Discrimination against section 8

Discrimination against section 8

Rental Property Investor · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 6 votes
So I was advertising my mothers upstairs appartment out of Buffalo New York, ( The appartment is not section 8 approved) this is my first time renting out a space and I assumed you had to be approved to take section 8 vouchers and I had posted in a face book group about my mothers appartment, " no smoking, no dogs, no section 8." I have taken down the post because someone had threatened to report me for discrmination. I researched and I understand regaurding the discrimiation on income but is it dicrimination if I cant accept the voucher? What are some ways you guys filter threw section 8 applicants?
3Reply
651 views

Most Popular Reply

Patti RobertsonBusiness Member
Property Manager · Virginia Beach, VA · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
7y

@Account Closed - See the article below. Looks like you cannot discriminate against income source in Buffalo. You could instead require a minimum credit score or raise your rent above the HUD budget for your bedroom size, or other criteria that would cause most SEC 8 tenants to disqualify themselves, but you would have to apply that criteria consistently among ALL applicants.

To say "this apartment is not approved for section 8" only sheds a bad light on you, once you know how the program works. (The only reason you would be banned by HUD would be if you committed fraud against them.) Landlords don't get properties pre approved for SEC 8. The official term is called the Housing Choice Voucher program. The operative word there is CHOICE. The tenant chooses where they live. Once a tenant chooses your property, they apply and have to meet your rental criteria (whatever that may be as long as you don't discriminate and screen every tenant to the same criteria). If accepted you and the tenant fill out some paperwork (it is not nearly as onerous as some folks on here may lead you to believe), and then SEC 8 will decide if financially this tenant can be approved for your rent amount. If they can, SEC 8 will then schedule an inspection for your property. This inspection is also not as onerous as most people would lead you to believe. Basically you have to meet minimum housing standards of safety and habitability. The only reason HUD would deny you is if you are basically operating a substandard rental - IE being a slumlord.

 Last week I posted a checklist we use in my PM office that includes the basic items SEC 8 inspects for.  If you go to my profile and look through my recent posts you should be able to find it pretty quickly.

https://buffalonews.com/2018/04/26/proposed-housin...

See this reply in the discussion

74 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:
    Originally posted by @Charlie MacPherson:

    @Account Closed Another thing to keep in mind - Massachusetts, and maybe NY, hires "testers".

    The sole function of these people is to pretend to be a buyer or tenant and to trick you into saying something that they can claim is discriminatory.

    I talked with another agent a few weeks ago.  She had what she was sure was a tester.  She showed them a home and at one point, they looked her in the eye and asked "is this white?"

    The agent obviously didn't take the bait.

    The key is to know what NY Fair Housing laws are, what the protected classes are and conduct your business accordingly.  If you set up your rental standards and apply them exactly the same to all applicants, you should be OK.

    This might help:

    http://www.homeny.org/services/fair-housing

     We have tons and tons of testers, because with us being the center of the countries legal economy, all the non profits that train the testers are located here.  I probably get contacted by a tester once a month. Ive even called some of them out and was correct.  I dont even mind needing to be compliant, as Im incredibly good at it ( Ive taught a Fair Housing class in the past)...but what I hate is how they waste my time. Going out to show a property to someone who is not a legitimate buyer. Once is fine....but I probably showed properties to half a dozen testers this past year. So you figure thats about 10 hours of work time just wasted.

    I've had the opposite. Despite having criteria that section 8 tenants would not meet, and having this not only in my listings but also going over it in email to confirm with the prospect that they meet the requirements before booking a tour, I get people who still show up with multiple pit bulls, section 8, etc. Three ladies from a house a few doors down had been on section 8 for FOURTEEN years in just THAT house, you read that right. Who knows how long they had  been in the program before that house. I didn't realize being on the tax payer dole was a way of life in America....

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jack B.:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:
    Originally posted by @Charlie MacPherson:

    @Account Closed Another thing to keep in mind - Massachusetts, and maybe NY, hires "testers".

    The sole function of these people is to pretend to be a buyer or tenant and to trick you into saying something that they can claim is discriminatory.

    I talked with another agent a few weeks ago.  She had what she was sure was a tester.  She showed them a home and at one point, they looked her in the eye and asked "is this white?"

    The agent obviously didn't take the bait.

    The key is to know what NY Fair Housing laws are, what the protected classes are and conduct your business accordingly.  If you set up your rental standards and apply them exactly the same to all applicants, you should be OK.

