Service Animals & Emotional support- Is animal restriction dead?

Service Animals & Emotional support- Is animal restriction dead?

Real Estate Broker · Watertown, NY · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes

Hey guys,

Is anyone noticing a huge uptick in the amount of people applying for apartments who have service and emotional support animals?  In just the last 3 months, I swear 7/10 people have had one of the two.  I even had one applicant tell me they had 4 service dogs!  Literally a small gang of dogs surrounding them at all times.

I have no issues with people who have these, but it feels like it's getting to the point where EVERYONE has one.  We even have to disregard our insurance companies strict breed restrictions and risk being canceled if there's ever a claim.

What's everyone doing to offset the risks that are being forced upon us with this new phenomenon?  Obviously animal proofing during the rehab is one, but what else?

4Reply
264 views

Most Popular Reply

Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
7y

@Jennifer J. you can't charge a deposit, no pet rent, nothing.

I've studied this issue for almost ten years and it's definitely getting worse and the government is doing nothing to help. Some states have instituted penalties for anyone falsely claiming an emotional support animal or service animal but they provide no guidance on how to file a complaint.

The easiest solution is to hand this over to www.PetScreening.com and let them deal with it. Their service is 100% free to the Landlord so why not let them do the work? They are experts in the law and will at least weed out most of the fraudsters, which takes care of about 60% of them. The remainder may make it past the screening but at least you'll have their animal information on file and can ensure it's kept current.

Virtually anyone can "prescribe" an emotional support animal. Psychologist, family doctor, family counselor, marriage counselor, and even a pastor. It needn't be a licensed medical practitioner and they're not required to have any medical training that qualifies them to identify the emotional "disability" that the individual suffers from. You feel sad? Get a dog! Things going poorly at work? Get a dog! You heard someone died in the war zone 27 miles from your location? Get a dog!

The most interesting part is that these people suffering from disabling emotional problems are usually not seeking any form of treatment. They see a doctor or counselor once, get a dog prescription, and then never go back. Why? Because they don't actually have a disability and they're not actually trying to heal anything. They just want their pet. 

Even though the animal is essentially considered a medical device in the eyes of the law, they still have to meet basic responsibilities like keeping it leashed, not allowing it to damage the property, cleaning up after it, keeping it quiet, not letting it threaten others, etc. I recently kicked someone out because their ESA lunged and snapped at two different people on two different occasions. If the animal does not abide by the rules, you can absolutely require them to remove it.

The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

86 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · CA · Member since 2018 · 135 posts · 174 votes
    7y

    @Dan H. 

    Dan, how would you deal with this situation in a multi-family setting? Wouldnt raising rent in only one of the units be perceived as discrimination?

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Pavel Shemyakin:

    @Dan H. 

    Dan, how would you deal with this situation in a multi-family setting? Wouldnt raising rent in only one of the units be perceived as discrimination?


    Our multi units have a wide range of rents which are mostly a function of length of tenancy, how good the tenant is, and what the market rate for the unit is in its current condition. As long as the rent is not a function of a protected class (race, gender, religion, etc.) then it is not illegal discrimination. In other words, If a tenant is not as good a tenant as their neighbor, but my criteria for good does not include a protected class, then I am allowed to charge a different rent. The issue can be what if the tenant is a protected class and believes that is the reason that their rent is higher? This could be a problem if the tenant was a unique protected class in my units but I do not have that case. I have or have had gay tenants, Hispanic tenants, Caucasian tenants, jewish tenants, catholic tenants, atheist tenants and I have had good tenants from each (I have only had a few bad tenants that I raise rent way above market). So far we have not had an issue with anyone claiming protected discrimination for having their rent set high (I believe they think we are clueless to what the market rent is) and it is because we do not use a protected class as the basis for the higher rent. In our bad tenant cases, there have been multiple lease violations or late payments but we did not boot them for those violations; instead we raised their rent to where they gave us notice. BTW I had a tenant that was surprised I could discriminate against smokers and indicated she would sue. I informed her smokers were not a protected class and that she should consult a lawyer. They think the threat of suit can result in them getting what they want. I have been threatened to be sued I do not know how many times (maybe 30) and have never been sued. Document things and follow the law. It is not against the law for me to charge my better tenants less than my worse tenants (at least not yet in CA). BTW 2: CA is very close to passing statewide rent control. They have 4 days to get it passed which could happen. Rent increases would be capped at 5% + inflation or 10% (whatever is lower). In recent times that will be a 7% to 8% total (last 3 years had inflation between 2% and 3%). Fortunately this will typically result in a higher than market increase. Our LTR rents vary from ~$1500 to $3500. If this regulation was in place in 2018, the max rent increase would have been 7.44%. On $1500, that is $111. Mostly we raised the rents on the $1500 range units $50/month (a little less than market increase). On the $3500 unit rents the 7.44% would be $260. We raised most of those rents $100 but a few a little more than $100 but none more than $150. My point is even with the proposed CA rent control regulation, it will be possible to raise rents in most years above the market rent.
  • Rental Property Investor · CA · Member since 2018 · 135 posts · 174 votes
    7y

