Yesterday for the first time I had a potential tenant tell me the she has a felony on her record when I sent her my application. I Googled her name and found out she was convicted in 2015. My unit is in Buffalo, NY. Is it OK that I tell her before she is submits the application that we do not accept applicants who were convicted as a felon? If yes, is that something I should do over a phone call, email or text? Or should I wait until she fills out an application? If yes, what's the legal why to tell her.
I’m not sure I’d have any tenants at all if I excluded anyone with a criminal background . If they called and told me they had a record I’d just say “ actually so do I ..I took a tenants life who didn’t pay me rent once “
@Michael Palmer Should consult with an attorney to make sure you are taking the proper steps according with fair housing laws. If you own rental property consulting with an attorney is money well invested. They can even probably even assist with your rental applications language and leases. Good luck!
She has a felony from 2015. When did she finish serving and what's her history been since then? If she finished serving in 2016 and has two years of clean history, including Landlord and work history, then I would consider her low risk. If she just got out three months ago, I would say no because there's a very high rate of recidivism.
It's good when people can be open and honest about their legal history.
We don't automatically write off someone with a felony. Ask more questions.
Here's an excerpt from our rental criteria.
LEGAL/CRIMINAL HISTORY
1.Criminal offenses of a violent nature against either person or property will result in denial.
2.Applicants with a non-violent criminal misdemeanor that occurred more than two years ago or a non-violent criminal felony that occurred more than five years ago may be considered if restitution for their crime was made in full and all time was served.Also, we may require an additional security deposit and demonstration of good employment history, credit history, and rental history since the time of the crime.Multiple offenses may result in denial regardless of what the employment, credit and rental history shows.
It is really nice when applicants are open and honest since it makes screening so much easier. If you have a no felony policy don't waste any time simply call her on the phone and inform her you do not accept felons. Never do it in any way that leaves a paper trail.
If you are afraid to manage your business then accept her application, do not bother screening her and when you do accept a applicant simply inform her the unit is no longer available. Do not give her any indication you have a issue with felons.
Never choose any applicant you do not want for any reason. Initial screening should eliminate this type of applicant. No reason to tell them why they are rejected once you have selected your new tenant.
It's good when people can be open and honest about their legal history.
We don't automatically write off someone with a felony. Ask more questions.
Here's an excerpt from our rental criteria.
LEGAL/CRIMINAL HISTORY
1.Criminal offenses of a violent nature against either person or property will result in denial.
2.Applicants with a non-violent criminal misdemeanor that occurred more than two years ago or a non-violent criminal felony that occurred more than five years ago may be considered if restitution for their crime was made in full and all time was served.Also, we may require an additional security deposit and demonstration of good employment history, credit history, and rental history since the time of the crime.Multiple offenses may result in denial regardless of what the employment, credit and rental history shows.
Marcia I don't think they are a protected class. but I am thinking Oregon just changed that or something to that effect with their new state wide rent control that passed.
I think there Is probably a NICHE for those that want to provide felon housing. Just like student housing or senior housing or section 8 housing or affordable housing projects.. one could build felon housing.. At least in states were evictions were slam dunk for no pay..
Yes, I agree, it could be a niche market. There are many people who have a felony on their record, a result of bad decisions they made and/or legal processes that convicted them rightly or wrongly. They face a tremendous barrier to employment and housing. Even after they have turned their life around and have not re-offended.
Efforts to make felons a protected class have been ongoing in the employment arena for some time now. Will that spill over to housing? There's talk, but it hasn't taken hold. I see it as inherently different than other protected classes. It's not about who you are; it's about what you've done.
It can be a risky class to rent to. Some are drawn to the criminal lifestyle, some got on the wrong track for a only a short while, and some made one mistake that cost them dearly. The key seems to be what led to the felony, the type of felony, their age at the time, their incarceration history, when they got out, what they've done since, and the likelihood of recidivism. The risk-benefit of renting to this group certainly needs to be explored. No-cause eviction is possible in our jurisdiction, so that's our exit plan if things go south. We can have someone out within 30 days if necessary. If I were in a jurisdiction where this wasn't possible, I'd think twice.
Actually in 2016 HUD did make it illegal for landlords to use "Felony Status" as rental criteria. This does not mean you cannot use their criminal history in your criteria. You just can't have a blanket policy that says you will not rent to anyone with a felony conviction, etc. @Marcia Maynard is doing it exactly right. Set a policy based on common sense. You can have different criteria for different properties and property types, just make sure the reason behind the criteria is something that will sound sound and logical to a Judge.Link to HUD 2016 Felony Status Protection Document
Actually in 2016 HUD did make it illegal for landlords to use "Felony Status" as rental criteria. This does not mean you cannot use their criminal history in your criteria. You just can't have a blanket policy that says you will not rent to anyone with a felony conviction, etc. @Marcia Maynard is doing it exactly right. Set a policy based on common sense. You can have different criteria for different properties and property types, just make sure the reason behind the criteria is something that will sound sound and logical to a Judge.Link to HUD 2016 Felony Status Protection Document
what do you think about catering to those felons although seems like for them to rent its probably most of the lower level type rentals that will make the exception. so one provides nicer units and maybe charges a premium .. For the first 12 to 24 months something like that.. plus higher deposit. or since you ladies are in the trenchs do you think this is just wishful thinking .
@Jay Hinrichs - I think charging a higher rent to a felon would be considered a fair housing violation, just like it would be to charge an old person a higher rate because they may not live long enough to finish the lease term. Like Marcia, I just use logic. No drug distribution or property destruction, ever. Someone who looks like a career criminal who is in and out of jail or violates parole is too high a risk, because they may get locked back up. No sex offenders in a multi family, etc.