    This might help:

    http://www.homeny.org/services/fair-housing

     We have tons and tons of testers, because with us being the center of the countries legal economy, all the non profits that train the testers are located here.  I probably get contacted by a tester once a month. Ive even called some of them out and was correct.  I dont even mind needing to be compliant, as Im incredibly good at it ( Ive taught a Fair Housing class in the past)...but what I hate is how they waste my time. Going out to show a property to someone who is not a legitimate buyer. Once is fine....but I probably showed properties to half a dozen testers this past year. So you figure thats about 10 hours of work time just wasted.

    I've had the opposite. Despite having criteria that section 8 tenants would not meet, and having this not only in my listings but also going over it in email to confirm with the prospect that they meet the requirements before booking a tour, I get people who still show up with multiple pit bulls, section 8, etc. Three ladies from a house a few doors down had been on section 8 for FOURTEEN years in just THAT house, you read that right. Who knows how long they had  been in the program before that house. I didn't realize being on the tax payer dole was a way of life in America....

    Jack there are parts of the deep south were fully 70% of the population is on some form of assistance. that's why HUD is not going away you would have anarchy.

  • Rental Property Investor · Gainesville, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 432 votes
    7y

    @Russell Brazil when you call them on it and ask if they are a tester, do they admit it? That is a waste of your time and knowing this and catching them in the act, so to speak, does that get you out of the showing. Clearly they are not looking to buy / rent.

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Daria B.:

    @Russell Brazil when you call them on it and ask if they are a tester, do they admit it? That is a waste of your time and knowing this and catching them in the act, so to speak, does that get you out of the showing. Clearly they are not looking to buy / rent.

     Yeah, I asked what Fair Housing organization they were with and they told me. They asked how I knew, and I told them that their questions were so far out of the norm of what someone would ask that only someone within the industry would be asking. I was already showing them the property, as I dont really prescreen anyone. They want to see the property, I set up the appointment to do so.  

  • Brie SchmidtBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    7y

    @Michael Lenahan - that will get him sued

  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 53 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brie Schmidt:

    @Michael Lenahan - that will get him sued

    Can you elaborate?

  • Brie SchmidtBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    7y

    @Michael Lenahan - saying you are not set up for it is not an excuse in an area where it is a protected class

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
    Originally posted by @Jack B.:
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:
    Originally posted by @Charlie MacPherson:

    @Account Closed Another thing to keep in mind - Massachusetts, and maybe NY, hires "testers".

    The sole function of these people is to pretend to be a buyer or tenant and to trick you into saying something that they can claim is discriminatory.

    I talked with another agent a few weeks ago.  She had what she was sure was a tester.  She showed them a home and at one point, they looked her in the eye and asked "is this white?"

    The agent obviously didn't take the bait.

    The key is to know what NY Fair Housing laws are, what the protected classes are and conduct your business accordingly.  If you set up your rental standards and apply them exactly the same to all applicants, you should be OK.

    This might help:

    http://www.homeny.org/services/fair-housing

     We have tons and tons of testers, because with us being the center of the countries legal economy, all the non profits that train the testers are located here.  I probably get contacted by a tester once a month. Ive even called some of them out and was correct.  I dont even mind needing to be compliant, as Im incredibly good at it ( Ive taught a Fair Housing class in the past)...but what I hate is how they waste my time. Going out to show a property to someone who is not a legitimate buyer. Once is fine....but I probably showed properties to half a dozen testers this past year. So you figure thats about 10 hours of work time just wasted.

    I've had the opposite. Despite having criteria that section 8 tenants would not meet, and having this not only in my listings but also going over it in email to confirm with the prospect that they meet the requirements before booking a tour, I get people who still show up with multiple pit bulls, section 8, etc. Three ladies from a house a few doors down had been on section 8 for FOURTEEN years in just THAT house, you read that right. Who knows how long they had  been in the program before that house. I didn't realize being on the tax payer dole was a way of life in America....

    Jack there are parts of the deep south were fully 70% of the population is on some form of assistance. that's why HUD is not going away you would have anarchy.

     We're currently at as close to full employment as we're ever going to see.  Employers are begging for people to work for them.  There are hundreds of thousands of unfilled listings.  If ever we were going to tell people "Hey slack, no more handouts for you.  Get a f'ing job", now is the time. 

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brian Ploszay:

    @Cody L     I still like section 8, and I have become and expert in the paperwork.  Still, the administration aspects can be frustrating at times.  The program has allowed me to take some properties in marginal areas, rent them and get a superior cash flow.  My main benefit was that I cut evictions and collection losses significantly.  And the yearly inspections actually forced me to keep up with repairs in an organized way.

     That's great.  I have zero problems with people who take section 8 and admit that if you're a property setup to do so and have polices and staff around taking section 8, it can be a money maker.  So I say "right on" to people who do it.

