite, but never formica

  • Cumming, GA · Member since 2014 · 218 posts · 71 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Jason Hirko:

    @Jared Smith Butcher Block!!! or granite, but never formica

     @Jason Hirko, can you relay any good experiences with using butcher block? my worry comes not from knife cutting marks or pot burns marks (repairable with sanding/planing and re-sealing), but from water splashing marks (it's almost to the point of "i wonder if they bath an elephant...") and water intrusion/damage marks

    also OP is in NJ, whcih means in winter low humidity, which means cracks in wood surface.

  • Lender · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y

    @Dumitru Anton I have it in all of my C and B rentals. You have to really hit it with a knife or try to burn it to leave a mark - you'd do as much damage to formica if not more than you would to butcher block. Never had a problem with water on it, as it is extremely well sealed. I don't know about super low humidity, but you aren't putting it outside, so it can't get that extreme, right?

  • Cumming, GA · Member since 2014 · 218 posts · 71 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Jason Hirko:

    @Dumitru Anton I have it in all of my C and B rentals. You have to really hit it with a knife or try to burn it to leave a mark - you'd do as much damage to formica if not more than you would to butcher block. Never had a problem with water on it, as it is extremely well sealed. I don't know about super low humidity, but you aren't putting it outside, so it can't get that extreme, right?

     @Jason Hirko, dare to be different, Thank you. if you don't mind, can you post a couple pictures also?

  • Medford, MA · Member since 2016 · 205 posts · 47 votes
    10y
    Thank you Russell Brazil Dumitru Anton Jason Hirko for the feedback on the post. What is everyone's thoughts on price range for buying Granite? Butcher block? Formica?
  • Newark, NJ · Member since 2015 · 162 posts · 102 votes
    10y
    Well, after much back and forth between Formica 180fx and granite, we went with granite. We're doing 2 10x10 kitchens, about 65 sqft of granite total and it came to just under $2100, for both of them. We checked a few places around Hudson and Essex Counties, and the businesses on 1&9 in Jersey City had the best prices, ~$29/sqft all inclusive (some with sink, some as an add on). They're also in a special tax zone, so you pay only 3.5%. We had considered butcher block from ikea, but after reading a couple of forum threads on it, we quickly moved away from it due to the hassle factor. From the discussion, it sounded like it works ok if you plan on spending lots of time sanding and sealing or simply changing the countertops after each tenant. I love the look though.
  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    10y

    I make my decision based on ease of replacement. A class, sometimes B+, would be stone, everything else is Formica. Tenants do not deserve any better than home owners, and since Formica is good enough for me it is good enough for my tenants.

    If something does not increase the rent to generate a pay back in less than 2 years it is a waste of money in a rental. 

  • NYC, NY · Member since 2016 · 619 posts · 456 votes
    10y

    Remember that granite must be sealed about once a year so it's not really maintenance free.  Before buying, consider whether the average tenant will do that.

  • Investor · Papillion, NE · Member since 2016 · 22 posts · 31 votes
    10y

    I priced granite vs formica that looks like granite on a new construction duplex, and for this property went with formica.  

    The end result was beautiful and still allowed me to hit my numbers.  Above answers are great, it all depends on your market.  Its nicer than the house I live in, so I'm happy with that too

  • Investor · Appleton, WI · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 464 votes
    10y

    I put formica in my own kitchen when we undertook a major kitchen remodeling  (knocked down a wall, moved the kitchen, new everything). We wanted Granite at first but for about 20% of the cost we had fantastic custom formica job. Full wrap finish. What really sold us is when we stopped out to the shop and the guy grabs a scrap piece of the countertops. Takes it over in the light by the window and has us look at the surface and check for imperfections. It was flawless. Then he pulls out a big old metal file and stabs, hits and scrapes at it about a dozen times full force. Asks us to look again. Not a single blemish. Stuff is tough and looks like granite. Low maintenance compared to stone products and easy everything.

  • Seattle, WA · Member since 2016 · 9 posts · 2 votes
    10y

    We use Quartz. It looks as good as granite but is so much more durable. No staining; and generally much better performing over the long haul. Price is generally a bit less than granite, but not always.

  • Investor · Springfield, MO · Member since 2016 · 42 posts · 11 votes
    10y

    Formica has worked well for my B rentals.  If an expense adds nothing to my rental rate, why do it.  All rentals in small SF homes in this town do not generate enough cash flow to warrant any expensive additions.  Which doesn't mean, I don't give other things - storage, cleanliness, working mechanicals.

  • Investor · Coeur d'Alene, ID · Member since 2016 · 551 posts · 218 votes
    10y

    I use granite/quartxz for my flips and a cheap counter in my rentals, depending on what I can find. Granite is more work then formica by the way, it might actually be the most maintence of all the counter tops minus butcher block.

  • Real Estate Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2014 · 529 posts · 217 votes
    10y

    In my area, HD and the local granite guys typically charge me 34 dollars a sqft for the basic type of kitchen. HD charges 28 sqft for laminate, so it's definitely worth putting in granite. Also, if you get a pre cut piece of Formica, it will most likely turn out to look like poop. Most walls are not straight so depending on the situation, you could have a gap that's almost an inch away from the wall! Backsplash and caulk will help that situation but it won't look that great. Probably Good enough for low end. Finally thought, if you can use a remnants piece of granite, the cost will drop to roughly 28sqft in my area. That's the best way to go, but they don't always have the piece you need to fit your kitchen. Hope thay helps.

  • Daniel HymanBusiness Member
    CPA · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y
    Nice look Chris!
    My Online Accountant572 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.