“Trying to Pick the Right Market for My First House Hack (NY/Westchester)”

Upstate New York, New York
New Member Introductions
7moFollow

“Trying to Pick the Right Market for My First House Hack (NY/Westchester)”

Justin DeArcePro Member
Member since 2025 · 2 posts · 3 votes
Hey everyone, I’m new here and just starting my real estate journey — looking to buy my first multifamily soon. I’m 22, based in New York, and have about $67K saved with a 765 credit score. My plan is to house hack a duplex or triplex using an FHA or conventional loan, live in one unit, and rent out the others. Right now I’m trying to figure out the best areas to focus on. Ideally I’d like to stay within about 1–2 hours of Westchester County, and I’m also open to Westchester itself if the numbers make sense. I’m mainly targeting B or B- areas with solid rental demand — somewhere that’s a good balance between a decent neighborhood and still having some cash flow. So far I’ve been looking at places like Glens Falls, the Saratoga area, Orange County, parts of the Hudson Valley, and even considering Westchester County, but I’m not sure if I’m focusing on the right markets for a first deal. Would really appreciate any insight from people with experience: • What areas would you recommend for a first house hack in NY or nearby? • Any underrated markets worth looking into right now? • Are there areas you’d personally avoid starting out? • For those investing in Westchester County, is it realistic to find a first deal that makes sense there? Just trying to make a smart first move and learn from people who’ve already done it. Appreciate any advice.
3Reply
173 views

Most Popular Reply

Mohammed Rahman
Real Estate Broker · New York, NY · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
7mo

Hey Justin,

Welcome to BP! I'm a real estate broker, and I work with a lot of first-time househackers in New York (particularly NYC + Long Island).

The first move I'd recommend is to get a pre-approval and understand exactly what you qualify for under both FHA and conventional financing. Speak to 2-3 investor-friendly lenders and see what they say. Once you have that number, you'll have a much clearer picture of which markets are even worth your time.

On your question, "For those investing in Westchester County, is it realistic to find a first deal that makes sense there?" Even in my markets, which are on the pricier side, house hacking works. It just comes down to whether the numbers make sense on the specific deal, that you're not forcing it just to get started, and that you have the right people around you guiding the process. Get those three things right and the market almost becomes secondary.

Happy to help if you have any follow-up questions. Feel free to DM me anytime!

1Reply
See this reply in the discussion

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Mohammed Rahman
    Real Estate Broker · New York, NY · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7mo

    Hey Justin,

    Welcome to BP! I'm a real estate broker, and I work with a lot of first-time househackers in New York (particularly NYC + Long Island).

    The first move I'd recommend is to get a pre-approval and understand exactly what you qualify for under both FHA and conventional financing. Speak to 2-3 investor-friendly lenders and see what they say. Once you have that number, you'll have a much clearer picture of which markets are even worth your time.

    On your question, "For those investing in Westchester County, is it realistic to find a first deal that makes sense there?" Even in my markets, which are on the pricier side, house hacking works. It just comes down to whether the numbers make sense on the specific deal, that you're not forcing it just to get started, and that you have the right people around you guiding the process. Get those three things right and the market almost becomes secondary.

    Happy to help if you have any follow-up questions. Feel free to DM me anytime!

    1Reply
  • Akua Sarpong
    Developer · Philadelphia · Member since 2026 · 4 posts · 6 votes
    7mo

    Congrats on starting at 22 with $67K and a 765!  you're in a great spot for a house hack.

    I invest in Philly so can't speak to every NY market but a few things i know from living in the area and things I wish someone told me early:

    • Don't just chase cheap purchase price. Run actual rental comps because a "cheap" triplex with low rents and high vacancy will bleed you. Check Zillow, Rentometer, even FB marketplace to see what units actually go for
    • Orange County and Hudson Valley could work. I'd be careful with Westchester for a first deal tho. Price to rent ratios can be tough
    • B/B- areas are the move for deal #1. Tenants who pay, price point you can actually cash flow at

    Biggest thing nobody tells you is that hidden costs are real. My first project I was almost 20K over budget from stuff I wasn't tracking. Permits, holding costs, contractor change orders. Budget 15-20% contingency minimum and track every dollar from day one. Way harder to reconstruct that stuff later.

    Avoid anywhere you can't physically check on regularly for your first one. And check census data for population trends in whatever county your looking at.

    Good luck 🙌

    1Reply
  • Nick Sansivero
    Rental Property Investor · Wilmington, NC · Member since 2019 · 69 posts · 51 votes
    6mo

    Hey @Justin DeArce - You'll want to dive deeper into each market, but at a high level:

    Westchester County: Median Home Value is $831,958 as of 2026-02-01, Market Rent is $2,938 as of 2026-02-01, Median Days on Market is 36 as of 2026-03-01, and the Rent to Price Ratio (1% Rule) is 0.353. That points to a strong but expensive market, which usually means weaker cash flow.

    Orange County: Median Home Value is $448,371 as of 2026-02-01, Market Rent is $2,213 as of 2026-02-01, Median Days on Market is 59 as of 2026-03-01, and the Rent to Price Ratio is 0.494. That is a much better cash-flow setup than Westchester.

    Saratoga County: Median Home Value is $443,229 as of 2026-02-01, Market Rent is $1,763 as of 2026-02-01, Median Days on Market is 66 as of 2026-03-01, and the Rent to Price Ratio is 0.398. It looks more balanced, but less strong on cash flow than Orange County.

    Glens Falls, NY: Median Home Value is $296,278 as of 2026-02-01, Market Rent is $1,430 as of 2026-02-01, Median Days on Market is 78 as of 2026-03-01, and the Rent to Price Ratio is 0.483. It’s the most affordable of the group, though the market is slower.

      1Reply
    Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
    Log InJoin for Free