    Thanks for your reply @Dan H.!

    Lets say you have a quad (I am looking at quads right now as a possibility), all units rent for the same amount. One of the tenants pulls an ESA card but has  no other issues. It seems to me that in this scenario, if the rent is raised, it could be concluded that due to lack of any other infractions - the rent raise was caused by attainment of ESA. Would that be considered illegal?

    Thank you for all your help man!

    Edit: The rent was raised above the rent of other identical units in the quad.

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Pavel Shemyakin:

    Thanks for your reply @Dan H.!

    Lets say you have a quad (I am looking at quads right now as a possibility), all units rent for the same amount. One of the tenants pulls an ESA card but has  no other issues. It seems to me that in this scenario, if the rent is raised, it could be concluded that due to lack of any other infractions - the rent raise was caused by attainment of ESA. Would that be considered illegal?

    Thank you for all your help man!

    Edit: The rent was raised above the rent of other identical units in the quad.


    I do not have any multiplex where all my units are the same rent but ... Discriminating based on a service animal is a protected class. It is why I indicated if I wanted to get rid of a tenant I would raise the rent but that I was not referring to for a service animal. If a tenant can make a good case that the reason his rent is higher was only due to him having a service animal, they would have an outstanding case. With a range of rents in all my units in each complex, such a person with a service animal would likely not find it easy to show that the reason his rent was higher was solely due to having a service animal. However, I want people who legitimately need service animals to have their service animal. I have one tenant in a no pet unit that has a service animal and it is legit service animal. Their rent is $25 less than their neighbor who is a great tenant but has a slightly better/more secure location and $425 less than the 3rd tenant in the duplex that has a bigger unit and is not as great a tenant (more verifiable lease violations that we need to address as we become aware of them). To discourage bogus ESA we recently started using PetSecreening.com. We have only had one unit become available since using PetScreening.com but we had no applicant that claimed to have an ESA. We had a few come to the open house that indicated they had an ESA but none ended up applying. What bothers me about ESA is we have units that allow pets. The units we do not allow pets all have a reason we do not allow pets. Primary reason is there is no yard or only a shared yard. The law indicates that I must let ESA into my no pet units. My view is that they should be restricted to units that allow pets but be exempt from any fees. Their ESA would negatively impact my other tenants in my units that do not allow pets. I will say my one tenant that has the ESA in a non-pet unit is so good about the care that in his case there is virtually no impact. He cleans up after his dog right away and the interior of their unit is cleaner than most of our units. The other ESA tenant we have is in a unit that we allow pets so they are saving the pet rent and deposit only (and happen to be over our animal limit (2) but I suspect we could have been hard assed and required one of the other two dogs (pets) to vacate to add the ESA (a roommate situation)). In summary, if the tenant can make a good case that the reason their rent is higher is because they have an ESA then they have a good case because that is illegal.
  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
    7y

    As others have stated, ADA and ACAA are not relevant in this context.  ADAs have rules for libraries, hotels, restaurants etc...and ACAA (Air Carrier Access Act) governs the airlines and forced the airlines to allow passengers to fly with their pets (cough cough ESAs). FHA is what governs prohibited acts by landlords.

    Service Animals and ESAs are indeed different, but are lumped together due to these confusion, and because many people buy these $20 SA vests and put them on their pets, and start to walk them into libraries, restaurants, stores, clinics etc...and it's totally unfair to those who have a legit need since we as Landlords are so sick and tired of these ESA scammers.

  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
    7y

    I also have an uptick of faked ESAs in the past year.

    Usually people who themselves have no clear understanding of the laws.

    Applicant: "I have two dogs and two cats, all emotional animals, so they cannot be denied".

    Me: "What are emotional animals?  Are your animals emotional or you emotional"?

