airBnB in subdivision HOA rule says for residential purpose only

airBnB in subdivision HOA rule says for residential purpose only

Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 1 vote

Hello,

I am looking to buy a house in my subdivision and wonder if I can make it an airBnB?

The HOA rule states, that lots are for residential use only? Does someone have any experience with that?

Thank you for your feedback in advance.

0Reply
193 views

Most Popular Reply

Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
5y
Originally posted by @Robert Gilstrap:

@Steve K. SF STR's are nothing like hotels; they have no parking lots, they don't have hundreds of strangers staying together in different rooms, they don't have onsite 24/7 staff performing housekeeping, front desk or maintenance, they don't have bars, restaurants, common areas, public restrooms or meeting spaces located on site, hotels are commercial structures designed to house hundreds or even thousands of people under one roof.

I'm actually a bit surprised that someone who is licensed thinks that something is "common knowledge among professionals" isn't more versed in the legal concepts and arguments for and against the topic but regardless my stance is still the same. Just because "they do it this way where I'm from" doesn't make it gospel for everyone, everywhere else.

It's not my opinion that STR's are commercial activity, and I have no desire to debate the issue with you, I'm just bringing up the fact that it's the way hundreds of courts have ruled beginning with NYC vs. Airbnb in 2011. I'm not an expert or a lawyer but I believe that may have been the case which established a legal precedent which was repeated soon after in LA, Miami Beach, San Fran, Santa Barbara, Santa Monica, Las Vegas, Denver, Boston, Paris, Barcelona, Amsterdam, London, Berlin, etc., etc. etc. in the early 2010's then spreading form major to smaller cities and towns all over the world during the past decade. Anyone looking to purchase a property to operate an STR in 2021 absolutely needs to be aware of this background and research the laws in their area as a starting point. Municipalities have the right to create and enforce zoning laws and they often consider short term rentals business activities which are not allowed (or are severely restricted) in residentially zoned areas. Again, it's not my opinion so please don't shoot the messenger here, just stating what I thought was well-known. There have been so many famous court cases over the past decade that have established STRs can be deemed commercial activity and treated accordingly that I thought it was common knowledge by now, but I guess I was wrong and I apologize if I offended anybody.

See this reply in the discussion

15 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · North Fork, NY · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 631 votes
    5y

    Probably not but if you own there already, read your HOA docs. Is anyone else doing it? Sounds like trouble unless it makes sense as a LTR.

  • Dave StokleyBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 705 posts · 799 votes
    5y

    Go to the board and ask for clarification. I would not consider an STR a residential use. And even if you can twist the language, if the board doesn't like it they're just going to change the rules to explicitly ban it.

  • Michael BaumPro Member
    Olympia, WA · Member since 2016 · 8k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    5y

    Hey @Mike Cichy, I would double check as @Nancy Bachety and @Dave Stokley suggested, but I think you are out of luck.

    I wouldn't put my money into something that would most likely be denied.

  • Robert GilstrapPro Member
    Residential Real Estate Broker · Cartersville, GA · Member since 2015 · 575 posts · 581 votes
    5y

    @Mike Cichy what would make you think that a Short Term Rental is not for "residential purposes"? I'm guessing at your personal home you eat, sleep, shower, use the bathroom, watch TV, engage in conversation with your friends/spouse, read books, etc. What activity do you think goes on at every STR on Earth? The guests eat, sleep, shower, use the bathroom, watch TV, engage in conversation with your friends/spouse, read books, etc.

    If you have no rental restrictions in your HOA then you should be good but obviously read and understand what the covenants say and of course your states laws will dictate to some degree, what state are you in?

  • John UnderwoodPro Member
    Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    5y

    STR is a commercial businesses. You have to get commercial insurance.

    So HOA rules are against you.

  • Property Manager · New York City · Member since 2017 · 61 posts · 28 votes
    5y

    @Mike Cichy condos can definitely be like that unfortunately! You just don't want to run into a situation where the condo finds out and shuts it down. I would recommend looking at other areas that don't have those restrictions in place. 

  • Robert GilstrapPro Member
    Residential Real Estate Broker · Cartersville, GA · Member since 2015 · 575 posts · 581 votes
    5y

    @John Underwood Do you consider the long term rental of residential property a "commercial business" as well?

  • Member since 2020 · 223 posts · 233 votes
    5y

    Am I taking crazy pills? Call the damn HOA. Sheesh the lengths people will go to, to avoid picking up the phone...

  • John UnderwoodPro Member
    Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Robert Gilstrap:

    @John Underwood Do you consider the long term rental of residential property a "commercial business" as well?

     I do not.

    I know I have to have a special commercial policy for my STR to be legally covered. It is considered a business. LTR's only require a standard landlord policy and are considered passive investments.

    Trying to do a STR is just a bad idea.

    My HOA went crazy when one person tried to do this. They complained that they did not know who was next door. It could be a felon or a child molester. They had them shut down.

    I see both side as living in an HOA and having a Vrbo in another area.

    Unfortunately insurance companies have labeled STR'S as commercial.

  • Robert GilstrapPro Member
    Residential Real Estate Broker · Cartersville, GA · Member since 2015 · 575 posts · 581 votes
    5y

    @John Underwood so your logic is that renting your place for 10 days is a business but renting it for 10 months or 10 years is somehow not a business? 

