Homeowner · Abington · Member since 2009 · 61 posts · 1 vote
The tenant called for the water heater repair on Wed afternoon, the repair man went to examine the water heater next day morning. He ordered the parts and parts will be in Tuesday. It takes really long time to fix. It caused the inconvenience for the tenant. Right now the tenant stated by law, she would not pay for the rent for the days without the water heater .The property is in PA. I am wondering what the law in PA for this issues . I know unemployment has one week waiting period etc. Insurance has some deduction according to the policy. I do not know what is those reasonable comprehend for the tenant. Thanks.
Why would it ever take nearly a week to fix a hot water heater? If the parts can't be purchased at a local hardware store, spend $600 to replace the water heater.
I have no idea what the law is, but as far as I'm concerned, if one of my tenants didn't have hot water for nearly a week, I would expect them to be pretty upset, and I certainly wouldn't charge them rent for the time they were without hot water.
Five days without hot water for tentant is really long .It caused tenant inconvenience.I do not know how to appraise reasonal and fair comprensation for the tenant in this case such working days or not working days , waiting period and proportion of the comfort level since the house is only without hot water. But total amount of the rent to deduct seems unreasonable for me. I know when fire and blood occur, it is portion to compensate the tenant . The comfortable leve without water heater appraisal.... please advise.
I'd give her 2 "free" days. My reasoning/explanation would be as follows: we normally take care of things in less than 72 hours. Given this maintenance request is taking longer due to A,B,C reasons, I am giving you a break on anything over 3 days.
This will make her happier, and reduce the aggravation.
Why would it ever take nearly a week to fix a hot water heater? If the parts can't be purchased at a local hardware store, spend $600 to replace the water heater.
I have no idea what the law is, but as far as I'm concerned, if one of my tenants didn't have hot water for nearly a week, I would expect them to be pretty upset, and I certainly wouldn't charge them rent for the time they were without hot water.
I agree, one week is too long. I think it is reasonable to have someone go to fix the water heater within 1 business day from when your tenant reports the problem. Once someone has gone to repair it, there should be no more than a few hours to get it fixed. Your tenant reported the problem on Wednesday, so if it wasn't fixed by Friday morning I think you need to give them some kind of a break on rent.
My son's school ( college) is shut down from Saturday and Tuesday due to snow . The door and a few building were closed due to without electricity. Should I ask the school tuition break or no dorm fee refund. They sent the kids home if they can or stay in other dorms. I do not know what is the other dorm mean. Must be uncomfortable. It is two hours drive for me. My son want to go home. The school calendar will not change according to this incident. With $54,000 per year cost to attend. how much I should get for this incident? For house, I called the repair man right away, It is sear water heater, it need special part. Some thing is out of my control . If you have production need electricity, power outrage, do you get refund for monthly charge from the electricity company. Last month, we have no train, I have monthly train pass.i do not recall the train get me credit for five days. I drove to work and paid for parking.
Out of so accommodations in the house, only hot water is out. ask for full rent credit for those days for shower....
I understand your points, that no school is going to pro rate tuition based on a snowstorm, and the train isn't going to pro rate your monthly pass, BUT wouldn't it be AWESOME if they did? Wouldn't you tell everyone you know about how wonderful your son's school is? How they are wonderful people and really run their school with integrity?
Now imagine your tenant saying that about you. "Frances is the best landlord ever! He went out of his way to fix the water heater, and when the repairman took a week to do it, Frances cut my rent in half! He really cares about his tenants." Wouldn't that be cool? A great reputation is worth it in the long run.
I know there are some people that will never care how much you do for them, they will always feel entitled. But most people will be loyal to you when they know how much you care. I hope that puts a different spin on things for you! :)
Hot water serves a lot more than the shower. Such as cooking and cleaning. Had their electricity been knocked out by the snow then they certainly would have had no claim against you. And, you're right, they certainly weren't out on the street. But no hot water is more than a minor inconvenience. You could have forked over $600 or whatever and just had your service guy replace it. Instead you choose to spend less and replace parts. That choice seriously inconvenienced your tenants. That was your choice, not mother nature or something out of your control.
For tax write off it is beneficial to repair versus replace.So depending on how much rent you would lose you would have to weigh repair versus putting new in.
I totally understand if a part is 50 bucks you do not want to spend 600 or more for a new one.
Especially if it is not that old.
I gave 100 rent credit to a tenant when the A/C was out for a few days.The outside fan motor needed replacement so rather than the A/C guy saying I need a new one at 2 grand we bought the fan motor at a supply house for 60 and fixed it.
So 2,000 versus 160 I will take the repair all day long.
Especially if you have a property you are planning on selling for development down the road you don't want to drop all new stuff in.Sure a developer will let me strip it out and cash out the parts before they take it down but I want to keep my replacements to as little as possible and only repair.
If you do too much the tenant will keep pushing the envelope.
If I was in your shoes I would definitely give a credit to the tenant.After you get the part fixed and the credit you are still probably ahead versus replacement in cash outlay.
Another consideration is if the water heater goes out on the weekend you might be better giving the credit versus paying for an emergency call and getting hit up with double the fees for everything.
I replaced the hotwater heater already yesterday. The total cost included labor and heater is $750. The tenant has been with me for three years already. We are in good relationship. I do beyond my duty. She also help me in other thing. We are like friends and she takes care of property. The lease did not included the appliance repair and replace. I paid for that since she is taking good care of the property and care about that cost of repair and watched out for me. I also gave her the lowest rent in the development. We are both happy about relationship, I told her about the replacement.
We are human and have feeling. Right I asked her consider all the factors and let me know the reasonable compensation .