Investor · Montréal, Québec · Member since 2016 · 52 posts · 17 votes
One of the tenants in my Triplex consistently pays rent late each month, the latest date paid so far has been the 11th of the month, the tenant adds to the fire by being impossible to reach, doesn't respond to calls or texts. Im located in Quebec, Canada where local laws heavily protect the tenant, basically can't do anything until the 21st of the month before taking any legal action and even at that the process is dauntingly long. The property is in a decent working class neighbourhood surrounded by businesses and generally has good renters, unfortunately I inherited this tenant on the purchase.. Anyone else see this kind of activity? Any feedback is highly appreciated :)
@Shawn Ackerman nice to see others dealing with the same problem, sadly though here we can't use late fees to compensate for the late rent, worst part is the neighbourhood is a B-C, the tenant however is meant for D-F and i inherited her :/
@Joe Splitrock I would not mind at all if the tenant had proper communication and gave me notice of the late rent, unfortunately in my case i have the type of tenant that avoids calls and all forms of communication
@Account Closed The only way to deal with this is to be disciplined. Serve a notice every 21st if rent is not paid. Is there a way of getting an order for costs so that the tenant has to pay for this inconvenience? Is there a provision that repeated late payment constitutes grounds for an eviction? There is supposed to be something along these lines in Ontario but I have heard it takes some pretty extreme behavior before the Landlord and Tenant Board will authorise an eviction for this alone.
You could just try cash for keys. Offer a few hundred towards moving costs and say that their payment practices are no longer welcome at your property. This tenant is a headache and your time is better spent growing your business, not chasing irritants.
In Ontario you can serve a tenant with an N4 eviction notice but you do not have to pay the LTB until you file for an application to evict, and at that stage you have to pay $190. Is it a similar process in Quebec or do you have to pay even if just handing the tenant a form? This is worth thinking about.
I would say that is your best bet as well. Giving them cash for keys and letting them know you have new tenants lined up. Also mention in a nice way that you do not want them to continue to live there.
That is tough laws. I would handle it 2 possible ways.
1. if they are bad (in other ways) or you are not willing to continue this way.....do not renew next time and get a new tenant.
2. if tenant is okay and want to keep them, but they are always going to be late, then increase their rent (if their is no rent control) to compensate for the delay. It is not a late fee it just a monthly rent. i.e. I charge three tenants in the same building 1200, 1200 and 1225.
@Joe Splitrock I would not mind at all if the tenant had proper communication and gave me notice of the late rent, unfortunately in my case i have the type of tenant that avoids calls and all forms of communication
That is my point. You have a problem and you need to communicate to them that their behavior is unacceptable. If you cannot get them to change their behavior, you need to get them out of your property.
@Account Closed I have a couple of tenants that pay late every single month, and only be a week or so. They also pay the late fee along with it. It makes no sense to me why they don't make the payment just a few days earlier, on time, and avoid monthly late fees. Personally, these tenants are fine in all other ways, so I don't bother with it anymore.
Some tenants do get government assistance, etc., so I have accommodated their rent due dates to be shortly after they get their subsidized checks in the mail so they can avoid the late fees.
Elias, as a Ontario landlord I share your concerns and problems. Landlords have very few rights and face extremely pro tenant boards in both Quebec and Ontario.
I have tried to read through your rental board guidelines but have been unable to learn much aside from the fact that tenants are required to pay on time and they have a 21 day grace period. The best I can do is relate what I am able to do dealing with late payment and perhaps you can find out if your system allows the same.
In Ontario when a tenant does not pay by midnight on the due date they are considered late. On the second we can send them a notice of rent due (N4) but this amounts to little more than a 14 day grace period. In essence the landlord is making the tenant a loan for 14 days. Since we can not charge late fees, although I do, there is no deterrent for them to pay late.
On the 15th, if they have not paid we can file a application to evict. If it goes to hearing the tenant is ordered to pay the rent, the landlords application to evict is denied and the landlord is out $170 for the application. Tenant pays, returns to apartment and the situation repeats next month.
I have a way around this situation due to the fact that in Ontario when a tenant does not pay on time we can immediately apply to the LTB for a request to pay rent owed (L9). We are not required to give the tenant any notice and there is no grace period. This is not a eviction request. There is a $170 filing fee and even if the tenant pays the rent prior to a hearing they still owe the landlord the $170 filing fee. At a hearing they will be ordered to pay the rent, if they paid the rent prior to the hearing they are still ordered to pay the landlords filing fee.
