Service Animals & Emotional support- Is animal restriction dead?

Service Animals & Emotional support- Is animal restriction dead?

Real Estate Broker 路 Watertown, NY 路 Member since 2016 路 1k+ posts 路 1k+ votes

Hey guys,

Is anyone noticing a huge uptick in the amount of people applying for apartments who have service and emotional support animals?  In just the last 3 months, I swear 7/10 people have had one of the two.  I even had one applicant tell me they had 4 service dogs!  Literally a small gang of dogs surrounding them at all times.

I have no issues with people who have these, but it feels like it's getting to the point where EVERYONE has one.  We even have to disregard our insurance companies strict breed restrictions and risk being canceled if there's ever a claim.

What's everyone doing to offset the risks that are being forced upon us with this new phenomenon?  Obviously animal proofing during the rehab is one, but what else?

4Reply
264 views

Most Popular Reply

Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Broker 路 Cody, WY 路 Member since 2010 路 28k+ posts 路 41k+ votes
7y

@Jennifer J. you can't charge a deposit, no pet rent, nothing.

I've studied this issue for almost ten years and it's definitely getting worse and the government is doing nothing to help. Some states have instituted penalties for anyone falsely claiming an emotional support animal or service animal but they provide no guidance on how to file a complaint.

The easiest solution is to hand this over to www.PetScreening.com and let them deal with it. Their service is 100% free to the Landlord so why not let them do the work? They are experts in the law and will at least weed out most of the fraudsters, which takes care of about 60% of them. The remainder may make it past the screening but at least you'll have their animal information on file and can ensure it's kept current.

Virtually anyone can "prescribe" an emotional support animal. Psychologist, family doctor, family counselor, marriage counselor, and even a pastor. It needn't be a licensed medical practitioner and they're not required to have any medical training that qualifies them to identify the emotional "disability" that the individual suffers from. You feel sad? Get a dog! Things going poorly at work? Get a dog! You heard someone died in the war zone 27 miles from your location? Get a dog!

The most interesting part is that these people suffering from disabling emotional problems are usually not seeking any form of treatment. They see a doctor or counselor once, get a dog prescription, and then never go back. Why? Because they don't actually have a disability and they're not actually trying to heal anything. They just want their pet. 

Even though the animal is essentially considered a medical device in the eyes of the law, they still have to meet basic responsibilities like keeping it leashed, not allowing it to damage the property, cleaning up after it, keeping it quiet, not letting it threaten others, etc. I recently kicked someone out because their ESA lunged and snapped at two different people on two different occasions. If the animal does not abide by the rules, you can absolutely require them to remove it.

The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

86 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker 路 Los Angeles, CA 路 Member since 2017 路 658 posts 路 293 votes
    7y

    @Ned J.

    I hear you. As far as insurance goes, what does your attorney say to requiring them to get renters insurance? There are companies that cover all breeds. As far as nuisance, I think you nailed it. The law says we must accept the pet even when not allowed, but what does your attorney say about them being a nuisance? Seems like they should be held to the same standards of the lease as everyone else. 

    I like to take the route of working with a loud animal rather than forcing someone to give p their home. There are always ways to build rapport and if it comes to it, take action. 

  • Investor 路 Eagan, MN 路 Member since 2014 路 86 posts 路 58 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:

    The first thing to do is to know what laws apply to you federally and locally. 

    Federal: you're mostly looking at FHA (Fair Housing Act) and ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act).

    FHA doesn't apply to you if you have a quadplex or less and live in one of the units (i.e. "house hacking"). Also doesn't apply to you if you have SFHs (3 or less) and rent them out yourself (i.e. you don't use a property management service).

    ADA: doesn't cover "emotional support animals" at all. You can ask for documentation of proof of necessity of a service animal if the disability is not apparent or known to the landlord - i.e., you can't ask someone who's blind for documentation that they need a seeing-eye dog, but you can ask for proof for someone who claims the need based on something not obvious - epileptic seizure, for example. 

