I've had an awful experience with my property manager in Ohio. 5 empty door out of six. Awful communication, etc. Never owning their shortcoming for blatant mistakes. 3 recent evictions...one property vandalized and they didn't take any responsibility for it etc etc etc. Basically my contract is month to month and they are making me go to another manager in the middle of vacant properties, a vandalized property waiting for rehab etc.. is there anything I can do legally if my contract ends by the end of November? Thanks. Any advice is greatly appreciated
@Orlando Osuna
Would you mind sharing which city?
How do you currently screen your property managers?
Your communication and relationship with a property manager is a marriage like commitment. What due diligence brought you to this company? If the company is rotten it's time to find a replacement. Start interviewing, asking investors in the CITY where the subject property sits. Maybe it's time to go to Ohio and figure out what is the real problem. If it's location, then it's time to sell. Without seeing the contract no one can advise you what to do. You only have a few days left of November so you should have the replacement in play by now. Were evictions related to covid excuses? If they are not, and are just habitual poor paying dudes then it's the management company not screening the credit and background.
Your communication and relationship with a property manager is a marriage like commitment. What due diligence brought you to this company? If the company is rotten it's time to find a replacement. Start interviewing, asking investors in the CITY where the subject property sits. Maybe it's time to go to Ohio and figure out what is the real problem. If it's location, then it's time to sell. Without seeing the contract no one can advise you what to do. You only have a few days left of November so you should have the replacement in play by now. Were evictions related to covid excuses? If they are not, and are just habitual poor paying dudes then it's the management company not screening the credit and background.
i think you're completely right. The screening process was probably not done correctly ... I'm in talks with a new pm but the issues the previous pm is leaving me with ate pretty awful.
thanks
I’m from the Hamilton area and currently work in Dayton. I’d recommend you to reach out to Oberer Realty in Dayton and see if they can help.
@Orlando Osuna
You should be able to terminate early if they’re not fulfilling their end of the contract. You should get a new property manager asap and get this stabilized one unit at a time.
I’m from the Hamilton area and currently work in Dayton. I’d recommend you to reach out to Oberer Realty in Dayton and see if they can help.
Thank you sir
@Orlando Osuna
You should be able to terminate early if they’re not fulfilling their end of the contract. You should get a new property manager asap and get this stabilized one unit at a time.
Thanks Mark. I might sell some of them too..do you work in OH? Thanks
If you would share the TK co and PM that would be huge! I’m like 15 minutes from Hamilton. Let me know if I can help.
I've had bad property managers before who didn't want to let me out of contracts. I just consistently contacted them via email and phone until they begged me to leave and let me out of my contract early.
When it comes to leaving with vacancies, that sounds like a good thing. Based on your current situation the last thing you want is for THEM to place another tenant.
Sorry you're in this situation, but the good news is it sounds like you have plenty of doors so positive cash flow should be coming soon.
If you would share the TK co and PM that would be huge! I’m like 15 minutes from Hamilton. Let me know if I can help.
Thanks Susie. The TK is Freedom Real Estate Group. PM is owed by them... independence property manager. I appreciate your help. Let's chat. Just sent you a request.
I've had bad property managers before who didn't want to let me out of contracts. I just consistently contacted them via email and phone until they begged me to leave and let me out of my contract early.
When it comes to leaving with vacancies, that sounds like a good thing. Based on your current situation the last thing you want is for THEM to place another tenant.
Sorry you're in this situation, but the good news is it sounds like you have plenty of doors so positive cash flow should be coming soon.
Thanks Adam. I believe this will be a blessing in disguise in the long term. I have never dealt with such an awful TK and PM ever. And they don't own their shortcomings. Seems like other folks have had the same issues with them! ....The worst part at least now is that I'm in the middle of an eviction and repairs due to vandalism in one of my properties...now i have to deal with that with a brand new pm who can hopefully help me stabilize these properties or help me sell them. I welcome your opinions and suggestions. Thanks again for your message.
Just get rid of them and find another PM. With 5 of the 6 units empty, now is a great time to do it.
"fire the PM"
"fire the PM"
"fire the PM"
These types of threads are always the same. Why is it that nobody actually provides a constructive look at the scenario as opposed to just chanting "fire the PM" when there is clearly not enough information to determine the root cause of what's going on here.