I file a L9 on every tenant that pays late and so far I have never had one repeat the habit of paying late. The $170 fee combined with being forced to attend a hearing requiring a day off work is a serious deterrent.
Check and see if Quebec allows you to file to collect rent owed on the 2nd of the month.
Hi Elias...if it were me I would give him a 3-day notice EACH time he didn't pay on time. If it continued, then I would give him a 60-days' notice due to consistent late rent. In California you don't need to give a reason...not sure what the rules are in Quebec.
I was totally that tenent. Only because- It was literally the only check I ever had the write. I was constantly forgetting. I'd set a calendar reminder- I would forget to stop at the mail box, ect.
I offered to cover the fee for online payment, my landlord didn't mind though. They often didn't cash it til later.
For me it was literally just that....I pay everything else online. Maybe make it easier for them set up a direct payment or something.
@Thomas S. what do you think of offering tenants in Ontario a rebate for paying on time? Let's say the landlord needs 1000/month. You charge 1050/month. If they pay on time, rent is 1000. After that it would be 1050. Would this be a good work around?
One of the tenants in my Triplex consistently pays rent late each month, the latest date paid so far has been the 11th of the month, the tenant adds to the fire by being impossible to reach, doesn't respond to calls or texts. Im located in Quebec, Canada where local laws heavily protect the tenant, basically can't do anything until the 21st of the month before taking any legal action and even at that the process is dauntingly long. The property is in a decent working class neighbourhood surrounded by businesses and generally has good renters, unfortunately I inherited this tenant on the purchase.. Anyone else see this kind of activity? Any feedback is highly appreciated :)
Elias, yes this is a common problem, good news, you are being paid the rent. You can enforce your late payment penalty provision, if you have this in your agreement, or simply work with the tenant to define an acceptable and amicable solution, if the particular tenant meets your rent rate guidelines. Lets face it, its almost more expensive to replace a tenant. Threatening on a monthly basis with legal action sounds awful. You simply have a habitually late paying tenant on your hands. Having dealt with this and frequently dealing with this issue, we apply the rules of the agreement, we try to work with tenants, we build our systems for the majority of our clients, this would be a minority case, as much as I do not like these situations, they are part of the business. Most important is they are paying, when they stop paying, then worry about it. Good Luck! Happy Investing
That's always frustrating. I had trouble with one of my inherited tenants as well when I bought my four plex. My thing is if they don't pay the whole balance of their rent by the end of that month, I push for eviction. Sounds like that might be a hard path in your particular market. I tried carrying a balance to the next month for that tenant and it just never worked. They just fell more and more behind. Once they got two months behind I knew I had to pull the plug. I am located in Kansas City KS, I am a small landlord and was totally inexperienced. I simply went down to the court house and explained my situation to them. It was not as bad as I thought. My city was very helpful, when I asked for guidance. I had testify against my tenant in front of the judge with the tenant there. That was a little intimidating. But I was just honest with the judge. I told him they have been behind more 3 months, their are still not caught up and I can't afford to let them stay for free any longer. I have taxes, insurance, repairs to cover on the property. I also said, "I am not rich." I am just trying to take care of my property, I can't afford to have someone stay there for free. The judge ruled in my favor and evicted my tenant 3 days before Xmas. It was not fun, but also not something to be afraid of as a landlord. It comes with the territory, its part of the business. I am not trying to be cutthroat or a greedy guy. But the contract says, they will pay by this date. If they don't they are at risk to be evicted. You got this, if you have to evict!
My only advise is stay up do date with your notices. You don't have to act on them but you won't lose out on precious days if you decide to start any type of proceedings and it will establish a behavior pattern so your tenants will always know where you stand.
If it were I would consider how late my tenant pays, do they always end up paying and if so, does that really effect my bottom line. Sometimes if they are nice people, good to your property and always end up paying, it may be better and cheaper than looking for new tenants. Having said that, I would still send them notices.
I am having cash flow issues in my business right now and my landlord sent me notice today. He happens to be my best friend and won't evict me but he is known as a stickler and he is covering himself.
I was talking to my friend about this today, apparently she pays her rent late all the time! She does it because nothing happens when she pays late. She's pushed it and pushed it, but she always does pay. I think if she got a notice on the 5th of the month she'd stop doing it! My point is that people respond to consequences and they will continue to do what they are doing in a consequence free environment.
It is very common to have a tenant pay rent late but there is a cut off per the lease. I recommend following exactly as the lease states. I am not an attorney, but it works well for us.