    Beyond that, you need to know your local laws. Personally, I think too many landlords just shiver in their boots about the threat of lawsuits. You just need to go into landlording knowing that you might one day have to go to court. The likelihood that you *will* get sued is ridiculously small, even by scammers claiming ESAs or other things. That's way too much trouble for most people who are just trying to smuggle in Fido or Bootsie. 

     There is no documentation for a service animal, an you cannot require it.  Only on an ESA animal can you.  You can only ask two questions, by law, of a service animal owner.

    Is the animal medically necessary?

    What service does the dog provide?

    If they answer yes to the first question, and "medical Alert" to the second question, you are done.  You cannot ask for papers.  You cannot ask what the disability is.  You do not need to know if it is for seizures, depression, diabetic, hearing, medication alert, PTSD, etc.  HIPAA prevents you from knowing.

    In situations where it is not obvious that the dog is a service animal, staff may ask only two specific questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability? and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform? Staff are not allowed to request any documentation for the dog, require that the dog demonstrate its task, or inquire about the nature of the person's disability.

    https://www.ada.gov/regs2010/service_animal_qa.html

  • Investor 路 Jacksonville, FL 路 Member since 2015 路 76 posts 路 22 votes
    7y

    @Michael Ablan yes there is a huge increase and a huge increase in fake service animals which is sad. The answer is 3rd party pet screening. There is currently only one good option I know of right now, www.petscreening.com they do a great job.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire 路 Northeast, TN 路 Member since 2015 路 10k+ posts 路 17k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Eric D.:
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:

    The first thing to do is to know what laws apply to you federally and locally. 

    Federal: you're mostly looking at FHA (Fair Housing Act) and ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act).

    FHA doesn't apply to you if you have a quadplex or less and live in one of the units (i.e. "house hacking"). Also doesn't apply to you if you have SFHs (3 or less) and rent them out yourself (i.e. you don't use a property management service).

    ADA: doesn't cover "emotional support animals" at all. You can ask for documentation of proof of necessity of a service animal if the disability is not apparent or known to the landlord - i.e., you can't ask someone who's blind for documentation that they need a seeing-eye dog, but you can ask for proof for someone who claims the need based on something not obvious - epileptic seizure, for example. 

    Beyond that, you need to know your local laws. Personally, I think too many landlords just shiver in their boots about the threat of lawsuits. You just need to go into landlording knowing that you might one day have to go to court. The likelihood that you *will* get sued is ridiculously small, even by scammers claiming ESAs or other things. That's way too much trouble for most people who are just trying to smuggle in Fido or Bootsie. 

     There is no documentation for a service animal, an you cannot require it.  Only on an ESA animal can you.  You can only ask two questions, by law, of a service animal owner.

    Is the animal medically necessary?

    What service does the dog provide?

    If they answer yes to the first question, and "medical Alert" to the second question, you are done.  You cannot ask for papers.  You cannot ask what the disability is.  You do not need to know if it is for seizures, depression, diabetic, hearing, medication alert, PTSD, etc.  HIPAA prevents you from knowing.

    In situations where it is not obvious that the dog is a service animal, staff may ask only two specific questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability? and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform? Staff are not allowed to request any documentation for the dog, require that the dog demonstrate its task, or inquire about the nature of the person's disability.

    https://www.ada.gov/regs2010/service_animal_qa.html

    I'm sorry, but you are wrong. What you say is true of *staff* of a business establishment that is not a place the individual intends to reside. Directly from the HUD directive on service animals:

    Housing providers may ask individuals who have disabilities that are not readily apparent or known to the provider to submit reliable documentation of a disability and their disability-related need for an assistance animal. If the disability is readily apparent or known but the disability-related need for the assistance animal is not, the housing provider may ask the individual to provide documentation of the disability-related need for an assistance animal.

    If you had read a little further, you would have found that information. A waiter stopping someone cannot ask for that proof, but a landlord absolutely can. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Verde Valley Arizona USA 路 Member since 2018 路 115 posts 路 98 votes
    7y

    @Greg M.If you think the government is going to solve this, you are sadly mistaken.  Here in Arizona the residential landlord tenant act states that the only Service Animals are dogs or miniature horses and doesn't mention Emotional Support Animals (ESA's) at all.