@Jay Hinrichs - I think charging a higher rent to a felon would be considered a fair housing violation, just like it would be to charge an old person a higher rate because they may not live long enough to finish the lease term. Like Marcia, I just use logic. No drug distribution or property destruction, ever. Someone who looks like a career criminal who is in and out of jail or violates parole is too high a risk, because they may get locked back up. No sex offenders in a multi family, etc.
thanks for your feedback was just curious about you folks in the business.. does HUD subsidized rent preclude felons ?? so if someone is approved with HUD you know for a fact they are not felons.. ???
I’m not sure I’d have any tenants at all if I excluded anyone with a criminal background . If they called and told me they had a record I’d just say “ actually so do I ..I took a tenants life who didn’t pay me rent once “
I'm a bit biased in this case because I volunteer in prison every Sunday and everyone I work with is a felon (and not just small time felons...the big guns...). So I've gotten to know a lot of them and interact with them regularly, both in prison and once they get out of prison.
I think ruling anyone out just because they have a felony is crazy. Some of the felons I know, and especially the lifers who have gotten out, are some of the hardest working people I know once they're out of prison. Of course not all felons will be like that, but I'd at least try to feel the person out before ruling them out. What was the felony for? What's her living history been since then?
I mean, she was upfront about it. That's a good start.
My policy is--with anyone I work with (employees, contractors, investors, tenants, etc.)--I don't care what your background is. If you do your job, act right, make my life more enjoyable and easy... let's work together. And honestly, I like people with more rugged pasts. Less facade, more fire, and less bull.
There is a very high level of recidivism in ex cons. There is a good possibility they are still involved in crime and have just not been caught. I know plenty of ex cons in that situation, drug dealers, B&E etc. Friends in low places.
If you can not have a blanket policy of rejecting all felons then just wait till you find a more qualified applicant and inform the felon the unit is no longer available.
@Jay Hinrichs@Marcia Maynard@Ali Boone - my own felon story. I used to manage a drag strip. I had a young man that worked for me for several seasons. Then one day he didn't show up. Other workers reported that he was in jail. He was 18 (adult) and got his 15 year old girlfriend pregnant. Parents were (righteously) pissed and had him charged with sexual assault. So, not only was he now a felon he was also on the sex offender list. And he has to pay child support for a child he never sees... There are all kinds of stories out there.
100% correct. No point in a landlord wasting their time to find out what the story is and if it is even true. Best policy is to have a strict screening policy that does not waste time and effort. Unless you want to be a social worker/landlord don't have grey screening standards. No felons, pass.
What is the felony for? Many states charge as felonies what others consider misdemeanors. Here in CA we're almost to where there's no such thing as prosecutable crimes.
"Why take on another level of risk if you don't need to?"
Exactly, why should a landlord have to work to find a reason to accept a applicant that is a clear rejection. Why care what the crime was, pass, next.
We are not social workers and have more important priorities in our business than giving people second chances. Let Mom and Pop landlord take those risks.
@Jay Hinrichs - That is correct. If the voucher holder or anyone over 18 in their household gets convicted of a felony or drug charge, they lose the privilege of having a voucher. If the criminal is a household member and not the voucher holder they can appeal as long as they remove the person from their voucher and show proof that the felon is residing elsewhere.
@Jay Hinrichs - That is correct. If the voucher holder or anyone over 18 in their household gets convicted of a felony or drug charge, they lose the privilege of having a voucher. If the criminal is a household member and not the voucher holder they can appeal as long as they remove the person from their voucher and show proof that the felon is residing elsewhere.
Ok in Oregon they are talking about you cant discriminate against felons.. and then you have the HUD saying no felons.. Mixed messages
@Jay Hinrichs - That is an interesting thought. I’ll have to think about that at an earlier hour. As a tax payer, I am supportive of the rules that say if someone wants to get free money they have to obide by some rules like having a job, reporting all people in the household and all income in the household, and no drug charges or felonies. I’m also OK with the law that says we can’t use felony status as a rental criteria. I’ve always used common sense, rather than felony status in my criteria.
Hi everyone, Very interesting stuff here. A lot of negative belief, however, good or bad your best bet to not end up in court with out of pocket costs that will hit you big time, and any positive cash flow will be hard to recover. Therefore, your best interest will be to abide by the Federal, State, and local laws. Otherwise, you may regret ever being a landlord. And it can ruin your finances, and budget for years to come. My personal point of view is be fair. Every person no matter what has the right to housing, and yes I believe you are discriminating when you refuse an ex-felon the right to a fair chance to housing just on being an ex-felon, and they do have the rights. Those who believe otherwise will get bitten on the butt eventually. All it takes is an ex-felon that knows his rights to file and you'll be in for a costly headache that won't go away. Win or lose its going to cost you. There is plenty of legal aid and support for them. However, as a landlord and to protect your profits and continue a profitable business you need to check your Federal, State and Local laws. If you really don't have the ability or don't want to fork out more on having a lawyer to draft up your lease agreement and educate you on the do and don't. But, would be well worth it if you don't have the time to research your State and local laws. Every state have laws the usually are even more stricter then the Federal laws. I could go on and on page after page. But, don't have the time so my honest suggestion if your want to stress less then some people suggest here. By just not allowing any ex-felon a fair chance to housing, which could very well be grounds for discrimination is to research some very important laws that will set you back. People can be great tenants or bad ex-felon or not most of us have family, extended family, or friends that are ex-felons these days. Those who don't, must not have very much family or friends or secluded or don't socialize or ? Whatever, the case may be no matter what, you can find bad tenants in every walk of life. Including family and friends, do your homework and be fair. I'm have no doubt if you do and not just deny any ex-felon a fair chance just because that person is an ex-felon with a great rental and credit history check, you will be doing yourself a bad business opportunity. Good Luck