@Thomas S. what do you think of offering tenants in Ontario a rebate for paying on time? Let's say the landlord needs 1000/month. You charge 1050/month. If they pay on time, rent is 1000. After that it would be 1050. Would this be a good work around?
I'm sure Greg will chime in with a more Ontario focused response, but we do not reward tenants for simply meeting their obligations of the lease.
In our practice here in New Brunswick, rent is due on, or before, the first day of the month. As of the second of the month it is late and habitual offenders will be assessed a late fee. If any amount remains outstanding three days later, they are issued a Notice to Vacate.
A first-time offender for late payment of rent may be afforded grace until the fourth day of the month before being assessed a late fee. If any amount remains outstanding three days later, the are issued a Notice to Vacate.
Roy N. there's no real reward. If your market rent is $1000. You'll charge the tenant $1050(late fee included) at the beginning of there tenancy. The tenant feels rewarded but your getting the rent you wanted.
Having a higher rent with a pay on time rebate can work but the problem is actually getting the rent up to the higher level. IN Ontario we are under rent control meaning we can not simply raise the rent. A major rent increase would need to be initiated at a tenant turn over.
If in Quebec you can raise the rent do so and offer the pay on time rebate. However $50 is a insignificant amount. Get it up to $100 and it may work. What you would do is implement it with a new tenant. Advertise the higher rent with a rebate. Make it very clear in screening as to how it is going to be applied. If your landlord tenant regulations do not reference a rent rebate you may not get away with this plan. In Ontario the regulations take legal priority over all lease language. A landlord is not permitted to inforce any lease language that is not included in the regulations. All non regulatory rules are voided in a lease. IN essence a lease is not recognised as a legally binding contract in Ontario. Our LTB will not inforce lease language beyond rent payment specifications.
If you can use the rent discount fee what you do is allow the lower rate until they pay late. Your tenant is then required to pay the higher rate until they have 6 months consecutive on time payment they then earn the right to the lower rent again.
IN Ontario we are allowed to evict for consistent late payment. To be successful you must give notice to the tenant every time they pay late and you would need a minimum 4-6 notices in similar time frame to be successful evicting. The only key to successfully training a tenant, or preferably getting rid of them is to make their lives unpleasant.
IN Ontario due to the pro tenant court system and the inability to evict or terminate tenants actually having tenant turn over is a blessing to the business not a hindrance.
Pretty typical. Some folks use a grace period to avoid sending out Demand for Possession for Non-payment notices over and over again...something less than 5 days. (You should always send a notice to everyone that is late--regardless of the excuse--once they miss the due date with or without a grace period.) Your lease should have a clause in it that states that late payments are grounds for eviction. (FYI: That's not the exact language you should use for the clause.) You could make it vague or make it specific to a certain number of months the payment was late. But, if this isn't Michigan--check with your local and state laws first. Good luck!
We manage about 1000 units for a couple hundred owners. On any given month around 20%-25% pay late. From my experience, that is just usually the number....and it usually is not the same ones month to month. You just have to stay on point with your notices - and eviction filings on the first date your state or local laws allow. If you do that, you can usually train them quickly about how the game goes. It can be really tough to stay on top of that if you self manage and do not use a good property manager, especially if you have a tenant that wants to push the limits.
Has any one had success asking the tenant to choose the monthly date of payment on their lease?
As most folks get their job payments on the 15th and 30th, maybe an alternate Rental Due date may decrease late rental payments?
Tony, great insight! Any other tips you can share? 1000 units makes for some incredible "in-the-trenches" experience. What percentage are simply dead-beats? Any tell-tale signs?
Allowing tenants to pick the start day of their rental period quickly becomes an administrative burden for the landlord or property manager.
We had a tenant who tended bar for a living and was paid weekly - which did not always align with the first of the month. Additionally, she did not trust herself - or, more likely didn't trust her partner - to hold onto the money for next month's rent until the first of the month. We provided her with a deposit-only debit card and she would remit a portion of her next month's rent each pay-day.
The solution worked well for both of us and she was never late with rent.
As someone with fairly little experience as a landlord, I need to ask the question:
If the rent is paid - even if it is paid late - what's the issue?
Yes, you may be right - that's what the lease says.
Ok, the tenant pays late, but they DO pay.
... but what is the profit in getting your guts in a knot, your undies in a bunch, etc. ? It takes your time, I'm reading about fees of $170 per instance, ... Seems to me your efforts should be directed in a more profitable direction.
The tenant pays late - consistently late. Then, again, they do pay consistently, just later than they should. You could do worse.