    The rules for ESA's come from the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)  @JD Martin mentioned the wording exactly.

  • Investor 路 Eagan, MN 路 Member since 2014 路 86 posts 路 58 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:
    Originally posted by @Eric D.:
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:

    The first thing to do is to know what laws apply to you federally and locally. 

    Federal: you're mostly looking at FHA (Fair Housing Act) and ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act).

    FHA doesn't apply to you if you have a quadplex or less and live in one of the units (i.e. "house hacking"). Also doesn't apply to you if you have SFHs (3 or less) and rent them out yourself (i.e. you don't use a property management service).

    ADA: doesn't cover "emotional support animals" at all. You can ask for documentation of proof of necessity of a service animal if the disability is not apparent or known to the landlord - i.e., you can't ask someone who's blind for documentation that they need a seeing-eye dog, but you can ask for proof for someone who claims the need based on something not obvious - epileptic seizure, for example. 

    Beyond that, you need to know your local laws. Personally, I think too many landlords just shiver in their boots about the threat of lawsuits. You just need to go into landlording knowing that you might one day have to go to court. The likelihood that you *will* get sued is ridiculously small, even by scammers claiming ESAs or other things. That's way too much trouble for most people who are just trying to smuggle in Fido or Bootsie. 

     There is no documentation for a service animal, an you cannot require it.  Only on an ESA animal can you.  You can only ask two questions, by law, of a service animal owner.

    Is the animal medically necessary?

    What service does the dog provide?

    If they answer yes to the first question, and "medical Alert" to the second question, you are done.  You cannot ask for papers.  You cannot ask what the disability is.  You do not need to know if it is for seizures, depression, diabetic, hearing, medication alert, PTSD, etc.  HIPAA prevents you from knowing.

    In situations where it is not obvious that the dog is a service animal, staff may ask only two specific questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability? and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform? Staff are not allowed to request any documentation for the dog, require that the dog demonstrate its task, or inquire about the nature of the person's disability.

    https://www.ada.gov/regs2010/service_animal_qa.html

    I'm sorry, but you are wrong. What you say is true of *staff* of a business establishment that is not a place the individual intends to reside. Directly from the HUD directive on service animals:

    Housing providers may ask individuals who have disabilities that are not readily apparent or known to the provider to submit reliable documentation of a disability and their disability-related need for an assistance animal. If the disability is readily apparent or known but the disability-related need for the assistance animal is not, the housing provider may ask the individual to provide documentation of the disability-related need for an assistance animal.

    If you had read a little further, you would have found that information. A waiter stopping someone cannot ask for that proof, but a landlord absolutely can. 

    Interesting discussion.  I have read the ADA stuff quite a bit over the years, and to me it is a very gray area.  You cannot ask to get access to medical records, and I would assume requesting to see a document with medical information on it is "medical records".  If a tenant was in the service, and says they have an PTSD dog, what documentation are they required to show?  Or if you can see they have an insulin syringe, and they say it is an insulin dog, is that enough?  You know the disability at that point.

    What documentation are you legally allowed to get, and what will that documentation actually show? How do you know it is real? Can you call the letter writer, if it is indeed a letter, and ask if it is real?

    None of that is required is defined in the law.

    I allow dogs, so the risk of a suit is not worth $25 a month. I can raise the rent that much extra at the next lease signing. When all a tenant has to do is make a phone call to HUD, or to a "ESA Certificate giver", it is not a battle that I am willing to fight.

    I would much rather limit kids, however that is indeed illegal.

    A housing provider also may not ask an applicant or tenant to provide access to medical records or medical providers or provide detailed or extensive information or documentation of a person's physical or mental impairments. Like all reasonable accommodation requests, the determination of whether a person has a disability-related need for an assistance animal involves an individualized assessment. A request for a reasonable accommodation may not be unreasonably denied, or conditioned on payment of a fee or deposit or other terms and conditions applied to applicants or residents with pets, and a response may not be unreasonably delayed. Persons with disabilities who believe a request for a reasonable accommodation has been improperly denied may file a complaint with HUD.  https://www.animallaw.info/sites/default/files/FHEO_notice_assistance_animals2013.pdf

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire 路 Northeast, TN 路 Member since 2015 路 10k+ posts 路 17k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Eric D.:
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:
    Originally posted by @Eric D.:
    Originally posted by @JD Martin:

    The first thing to do is to know what laws apply to you federally and locally. 