    During the application I explicitly ask them to fill in my ANIMAL section.  It asked about type, breed, age, color, weight, mature height, mature weight, name etc etc etc...It stated that the animal section covers pets, service animals, emotional support animals, working animals, therapy dogs.  ALL INCLUSIVE.  I also state that the application is going to be binded with the lease agreement so anything falsified will be grounds for termination of lease.  Any animals added after lease signing must be cleared and written permission obtained from landlord and information must be provided to landlord prior to occupancy so that landlord may verify and consult with property insurer.  If they pull the I've got an ESA a month into occupancy I will absolutely kick them out not for having an ESA but for not obtaining prior written permission.

    Having said that you can refuse ESA under FHA there are a number of exceptions such as if causes financial burden on you, if you have less than 3 properties, if you are living in one of the building apartments, I don't have the full list and wording but look it up.

    I also ask for verification from their doctors, but I can't insist.  Florida just had a bill (1128) a few months ago that looked like it was going to pass by requiring ESA to have their primary doctor endorsement then suddenly the bill died.  Sad...

    I also would make sure their faked ESA letters are active and current.  If inactive force them to pay again to get a new one.  Ask for vaccination records, ask for bite history, your insurer most likely need that.

  • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
    7y

    OK, so a lot of people are wondering, what does it take to get these online ESA endorsement letters?  HOW LOW IS THE BAR?  ARE THEY LEGIT?

    So I actually went ahead to one of those (there are MANY websites) and they do not even pretending because their websites says

    "AVOID PAYING ANY PET FEES"

    and "FLY WITH YOUR PET WITHOUT HASSLE"

    and "5 MINUTES TO TURN A PET INTO AN EMOTIONAL SUPPORT ANIMAL GURANTEED!!!"

    So bear with me a bit as I take you through the steps on what it takes.

    First, you are asked to enter some basic information, your name, age, gender, email address and whether you have a pet at this moment, what kind of pet and it's name.

    Next, you have to fill out a fairly long list of bogus questionnaire, basically to establish that you have some sort of "anxiety".  Here is such a questionnaire below.  Answers are Yes/No or scale from 1 to 5.

    Describe your feelings in the last 30 days

    • 1. Little interest or pleasure in doing things?
    • 2. Feeling down, depressed, or hopeless?
    • 3. Feeling more irritated, grouchy, or angry than usual?
    • 4. Sleeping less than usual, but still have a lot of energy?
    • 5. Starting lots more projects than usual or doing more risky things than usual?
    • 6. Feeling nervous, anxious, frightened, worried, or on edge?
    • 7. Feeling panic or being frightened?
    • 8. Avoiding situations that make you anxious?
    • 9. Unexplained aches and pains (e.g., head, back, joints, abdomen, legs)
    • 10.Feeling that your illnesses are not being taken seriously enough?
    • 11. Thoughts of actually hurting yourself?
    • 12. Hearing things other people couldn't hear, such as voices even when no one was around?
    • 13. Feeling that someone could hear your thoughts, or that you could hear what another person was thinking?
    • 14. Problems with sleep that affected your sleep quality over all?
    • 15. Problems with memory (e.g., learning new information) or with location (e.g., finding your way home)?
    • 16. Unpleasant thoughts, urges, or images that repeatedly enter your mind?
    • 17. Feeling driven to perform certain behaviors or mental acts over and over again?
    • 18. Feeling detached or distant from yourself, your body, your physical surroundings, or your memories?
    • 19. Not knowing who you really are or what you want out of life?
    • 20. Not feeling close to other people or enjoying your relationships with them?
    • 21. Drinking at least 4 drinks of any kind of alcohol in a single day?
    • 22. Smoking any cigarettes, a cigar, or pipe, or using snuff or chewing tobacco?
    • 23. Using any of the following medicines ON YOUR OWN, that is, without a doctor's prescription, in greater amounts or longer than prescribed [e.g., painkillers (like Vicodin), stimulants (like Ritalin or Adderall), sedatives or tranquilizers (like sleeping pills or Valium), or drugs like marijuana, cocaine or crack, club drugs (like ecstasy), hallucinogens (like LSD), heroin, inhalants or solvents (like glue), or methamphetamine (like speed)]?

    In the past 7 days

    • 1. I was irritated more than people knew.
    • 2. I felt angry.
    • 3. I felt like I was ready to explode.
    • 4. I was grouchy.
    • 5. I felt annoyed.

