Mount Pleasant, SC · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 6 votes
I'm considering investing in a property up near Lake Toxaway (or close by) with my number one criteria being that it cash flow. Does anyone have any experience investing in that area. I know close by in Pigeon Forge there is a huge STR market for mountain cabins but not sure in the more remote areas near Cashiers, NC. Any advice would be much appreciated.
@Brandon Dawson I second John. Take a look at your potential neighbors’ calendars on the rental platforms and see what they are charging and how booked they are.
Hey @Brandon Dawson that's a gorgeous area! I have family with a lake home at Toxaway and they love it, and Highlands and Cashiers are fantastic.
First, I'd look into the local STR regulations. Those are high-end communities and STRs are likely quite regulated. Make sure you're comfortable conforming to the rules there.
@John Underwood has good advice re: looking at what comparable properties are going for, and check their calendars too. Right now is not going to give you a good idea of "normal", but just factor in that demand is depressed right now. (I also don't know if there might be current restrictions on travel in NC, so check that too!)
Finally, I love the NC mountains, they're my favorite side of the Smokies and I've been going there since I was a kid. However, I invest in TN - not only because the demand is so high around Pigeon Forge, but because the taxes are much lower! Property taxes are dirt cheap and there's no state income tax in Tennessee, so your overall tax burden is significantly lower than on the NC side. Make sure you look at those costs, and don't forget HOAs either. :) If your goal is cash flow, you may be happier over on the Tennessee side of things.
Thanks everyone! I started looking on AirBnB but given the COVID situation it's tough to discern how realistic the numbers are. I know my STR here in Mt. Pleasant is way out of whack from normal.
I had not considered the tax difference in TN verse NC so thanks for that very helpful piece of info. I'm trying to stay inside of five hours so I could realistically use the property which makes TN less desirable.
Thanks again for all the great advice! Definitely a lot to chew on.
Agreed, it's tough to have your cake and eat it too. I failed to mention that cash flow was #1 and personal use #2. I realize that may be a fiction right now though.
I was very satisfied using Mashvisor data to help me analyze cash flow for potential vacation rental properties. I was able to gain a valuable insight in my market (Lake Tahoe), that condos cash flow better than single family homes. Condos command comparable rents per bedroom, but the expenses are much lower because purchase prices are much lower (even accounting for HOA fees). I'm sure this is not a universal insight, but using data is the only way to learn this type of stuff. Having data to backup my numbers also gave me the confidence to close the deal. Good luck!
Hi @Brandon Dawson -- if cash flow is #1 and personal use #2, I would maybe look more into the Pigeon Forge/Gatlinburg area. The numbers there are just hard to beat. And since it's not that far away from what you are already considering, it also shouldn't be that much harder to get to for personal enjoyment, right? The lockdown definitely had impact on our rentals, but we were really fortunate to be able to rebook all of our dates. So far looking at 100% occupancy in April and May for reasonable rates. May is actually poised to be our best month so far.
That's great to hear! I'm hoping my STR here will rebound as well as yours. I do agree that pigeon forge is the better investment play but it's another few hours from me which put it further than what I'd consider for a weekend getaway. It really sounds like I need to get over personal use or move closer to the mountains haha