For example, let's talk about the most obvious statement of scapegoating. The property was vandalized. How in the world does it make sense to blame the property manager for that? Somebody explain to me in a rational manner how the property manager should be stopping criminals from breaking into the home?
"fire the PM"
"fire the PM"
"fire the PM"
These types of threads are always the same. Why is it that nobody actually provides a constructive look at the scenario as opposed to just chanting "fire the PM" when there is clearly not enough information to determine the root cause of what's going on here.
For example, let's talk about the most obvious statement of scapegoating. The property was vandalized. How in the world does it make sense to blame the property manager for that? Somebody explain to me in a rational manner how the property manager should be stopping criminals from breaking into the home?
I agree sometimes folks can be very biased and blame everything on the pm. This situation with this particular tk and pm has been happening and it has extended from the beginning of the business relationship for over a year and a half. I tried to work with them to fix the issues with their way of handling my properties. Renovations we're poorly done, city fines, monthly repair bills, apparent negligence in screening tenants, then the vandalism incident that will cost me 20k. To answer your question, if you are an out of state investor, your pm is your eyes and hands that should be looking after your asset. In this case, the eviction that happen before the vandalism (pm suspects it was the tenant that committed it). I believe the pm should have protected the property for the following days after the eviction by checking on the property constantly..just as an owner would have done...
also, out of the 6 doors they manage for me, 6 are not paying rent this month...if that can be called a coincidence or bad luck I think most of us would disagree ... There is obviously something off with the pm in that case. Also check the other person that complaint about Freedom Real Estate group. His case is exactly the same as mine... Another coincidence ..? Doubt it.
for anyone considering doing business with FREEDOM REAL ESTATE GROUP AND INDEPENDENCE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT... PLEASE listen to me and STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY. you will thank me later. I wish someone has prevented me from investing with them.
thanks
@James Wise I'm somewhat with you. Buy a property out of state: get detailed inspections, do repairs before closing, inspect repairs, interview the manager don't inherit old manager and old tenants and think everything is good. When buying a property from anyone who does not live in the subject they are removed a layer of guilt/knowledge/day to day reality to have to disclose. Assume everything is broken and existing tenants haven't paid since the start of Covid.
I'm not sure how long subject went from 100% occupied to zero but it sounds like over a long period such as six months? When the first eviction happened it was time to go there in person.
Everyone evicted: who ever picked six bad apples was incompetent and the subject is in the red on the crime map. Change the PM right away. Clean up, do repairs, secure, add exterior lighting, add cameras, add fencing, spend the money to ave your investment, whatever is needed to make the subject safer, desirable, and cost effective. If doubling down with more work and funds is not going to override the location or workable, sell this week, right away, fire sale and call it a day.
My theory is to never throw good money after a bad pick. Market is high.
I've had bad property managers before who didn't want to let me out of contracts. I just consistently contacted them via email and phone until they begged me to leave and let me out of my contract early.
When it comes to leaving with vacancies, that sounds like a good thing. Based on your current situation the last thing you want is for THEM to place another tenant.
Sorry you're in this situation, but the good news is it sounds like you have plenty of doors so positive cash flow should be coming soon.
Thanks Adam. I believe this will be a blessing in disguise in the long term. I have never dealt with such an awful TK and PM ever. And they don't own their shortcomings. Seems like other folks have had the same issues with them! ....The worst part at least now is that I'm in the middle of an eviction and repairs due to vandalism in one of my properties...now i have to deal with that with a brand new pm who can hopefully help me stabilize these properties or help me sell them. I welcome your opinions and suggestions. Thanks again for your message.
How exactly does that play out? How many days do you want them to put eyes on your property? 3 days? 5 days? What's the bill rate for this? $50/hour? $75/hour. Let's say they have eyes on it for 5 days straight at $75/hour? That is 120 labor hours. You plan on paying your property manager $9,000 for this service every time one of your houses goes vacant? Call me crazy but I don't see that being a viable strategy.
I've had bad property managers before who didn't want to let me out of contracts. I just consistently contacted them via email and phone until they begged me to leave and let me out of my contract early.
When it comes to leaving with vacancies, that sounds like a good thing. Based on your current situation the last thing you want is for THEM to place another tenant.
Sorry you're in this situation, but the good news is it sounds like you have plenty of doors so positive cash flow should be coming soon.