    Additional Question 1: Describe your happiness

    • I do not feel happier or more cheerful than usual.
    • I occasionally feel happier or more cheerful than usual.
    • I often feel happier or more cheerful than usual.
    • I feel happier or more cheerful than usual most of the time.
    • I feel happier of more cheerful than usual all of the time.

    Additional Question 2: Describe your confidence level

    • I do not feel more self-confident than usual.
    • I occasionally feel more self-confident than usual.
    • I often feel more self-confident than usual.
    • I frequently feel more self-confident than usual.
    • I feel extremely self-confident all of the time.

    Additional Question 3:Describe your sleeping patterns

    • I do not need less sleep than usual.
    • I occasionally need less sleep than usual.
    • I often need less sleep than usual.
    • I frequently need less sleep than usual.
    • I can go all day and all night without any sleep and still not feel tired.

    Additional Question 4: Describe your social skills

    • I do not talk more than usual.
    • I occasionally talk more than usual.
    • I often talk more than usual.
    • I frequently talk more than usual.
    • I talk constantly and cannot be interrupted.

    Additional Question 5: Describe your activity levels

    • I have not been more active (either socially, sexually, at work, home, or school) than usual.
    • I have occasionally been more active than usual.
    • I have often been more active than usual.
    • I have frequently been more active than usual.
    • I am constantly more active or on the go all the time.

    Additional Question 6: For Travel Letters - How will your pet be traveling with you?

    • Travel carrier
    • On my lap
    • At my feet
    • My pet will not be traveling

    Once these questions are answered, you are asked one more question.

    Describe the reasons why you need an Emotional Support Animal AND what specific symptoms you are hoping to alleviate by having your ESA with you.

    Get this, my answer to this question was "I want to avoid pet fees when moving to a new apartment and it would be great to go to restaurants with my pet". I wasn't kidding, that's what I entered.

    I hit NEXT, then it tells me I do qualify for ESA letter and asked me to pick a package and price.

    • Medical Licensed Therapist Endorsed Housing Letter
    • Mental health Professional Endorsed Travel Letter
    • Medical Licensed Therapist Endorsed Housing and Travel Combo Lette

    YUP, it's THAT easy.  Basically you self diagnosed and say you needed one, then you get a letter rubber stamped by a professional.

    • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
      7y

      Also, the reason ESA and true service animals are often lumped together in rental contexts is because HUD lumped them together as "assistance animals".

      The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) uses the term "assistance animal" to cover any animal that works, provides assistance, or performs tasks for the benefit of a person with a disability, or provides emotional support that alleviates one or more identified symptoms or effects of a person's disability. (FHEO Notice: FHEO-2013-01 at page 2). An emotional support animal is one type of assistance animal allowed as a reasonable accommodation to a residence with a "no pets" rule.

      Whats relevant here is HUD's FHA reasonable accomodations. Not ADA or ACAA.

    • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
      7y
      Originally posted by @Sam Leon:

      Also, the reason ESA and true service animals are often lumped together in rental contexts is because HUD lumped them together as "assistance animals".

      The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) uses the term "assistance animal" to cover any animal that works, provides assistance, or performs tasks for the benefit of a person with a disability, or provides emotional support that alleviates one or more identified symptoms or effects of a person's disability. (FHEO Notice: FHEO-2013-01 at page 2). An emotional support animal is one type of assistance animal allowed as a reasonable accommodation to a residence with a "no pets" rule.

      Whats relevant here is HUD's FHA reasonable accomodations. Not ADA or ACAA.


      A follow up question to my last post, in terms of how HUD has grouped service animals and ESA together and just put both under the umbrella of "assistance animals". Does that mean as far as HUD's fair housing is concerned, there is no distinction in their policies and guidelines on how SA and ESA owners are to be treated/screened/verified by landlords?

      I find that many applicants - most likely because they are not legit SA/ESA, use many terms interchangeably.

      "I have a support animal".

      "I have a service dog providing emotional support".

      "I have 2 dogs and 2 cats, all providing support and services".

      In these cases where you are not even sure what type it is, how far can a landlord inquire about the animal and what it does to the applicant without crossing any lines.

      I have often heard that for a service animal, the only questions one can ask are limited to (a) whether it's needed due to a disability and (b) what task is the animal been trained to perform.  That's it, and those two questions can only be asked when the disability or need is not obvious.  The rules are explicit, you "cannot ask about the person’s disability, require medical documentation, require a special identification card or training documentation for the dog, or ask that the dog demonstrate its ability to perform the work or task".  This is directly from the ADA web site.  But this is ADA, which covers public facilities like hotels, restaurants, libraries, stadiums etc...it doesn't govern rental properties.