    Federal: you're mostly looking at FHA (Fair Housing Act) and ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act).

    FHA doesn't apply to you if you have a quadplex or less and live in one of the units (i.e. "house hacking"). Also doesn't apply to you if you have SFHs (3 or less) and rent them out yourself (i.e. you don't use a property management service).

    ADA: doesn't cover "emotional support animals" at all. You can ask for documentation of proof of necessity of a service animal if the disability is not apparent or known to the landlord - i.e., you can't ask someone who's blind for documentation that they need a seeing-eye dog, but you can ask for proof for someone who claims the need based on something not obvious - epileptic seizure, for example. 

    Beyond that, you need to know your local laws. Personally, I think too many landlords just shiver in their boots about the threat of lawsuits. You just need to go into landlording knowing that you might one day have to go to court. The likelihood that you *will* get sued is ridiculously small, even by scammers claiming ESAs or other things. That's way too much trouble for most people who are just trying to smuggle in Fido or Bootsie. 

     There is no documentation for a service animal, an you cannot require it.  Only on an ESA animal can you.  You can only ask two questions, by law, of a service animal owner.

    Is the animal medically necessary?

    What service does the dog provide?

    If they answer yes to the first question, and "medical Alert" to the second question, you are done.  You cannot ask for papers.  You cannot ask what the disability is.  You do not need to know if it is for seizures, depression, diabetic, hearing, medication alert, PTSD, etc.  HIPAA prevents you from knowing.

    In situations where it is not obvious that the dog is a service animal, staff may ask only two specific questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability? and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform? Staff are not allowed to request any documentation for the dog, require that the dog demonstrate its task, or inquire about the nature of the person's disability.

    https://www.ada.gov/regs2010/service_animal_qa.html

    I'm sorry, but you are wrong. What you say is true of *staff* of a business establishment that is not a place the individual intends to reside. Directly from the HUD directive on service animals:

    Housing providers may ask individuals who have disabilities that are not readily apparent or known to the provider to submit reliable documentation of a disability and their disability-related need for an assistance animal. If the disability is readily apparent or known but the disability-related need for the assistance animal is not, the housing provider may ask the individual to provide documentation of the disability-related need for an assistance animal.

    If you had read a little further, you would have found that information. A waiter stopping someone cannot ask for that proof, but a landlord absolutely can. 

    Interesting discussion.  I have read the ADA stuff quite a bit over the years, and to me it is a very gray area.  You cannot ask to get access to medical records, and I would assume requesting to see a document with medical information on it is "medical records".  If a tenant was in the service, and says they have an PTSD dog, what documentation are they required to show?  Or if you can see they have an insulin syringe, and they say it is an insulin dog, is that enough?  You know the disability at that point.

    What documentation are you legally allowed to get, and what will that documentation actually show? How do you know it is real? Can you call the letter writer, if it is indeed a letter, and ask if it is real?

    None of that is required is defined in the law.

    I allow dogs, so the risk of a suit is not worth $25 a month. I can raise the rent that much extra at the next lease signing. When all a tenant has to do is make a phone call to HUD, or to a "ESA Certificate giver", it is not a battle that I am willing to fight.

    I would much rather limit kids, however that is indeed illegal.