Thanks Adam. I believe this will be a blessing in disguise in the long term. I have never dealt with such an awful TK and PM ever. And they don't own their shortcomings. Seems like other folks have had the same issues with them! ....The worst part at least now is that I'm in the middle of an eviction and repairs due to vandalism in one of my properties...now i have to deal with that with a brand new pm who can hopefully help me stabilize these properties or help me sell them. I welcome your opinions and suggestions. Thanks again for your message.
How exactly does that play out? How many days do you want them to put eyes on your property? 3 days? 5 days? What's the bill rate for this? $50/hour? $75/hour. Let's say they have eyes on it for 5 days straight at $75/hour? That is 120 labor hours. You plan on paying your property manager $9,000 for this service every time one of your houses goes vacant? Call me crazy but I don't see that being a viable strategy.
That would be cheaper than a 20k bill that I have now.. so yeah I would actually pay extra for them to secure and keep an eye on a property after throwing out a disgruntled tenant. The fee would be a lot less than that too of they had just secured the main entrances and doors with plywood or something like a $200 metal security door from Homedepot...it's just common sense..not a lot of people have it these days..
@Tim Meyer
Thanks for your recommendation. I will definitely give them a call.
@Orlando Osuna
Yeah I specialize in Columbus but work all through Ohio.
@Marc Rice
If anyone can recommend a local real estate attorney in the Dayton area I would appreciate it. I live in new Mexico and my legal team works only in the albuquerque area. I want to consult and see what kind of legal action I can't take against the pm and TK company. I've consulted with my local team already and they suggested this. Thanks
I have a ton of things I could mention regarding this company… but one incident that just happened two days ago is that the CEO of the company itself Aaron Davis tried to end my contract with the PM branch of Freedom Real Estate because he thought they couldn't help me resolve my issues. He illegally tried to break the contract by the end of this month of November 2021 to get rid of me asap, when the contract provides the customer with a notice of at least one month in advance. We are in the middle of an eviction, one vandalized property and a non paying renter (my last paying renter didn't pay this month.). I am a very reasonable person, i am a software engineer and I have worked at a national lab for almost 20 years. I'm a decent working person and I am not doing this just because. I have never dealt with such an awful real estate company in my life. I have asked several times during the last year and a half to talk to the owners Flip and Dani. If anyone know how to get a hold of them please let me know. Thanks again for your support.
I've had bad property managers before who didn't want to let me out of contracts. I just consistently contacted them via email and phone until they begged me to leave and let me out of my contract early.
When it comes to leaving with vacancies, that sounds like a good thing. Based on your current situation the last thing you want is for THEM to place another tenant.
Sorry you're in this situation, but the good news is it sounds like you have plenty of doors so positive cash flow should be coming soon.
Thanks Adam. I believe this will be a blessing in disguise in the long term. I have never dealt with such an awful TK and PM ever. And they don't own their shortcomings. Seems like other folks have had the same issues with them! ....The worst part at least now is that I'm in the middle of an eviction and repairs due to vandalism in one of my properties...now i have to deal with that with a brand new pm who can hopefully help me stabilize these properties or help me sell them. I welcome your opinions and suggestions. Thanks again for your message.
How exactly does that play out? How many days do you want them to put eyes on your property? 3 days? 5 days? What's the bill rate for this? $50/hour? $75/hour. Let's say they have eyes on it for 5 days straight at $75/hour? That is 120 labor hours. You plan on paying your property manager $9,000 for this service every time one of your houses goes vacant? Call me crazy but I don't see that being a viable strategy.
That would be cheaper than a 20k bill that I have now.. so yeah I would actually pay extra for them to secure and keep an eye on a property after throwing out a disgruntled tenant. The fee would be a lot less than that too of they had just secured the main entrances and doors with plywood or something like a $200 metal security door from Homedepot...it's just common sense..not a lot of people have it these days..
Lol well come on up to my neck of the woods brother. I got no problem throwing an extra $9,000 charge for that onto all of your turnovers. If you want we'll call it an even $30k and I'll have my guys chill there for 3 weeks.
On a serious note I am sure any PM will be fine to do this for you as it'd be pretty profitable but you need to bring it up and explain you're willing to pay the bill rate the whole time. Becaide nobody is going to think there is someone crazy enough out there to want this service, because frankly, it's bat s*** crazy to pay someone to camp out at your houses everytime you have a turnover.
@Orlando Osuna Sorry to hear that. That happened to a recent client of mine. I suggest you end your relationship with your Property Manager. It may be more costly to take legal action.