      Yet HUD grouped SA and ESA into one class and does not seem to address the fact that SA and ESA are very different - a seeing eye dog is a true need and is trained to provide such service, an ESA is untrained and 99% of the time is a stun to get into pet free housing. Do we as landlords need to treat the two groups of animals differently because HUD doesn't?

      Specifically. do you adhere to the ADA's service animal guidelines because HUD doesn't have one - as far as what you can and cannot ask just to be on the safe side?

      I see many landlords ask for ESA documentation such as a verifiable actively licensed MHCP's prescription for the ESA, myself included. I kept wondering if this is allowed by HUD for all assistance animals, does it mean we are allowed to ask for medical documentation if an applicant claim to have a service dog and it's not obvious to us why, and would like to see documentation?



    • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2017 · 319 posts · 330 votes
      7y

      I do believe that, at most, they can only request an accommodation for one animal per person. So, one person with four pets is right out. 

    • Investor · Fort Lauderdale, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 465 votes
      7y
      Originally posted by @Russ B.:

      I do believe that, at most, they can only request an accommodation for one animal per person. So, one person with four pets is right out. 

      Not necessarily.  While I think 99% of the ESA claims are total BS, I cannot deny more than one animal out right.

      You can certainly have a service animal and an emotional animal.  A person that's blind needing a seeing eye dog and also some sort of anxiety disorder needing an ESA, and are two different animals.

      While this is unlikely, I did have several inquiries recently from potential applicants saying they have multiple service animals.  The main issue here is they don't even know the different between service animals and ESA, they are mostly likely repeating what their friends told them "just say you have service animals and they will back off".  So when I told them I gladly accept service animals and emotional support animals, then went on to tell them their respective definitions and how I just need to have them provide a doctor's letter for me to call and verify, they never bother to follow through with the application.

      But going back to whether multiple ESAs are legal, I did a search and there doesn't seem to be specific clauses on HUD about whether multiple assistance animals are OK, but I found this:

      Michigan State College Of Law Animal Legal and Historical Center FAQ on ESA

      At least this is the interpretation from a legal profession and on item #14 of the FAQ:

      14. Can a person have more than one service or emotional support animal?

      While there do not seem to be any cases dealing with the issue of multiple emotional support animals, the basic requirements for this reasonable accommodation would still be the same. In other words, if a person were claiming the need for multiple emotional support animals, then he or she would need documentation supporting this need from his or her physician or medical professional. The practitioner would need to provide documentation that each support animal alleviated some symptom of the disability.

       So I guess technically one person can have multiple ESAs as long as the doctor treating the patient prescribe that.

      One other thing I found while reading through this FAQ is the following.

      17. What about the emotional support animals/assistance animals of my guests?

      HUD does not cover this issue specifically in its notice to housing providers. However, the underlying purpose of the FHA is provide an equal opportunity to use and enjoy housing regardless of disability. If a tenant cannot have a particular guest over who uses a service or assistance animal, then the tenant may be deprived of the ability to use and enjoy his or her dwelling based on the presence of a disability. There do not yet appear any published legal cases that have reviewed this issue. In 2011, the United States District Court for the District of Nevada entered a consent decree (a settlement of a lawsuit where a party agrees to take an action without admitting liability) on a this issue. The complaint in the underlying case alleged that the defendants declined to allow a friend of their tenants who uses a service animal to visit the tenants' apartment. The defendants then evicted the tenants based on the service animal's presence in the apartment. As plaintiff, the United States alleged that this denied the tenants the "full enjoyment of their apartment at Defendants' apartment building." See U.S. v. DeAngeli, Case No. 3:11-CV-00796-RCJ-WGC (July 8. 2013), available at http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/crt/legacy/2013/10/30/deangelisettle.pdf. As part of the agreement, the defendants had to agree to comply with the Fair Housing Act, create a policy for assistance animals in their apartment building, undergo education and training on the issue, and abide by other requirements of the consent decree.

      I am more worried about a guest's ESA.  You can't screen a guest.  So if your lease allows a guest to stay for say 7 days a month, technically you have to allow that guest who has an ESA to visit with an ESA without your having an opportunity to verify.  As a matter of fact, your tenant may have a dozen close friends all having ESAs who visit from time to time.  How would any Landlord do?  There is really no defense against such abuse because there is no clause you can put in the lease to prevent that and there is no verification possible to guard against it.  

    Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.