    A housing provider also may not ask an applicant or tenant to provide access to medical records or medical providers or provide detailed or extensive information or documentation of a person's physical or mental impairments. Like all reasonable accommodation requests, the determination of whether a person has a disability-related need for an assistance animal involves an individualized assessment. A request for a reasonable accommodation may not be unreasonably denied, or conditioned on payment of a fee or deposit or other terms and conditions applied to applicants or residents with pets, and a response may not be unreasonably delayed. Persons with disabilities who believe a request for a reasonable accommodation has been improperly denied may file a complaint with HUD.  https://www.animallaw.info/sites/default/files/FHEO_notice_assistance_animals2013.pdf

     Ha! I'm with you on the kids thing, and yes that is illegal 馃槀

    I agree with you in that the simple answer is not prohibiting pets one way or the other, and if you have a person that is likely to be a problem, disqualify them for some reason other than the service animal/esa. Luckily for us, most people who are going to be obnoxious PITA's have something else on their background/application that would lead one to choose a different applicant. 

    And, at the end of the day, don't shiver in your boots about the threat of lawsuit. I was once sued by the EEOC as part of my official capacity at the city, and won that one. 99% of people who threaten to sue are full of hot air and don't have two nickels to rub together to get a lawyer, or someone to take their case. My strategy in real estate is the same as my strategy in life and my job: always make the other guy appear to be the unreasonable A*. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Investor 路 Eagan, MN 路 Member since 2014 路 86 posts 路 58 votes
    7y

    In the end, it's all about tenant quality.  Good pets follow good tenants.  Or at least the good tenants will pay for damages.

  • Member since 2019 路 2 posts 路 0 votes
    7y

    @Michael Ablan, I agree with the fees. As for regulations, the only way is for insurance lobbying to make that happen. That should be the only way landlords will get fair treatment with the law and insurance requirements. Pet owners will have to think twice about cost for the risks of damages before getting one.

    People that have legitimate use of ESA should insurance as well. Not sure if that is he case currently. Owning animals is a privilege not a right, with this privilege comes responsibility.

  • Rental Property Investor 路 Los Angeles, CA 路 Member since 2017 路 2k+ posts 路 5k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Henry Kaldenbaugh:

    @Greg M.If you think the government is going to solve this, you are sadly mistaken.  Here in Arizona the residential landlord tenant act states that the only Service Animals are dogs or miniature horses and doesn't mention Emotional Support Animals (ESA's) at all.

    The rules for ESA's come from the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)  @JD Martin mentioned the wording exactly.

    Other than my general distrust of our government being able to get anything done, I have no reason to believe that they will not take up the issue of ESA's as more notice of this fraud gets made public. When the general public starts to understand that people are pretending to be disabled to get special treatment, there will be public outrage and the lawmakers will act.

    The rules for ESA's does not come from the ADA, they are covered under the Fair Housing Act (Section 5). Landlords are required to make reasonable accommodations to individuals with disabilities and this includes mental or emotional disability which an animal that provides emotional support falls under. 

    The only service animals are dogs or miniature horses is directly from the ADA, but may be mirrored by Arizona law.

  • Rental Property Investor 路 Springfield, MO 路 Member since 2017 路 266 posts 路 312 votes
    7y

    What if I (as the landlord) have a condition that prevents me from entering my rental due to pet hair or dander? If I was extremely allergic to animal hair to the extent that just a few minutes inside would cause a severe reaction? I know this is out there a bit, but don't I have the right as the owner to enter my own property without fear of physical harm?

    At what point does the tenant's rights to a pet override my right to manage my business?

  • Rental Property Investor 路 Los Angeles, CA 路 Member since 2017 路 2k+ posts 路 5k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Guy Yoes:

    At what point does the tenant's rights to a pet override my right to manage my business?

    When it is no longer a reasonable accommodation. And not pet, but an ESA. Would it be unreasonable for you to find someone else to enter the unit to do an inspection or repair a problem? Probably not. 

    Now if you had a building that was specifically designed to house people who had pet allergies and you took active steps to rid the building of these allergens, then you could refuse the ESA. 

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent 路 Washington, D.C. 路 Member since 2012 路 17k+ posts 路 30k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Greg M.:

    People (LANDLORDS) need to stop lumping Service Animals and Emotional Support Animals together when talking about them. Anyone who knows the difference is going to look at you like you are clueless or a jackass who hates disabled people. 

