Rental Property Investor · Pittsburgh, PA · Member since 2016 · 28 posts · 10 votes
I have a tenant that paid security deposit and half months rent on house they didnt see in person as they were moving across country, lease signed as well. They get here and apparently cant fit furniture upstairs and want to go somewhere else. What do I do?
I have 2 month penalty in lease...do I enforce that? Just let them go?
It's difficult to hold them to the terms because you failed to set the expectations up front.
I rent to dozens of people every year that are moving from other states. I give them a verbal and written warning before accepting any money from them:
If they show up and decide they don't like the neighborhood, their furniture doesn't fit, the rental isn't cleaned to their standard, or whatever, it's 100% on them and they will accept it or pay the penalty.
Now, I'm not a slumlord and I don't try to take advantage of anyone. We are very, very clear about our rentals. We offer a video chat and walk them through or around the property. We will often take measurements of rooms and share that with prospects so they better understand room size. And I do a pretty good job of making sure rentals are clean.
Because I warn them so heavily up front, I rarely get a complaint. When I do get someone that just can't follow through, I have no problem charging the penalty and I can't remember the last time someone complained about that.
I'd keep a deposit then refund the rest once it's rented again.
We sold a home that the young couple spent a lot of time measuring & having it inspected by the friends & family.
After they moved in you literally could barely walk through the living room, basement or from the ground floor bedroom into the ensuite bathroom. They put their huge xmas tree in front of the kitchen island rendering it useless.
We have another large 2 bed/2 bath unit that the young kids have packed with 'stuff', they obviously do not use the kitchen stove as its piled with more stuff & they constantly order in food. Plus Amazon is delivering more STUFF constantly??? But the 82 inch TV is free & clear for viewing & gaming.
We assume that these kids must have originally moved out of a warehouse :)
It's difficult to hold them to the terms because you failed to set the expectations up front.
I rent to dozens of people every year that are moving from other states. I give them a verbal and written warning before accepting any money from them:
If they show up and decide they don't like the neighborhood, their furniture doesn't fit, the rental isn't cleaned to their standard, or whatever, it's 100% on them and they will accept it or pay the penalty.
Now, I'm not a slumlord and I don't try to take advantage of anyone. We are very, very clear about our rentals. We offer a video chat and walk them through or around the property. We will often take measurements of rooms and share that with prospects so they better understand room size. And I do a pretty good job of making sure rentals are clean.
Because I warn them so heavily up front, I rarely get a complaint. When I do get someone that just can't follow through, I have no problem charging the penalty and I can't remember the last time someone complained about that.
In this instance I would keep the security deposit but let them out of the 2 month penalty. Sometimes thing just dont work out and thats unfortunate. This isn't your fault however, if they made the commitment thats on them, it's not your fault their furniture doesn't fit. You should still be compensated for the hassle, and for the time it will sit vacant because of their error.
I think most people are on the same page. You could communicate with them that they are repaonicle for the rent until its re-leased. Put it back on the market now and fill it asap. Then, deduct your ACTUAL damages from the money's collected and refund the rest. As long as you are made whole, there shouldn't be an issue on either side.
@Nathan G. Great response! All about setting expectations and communicating. We have an addendum for “sight unseen” cases like this.
But given your scenario, keep security deposit and the half a month’s rent until it is re-dented. If re-rented quickly, return the half a month’s rent. You don’t want a tenant living in your home that doesn’t want to be there.
This is why I do a 1/2 month NON-REFUNDABLE reservation fee which holds the apartment for up to 14 days. I keep that money if they don't move in (or execute a lease) and apply to first month's rent if they do move in.
Do you see more issues with this type of scenario, tenants backing out, in the C-D properties, compared to that of the A-b range? Curious to hear from an investor that has units in those categories.
@John Korn tell them they are responsible until you or they can get someone to take over the lease. Find someone/market the property ASAP.
Tell them hopefully you can do it in two weeks or less. That shouldn’t cost them much. You shouldn’t be penalized and just let them go but they shouldn’t be screwed over imo. Both should take a small hit but you are the boss, work to solve that problem!
No. In the very beginning before I started my reservation to hold policy. I had people that would keep doing the I'll have it I swear on Friday. Just two more days, yada, yada. The non-refundable reservation fee fixed that problem The 1/2 month reservation fee is a popular option because it allows most people time to get another paycheck before they have to come up with all the money.
@John Korn, I really like @Nathan Gesner's advice, but most of all I like his procedure. It is designed to head off problems like the one you experienced before they occur. That's a sign of successful land lording!
One additional comment on whatever you decide to do: as your investment portfolio grows, you risk being charged with discrimination claims every time you make exceptions to your policies and procedures. Your lease today says "2 months penalty". If you fail to enforce that for this early termination, you should consider striking that clause out of your lease because anyone down the road you try to enforce it on can claim you are discriminating against them for reason X, Y, or Z (or all three!). The claim(s) could be totally without merit, but you'll have to pay a few thousand $$$ in court to defend yourself and prove otherwise.
Btw, good luck getting a broke tenant to pay your court costs, even if you prevail.
The alternative would be to document every time you make an exception. Then you could keep your 2 month penalty in the lease and simply make the exception today, and all future situations where this happens can be handled the same way. Maybe your documentation says something like this, "Tenant was moving in from out of state, didn't inspect the premises in person, and didn't realize the rooms were too small for their furniture. They had only started moving in the house for 2 days before discovering this. Due to the very short time the tenants were in the property, and in consideration of their inability to inspect the premises, management has decided in lieu of the standard lease break penalty equal to two months of rent, we only charged an amount equal to the security deposit provided they moved out within 1 week and left the premises in broom swept condition, and that they allow us full access during reasonable hours (7 am to 7 pm) to show the property to other interested prospects while they are finishing moving out and cleaning."
As you can see, making exceptions to policy sets up a need for detailed record keeping, which I why I advise against it most times. A better idea is to make good policies, set clear expectations around them like Nathan G does, and always enforce them impartially.
Document, document, document! We call it "CYA", and it's there for a reason.
P.S. Don't ever "just keep" the deposit. You BILL CHARGES against the deposit and send the proper accounting per your state's regs. This may sound nitpicky, but it needs to be done properly.
I would also recommend any investor, but particularly those with larger portfolios, to have written policies surrounding all aspects of their rental processes. However, you need to make sure they are actually followed and properly documented as Erik said. When, not if, you get a discriminatory complaint, you can turn to those policies to justify that no discrimination took place. I've seen local fair housing authorities send in "shoppers" that match the same criteria as denied applicants, excepting one or two changes, to see if any discrimination is taking place. If you don't have those written policies in place, make a one-time exception, and then fail to offer the same circumstances to another party, you're going to be hot water. Property investors should follow the same strict policies and procedures as a good property management company.
I personally recommend having the following written policies at a minimum:
Application Criteria: required docs, income, credit, rental history, etc.
Security Deposit: Documentation, invoicing, deductions, timelines, penalties, etc.
Move-in/out: Process, timeline, documentation, etc.
Late Rent
Lease Violations
Pets
Make sure these policies follow your local law.
Does anybody have examples of these types of scenarios when a written policy, or lack thereof, affected the outcome of a situation?
Thank you everyone for the advice, a lot of really options I didnt think of. I ended up just keeping the deposit and let them go. @Erik Whiting really good material...appreciate it.