    But you have to respect the fact that others, like me, don't want to do it.  I don't want the government as a tenant and I don't see how rejecting the government as a tenant, who doesn't follow my rules in the lease, is a protected class.  And as was perfectly written by someone else (can't see their name atm), I have moral issues with renting to people who Know are gaming the system and sucking money from the taxpayer.  The whole thing makes me feel gross.  If it's someone down on their luck who needs a hand, no problem, there are private charities for that.  But I don't want people in my properties that are living off the government (i.e., my taxes)

  • Rental Property Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Wesley W.:
    Originally posted by @Patrick M.:

    @Steve B. and @Wesley W.

    It has nothing to do with being qualified as an approved apartment, it has everything to do with refusing to rent to section 8 applicants:

    https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.app.com/amp/84182364

    If someone calls you in NY and NJ and says do you accept section 8 you can’t say no.

    Again, I'm taking exception that you are lumping NY in with your broad statements about "mandatory S8 applicants."

    I looked at the article you quoted, and nowhere in there do I see the state of NY mentioned.  It's true that some liberal-leaning municipalities in NY are requiring landlords to take these people (Buffalo, for one, apparently) but it is just not true that the state as a whole has this rule.

    I was advised by my attorney that one is NOT REQUIRED to participate in S8 programs in NY.  Unless there was sweeping legislation passed in this state within the last few years that miraculously went unnoticed by me and others, that advice should still hold.

    I do not put "no section 8" in my ads, but I require first,last, security at signing so that self-selects all of those people out anyways.  Maybe it's semantics, but I tell them "my lease doesn't conform to S8 requirements."

     Why don't I like section 8? 

    (1) In my investment area, they will not pay what the FMV of what apartments will rent for.

    (2)  The tenant has to pay a portion, and the HA pays a portion.  I have to track different payments from different sources for the same unit.  Minor PITA.

    (3)  I only accept payments to a checking account.  Some programs do a voucher, where they mail you the voucher, you fill it out, then send it back, THEN a check is cut, and mailed back to you, and you have to deposit it.  On average you get your rent money about 3 weeks late.

    (4)  The payment method above violates my lease.  The single exception nullifies my systematization of process.  If I have to deposit one person's check, I may as well be depositing them all.

    (5)  They require 1 year term leases.  I only offer M2M.

    (6)  Additional government oversight on how I run my business.  (Inspections, paperwork, etc.)

    (7)  The inspections are over-reaching.  When I used to accept S8 the inspector would find ticky-tack things just to justify their role in the process, in my opinion.  I was written up once for a piece of laminate veneer coming off the edge of a cabinet door, for example.  I have to fix the violation within 30 days and have a reinspection or they WITHHOLD THE ENTIRE RENT CHECK.

    Also - as an aside, a large number of tenants in my area are gaming the system.  The system is rife with abuse and there doesn't seem to be concern over stewardship of the taxpayers' money to vet the candidates better or transition them out of the program, as intended.  Many are "lifers."  This creates a moral issue with me.

     Dude, I gave you a like but if you were in San Diego I'd go and give you a hug.  Well written post. 

  • Real Estate Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2016 · 22 posts · 3 votes
    7y

    One question for people in NYC who KNOW (rather than assume) - can a landlord demand a minimum credit / income to qualify tenants? I don't mean choosing the most qualified tenant, but making a specific minimum requirement - let's say a 650+ credit or income x40 rent? 

  • Andrew SyriosPro Member
    Moderator
    Residential Real Estate Investor · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    7y

    Some states have laws against discriminating against "source of income" and some don't. I believe New York does have such a law but you'll need to look into it to see whether or not you're allowed to not accept Section 8 vouchers.

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Gal Alberman:

    One question for people in NYC who KNOW (rather than assume) - can a landlord demand a minimum credit / income to qualify tenants? I don't mean choosing the most qualified tenant, but making a specific minimum requirement - let's say a 650+ credit or income x40 rent? 

     Not only can you do that......you absolutely should do that, and everywhere. The easiest way to protect your self from a fair housing claim is to have a set of WRITTEN criteria, credit score, income, etc....and stick to that criteria 100%. 

    But also, your criteria should be realistic. You want to make sure the average renter you want passes your criteria.

  • Real Estate Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2016 · 22 posts · 3 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Russell Brazil:
    Originally posted by @Gal Alberman:

    One question for people in NYC who KNOW (rather than assume) - can a landlord demand a minimum credit / income to qualify tenants? I don't mean choosing the most qualified tenant, but making a specific minimum requirement - let's say a 650+ credit or income x40 rent? 