    Service Animals are highly trained and somewhat rare to encounter. They are the equivalent of a wheelchair or grab bar or blood sugar measuring equipment for a disabled person. They are a safety/mobility/medical device. 

    Emotional Support Animals are 98% a scam. They make you feel better. There are people who legitimately benefit from having a pet around, but most just want a pet.

    The only way this ESA abuse is going to stop is if Congress passes a law or directs HUD to outline true requirements for an animal to be called an ESA. Who here has written their Congresscritter?

    You should familiarize your self with HUD guidelines on enforcement of the Fair Housing Act. ESAs as defined by FHA are in fact service animals, and there are already laws and regulations on the subject. Reference HUD guidance memo FHEO-2013-01.

  • Russell BrazilBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Agent 路 Washington, D.C. 路 Member since 2012 路 17k+ posts 路 30k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Henry Kaldenbaugh:

    @Greg M.If you think the government is going to solve this, you are sadly mistaken.  Here in Arizona the residential landlord tenant act states that the only Service Animals are dogs or miniature horses and doesn't mention Emotional Support Animals (ESA's) at all.

    The rules for ESA's come from the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)  @JD Martin mentioned the wording exactly.

     The ADA is not the applicable law for housing. ADA applies to public accommodations...hotels, office buildings....it is not applicable to residential real estate. The applicable law is the Fair Housing Act (and its later ammendments.) The 2 laws use the same term, service animal, but have 2 entirely different definitions of that term. So the definition under ADA has nothing to do with FHAs definition or applicability. 

  • Investor 路 Eagan, MN 路 Member since 2014 路 86 posts 路 58 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Guy Yoes:

    What if I (as the landlord) have a condition that prevents me from entering my rental due to pet hair or dander? If I was extremely allergic to animal hair to the extent that just a few minutes inside would cause a severe reaction? I know this is out there a bit, but don't I have the right as the owner to enter my own property without fear of physical harm?

    At what point does the tenant's rights to a pet override my right to manage my business?

     What if you had a phobia about people with a hook for a hand?  Could you discriminate against that?

    It is the same answer as the ESA/Service dog.

  • Rental Property Investor 路 Springfield, MO 路 Member since 2017 路 266 posts 路 312 votes
    7y

    It鈥檚 not a phobia it鈥檚 a health issue.   A person could wear a hazmat suit I guess.  The question is ... should a tenants right supersede the rights of the owner?  Where is the line? We have pets and allow pets but I should have rights as well. Thinking I may sell the properties and invest in more notes and tax liens. No worries that way (or law suits). 

  • Investor 路 Milwaukee, WI 路 Member since 2013 路 1k+ posts 路 1k+ votes
    7y

    Fun read.

    I have not yet encountered a disabled person simply because, they are few in number. When I finally do, I will have zero issues providing reasonable accommodations and welcoming them to my property. I suppose I feel a human obligation to help out those less fortunate when the circumstance falls at my feet.

    As far as the ESA's? Give me a break. How about a little dose of get the F over it? Sunshine, exercise and Vitamin D work wonders. Further, how is the mental health of the people now the landlords problem? How is it that the go-to solution is becoming a pet? What about therapy? Meds? What about our property rights? It's a big fat BS sandwich.

    The thing to do really, is to start speaking out and making a stink over such nonsense. Make our opinions on the idiocy known. Shame people for being so pathetic and placing their emotional problems, that have numerous and effective alternate solutions, on our feet. Controlling the narrative is a powerful thing. So is controlling ones own mind and thoughts. If we allow this trend to continue, which will lead to essentially allowing pets all the time, rents will simply increase to cover the inevitable losses.

  • Verde Valley Arizona USA 路 Member since 2018 路 115 posts 路 98 votes
    7y

    @Russell Brazil I can't agree more but the inventive tenant will use the ADA if it helps them.  This scares the PM's and lawyers.

  • Investor 路 Spokane Valley, WA 路 Member since 2014 路 175 posts 路 94 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Michael Ablan:

    @David Stumpf -  This is my first time hearing of this website!  Seems promising!  Have you used it?