    You keep repeating this mantra that you are required to have commercial insurance for a STR which is just not true (at least not universally true). I get it that you have a commercial STR policy. I also have a commercial long term rental policy but that doesn't define the activity. We simply bought a product with defined parameters.  What type of insurance one has, whether or not someone is required to have a business license or even how something is taxed does not define it's legal status. I mention that because lots of court cases in this space have centered around just that argument and appellate courts have rejected that logic. 

    I will agree with you that dealing with HOA's can be problematic for sure and depending on what state this person is in might make it all an uphill battle not worth fighting but I never try to dissuade someone from investigating further,

  • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    5y

    @Robert Gilstrap there's tons of case study going back around 15 years showing STR's are legally considered a commercial business, like a hotel, because there are new guests every night or every few days which is different than a long term or medium term (30+ day) rental. It's been decided in court numerous times. AirBNB even literally has a team of dozens of Yale-grad lawyers on staff and they've fought this fight over and over again for over a decade, and lost. You can research the cases just google it. Many HOAs and even many entire cities have banned them and those restrictions have held up in court just about every time. It's unfortunate for those looking to operate an STR within an area that restricts them, but it is what is. Nothin new, been this way a long time now that's why we have to research the local laws and HOA bylaws before investing in an STR.

  • Robert GilstrapPro Member
    Residential Real Estate Broker · Cartersville, GA · Member since 2015 · 575 posts · 581 votes
    5y

    @Steve K. The problem with your blanket statements of "tons of case studies" is that case studies hold no weight under law. I'm interested in COURT decisions. I have no doubt that in some court, some where a judge has  decided that renting short term is commercial activity and may be considered a business but as I'm sure you're aware we have 50 incubators in this country and thousands of courts who come to completely different decisions everyday and every single case has different relevant facts. So my point is in responding that there is absolutely no consensus on the issue which is why I asked the person posting what state they were in as that would allow one to make an informed decision based on his/her state laws.

  • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    5y

    @Robert Gilstrap there are hundreds of examples of STRs being ruled as commercial activity by HOAs and municipalities across the world, going back over a decade, easily available to anyone wanting to do the research. Anyone who doesn’t know this hasn’t been paying attention, at all, for a long time. In my area STRs are licensed like small businesses, and regulated and taxed like hotels (which they basically are). It’s been this way for many years in most places so honestly a little surprised to be having this conversation in 2021. Airbnb fought a good fight with an army of lawyers over and over again and lost just about every time. I consider this common knowledge within the industry among professionals at this (very late) stage in the game.

  • Robert GilstrapPro Member
    Residential Real Estate Broker · Cartersville, GA · Member since 2015 · 575 posts · 581 votes
    5y

    @Steve K. SF STR's are nothing like hotels; they have no parking lots, they don't have hundreds of strangers staying together in different rooms, they don't have onsite 24/7 staff performing housekeeping, front desk or maintenance, they don't have bars, restaurants, common areas, public restrooms or meeting spaces located on site, hotels are commercial structures designed to house hundreds or even thousands of people under one roof.

    I'm actually a bit surprised that someone who is licensed thinks that something is "common knowledge among professionals" isn't more versed in the legal concepts and arguments for and against the topic but regardless my stance is still the same. Just because "they do it this way where I'm from" doesn't make it gospel for everyone, everywhere else.

  • Realtor · Boulder, CO · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Robert Gilstrap:

    @Steve K. SF STR's are nothing like hotels; they have no parking lots, they don't have hundreds of strangers staying together in different rooms, they don't have onsite 24/7 staff performing housekeeping, front desk or maintenance, they don't have bars, restaurants, common areas, public restrooms or meeting spaces located on site, hotels are commercial structures designed to house hundreds or even thousands of people under one roof.

    I'm actually a bit surprised that someone who is licensed thinks that something is "common knowledge among professionals" isn't more versed in the legal concepts and arguments for and against the topic but regardless my stance is still the same. Just because "they do it this way where I'm from" doesn't make it gospel for everyone, everywhere else.

    It's not my opinion that STR's are commercial activity, and I have no desire to debate the issue with you, I'm just bringing up the fact that it's the way hundreds of courts have ruled beginning with NYC vs. Airbnb in 2011. I'm not an expert or a lawyer but I believe that may have been the case which established a legal precedent which was repeated soon after in LA, Miami Beach, San Fran, Santa Barbara, Santa Monica, Las Vegas, Denver, Boston, Paris, Barcelona, Amsterdam, London, Berlin, etc., etc. etc. in the early 2010's then spreading form major to smaller cities and towns all over the world during the past decade. Anyone looking to purchase a property to operate an STR in 2021 absolutely needs to be aware of this background and research the laws in their area as a starting point. Municipalities have the right to create and enforce zoning laws and they often consider short term rentals business activities which are not allowed (or are severely restricted) in residentially zoned areas. Again, it's not my opinion so please don't shoot the messenger here, just stating what I thought was well-known. There have been so many famous court cases over the past decade that have established STRs can be deemed commercial activity and treated accordingly that I thought it was common knowledge by now, but I guess I was wrong and I apologize if I offended anybody.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.