     Not only can you do that......you absolutely should do that, and everywhere. The easiest way to protect your self from a fair housing claim is to have a set of WRITTEN criteria, credit score, income, etc....and stick to that criteria 100%. 

    But also, your criteria should be realistic. You want to make sure the average renter you want passes your criteria.

     Yes, this is what I know. Thing is that a friend of mine has gotten a few phone calls in the past few days from section 8 renters saying that it's not legal to ask for the credit since the rent is 100% covered by the voucher. now I think it's BS but he says he got few calls like these this week saying *exactly* the same thing, like they have been told otherwise.. maybe NYC specific fair housing or something 

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2017 · 719 posts · 658 votes
    7y

    @Gal Alberman I think checking on credit is important in more ways than just paying rent.

    Tenants pay water and it's usually billed by the landlord since water is on the property.

    They could sell appliances on CL if they have problems with paying other bills, like electricity and gas, they could get property subleased etc

    If someone is responsible - it shows on their credit. If I have every Tenant credit report - this is not a discrimination 

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2017 · 719 posts · 658 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Andrew Syrios:

    Some states have laws against discriminating against "source of income" and some don't. I believe New York does have such a law but you'll need to look into it to see whether or not you're allowed to not accept Section 8 vouchers.

     I never discriminated against source of income but combined income must meet my criteria: 3 rents with FICO higher 620 and 4 rents if below or no credit. Generally, my Tenants have score around 520-540 if any, so they have to meet my 4-rents income requirements. I don't expect them to be too creditworthy because with 580 you can qualify for a mortgage and with 620 it's easy, if they don't have much debts to pay.

  • Investor · Anchorage, AK · Member since 2016 · 222 posts · 294 votes
    7y

    @Account Closed First find out if it is legal or not on your state to not accept section 8. Then if it isn't illegal, put it in your ad, so those people don't waste your and their time by calling you :) I don't accept it for my rentals at the moment..But if I had rentals in lower income areas, I probably would.

  • Rental Property Investor · The Vampire State · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Andrew Syrios:

    Some states have laws against discriminating against "source of income" and some don't. I believe New York does have such a law but you'll need to look into it to see whether or not you're allowed to not accept Section 8 vouchers.

    *sigh*  Good fricken' grief.

    Well, I'll say it again, this time more slowly...NEW YORK STATE DOES NOT HAVE A LAW THAT FORCES LANDLORDS TO ACCEPT SECTION 8! 

    Please don't post what you "believe" - this is how incorrect information gets perpetuated.  

    New York State does not have a law that forces landlords to accept section 8.

    Here is a link to the NYS Attorney General's publication entitled "Source of Income Discrimination."

    https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/pdfs/publica...

    TL;DR:  this "source of income" as a protected class is restricted to several municipal jurisdictions that have passed their own local laws, but it is not true in the overwhelming majority of New York State!  There is no such state law.

    New York State does not have a law that forces landlords to accept section 8.

  • Member since 2018 · 7 posts · 5 votes
    7y

    I allow section 8 in my properties, but I also have guidelines set up like a credit score minimum, clear eviction history, clear criminal background, income must 2-3x rent, and such. 

  • Member since 2018 · 14 posts · 7 votes
    7y
    @Brian Fuerle check your state laws. In NJ you can be more selective in an owner occupied multi family. So if your mother lives there she may be able to say no to section 8.
  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2017 · 719 posts · 658 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Gary Mawson:
    @Brian Fuerle check your state laws. In NJ you can be more selective in an owner occupied multi family. So if your mother lives there she may be able to say no to section 8.

    It has to be up to 4 units - everything more than that won't be applicable  for Mrs.Murphy exemption from the Fair housing.

    I guess, you mom-in-law also has to b the owner of the building

  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 61 posts · 40 votes
    7y

    Definitely pros and cons on taking section 8. All the pros I can think of have been mentioned. Some cons (in CA) not mentioned are the terms required such as landlord must give 90 days notice to terminate agreement which is longer than what the state requires; housing can terminate their financial assistance with 30 days notice (happened to me due to tenant failing the annual inspection) which almost guarantees the rent won't be paid in full after that short notice.

  • Member since 2018 · 19 posts · 14 votes
    7y

    I'll accept Section 8 as long as the tenant has a decent job history and no evictions on the record. I'll also State the minimum income required right there in the ad,

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, GA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    7y

    I often get inquiries regarding whether we take section 8 and I just tell them we don't accept vouchers of any sort. If my rentals were in a state that required me to accept section 8, I would seek another means of income. I'm not opposed to the section 8 program, I just don't intend to participate in it with my properties. It's highly unlikely a section 8 tenant would meet our rental criteria anyway.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.