    I am currently in the midst of trying to use this service with one of my tenants and while the idea/concept is awesome, the execution is not so great. So far it's been over a month without them giving a "decision". They asked the tenant for vaccination records which she says she's tried to upload but it "doesn't work". So now i either have to A) try to play mr. fixit and assist them with the process, B) Just give up and let them have the ESA without continuing the due diligence C) deny the ESA and likely get a lawsuit against me.

  • Investor 路 Spokane Valley, WA 路 Member since 2014 路 175 posts 路 94 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    Fun read.

    I have not yet encountered a disabled person simply because, they are few in number. When I finally do, I will have zero issues providing reasonable accommodations and welcoming them to my property. I suppose I feel a human obligation to help out those less fortunate when the circumstance falls at my feet.

    As far as the ESA's? Give me a break. How about a little dose of get the F over it? Sunshine, exercise and Vitamin D work wonders. Further, how is the mental health of the people now the landlords problem? How is it that the go-to solution is becoming a pet? What about therapy? Meds? What about our property rights? It's a big fat BS sandwich.

    The thing to do really, is to start speaking out and making a stink over such nonsense. Make our opinions on the idiocy known. Shame people for being so pathetic and placing their emotional problems, that have numerous and effective alternate solutions, on our feet. Controlling the narrative is a powerful thing. So is controlling ones own mind and thoughts. If we allow this trend to continue, which will lead to essentially allowing pets all the time, rents will simply increase to cover the inevitable losses.

    The trouble with this is that everybody today LOVES to grab a pitchfork whenever they see someone not being "sympathetic". So if you were to voice that opinion and start gaining any sort of traction, you'd quickly become a target. Unfortunately playing the victim is far easier than defending oneself from "attacking" said victim. My prediction is that it gets significantly worse before it gets better. I am fairly certain it will be well past public knowledge before anything is done about it, if anything is done at all.

    Nobody has sympathies for us "greedy landlords", especially not when we're up against the "poor mistreated tenant that just needs her attention cat". And if said cat destroys our property? Then i guess that's just our fault and is what we should expect since we wanted to be in this business.

  • Investor 路 Milwaukee, WI 路 Member since 2013 路 1k+ posts 路 1k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Shane H.:
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    Fun read.

    I have not yet encountered a disabled person simply because, they are few in number. When I finally do, I will have zero issues providing reasonable accommodations and welcoming them to my property. I suppose I feel a human obligation to help out those less fortunate when the circumstance falls at my feet.

    As far as the ESA's? Give me a break. How about a little dose of get the F over it? Sunshine, exercise and Vitamin D work wonders. Further, how is the mental health of the people now the landlords problem? How is it that the go-to solution is becoming a pet? What about therapy? Meds? What about our property rights? It's a big fat BS sandwich.

    The thing to do really, is to start speaking out and making a stink over such nonsense. Make our opinions on the idiocy known. Shame people for being so pathetic and placing their emotional problems, that have numerous and effective alternate solutions, on our feet. Controlling the narrative is a powerful thing. So is controlling ones own mind and thoughts. If we allow this trend to continue, which will lead to essentially allowing pets all the time, rents will simply increase to cover the inevitable losses.

    The trouble with this is that everybody today LOVES to grab a pitchfork whenever they see someone not being "sympathetic". So if you were to voice that opinion and start gaining any sort of traction, you'd quickly become a target. Unfortunately playing the victim is far easier than defending oneself from "attacking" said victim. My prediction is that it gets significantly worse before it gets better. I am fairly certain it will be well past public knowledge before anything is done about it, if anything is done at all.

    Nobody has sympathies for us "greedy landlords", especially not when we're up against the "poor mistreated tenant that just needs her attention cat". And if said cat destroys our property? Then i guess that's just our fault and is what we should expect since we wanted to be in this business.

    Sticks and stones.

    The squeaky wheel gets the grease.

    If landlords say and do nothing, our fate will be dictated by others who are more courageous to voice an opinion. That my friend, is how the world works.

    The politicians favorite race is the one where they go unopposed.

    But I keep faith. While common sense and truth are often eluded, they are also forces to be reckoned with. I say speak the truth always and most often the truth will prevail. The truth of this matter is, people have options for mental health therapy that does not infringe on the property rights of landlords. That is the narrative we all need to present to the world. That last thing we should do is stick our heads in the sand and hope it goes away.

  • Rental Property Investor 路 CA 路 Member since 2018 路 135 posts 路 174 votes
    7y

    Wrote this as a reply on another post, but this thread is bigger so i figured i'd plug it here as well:

    I know you have to be very careful and not discriminate against a tenant based on their ESA, but what about not renewing the lease after it is up?

    Lets say you have a tenant that is month to month, no ESA, another tenant shows interest in your property and you decide that this new person is a better fit. Since you contract is month to month, you should have no problem giving your current resident a 30 (or 60) day notice and move them out. Right?

    Now add an ESA to the mix. What changes? If you dont explicitly state that you are not continuing business with that person due to their ESA - should be no issue. Right?

    P.S.

    I have never dealt with this issue, thus i have no experience. I could be completely wrong. Just looking for input.

    Thanks.

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor 路 Poway, CA 路 Member since 2015 路 7k+ posts 路 8k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Pavel Shemyakin:

    Wrote this as a reply on another post, but this thread is bigger so i figured i'd plug it here as well:

    I know you have to be very careful and not discriminate against a tenant based on their ESA, but what about not renewing the lease after it is up?

    Lets say you have a tenant that is month to month, no ESA, another tenant shows interest in your property and you decide that this new person is a better fit. Since you contract is month to month, you should have no problem giving your current resident a 30 (or 60) day notice and move them out. Right?

    Now add an ESA to the mix. What changes? If you dont explicitly state that you are not continuing business with that person due to their ESA - should be no issue. Right?

    P.S.

    I have never dealt with this issue, thus i have no experience. I could be completely wrong. Just looking for input.

    Thanks.


    Not renewing a lease is not an eviction but lay people refer to it as an eviction. LL terminating a tenant, regardless of it being the end of the lease, garners sympathy. What we do when we want to get rid of a tenant (any tenant - not stating this would be for an ESA) is simply raise the rent above market. The tenant may think we are clueless to what the market rent is. Raise the rent enough above market and either 1) they will give their notice or 2) you are getting compensated for what ever makes them an less than desirable tenant. It is tough for the tenant to complain about having to move when they are the ones that chose to move rather than pay the requested rent. My family has never terminated a rental relationship for any reason other than missed payment. We started in the 1970s. We have also never had a tenant complain about needing to vacate because it was either due to their failure to pay or because they gave us notice. This is less an option where the rent control limits rent increases such that typically you cannot raise the rent to get it even to market rate. BTW I used petScreening.com for the first time on a unit that had tenant placed Sept 1 (last weekend). I think just the process of requiring perspective tenants to go to the website and document their ESA eliminated any ESA applicants. We had a few people who came to see the place tell us they had an ESA. We informed them what was required (i.e. animal profile on PetScreening.com who would make any decision regarding ESA) and voila, none of them applied. I do not really know how good PetScreening.com is at eliminating bogus ESA that actually register with their site (but they did send me an email with their claimed rate of rejection) but simply requiring the tenant to use the site I believe leads some tenants with bogus ESAs to look elsewhere. Good luck
  • Los Angeles, CA 路 Member since 2013 路 555 posts 路 261 votes
    7y

    I was looking into how easy it is to get an ESA letter online, and some places say the applicant needs to talk to a mental health professional before they will issue a letter.

    Do they actually connect you with a licensed mental health professional who takes your history and truly assesses the mental illness, or is it all lies?

    For $20, I'm going to guess that an applicant never speaks to anyone about jack.

    if they just grant everyone an ESA letter without professional assessment, that's fraud, and we should report that garbage to the FTC or whatever government authority takes care of this crap.

  • Rental Property Investor 路 CA 路 Member since 2018 路 135 posts 路 174 votes
    7y

    @Dan H. Great strategy!!! Thanks for the tip!

    @Mike Franco I agree.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.